jswranch Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Current American Protestantism teaches we are a body soul and spirit. CCC we are Body and Soul. At first I thought this was a non-issue, but am now finding a larger issue of how salvation/relation to God works. Thoughts?
cmotherofpirl Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1055437' date='Sep 1 2006, 10:01 PM'] Current American Protestantism teaches we are a body soul and spirit. CCC we are Body and Soul. At first I thought this was a non-issue, but am now finding a larger issue of how salvation/relation to God works. Thoughts? [/quote] Which version of American protestantism are you referring to?
jswranch Posted September 2, 2006 Author Posted September 2, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1055630' date='Sep 2 2006, 08:01 AM'] Which version of American protestantism are you referring to? [/quote] Well, I have seen it now from Episcopal, Evangelical, Baptist, and Pentacostal sources. [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1055617' date='Sep 2 2006, 07:09 AM'] Could you elaborate? [/quote] CCC: God created us as a soul consisting of a body and a spirit Protestant: God created us as an individual consisting of a body, soul, and spirit. As usual, they do not seem to have thought out exactly which part is which (intellect, emotion, fortitude, will etc), and if they have thought out the details, they do not agree within themselves. Is this an issue? How does the church justify her position from scripture?
jswranch Posted September 3, 2006 Author Posted September 3, 2006 Ok, may have answered some of my own question. Here is a quote from a Baptist church on the subject. [quote]Trichotomism In this belief, man is composed of three elements. The first of these elements is the physical body and is composed of flesh and bones. The second element is the soul and it is the area of the human life where we find reason and emotions. The third element is the spirit and this is the center of man's religious nature. It is here that man is able to perceive spirituality. We find evidence of trichotomism in 1 Thess. 5:23, Heb. 4:12 and 1 Cor. 2:14-3:4. It is believed that at death, the three natures of man separate. The soul is believed to be associated with the body and therefore is mortal. The spirit, however, in immortal and will live on after death. (Erickson 521, Cooper 9) This was the belief held by many of the early Alexandrian church fathers such as Clement of Alexandria, Origen and Gregory of Nyssa. Dichotomism This belief is the one most widely held by Christian throughout the history of the church. In this view man consists of only two elements; the material and the immaterial; the body and the soul/spirit. This view of often call dualism. (Erickson 522) This view holds that the soul/spirit are actually the same thing because in Scripture, they are often uses synonymously as in Luke 1:46-47, Matt. 6:25; 10:28. [Gen 2:7, 1Cor5:3, 1Cor7:34 They also hold that if we can say there are three elements that make up man, then we must also say there are more such as in Luke 10:27 where there are four ; heart, mind, soul and strength. How many is it? The dichotomist's view is that this is only an example of the whole person when they separate soul and spirit. [LK1:46] Dichotomism states that the body and soul/spirit is separated at death. It states that the body is dependent on the soul/spirit for life but that at death, the soul/spirit separates from the body and lives on. (Cooper 10, Erickson 523) The dichotomist position was the one held by Augustine, Aquinas and Calvin. It remains today as the orthodox and the liberal position on the nature of man. [/quote] The church appears to have handled this issue already. Ott, page 96 describes the De Fide of Body and Soul declared at 4th Lateran Council in opposition to Origen. Further down, Ott writes [quote]Again incompatible with Chruch dogma is the trichotomism taught by Plato, the gnostics, manichaeans... according to which man is composed of three essential component parts, the body, the animal soul, and a spiritual soul. [/quote] But is the trichotomism here the same as the one taught by some Prots today even though they use the same term? I am not certain.
