Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Original Sin and IVF/Cloning


Recommended Posts

Posted

I didn't think of this question until I stumbled across the following from the Summa Theologica:

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/208104.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/summa/208104.htm[/url]

Question: Whether original sin would be contracted by a person formed miraculously from human flesh?

[quote]I answer that, As stated above (1,3), original sin is transmitted from the first parent to his posterity, inasmuch as they are moved by him through generation, even as the members are moved by the soul to actual sin. Now there is no movement to generation except by the active power of generation: [b]so that those alone contract original sin, who are descended from Adam through the active power of generation originally derived from Adam, i.e. who are descended from him through seminal power; for the seminal power is nothing else than the active power of generation[/b]. But if anyone were to be formed by God out of human flesh, it is evident that the active power would not be derived from Adam. Consequently he would not contract original sin: even as a hand would have no part in a human sin, if it were moved, not by the man's will, but by some external power.[/quote]

Posted

Well, I don't think we necessarily hold to a midieval view of Original Sin being transferred "by the seed" anymore. It comes from Fallen Human Nature, a defective Form in man, not the semen. As such, I think you could get it even if you only had a mother.

Still, the general conclusion of Aquinas remains true:

[quote]Consequently he would not contract original sin: even as a hand would have no part in a human sin, if it were moved, not by the man's will, but by some external power.[/quote]

If God were the maker of some new creation, He could give it any nature He wanted (fallen human, unfallen human, glorified human, or even non-human) even if it was made out of human flesh.

But clones and in vitro babies are not "miraculously" made of human flesh by God. They are still made by flawed human agency, taking human nature from their parents' fallen nature and, as such, still have original sin.

[u]Human[/u] agency is still the cause of those babies. They aren't direct miracles of God.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

My limited knowledge:
IVF uses sperm and eggs to create the embryos. Cloning would be like an embryo splitting in the womb. Twins have Original Sin, why not clones?

Of course I am not addressing the fact that cloning is pure evil in the first place...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...