Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey guys,

I've been reading the phatmass phorum regularly for well over a year, and I've hardly ever posted before, so consider this my "formal" joining of the "phamily."

Anyway, what brings about this post is some questions I have. And since the combined knowledge in this phorum is about 100 times greater than my own, I thought I'd ask those who knew best.

I recently started my first year at a university, and joined the student parish here. It's a nice community and stuff, but they do some things during the mass that I'm not sure are..."kosher," so to speak. Here's some things that have me a bit worried:

-The tabernacle is not prominent at all, it's tucked away in a corner, and there's no red light visible from the pews. I didn't know where to genuflect. Most people don't genuflect, and if they do it's toward the altar.

-On weekday mass, the priest doesn't wear clerics under his robes (no roman collar). Just a nice shirt and pants.

-There are NO kneelers in the church.

-The reason why there are no kneelers is because there is no kneeling during the mass. People stand during the consecration. I know some churches have discrepencies on this, but it really makes me angry and uncomfortable, kneeling at the consecration for over 9 years. I'll stand for the president, but I'll kneel for my God.

-On weekday mass, the priest has the entire congregation GATHER around the altar (still standing) for the consecration. There's really no way of getting out of it, and kneeling during this would make it seem I was rebelling, almost.

Those are the main things that bug me. My question: Are these just things I have to get used to with a new parish, or should I be sending a letter to my bishop in the near future?

Please be kind, I am but an ignorant newbie, and am very excited to re-join the active phorum here.

God Bless!

Tony of Padua

heavenseeker
Posted

Are you sure its a catholic church? If it is it seems to be extreamly liberal to me.

Posted

Check out "Mass Confusion" by Jimmy Akin. A little old, but he addresses a lot of Liturgical abuses.

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

Ask the priest about the Tabernacle and suggest that maybe it would be better to have it in the centre, so that people to know where to genuflect to. The same goes for the red light. Remember, the emphasis is on SUGGEST. Don't go in all guns blazing. Ask the priest why he does certain things-people generally prefer to be asked why they do something than be told outright that what they do is wrong. With regards to kneeling, I kneel even if there are no kneelers. I remember in the Adoration tent in Lourdes it was a tarmac floor with stones and I was the only one who knelt, but for me it is something that has to be done. Again, your're better to ask the priest why the congregation does not kneel during the Consecration. I usually find that it isn't helpful to go in stacked up with quotations from documents because it makes people very defensive. Tell him that you are aware that certain things that are done in this church are not advocated by the Church as a whole, but make sure you don't sound arrogant or a know-it-all. People hate that.

Edited by Noel's angel
Posted

Tony, welcome. You look great today, and I'm glad you have posted again.

You're in a tough spot. I was in a similar situation, ended up moving, and saw it as a perfect opportunity to switch parishes. Now I don't worry about it.

In retrospect, I think the more noble thing to do would have been to stay at my former parish and try to influence a change for the better. The very first thing I would do (and this takes a lot of courage) is to simply talk to your priest about it. Ask him the exact same questions you asked here. Once he gives you some answers, bring those back here and we can help you decide if any of his answers might be an issue you can take to your bishop.

Personally, I would never take something to the bishop before first talking to the priest about it--out of common courtesy. :)

Mateo el Feo
Posted

Many prayers for you, and a book recommendation: [b]Father, Forgive Me for I Am Frustrated[/b] by Fr. Mitch Pacwa, SJ.

Link: [url="http://www.amazon.com/Father-Forgive-Me-Am-Frustrated/dp/089283840X/sr=8-1/qid=1157062280/ref=sr_1_1/103-0836045-8465446?ie=UTF8&s=books"]http://www.amazon.com/Father-Forgive-Me-Am...TF8&s=books[/url]

Posted

[quote name='tonyofpadua' post='1054724' date='Aug 31 2006, 06:32 PM']
Hey guys,

I've been reading the phatmass phorum regularly for well over a year, and I've hardly ever posted before, so consider this my "formal" joining of the "phamily."
[/quote]

Welcome welcome :cool:
Awesome to "see" you here, and God bless you :)

You listed, among other things:
-The tabernacle is not prominent at all...
-There are NO kneelers in the church...
-The reason why there are no kneelers is because there is no kneeling during the mass...


