EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 I think this is topic is worthy of discussion. How far do we go in boycotting companies that have done things we as Catholics cannot support? I realize that sometimes, there is almost noway to avoid it, like in the case of Johnson and Johnson. Microsoft is hard to avoid too. But do we stop buying Sony Playstations because they made the Da Vinci Code movie? Do we stop buying Disney DVD's? As someone who struggles with scruples as much as anybody, it would be awesome if we could establish some standard - to whatever extent that can be done.
aalpha1989 Posted September 3, 2006 Posted September 3, 2006 (edited) I've been thinking about this too....I don't really want to go to Disney World with my band next year because of all the Disney stuff....I know I would have a great time and it would be unforgettable, but still....And my friends all say 'Disney isn't worth giving up". I think for the sake of human life it is. But idk it's all so confusing. Btw I think ceasing to buy playstations isn't that big a deal....I'm not completely against video games but people spend way too much time with them anyway. Edited September 3, 2006 by aalpha1989
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted September 6, 2006 Posted September 6, 2006 You pose an interesting question, I must admit that I have never done alot of thinking on the subject. My immediate thoughts are these. 1) 1 Corinthians chp 8: St. Paul tells us that it is ok to eat meat that is sacrificed to idols, so long as it does not become a stumbling block to others. Here's what I get from this: We are allowed to sustain ourselves with something brought forth by unholy means so long as we do not cause another brother (sister) to sin by it. If we buy something, and the profits are then (knowingly) used for something unholy are we not then contributing the sin of a brother? If someone was to offer to sell you their TV valued at $1000 for only $200, but you know that they will use the money to buy an 8 ball of coke are you justified in buying th TV, because it is a good deal? I say that you are not. 2) Mathew 10:11-15: Jesus tells the twelve to shake the dust off their feet if any house they visit does not recieve them and listen to their words. Granted this is specific instruction to the twelve, but I see ourselves fitting into the situation to a degree. If a company is doing something which is morally wrong, and they do not listen, then should we not also "shake the dust from our feet?" We should stop doing business with them and pray for them instead. This may be an inconvience and more expensive, but I think if we have knowledge of something and do nothing to try to stop it then we ARE condoning it. I don't know if this makes sense to anyone else, and I'm looking forward to seeing other responses, maybe it can help me flush this out too.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted September 6, 2006 Author Posted September 6, 2006 What do you think about large stores that don't contribute profits to abortion, etc. but still profit from the sale of say, condoms? What about companies like Sony who do not contribute to bad causes but made substantial profit off of the Da Vinci Code?
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted September 6, 2006 Posted September 6, 2006 The first thing that came to my mind over the last queastion was that even mother Theresa accepted money from criminals, mobmen, ect. In light of this and realizing that it is increasingly difficult, and down right impossible (impossible in my area I've looked) to buy food at a store that doesn't sell condoms. In that case I then look to what the company does. I buy at Wal-Mart for a couple of reasons. 1) They contribute a good ammount of money to natioanl Charities 2) They encourage their employees to do community service, and will donate money on behalf of those who do, to those charities, 3) They help associate invest their money in the stock Market by not only paying brokrage fees, but buying additional stock for them. 4) they refuse to sell music with explicit lyrics 5) They acctually watch Movie ratings and Video Game rating on a regular basis (at least in my experience) 6) They show true respect for the individual human, at least the ones that are born 7) More often than not they support an individual who needs time for family 8) They are VERY flexible in their scheduling of employees for those with religious requirements. I can think of many other reasons as well, but after looking at Kroger/Dillons/ Price Chopper/ Wal-Greens ect I can not find a positive list quite like this. So like voting for Political Officials, the first thing I look at is the non-negotiables, first with the one that affects the most people, and I chose the one who support the largest value in life. In a similar way when all of your options support sin we must look at which one does the best job at supporting morality too. I still think that we are obliged to let the company know we disagree with policies or stances though.
