Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

To join or not to join?


Recommended Posts

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted (edited)

As of Monday I have found myself in a very sticky situation. I have had the possibility of being a part of VTV, which is a Christian television show run by teens, this year. The problem has come up with differing beliefs between myself (one of two Roman Catholics there) and the other fundamentalist Christians, including the pastor of the church this is being shot out of and my neighbor and one of my best friends, who got me in on this. I have not yet let the others there know about this conflict, although I have spoken to the student chaplain at my school. Here are the major conflicts:
1)they are creationists while I believe in evolution (within the mandates of the Church, mind you)
2)this is a direct quote from one of the other teens on VTV, "We should let them (the audience) know that if you don't believe everything in the Bible you don't believe anything."
3)this got me really riled up, I'm going to be honest. I brought up the possibility of doing different ministries to show Christianity in action (food pantries, nursing homes, etc.) and the producer said something along the lines of if we help the homeless we should let them know that if they accept Jesus into their hearts everything will get better.

As of now, I think I have three choices:
a)stay on no matter what (already ruled out)
b)wait and see what happens in other meetings
c)leave now before I get in too deep

Right now I'm thinking that I should wait and see what happens at the next meeting, which will be in a few weeks. At that time I think we will be asked to sign a contract, so this isn't something that I can put off until the big conflict comes up. And there will be a conflict, because one thing the producer said they did last year was go to Starved Rock (a state park in Illinois) and have some people act like monkeys while another person interviwed random people about evolution. Then at the end talking about the creationist belief. So far there have only been two meetings, the auditions and the one on Monday which was an orientation and a brainstorm session on what we'll do this year, but already I have seen a lot of conflict in our beliefs. I do not know how well the other Roman Catholic knows his Faith, nor do I know him well at all (I just met him at the auditions, so have only seen him twice), and since I don't know how to contact him I don't know if I would be able to talk to him before the next meeting. Fr. Paul, my chaplain, told me to wait and see what the contract says and go from there, and also recommended that I read the book [u]Finding Darwin's God[/u] by Kenneth Miller, and I am in the process of reading it right now. Please, what do you think the best course of action for me to do is? Since I know there will be a conflict of beliefs now, I know that I will not sit by and let things happen as they may, so as I said before choice a is already ruled out, but if anyone has any advice please let me know. And prayers are also greatly appreciated. Thank you!

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

Edited by NazFarmer
Posted

Well, I say screw them. Take your catholic sister/brother who is with you on the project and dont bother going. Fundies are a nasty type and have no respect for catholicism (or common science for that matter, I believe in evolution too, through the churches perspective). Its not worth being on TV with these whackos.

Posted

[quote]b)wait and see what happens in other meetings[/quote]

Take this option.


When you joined this group, what did you expect?

Posted

Hi Joe. I don't know where in Illinois you are from (I'm on the NW side of Chicago right along the Chicago/Elmwood Park border).

These people sound like extremist nutjobs. Here are two things that you can challenge them on:

[quote name='NazFarmer' post='1055803' date='Sep 2 2006, 09:14 PM']
2)this is a direct quote from one of the other teens on VTV, "We should let them (the audience) know that if you don't believe everything in the Bible you don't believe anything."
[/quote]

Ask them to explain:

1) The dome that separated the waters in the sky from those below the sky (Genesis 1:6-7). NASA should have found it by now.

2) If someone says that the dome came crashing down as part of Noah's flood, point out that "floodgates" that were opened (Genesis 7:11) and closed (Genesis 8:2). Another thing NASA should have found by now.

3) The order of creation in Genesis 1 is different than that in Genesis 2. In Genesis 1, man was created after the vegetation and animals, in Genesis 2 man was created before the vegetation and animals. If you take the Bible super-literally, both cannot be true. Either one or the other. But according to their logic, both have to be simultaneously true or the whole Bible is false.

4) Various statements that the earth does not move (1 Chr. 16:30, Psalms 93:1, 96:10, and 104:5). Or are we going to challenge the notion that the earth orbits the sun? Did we not learn anything from the Galileo incident?

And when you do challenge them, do it publically and don't let up. If they kick you out, that might be the answer you are looking for. If they don't, some parishes may have extra people in RCIA for next Easter Vigil.

[quote name='NazFarmer' post='1055803' date='Sep 2 2006, 09:14 PM']
we should let them know that if they accept Jesus into their hearts everything will get better.
[/quote]

Then ask him to explain why there are so many virgins - especially those that lost families early in life and clearly are a higher priority - are being rejected and losing out to fornicating bums.

