Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Jewish Man Removed From Airplane For Praying


Recommended Posts

Posted

There have been a lot of folks recently removed for various reasons: panic attacks, drunkenness, even an autistic boy who got out of control.

Our 13 yr old son is PDD-NOS/ADHD (which is on the autism spectrum) and someday will be in that spot I am sure. He would be JUST the type to read the sign that says 'No weapons, knives, explosives etc' and SAY 'Hey I have an explosive!!!' on impulse. Since most flights don't have on-board psychiatric services, I think the prudent thing to do would be to get him off the plane.

Unfortunately for this Jewish man his rocking back and forth perhaps was done in the wrong place at the wrong time. Would it be appropriate for him to 'pray' (and by that I mean the rocking back and forth, not the mental prayer) during a Broadway play? During your wedding service? During surgery? When he is stopped for a traffic ticket? I think we underestimate the gravity of air travel---it has become serious business, not a bus ride. No doubt we will eventually be stripped to our bathing suits with no luggage someday--but certainly behavior which is erratic is a cause for concern in these post 9/11 times. I guess I do not blame the airlines---wow, have they been burned as of late, and when you think about it, they are still sitting ducks.

Posted

Nobody should be arrested for praying, whether they're Muslims, Jews, Christians, whatever. It doesn't matter if it "bothers" you or seems "conspicuous". Prayer is not a crime.

If it's somehow disruptive, then it would be acceptable to ask him to respect the other passengers.

But it shouldn't matter if he's a Jew or a Muslim. That's religious bigotry of the worst kind. What if he's an Arabic Christian praying the Angelus in Arabic, and kneels down to reverence the Incarnation?

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1057728' date='Sep 6 2006, 09:16 AM']
Nobody should be arrested for praying, whether they're Muslims, Jews, Christians, whatever. It doesn't matter if it "bothers" you or seems "conspicuous". Prayer is not a crime.

If it's somehow disruptive, then it would be acceptable to ask him to respect the other passengers.

But it shouldn't matter if he's a Jew or a Muslim. That's religious bigotry of the worst kind. What if he's an Arabic Christian praying the Angelus in Arabic, and kneels down to reverence the Incarnation?
[/quote]

Here Here!

Posted

I agree, praying is not a crime, but blocking the walkway, or banging the seat back, or incessant out loud chanting in a closed space, or lighting incense or whatever may cause disruption especially on a shiny silver tube 35,000 feet in the air where another traveler cannot excuse himself to leave.

I have had times where I could not get to my overhead luggage, and have used my God-given 10 fingers to pray a Rosary. That is my right. It is not my right to bang the seat back, or disturb my neighbor who is reading his work papers by saying the Rosary out loud, or break the airline rules at takeoff and get my overhead luggage out to get my Rosary beads.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1057752' date='Sep 6 2006, 11:05 AM']Here Here![/quote]i think you mean [color="red"]Hear Hear![/color]

anyway, i agree with Era as well.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...