N/A Gone Posted September 5, 2006 Posted September 5, 2006 off the top of my head, Doesnt SHeed use the Concept of a body, soul and spirit in a human?
jswranch Posted September 5, 2006 Author Posted September 5, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1056929' date='Sep 4 2006, 10:09 PM'] off the top of my head, Doesnt SHeed use the Concept of a body, soul and spirit in a human? [/quote] Not sure but Trichotomism really seems to be [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14153a.htm"]condemned by the Church. From the Newadvent site on 'soul.'[/url] [quote]This Pauline system, presented to a world already prepossessed in favour of a quasi-Platonic Dualism, occasioned one of the earliest widespread forms of error among Christian writers -- the doctrine of the Trichotomy. According to this, man, perfect man (teleios) consists of three parts: body, soul, spirit (soma, psyche, pneuma). Body and soul come by natural generation; spirit is given to the regenerate Christian alone. Thus, the "newness of life", of which St. Paul speaks, was conceived by some as a superadded entity, a kind of oversoul sublimating the "natural man" into a higher species. This doctrine was variously distorted in the different Gnostic systems. The Gnostics divided man into three classes: [/quote] Seems this 'man=body+soul+spirit' was a Gnostic thing for a long time. Also, here is a line from the Athanasian Creed: [quote]For as [u]the reasonable soul and flesh is one man[/u], so God and man is one Christ.... This is the Catholic Faith, which except a man believe faithfully and firmly, he cannot be saved. [/quote] Though I am not certain if the context applies.
N/A Gone Posted September 5, 2006 Posted September 5, 2006 I have a friend borrowing my book, but I thought I read about it in Theology for beginners.
phatcatholic Posted September 5, 2006 Posted September 5, 2006 human beings are body and [b][i]spirit[/i][/b]. here's how i've always understood it: the soul is the animating principle of a living thing, or that which gives life to a living thing. a spirit is a type of soul that can exist and act w/o a body. thus, bugs and plants and dogs have souls. human beings have a type of a soul that is called a spirit. in other words, human beings have spiritual souls. read this: [url="http://www.cts.org.au/2000/soulsandspirits.htm"]http://www.cts.org.au/2000/soulsandspirits.htm[/url]
batteddy Posted September 5, 2006 Posted September 5, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1057129' date='Sep 5 2006, 03:23 PM'] human beings are body and [b][i]spirit[/i][/b]. here's how i've always understood it: the soul is the animating principle of a living thing, or that which gives life to a living thing. a spirit is a type of soul that can exist and act w/o a body. thus, bugs and plants and dogs have souls. human beings have a type of a soul that is called a spirit. in other words, human beings have spiritual souls. read this: [url="http://www.cts.org.au/2000/soulsandspirits.htm"]http://www.cts.org.au/2000/soulsandspirits.htm[/url] [/quote] phatcatholic is correct. Soul and spirit mean two different thing...but our soul IS a spirit. Animals have a soul, the metaphysical "form" of Life, but it is not a spirit. It is not conscious or self-aware. It is just the metaphysical "template" that animates it. Whereas our souls are spiritual souls. The "form" of our body...is Conscious and Self-Aware. It has intellect and Free Will. Finally the Angels are Spirits but not souls. They have a mind, a consciousness...but no body. They are pure Form, without biological organic material life.
jswranch Posted September 6, 2006 Author Posted September 6, 2006 (edited) Phat & batteddy, Ok test this statement: Man consists of a spirit and a body. The term 'soul' has many meanings to include spirit, man, entire human, that which is in the image of God, mind, and principal of life in a living/breathing/biological/material being. Edited September 6, 2006 by jswranch
phatcatholic Posted September 10, 2006 Posted September 10, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1057664' date='Sep 6 2006, 06:47 AM'] Phat & batteddy, Ok test this statement: Man consists of a spirit and a body. The term 'soul' has many meanings to include spirit, man, entire human, that which is in the image of God, mind, and principal of life in a living/breathing/biological/material being. [/quote] i wouldn't equate "soul" with "man" or "entire human."
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 10, 2006 Posted September 10, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1055437' date='Sep 1 2006, 08:01 PM'] Current American Protestantism teaches we are a body soul and spirit. CCC we are Body and Soul. At first I thought this was a non-issue, but am now finding a larger issue of how salvation/relation to God works. Thoughts? [/quote] Both are valid and they are not mutually exclusive. Bipartite and tripartite anthropologies are both present in Catholic thought throughout history and are really just two ways of describing the same thing.
