Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

People Are Stupid....


Recommended Posts

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

So I was watching the Early Show on CBS while making sure the grade-school siblings were getting ready to get on the bus, and theres this story on about prenatal testing for Downs Syndrome and a family who chose to keep their baby despite finding out that she would have DS. AWESOME, right?

The story was cool because it put such a positive light on keeping your baby even if he might have a birth defect, as the mom said "Its still your baby and you still love it" (paraphrased). But there was a doctor they interviewed that said that she "Absolutely" offers "termination" to every parent who tests positive (which, I know pretty much all doctors do that, at least my doctors and midwives were always happy when I refused the tests and said no matter what I was keeping my baby).... it was just the way she said it. It ticked me off. She also said that up to 80% of people who test positive do abort their baby... which makes me sick to my stomach (in addition to the loss of innocent life) because I have known people who had false positives.

Then at the end of the story the reporter (I forget which one she is, I don't it watch often enough to know... some blonde woman) said how "Now women can have these tests done before they are showing, it can be done on an embryo even before they're pregnant!" I yelled at the TV, "You dumb***! If you've got an embryo in there you ARE pregnant!" (the kids weren't in the room...) I suppose her statement possibly could be true of women use IVF to conceive... but.... argh... the way she closed the story made me soooo annoyed! The family with the little girl with DS were so happy and put such a positive light on it all, even though the mom strongly advocated getting the test done it wasn't for the sake of aborting the baby if you found out your child would have a birth defect, it was to be better prepared to handle the demands of a special needs child if the test were positive.

Why do they have to ruin a perfectly good story like that? <_<

Posted
<_<


Those tests are not always accurate, either ... I had friends whose third baby tested positive for DS but he doesn't have it.
Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Wow! Maybe soon we'll have a test for blue eyes and red hair. How cool is that? Then, if the kiddo...er piece of tissue...has the potential to develop the wrong colors, ya just ..um...terminate the session and start again.


*ultimate disgust* :wacko: :ohno: :maddest: :annoyed:

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1057701' date='Sep 6 2006, 10:14 AM']
<_<
Those tests are not always accurate, either ... I had friends whose third baby tested positive for DS but he doesn't have it.
[/quote]

Yeah, I know some people who have had false positives, too. One of my Mom's friends got a false positive and she became so stressed out and upset worrying over how to deal with it and how to break the news to her husband when he got home that evening that she went into premature labor (remember they do these tests typically BEFORE week 20, usually around week 16 or 17). She wound up giving birth to a perfectly healthy baby girl (her first daughter after about 4 or 5 boys) who didn't survive the night because she was so premature. :ohno:

That, on top of the fact that I would never abort my child, convinces me that (for me) these tests are totally pointless and a waste of money.

Posted

I got the test during both of my pregnancies. Not because I wanted abortions, but rather, because if there was the possiblility of DS I wanted to be as informed as possible before my son or daughter was born. Frankly, I know next to nothing about DS, so I would have taken that time to research and find out what I may not have had time to find out after the birth.

franciscanheart
Posted
:maddest:



:sign: Lord, have mercy.
IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1057790' date='Sep 6 2006, 01:03 PM']
I got the test during both of my pregnancies. Not because I wanted abortions, but rather, because if there was the possiblility of DS I wanted to be as informed as possible before my son or daughter was born. Frankly, I know next to nothing about DS, so I would have taken that time to research and find out what I may not have had time to find out after the birth.
[/quote]


I'm totally cool with that, I have alot of respect for people who choose to go ahead with the testing for that reason (like the family on the news this morning)... but the other people out there... ARGH. Its optional for a reason. lol This would probably make me even more annoyed if it was mandatory!

KnightofChrist
Posted

I recall reading something from Britain where doctors suggest to mothers that their babies be aborted for something as silly as webfingers and toes... This is all the newage Nazism, the search for the "perfect human."

Posted
:ohno: For the sake of His sorrowful passion, have mercy on us and the whole world
she_who_is_not
Posted

I can hardly contain my anger when I hear about things like this. My two sisters have suffered two miscarriages and two ectopic pregnancies between them, and either would thank God for any child and give them the most loving home available. I am so sick of the culture of death!!!!

Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1057682' date='Sep 6 2006, 09:46 AM']
Why do they have to ruin a perfectly good story like that? <_<
[/quote]
Because the culture of death can't have anyone thinking that they may not want to murder their baby, Down's Syndrome or not.

I've worked with quite a few OB-GYNs, and they tend to be quite secular. No compunction about treating an unborn baby as a thing. I am scared about what I will be faced with when I get to my OB rotation.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I am sure when its your turn you will do everything you have to to stand your moral ground. There are "NFP only" doctors out there, but they are few and far between, and there are alot of us out there looking for them. You'll definately be in my prayers, I know your job won't be easy!

When my mom got home from work the kids tried explaining the news story to her... apparently all the 7 year old twins got out of it was "there was a lady who had a baby and something was wrong with her" and the 9 year old piped in and added her two cents, "she was mental" (with a sigh and eye rolling as if to say "You're hopeless"). After I explained the story to my mother her reaction was nearly exactly the same as mine, just worded a little differently (and she didn't call the newslady a dumb***).

Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1058083' date='Sep 6 2006, 07:40 PM']
I am sure when its your turn you will do everything you have to to stand your moral ground. There are "NFP only" doctors out there, but they are few and far between, and there are alot of us out there looking for them. You'll definately be in my prayers, I know your job won't be easy!
[/quote]
Unfortunately, I have to perform my rotation in a specific hospital. I don't get to choose who I study with. And I can't be forced to participate in any abortive act, I will not counsel a woman to have an abortion, even if my grade depended on it, but I am legally required to make a patient know what are her options under the law.

It's only a 4 week rotation (and after that 4 weeks I'll never have to think about OB again, but I just think that it's going to be very demoralizing to be in a place where I know that my beliefs are laughed upon, and where selfishness is king. I've been considering purchasing a saint medal to "protect" me, but I'm not too sure who to choose. Any ideas?

Posted

blessed gemma? i think?

nope, not it. i'll find her.

blessed gianna molla, find more about her here: [url="http://www.catholic-forum.com/SAINTS/saintgaq.htm"]http://www.catholic-forum.com/SAINTS/saintgaq.htm[/url]

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Blessed Gianna for sure, also St. Gerard Majella (I might be misspelling his last name) is the patron of expectant mothers...

And Our Lady of Guadalupe, I believe, is also a patron of the unborn.

Posted
:sick: i am feeling a bit ill from this... URP
Posted

I have heard tell that when my mother was pregnant with me, there was the possibility of Downs Syndrome. Well...it turns out that I did not have DS. That story really scares me. People are people. People should be alive and loved. I just feel a little shaken up. I probably would have beaten the TV with the cactus...

...or maybe not.

CoffeeCatholic
Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1058126' date='Sep 6 2006, 09:01 PM']
Blessed Gianna for sure, also St. Gerard Majella (I might be misspelling his last name) is the patron of expectant mothers...

And Our Lady of Guadalupe, I believe, is also a patron of the unborn.
[/quote]

and St. Gerard

Posted

80 percent... :ohno: simply terrible

it is great that the story tended to focus on the parent keeping thier child.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...