Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is sex only for Procreation?


Recommended Posts

Guest David Sunrise
Posted

Ref:
Code of Canon Law #1084.3: "Sterility neither prohibits nor invalidates marriage"
Based on law above:

1.Is it appropriate for the priest to perform a marriage between 2 older woman and man (50s or 60s)? The priest knows that by medical standard, there is no expectation for procreation. The couple realizes this very well and by common sense, they don't expect to have any child.

2.Since sex is for procreation, is it appropriate for the married couple with children to continue having sex even after the woman has menopause? Maybe until they are 60s or even 70s?

Artificial contraception is mortal sin. If I tell a catholic couple that contraception is mortal sin and they don't believe in it out of their common sense thus they continue on practicing artificial contraception, does this couple have mortal sin because of this? How about if I tell this to non-catholic couples and they don't believe it, do they have mortal sin?

Thanks

Posted

[quote name='David Sunrise' post='1055191' date='Sep 1 2006, 01:12 PM']
Ref:
Code of Canon Law #1084.3: "Sterility neither prohibits nor invalidates marriage"
Based on law above:

[/quote]

Pre question ref. While sterility does not prohibit marriage, the inability to consumate a marriage does. Additionally, when one consents to marriage they consent to being open to life. They do not necessarily mean to have a child because of every intercoarse.

1. Sex is for procreation, but sex is not solely for procreation. The other necessary component is the unitive aspect. They are intrisically linked so that if you take away one you take away the other.

2. Yes, sex is very good.

(You must be open to life even if it seems unlikely. See Sarah and Abraham.)

3. We can never judge as humans if a sin is mortal or not because some of the conditions for a sin to be mortal have to do with intent and knowledge. However, we are able to judge the seriousness of sin. However, YES, it would be a serious sin.

Men and women are able to argue from reason as to the evil of contraception. Gandhi knew contraception to be evil, and he was not even Christian. For more info I would look up Janet Smith or email me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...