jswranch Posted September 19, 2006 Author Posted September 19, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1060206' date='Sep 10 2006, 12:27 PM'] i wouldn't equate "soul" with "man" or "entire human." [/quote] Why not? When we say 'our [u]souls[/u] will spend eternity in heaven at the resurection of the body' do we not mean our own personal entire human existance will be there, thus the use soul can mean entire human in this instance? [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1060209' date='Sep 10 2006, 12:31 PM'] Both are valid and they are not mutually exclusive. Bipartite and tripartite anthropologies are both present in Catholic thought throughout history and are really just two ways of describing the same thing. [/quote] Help my understand. I see you telling me Dichotomy and Trichotomy are both ok, but I see Ott saying: [quote]Again incompatible with Chruch dogma is the trichotomism taught by Plato, the gnostics, manichaeans... according to which man is composed of three essential component parts, the body, the animal soul, and a spiritual soul. [/quote] He also cites other strong statements against trichotomism. I called Tim Staples at CA and he also affirmed that it was a heresy (not that he is a church uber-scholar). [url="http://www.catholic.com/audio/2006/MP3/ca060905b.mp3"]Here is the call in show. Forward to about 33 minutes.[/url] Also, is not CCC 362-368 fairly certain on this?
N/A Gone Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 Christians can affirm a tri - partite anthropology. In fact, Paul seems to do so on a couple of occasions. The issue with the Gnostics has to do with whether the body is redeemed within that scheme. Tha quote from the Athanasian Creed is about another issue altogether, the question of whether Jesus has a human soul or not. (He did!) Be careful how you use New Advent. It can be helpful in some cases (the NPNF series is nice.) But a lot of the info is really antiquated. nick.. I'm not sure what "spiritual souls" are. It seems like you're trying to have your cake and eat it too! If you want to distinguish between humans and animals, just use a standard tri - partite division of the soul (appetitive, part concerned with honor, and rational/spiritual). You can then argue that animals don't have a rational soul. This also takes care of the (apparent) problem with the "spirit" terminology
phatcatholic Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1066638' date='Sep 19 2006, 12:55 PM']Why not? When we say 'our [u]souls[/u] will spend eternity in heaven at the resurection of the body' do we not mean our own personal entire human existance will be there, thus the use soul can mean entire human in this instance?[/quote]when do we say that? any soul that receives its judgment before the second coming is already spending eternity in heaven, if of course that is what the soul deserves. this soul would not be an "entire human existance" b/c it is separated from the body. when Jesus comes again, that soul will receive a glorified body, and then it will be entire. but, we wouldn't call that body-soul combination a "soul", we would call it a "human person." i suppose that one could use "soul" in some colloquial way to refer to the whole person (as in, for example, when someone says, "oh, you poor soul!"). the CCC, #363 refers to the colloquial use of the word as well, as it is occasionally found in the bible. but, strictly speaking, the soul is the animating principle of a person, and not itself the entire person. in theology, we always want to be as precise with our wording as possible. [quote]Also, is not CCC 362-368 fairly certain on this?[/quote]yup! you seem to have found your answer, and from what i can tell, this section only affirms what i have been saying. [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1066738' date='Sep 19 2006, 03:21 PM']Christians can affirm a tri - partite anthropology. In fact, Paul seems to do so on a couple of occasions. [/quote]are you sure about this? it has always been my understanding --and the CCC affirms this (#367)-- that a tripartite anthroplogy would be incorrect. the CCC references the 4th Council of Constantinople. i believe the pertinent info is found in Canon 11:[list]Though the old and new Testament teach that a man or woman has one rational and intellectual soul, and all the fathers and doctors of the church, who are spokesmen of God, express the same opinion, some have descended to such a depth of irreligion, through paying attention to the speculations of evil people, that they shamelessly teach as a dogma that a human being has two souls, and keep trying to prove their heresy by irrational means using a wisdom that has been made foolishness. Therefore this holy and universal synod is hastening to uproot this wicked theory now growing like some loathsome form of weed. Carrying in its hand the winnowing fork of truth, with the intention of consigning all the chaff to inextinguishable fire, and making clean the threshing floor of Christ, in ringing tones it declares anathema the inventors and perpetrators of such impiety and all those holding similar views; it also declares and promulgates