aalpha1989 Posted September 7, 2006 Posted September 7, 2006 [quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' post='1057793' date='Sep 6 2006, 12:08 PM'] The first thing that came to my mind over the last queastion was that even mother Theresa accepted money from criminals, mobmen, ect. In light of this and realizing that it is increasingly difficult, and down right impossible (impossible in my area I've looked) to buy food at a store that doesn't sell condoms. In that case I then look to what the company does. I buy at Wal-Mart for a couple of reasons. 1) They contribute a good ammount of money to natioanl Charities 2) They encourage their employees to do community service, and will donate money on behalf of those who do, to those charities, 3) They help associate invest their money in the stock Market by not only paying brokrage fees, but buying additional stock for them. 4) they refuse to sell music with explicit lyrics 5) They acctually watch Movie ratings and Video Game rating on a regular basis (at least in my experience) 6) They show true respect for the individual human, at least the ones that are born 7) More often than not they support an individual who needs time for family 8) They are VERY flexible in their scheduling of employees for those with religious requirements. I can think of many other reasons as well, but after looking at Kroger/Dillons/ Price Chopper/ Wal-Greens ect I can not find a positive list quite like this. So like voting for Political Officials, the first thing I look at is the non-negotiables, first with the one that affects the most people, and I chose the one who support the largest value in life. In a similar way when all of your options support sin we must look at which one does the best job at supporting morality too. I still think that we are obliged to let the company know we disagree with policies or stances though. [/quote] I agree, your points are convincing . So would Disney fall into the category of your first post?
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted September 7, 2006 Posted September 7, 2006 for me Disney would generally fall into the first category. I say generally, because there may exist a circumstance which would show a greater reason to patronize Disney, but I can't think of example now.
Veritas Posted September 7, 2006 Posted September 7, 2006 [quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' post='1057793' date='Sep 6 2006, 10:08 AM'] The first thing that came to my mind over the last queastion was that even mother Theresa accepted money from criminals, mobmen, ect. In light of this and realizing that it is increasingly difficult, and down right impossible [/quote] + I think it is important that we make a distinction between money RECEIVED (regardless of the source) and intended for good i.e. money given to M. Teresa and money GIVEN (again, regardless of the source) and intended for evil i.e. Wal-Mart's recent alignment with pro-homosexual agenda (cf. [url="http://www.afa.net/walmartadage.htm"]http://www.afa.net/walmartadage.htm[/url] ). Personally, in spite of the many lovely points you made about Wal-Mart practices, as soon as they touched on this non-negotiable, I let them know I will not be making any further purchases at Wal-Mart.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted September 7, 2006 Author Posted September 7, 2006 Sadly, that probably does not make Wal-Mart different from a lot of other big companies.
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted September 7, 2006 Posted September 7, 2006 [quote name='Veritas' post='1058315' date='Sep 7 2006, 02:54 AM'] + I think it is important that we make a distinction between money RECEIVED (regardless of the source) and intended for good i.e. money given to M. Teresa and money GIVEN (again, regardless of the source) and intended for evil i.e. Wal-Mart's recent alignment with pro-homosexual agenda (cf. [url="http://www.afa.net/walmartadage.htm"]http://www.afa.net/walmartadage.htm[/url] ). Personally, in spite of the many lovely points you made about Wal-Mart practices, as soon as they touched on this non-negotiable, I let them know I will not be making any further purchases at Wal-Mart. [/quote] Your point of Money given and recieved is valid. The point I was trying to make is that Wal-Mart takes money from the sale of condoms (Bad), and they still apply good to that money. I am not a utilitarian, and the means DO NOT justify the ends, however if your case is a Bad that leads to Bad or Bad that leads to good, then in this example I believe the last option is the one to go with. Further while the AFA does find a good number of stories not heard about elsewhere, it is important to recognize that they do not always present the most balanced of approaches. Wal-Mart did join the group mentioned, however I am very strong in my belief that we can love our neighbor, and even do business with our neighbor without supporting the ACTIONS of our neighbor. I realize that is may sound like a contradiction from my earlier posts, so let me try to explain. I do not see Wal-Mart even in this action as actively saying WE SUPPORT GAY RIGHTS!!! What I do see is Wal-art saying we are willing to have a relationship and do business with companies owned by homosexuals. As salt of the earth we are not called to seperate ourselves completely from the world. We are the salt of the earth, and if salt never comes in contact with that to be seasoned or preserved then what good is it? I still see Wal-Mart as up holding the greatest good in an age where it is difficult to find ANY corporation to support any good. I open to changing this position, but I do not see adequte information to do so coming from soley the AFA
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now