That carp hacks me right off as well. and that's about as bad as I ever heard as far as bastardizing of the Lord's the Holy Mass - and that's exactly what it is.
Dust is right in saying:
[quote name='dUSt' post='1054738' date='Aug 31 2006, 06:52 PM']
…talk to your priest about it. Ask him the exact same questions you asked here. Once he gives you some answers, bring those back here and we can help you decide if any of his answers might be an issue you can take to your bishop.
[/quote]

I am interested in what the priest would say about this daily abomination of Sacred Liturgy

Posted

Do you go to a Catholic college? If you don't, the lack of kneelers and the placement of the tabernacle could be due to the wonder of ecumenical worship space. You can't have the tabernacle front and center if other religions are using the same room. Also, if Catholics are the only ones who would use the kneelers, they might just not have bothered installing them...as for the other stuff...yuck...

Posted

Don't elevate the importance of rubric elements above the efficacy of the sacrament's grace. Generally, don't fall into trap of overemphasisng the importance of the ritual to the point you can't recieve sacramental grace.

Didn't Budge challenge Catholic priorities in regards to 'ritualism' in another thread.

Was he right after all?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1055176' date='Sep 1 2006, 01:41 PM']Don't elevate the importance of rubric elements above the efficacy of the sacrament's grace. Generally, don't fall into trap of overemphasisng the importance of the ritual to the point you can't recieve sacramental grace.

Didn't Budge challenge Catholic priorities in regards to 'ritualism' in another thread.

Was he right after all?[/quote]He wasn't right, any more than the Judas Iscariot was right for complaining about the expensive oil that Mary used to annoint Our Lord ([url="http://www.usccb.org/nab/bible/john/john12.htm#v3"]see John 12:3-8[/url]).

Ironically, some Protestants could easily be seen as "too ritualistic" when they complain about Catholics and other Protestants who accept the practice of baptism by infusion (i.e. pouring water) or even aspersion (i.e. sprinkling), and don't exclusively practice immersion (i.e. dunking).

Accusations of ritualism are a two-way street.

In any event, the externals serve to protect and highlight the underlying Truth that is the foundation of the Christian Liturgy. We realize that Our Lord is truly present with us at the altar, and we Catholics honor Him through external signs, just as Mary Magdalen did in the gospel of John.

Edited by Mateo el Feo
Posted

Stop going there and write the Bishop.

Posted

It sounds pretty fishy to me.. I think once I went to a Mass where there wasn't kneelers and everybody stood, but it was temporarily in the gym because .. i forget why.. they were rennovating their church or something. Other than that, I've never heard of Catholics not kneeling at least during the consecration (although, as brought up months ago, some parishes are allowed to stand after the Lamb of God and after the consecration). It sounds to me like a pseudocatholic church or somethin..but definatly talk to the priest, and maybe talk to someone else in the congregation too. It wouldn't hurt to go to another nearby parish in the next town and ask the priest there about it.

Posted

You're from Saline? Is St. Andrew's your home parish? I know quite a few people from there......

Posted

Thank you guys SO MUCH for your advice. To answer some questions and address some issues...

[quote name='heavenseeker' post='1054729' date='Aug 31 2006, 04:41 PM']
Are you sure its a catholic church? If it is it seems to be extreamly liberal to me.
[/quote]
Yes, it's a Catholic church. Explicitly Catholic. On the front it says "St. John's Catholic Church and Catholic Student Center" (or something along those lines...) The building was erected for the soul purpose of being a Catholic church.


[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1054736' date='Aug 31 2006, 04:50 PM']
Ask the priest about the Tabernacle and suggest that maybe it would be better to have it in the centre, so that people to know where to genuflect to. The same goes for the red light.
[/quote]
The problem here is that the tabernacle has it's own room or "chapel." I appreciate that they have a separate place for private reverence and adoration in front of the tabernacle, the problem is that I had no idea where it was. Moving it doesn't seem to be an option.


[quote name='TrueImage' post='1055161' date='Sep 1 2006, 10:38 AM']
Do you go to a Catholic college? If you don't, the lack of kneelers and the placement of the tabernacle could be due to the wonder of ecumenical worship space. You can't have the tabernacle front and center if other religions are using the same room. Also, if Catholics are the only ones who would use the kneelers, they might just not have bothered installing them...as for the other stuff...yuck...
[/quote]
Again, it's a church, and strictly "Catholic". As far as I know, there are no other ecumenical groups that use the worship space.