that nobody at all should hold or preserve in any way the written teaching of the authors of this impiety. If however anyone presumes to act in a way contrary to this holy and great synod, let him be anathema and an outcast from the faith and way of life of Christians. [/list]you can read the rest of the council here: [url="http://www.piar.hu/councils/ecum08.htm"]http://www.piar.hu/councils/ecum08.htm[/url] [quote]I'm not sure what "spiritual souls" are. It seems like you're trying to have your cake and eat it too! If you want to distinguish between humans and animals, just use a standard tri - partite division of the soul (appetitive, part concerned with honor, and rational/spiritual). You can then argue that animals don't have a rational soul. This also takes care of the (apparent) problem with the "spirit" terminology[/quote]i don't see any problem with refering to the human soul in this way. did you read the article i linked to in my earlier post? the CCC uses this phrase "spiritual soul" as well, in #364, 365, and 366. pax christi, phatcatholic
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 I remember seeing something like this on another thread recently. Asserting two souls is heretical and is not what tripartite anthropology means in the Catholic context. revp is correct in suggesting that St. Paul assumes a tripartite anthropology and this is not an uncommon approach in Catholic thought. See "Theology in History" by Henri de Lubac if you don't believe me. And in a way perhaps less profound than St. Paul, St. Thomas Aquinas has a tripartite anthropology. And actually the Catechism seems to reflect the tripartite model. I can't lookup quotes right now, but I'm pretty much positive. Here is a quote about the de Lubac book I mentioned: [quote]The second section, comprised entirely of an unpublished work on tripartite anthropology tracing the body-soul-spirit distinction from St. Paul, the patristic tradition, St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas, up to the modern period, will prove an invaluable guide for further study and reflection.[/quote]
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 Here is a thread from two years ago: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=17220&mode=linearplus"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...mode=linearplus[/url]
jswranch Posted September 20, 2006 Author Posted September 20, 2006 To all those who feel the tripartite of man [s]is[/s] can be an orthodox teaching (that man may be made up of a soul, spirit, and body such that man= soul+spirit+body), I ask you to state your case from councils, papal statements, and church fathers. I am currently under the impression that tripartite/trichomomism man is incompatible with Catholic dogma. Please help me understand. Here is my current data: [quote][u]Vatican I D:1783 [/u] [God] fashioned each creature out of nothing, spiritual and corporeal, namely angelic and mundane; and then the human creation, common as it were, composed of both spirit and body.[/quote] [quote][u]Lateran IV D:428[/u] [God created] ... the human, constituted as it were, alike of the spirit and the body.[/quote] [quote][u]Ott, Man consists of two essential parts-a material body and a spiritual soul. (De fide.): [/u] Again incompatible with Church dogma is the trichotomism taught by Plato, the gnostics, manichaeans, apollinarians, and in recent times also by GUnther, according to which man is composed of three essential component parts, the body, an animal soul, and a spiritual soul. ... The Fathers defend dichotomism notably against the Christologically false teaching of Apo!linaris of Laodicea founded on trichotomism. The locution" Spirit and Soul" serves on occasion as a designation of the higher and the lower soul-life, without involving the distinction between two principles.[/quote] [quote][u]Gen 2:7[/u] And the Lord God formed man out of the slime of the earth, and breathed in his face the breath of life, and man became a living soul. (multiple other verses also apply)[/quote] [quote][u]CCC Body and Soul but truly one[/u] (paraphrase) 362 The human person... is a being at once coporeal and spritual. 363 In Sacred Scripture the term "soul" often refers to human life or the entire human person. 367 Sometimes the soul is distinguished from the spirit: St. Paul for instance prays that God may sanctify his people "wholly", with "spirit and soul and body" kept sound and blameless at the Lord's coming. The Church teaches that this distinction does not introduce a duality into the soul.[/quote] As per 367, I understand 'duality of the soul' to mean person= body+ spiritual soul (aka spirit) + animal soul (aka soul). [quote][u]New Advent: Soul[/u] This Pauline system [1Thess5, Heb4], presented to a world already prepossessed in favour of a quasi-Platonic Dualism, occasioned one of the earliest widespread forms of error among Christian writers -- the doctrine of the Trichotomy. According to this, man, perfect man (teleios) consists of three parts: body, soul, spirit (soma, psyche, pneuma). [/quote] Perhaps we are discussing two different things.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now