One other thing. I saw your profile, and you are only 16. Unless the law has changed, you cannot legally enter into a contract until you are 18. Check this out.

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

I actually didn't know what to expect: I hadn't even heard of it before I found out that I could be on it. My neighbors old youth minister was talking to the producer of VTV for buisness, and the topic of VTV came up, and the producer told my friends youth minister to bring someone he knew was really into their faith and a friend of theirs who was also into their faith. So my friend's youth minister brought him, and he brought me. All I knew about it before the auditions (and up until Monday) was that they went backstage and interviewed Christian bands and did some work on the streets (interviewing random people, etc.)
Norseman, thank you very much for your advise: I will definately have to look into the contract thing. With that, though, we are not being paid, so I think the contract is basically saying that we will make every meeting and give our all to VTV. I must say some of the examples you provided to disprove the notion that everything in the Bible must be true or none of it is true made me laugh, but I must add this. I was talking to my neighbor (the same neighbor who is also on VTV) last weekend about believing everything as stated in the Bible, and I brought out the example of two creation stories: he had never heard of the second story of creation. The way all of this came up was because he started to talk about the new series on abcfamily called Fallen, or something like that, and how it's about someone who is half angel half human, and how that is actually based in Scripture. There is a passage right before the Flood story which mentions these creatures (Nephalim), but the footnote in the NAB says these were part of an old legend. Logically they could not and cannot exist because angels are not physical beings while we are: they don't even have gender. My friend discounted all of this and brought up the point of the Annunciation: Jesus was conceived without sex. :huh: That has nothing to do with Nephalim (in Genesis 6:1-4 if you want to read what I'm talking about): God is God and angels are not, so there is no way that an angel could procreate with a human. This is how fundamentalist they are.
And Picard, thank you for making the point of needing to talk to the other Catholic there. I hadn't taken into account that I am morally responcible to at least see where it is he stands with this.

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

P.S. I'm about an hour from where you are, Norseman, and VTV is being shot out of the Lasalle/Peru area.

Posted

[quote name='NazFarmer' post='1055893' date='Sep 2 2006, 10:58 PM']
There is a passage right before the Flood story which mentions these creatures (Nephalim), but the footnote in the NAB says these were part of an old legend. Logically they could not and cannot exist because angels are not physical beings while we are: they don't even have gender.
[/quote]

I'm familiar with the story, but I never thought of that point! You learn something new every day.

Is there a website for this VTV?

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1055895' date='Sep 2 2006, 11:04 PM']
I'm familiar with the story, but I never thought of that point! You learn something new every day.

Is there a website for this VTV?
[/quote]
Not that I know of. It was just local last year, so I don't think many people really saw it (this coming from someone who mainly watches EWTN, if any TV, lol), but this year they are going nationwide, so they may have one by the end of the year. Please don't think, though, that because they will be nationwide or simply because it is being on TV that I wouldn't quit if they forced me to compromise my beliefs for them: I would leave in a heartbeat, trust me. Plus that wouldn't make any sense if they did want me to compromise my beliefs, since they want teens who are strong in their faith.

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

cmotherofpirl
Posted

It sounds like they want teens who are strong in their faith AND agree with them.
You could limit your part to those parts of catholic ministry they agree with - food banks, abortion, care of the homeless etc.
But you have so many fundamental differences with this group you will either cave or continously bash your head against the wall.
Why bother?
If they want a short frank discussion of how their beliefs differ from the Church fine and you can do some great evangelizing, but unless you are offering to be a full time apologist to them, graciously decline.

Wait til the next meeting but in the mean time prayers would probably be most effective.

Posted

Stick around and see what you learn...

:idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='Budge' post='1056243' date='Sep 3 2006, 08:32 PM']
Stick around and see what you learn...

:idontknow:
[/quote]

Sure stick around and instead of learning, teach. It is obvious that they are in the same believe as the word of faith churches. It seems like they preach a prosperity gospel. There is nothing more heretical, than thinking God is there to bring you earthly riches.

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

Thank you very much for your replies. I don't think that I would be able to be a full time apologist just yet, so being on VTV full time would pose a big challenege. The biggest challenge for me in this decision is that there is a chance that it would negatively affect the friendship between me and my neighbor, and right now that is my biggest worry. Please pray for me in this decision, especially for the strength and courage to do the right thing here. Thank you very much.