[quote name='Tarcisius' post='1055220' date='Sep 1 2006, 01:32 PM']
Stop going there and write the Bishop.
[/quote]
To address this and what some others have said, going to another church is not really an option. I'm a freshman, so I can't have a car, and I doubt any of my Catholic friends would offer to give me a ride to the nearest church in town.

And some other issues: I'm not sure if this matters or not, but while I'm at a new university, I am still in the same diocese as my old home parish. Does this matter at all in terms of what the church is or isn't allowed to do?

Also, you're right in that talking to the priest is the best option. I've met him, and he seems like a good man. I'd really like to be able to foster a good relationship with him (after all, he is my new pastor) and wouldn't like to offend him right out. I'll definitely have to pray to the Lord for courage on this one.

So...what I'm getting is that these [i]are [/i] specifically liturgical abuses. Am I right? Again, thanks for your help, and if anyone else has any suggestions, please leave them here.

And tomasio...yeah, St. Andrew's is my home parish. I pretty much know EVERYONE there. Who do you know?

Posted

One specific liturgical abuse would be the gathering around the altar--this is something Lifeteen did that Cardinal Arinze specifically ordered them to stop doing.

Not allowing kneeling during consecration is also a liturgical abuse, I believe. Not having kneelers doesn't mean you can't kneel--just put a little more space between rows and you'll be fine. There are parts of the mass where the bishop is allowed to have people stand instead of kneel, but I don't believe the consecration is one of them.

I don't believe having the tabernacle to the side is necessarily an abuse, but it definitely damages spiritual life--without Christ in the center of the church your focus is diverted away. But I don't think it's necessarily an abuse. It's definitely a sucky idea, but not against the rules...I could be wrong, and I'd be very happy if it was so, so someone correct me if I am indeed wrong.

Posted

Yup, I think you're spot on jiyoung

Posted

So I just thought I'd update a little on my progress since I last posted here.

I talked to my pastor from my old parish (a really great priest) he said that when he was a pastor at a student parish a few years ago, they did the same things, and he couldn't change them, even though he really wanted to.

The gathering around the altar and the lack of kneeling, he said, isn't so much for the students, but remnants of the (for lack of better terms) "hippie" era directly following Vatican II.

According to him, the "hippies" were very eager to implement the changes after the council, because they wanted to be really "avant garde" and stuff. However, now that (depending on who you ask) most of the kinks of the council have been worked out, there are still some hangers-on who still feel the need to be radical and different. And since they are the ones who help finance the church (the students really can't), it's a lot harder for a priest to change things that have been in effect for a long time.

So his advice to me was to approach things in a curious manner, not to go in all "guns-a-blazing" and stuff. Also, while I plan on kneeling for the consecration regardless, it wouldn't be wise to do so in an obtrusive, "holier-than-thou" way. But, if change is possible, I will do my best to see that it happens. As it stands, I'll prayerfully discern further courses of action.

Thanks for all your guys' help, and I'll keep you posted if there are any developments here.

+JMJ+

Posted

Tony--

we belonged to a parish when we lived in Oldham County in KY--Transfiguration of Our Lord it was named. All of the above was part of the Mass, (although they did have kneelers) AND there was a 10-minute 'sign of peace' which included crossing the whole sanctuary and chatting it up. It was awful and we ended up moving back to Chicagoland 10 months later anyway. Some things are just deviant, and you either need to get outta there or ring some bells. It can be very tricky, and of course should involve much prayer and a diplomatic yet firm interaction.


The situation in KY was precipitated by some well-meaning but 1960's-corrupted older folks who wanted more 'kum-by-yah' in their worship and less Liturgy. Funny but flower children have grown up and they are old people now.....

Posted

The General Instruction of the Roman Missal contains what national standards there are regarding posture during the Mass - kneeling vs. standing - the only problem there is that almost all of the standards may be modified by the Bishop in appropriate circumstances . . . which may exist now, or may have existed whn the church was built/dedicated.

potentially a little dated . . . but will help point you toward the sources of the applicable rules.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...