Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Is there an appropriate term to call a relationship that was annulled, or the parties involved?

Because most people just call it a previous marriage, and the ex-husband/ex-wife. But because they were not actually married, it doesn't seem like we should call it that. Especially because I think it encourages people to think of annulments as a "Catholic divorce".

Posted

The whole concept is a difficult one.

The way I explain it is that the annulment states there was no Sacrament there. The marriage existed as a civil contract but because of a defect the Sacrament was not present in the marriage. :idontknow: Maybe someone will have a better explanation

  • 3 weeks later...
Theologian in Training
Posted

That is a good question, and perhaps one that Church might look further into. As for right now, I would just say that they were civilly married, because they were. Otherwise, I don't know what else you could say.

On a similar topic, I just did my little Q&A for the parish about this topic, I don't know if can help, but I will paste it below.

In today’s readings, we see a lot about marriage. In fact, our first reading from Genesis is a reading commonly selected and recommended for couples in the Marriage Rite. However, in the Gospel, we see Jesus speak very strongly on the whole idea of Divorce, something, unfortunately, that seems to be quite common in today’s world. Yet, if a Catholic gets a divorce, a lot of confusion seems to abound and I think it has a lot to do with an unclear distinction or understanding between a Catholic marriage and a civil marriage. It is with this I am going to pose a very difficult question, and one that is a lot more complex then the simplified version I try to offer below.

[b]What is the difference between a divorce and an annulment?[/b]

In order to best understand this, we need to define three terms in their civil and religious context: marriage, divorce, and annulment.

Civilly a marriage is more or less a contract by which a man and woman decide to live as husband and wife. In the Catholic Church a marriage is different. [i]The Catechism of the Catholic Church[/i] defines it this way: “A covenant or partnership of life between a man and a woman, which is ordered to the well-being of the spouses for the procreation and upbringing of children. When validly contracted between two baptized people, marriage is a sacrament.”

There are a few key phrases I would like to point out. First, it is a covenant rather than a contract, which means, it is not a simple signing of a piece of paper, rather, as the [i]Catechism[/i] further defines: “It is a solemn agreement between human beings and God or between two human beings, a mutual commitment or guarantee.” And, it was by the establishment by Christ of the New Covenant, whereby He loved the Church like a bride that it was raised to the dignity of a sacrament. We read in Ephesians (5:25) “Husbands, love your wives, as Christ loved the Church.”

A civil divorce, according to dictionary.com is “a judicial declaration dissolving a marriage in whole or in part, esp. one that releases the husband and wife from all matrimonial obligations.” In the Catholic Church, quite simply, this does not exist.

Similarly, in the civil realm, as it were, there is no such thing as an annulment because they only recognize the contract between parties, rather than the covenantal relationship that is established. This is why it is only the Catholic Church that grants annulments.

The easiest way to understand the difference is to think of a divorce as dealing with the marriage as it is now and an annulment dealing with the marriage as it apparently occurred at the altar. The divorce does not even take the latter into consideration, because its primary focus is on the current relationship of the couple, which is obviously strained and seen to be irreconcilable. Incidentally, this is why legitimacy of children is not a factor.

The Catholic Church, on the other hand, sees all marriages as valid until proven otherwise, and will only seek an annulment of a marriage if there is the probability that indeed the marriage was not valid to begin with. Therefore, the main focus of the Church is to try to prove or disprove the validity of that marriage. This is why there really is no such thing as a “Catholic divorce” because, strictly speaking, it is not concerned with the current state of the couple, since they are usually divorced by that time anyway, rather, its concern is to determine whether the couple should have been married in the first place. This is why before being married in the Catholic Church the priest will ask what seem to be very strange questions, because he is trying to determine 1) that the couple is free to marry 2) that there are no impediments to that marriage, that is, nothing which would prevent them from being validly married and 3) that if they marry, they understand what is expected of them and the new obligations that marriage will entail.

I know that this may not cover everything, but I hope it offers a little insight into this very complex and difficult topic.

Fr. Brian

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...