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

Posted

[quote name='NazFarmer' post='1056730' date='Sep 4 2006, 06:24 PM']
The biggest challenge for me in this decision is that there is a chance that it would negatively affect the friendship between me and my neighbor, and right now that is my biggest worry.
[/quote]

Joe,

You need to ask yourself what is more important, your faith or your neighbor's friendship.

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1056930' date='Sep 4 2006, 09:11 PM']
Joe,

You need to ask yourself what is more important, your faith or your neighbor's friendship.
[/quote]
I know. I know that, if the circumstances call for it, my friendship with my neighbor may not be what it is now. I'm not going to recite my life's story, but friendship is very dear to me, and so the possibility of losing a good friend is very daunting. However, I now see that, if this friendship does not survive, God has been working in my life in other ways so as the possibility of fostering another great friendship is there. However, also, now that I think about it, I cannot imagine my neighbor being offended if I had to refuse VTV on the grounds of Faith: we have had many conversations about faith in general, and we both know how devoted each of us is to our beliefs. Norseman, thank you for posting that comment. As small as it was, it has made me realize that friendships, though very important in life, cannot take precedence to our relationship with God. Thank you, and please do continue to pray for me. Although I do not know when the next meeting will be yet, there will be a conflict of beliefs there, and I don't know what the outcome of that will be. I just hope and pray I can hold my ground and defend the Teachings of the Church. Thank you again.

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

When they mentionedthings like Creation and Literal interpretation of the Bible, did you respond in anyway, and if so how did they react? Not knowing the group myself I can not jump up and down calling them fundie wacko's. I think as Catholics we sometime forget that WE misjudge the Protestants as much as Protestant misjudge us :shock: . My advice is to Pray, and seek legitamate dialogue when someone says something you question. Don't say "that's not right..." But you might try something like, I don't know if I'm comfortable with that because my Faith teaches me this..." You might find them accepting, you might not. If they tell you your going to Hell for disagreeing then let me know and then I'll call them fundie wackos :lol:

Posted

A Note to Norseman and Picard:
How many fundamentalist Protestants do you know? You do realize that culturally they are our biggest allies (ie pro-life, pro marriage)? There are a few very vocal against the CAtholic Church (mostly ex-Catholics), but the majority are just happy for faithful Catholics as faithful Christians. I personally have received as much, if not more, support from fundamentalist firends in my discernment of a call to the priesthood.

As far as no respect for science, creationists far from having a corner on it, evolutionists go way out as well (yay spontaneous generation!).

Naz, follow Father's advice. Odds are you won't be able to sign the contract in good faith, so see if they will let you amend or cross out the Bible as final authority clause (however they have it worded). If they will not budge, respectfully tell them that you can't sign and leave. (Also, bring this issue up with your friend before the meeting, odds are your friendship will survive if you both respect each other's beliefs.)

Chris

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

I have to echo Chris experience in recieving very posotive feedback fro Protestant in term of my discernment of the Priesthood as well. I find it amazing how much many do indeed respect the Church

Posted

[quote name='nowak.chris' post='1057789' date='Sep 6 2006, 12:02 PM']
A Note to Norseman and Picard:
How many fundamentalist Protestants do you know? You do realize that culturally they are our biggest allies (ie pro-life, pro marriage)? There are a few very vocal against the CAtholic Church (mostly ex-Catholics), but the majority are just happy for faithful Catholics as faithful Christians. I personally have received as much, if not more, support from fundamentalist firends in my discernment of a call to the priesthood.
[/quote]

I actually know quite a few. I am one of the few, if not only, Catholic in a Christian sportbike group dominated by the sola-scriptura OSAS-type evangelicals (in fact, I am in a running debate currently with some of them over Catholic issues). Although most are not anti-Catholic, the ones who are [i]most vocal[/i] are more anti-Catholic than not. And, in my experience, which dates prior to my joining Phatmass, the ones that openly voice the "all or none" option regarding literal interpretation of scripture are typically the vocal ones who typically try to bully others into submission to their interpretation.

Granted, knowing them in person face-to-face does defuse tensions.

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

Thank you all very much for your advice and support. I did not say anything at the two meetings there have been so far, because I wasn't sure what I was getting into exactly. When the next meeting comes, I know what it is I'll hvae to do. Thank you again for your advice and prayers: it really means a lot to me!

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...