Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I found this today. I think it's great. :)

[url="http://catholiceducation.org/articles/arts/al0288.htm"]http://catholiceducation.org/articles/arts/al0288.htm[/url]

Edited by Colleen
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Amen. I'm glad to see this show up more often.

homeschoolmom
Posted

What's sad is that in just a couple of years as a Catholic, I know all those hymns... in fact, I rarely hear a new one. It seems as though we are destined to sing the same handful over and over and over....

But we have a new music director-- I'm optomistic.

Posted

While I agree that hymns and songs containing hereodoxy have no place at Mass (or other Catholic gatherings), I'm not as quick to agree that we shouldn't sing in the voice of Christ. So long as it's doctinally sound, why not? We certainly quote Jesus often enough ......

The one thing to be careful of is that it should be very clear that Jesus is meant to the one speaking in the song... so that it isn't confusing.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I think he is wrong about [i]Be not Afraid.[/i]

Posted
:ohno:

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1054995' date='Aug 31 2006, 11:56 PM']
I think he is wrong about [i]Be not Afraid.[/i]
[/quote]
Posted

I can see his point about "Be Not Afraid", but hymns aren't necessarily praying, but proclaiming as well. If speaking with the words of Christ, it would just be a proclamation of those words.

I actually like "Be Not Afraid" though, the melody.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I must admit some sympathies for "I Am the Bread of Life" because I dig the Gospel of John...

Posted

I read that recently as well....I sent it to my "STAPLES Moderator" (St. Thomas Aquinas Prayer Liturgy and Evangelization Squad, we plan our schoool masses....we (not I) also like to add things to the Mass which makes me really mad....) hoping that she would care? But no.....anyway I can only do so much. I'm the sacristan for my school :)!

Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='1055046' date='Aug 31 2006, 11:57 PM']
I must admit some sympathies for "I Am the Bread of Life" because I dig the Gospel of John...
[/quote]

I want "I Am the Bread of Life" played at my funeral full blast for all my non-Catholic friends' benefit.

Posted

JMJ
9/1 - Twenty-first Friday

I just think the following quote, from Msgr. Robert Hugh Benson's novel [i]The Necromancers[/i], is great...

"For the pastor always said, 'It seems that only heretics go in for hymns.'"

Some hymns are beautiful and raise the mind to God. Ultimately, though, hymnody doesn't really begin until the Protestants had to replace things like the introit.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1055034' date='Sep 1 2006, 12:35 AM']
I can see his point about "Be Not Afraid", but hymns aren't necessarily praying, but proclaiming as well. If speaking with the words of Christ, it would just be a proclamation of those words.

I actually like "Be Not Afraid" though, the melody.
[/quote]

I like it. There is nothing wrong with proclaiming the word of God. If you were singing a psalm it would be in the first person as well. I sing this at funerals about every other week or so. The melody is stirring, the harmonies amazing, and it stirs peoples heart to God. THAT is a good enough hymn for me. :)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I like Be Not Afraid in itself (it's a little sappy, but it's calming), but I don't think I care for it at Mass.

Posted

personally, i love I Am The Bread of Life... Bread of Life too.. I agree about the heretical things, but a lot of the songs the "heresy" contained therein is so small and insignificant that you have to really analyze the song in depth and in one particular way, versus all the other ways you could interpret that song. Just because we "rise again from the ashes to be created anew" (or whatever teh exact wording was) doesn't mean Christ didn't raise us up from those ashes.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Franimus' post='1055237' date='Sep 1 2006, 04:40 PM']
personally, i love I Am The Bread of Life... Bread of Life too.. I agree about the heretical things, but a lot of the songs the "heresy" contained therein is so small and insignificant that you have to really analyze the song in depth and in one particular way, versus all the other ways you could interpret that song. Just because we "rise again from the ashes to be created anew" (or whatever teh exact wording was) doesn't mean Christ didn't raise us up from those ashes.
[/quote]
The problem with the ashes song is that it's "to create ourselves anew," which implies that we do it.

However, the change you made to it may be sufficient for theological accuracy.

Posted

Basically everything he wrote is exactly what my family has been trying to tell the music directors in our parish for over a decade now. But the songs he cited as examples? --- Those are a breath of fresh orthodoxy compared to the stuff we usually are subjected to. :pinch:

Posted

I love this. "Old school Lutherans take their hymns very seriously."

Domine ut Videam
Posted

Last year at my highschool on Ash Wednesday the song "Ashes" was banned from the liturgy by our chaplain because it was: and i quote, "A theological traversty of a song" :cool: We (the choir) turned the page over in our music books and wrote in permanent markers, "theological traversty", banned, Pearls O' Wisdom from Fr. Klamut. :lol: It was so funny although it did cause a bit of a revolt.....

-Yours in Christ
Lauren

Posted

I heard Adoro Te Devote and Let All Mortal Flesh Keep Silence live at Mass for the first time this year, at the EWTN conference in San Francisco. I was amazed. I'd never heard anything so beautiful.

I don't think I'd ever been to Mass before where I heard a song older than my mom. Which is creepy, to say the least.

The problem is that they're setting the words to the music, and it should be vice versa. Just like we don't have the priest start with the homily and then just work scripture in to fit it.

Posted

I am an organist, but I must follow the songs laid down on the schedules by my superiors. Honestly, I like some of those Jesus-talking songs. And "Ashes" gets played every year at Ash Wednesday, and I've never noticed that before....hmmm.....This interests me quite a bit as I have been thinking of majoring in Liturgical music when I head off to college.

Tindomiel, what sorts of stuff are you subjected to?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...