Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

Is it a sin?

Posted

its a disease.

I almost died from it.

Is cancer a sin?

Posted

I am so angry at the future peeps for judging anorexia, when they've never had it. Its a mental illness people. Don't even get me started...I'm not going to post anymore in this thread because if I do it'd be inappropriate!!!!! :maddest: i'm not mad at you, op, just the future peeps who take the position of God and judge a mental illness. Puke on them.

Posted

[size=1]So you assume youd know what we would say?
[/size]

homeschoolmom
Posted

Who are these "future people"? Why not wait and see what people post before getting upset with them...?

Posted

I for one am the mom of a young girl who suffered with bulemia. In NO WAY is it sinful, it is a mental illness, and can be helped with appropriate treatment. Folks with eating disorders (and other mental illnesses) need our prayers not theoretcial judgement.

Peep, I am sorry for your suffering, I pray what you went through combined with your faith can aide the lives of others, and that your heart finds forgiveness for the ignorant who jump to conclusions of which you speak.

Posted

I think the question is: is the action sinful? To which the response would be affirmative: the action of intentionally starving yourself is sinful.

Those who have the mental disorder of anorexia nervosa are not culpable for this action, and thus they are not committing the sin. If someone does not have the mental disorder of anorexia nervosa but merely decides to starve themselves to unhealthy levels, then they would be culpable for that sin.

Mental disorders hinder the human will, and when our will is hindered through no fault of our own then we are incapable of committing/being deemed culpable for actual sin.

Domine ut Videam
Posted

am currently undecided........................

as of now i am confessing it, but now that i think about it more indepthly i suppose that it is more of a thing in my mind that i cannot control than a sin. I confess it though because i feel guilty even though i cannot stop myself and these actions.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

It never occured to me to ask this question. While I have never struggled with it one of my best friends battled with anorexia and bulemia through high school and college, and I can honestly say I do not for one second believe that its sinful for the very reasons Al stated. I spent alot of time with my friend in college trying to help her overcome her eating disorders, she has told me that if it weren't for me she probably wouldn't have been able to be as diligent about trying to stop those behaviors--the support really helped her through those times. She didn't actually stop until she'd gotten married and conceived her first child. I am pretty sure from time to time those thoughts still cross her mind but she resists for the sake of her kids and husband.

The thing to remember is, even though you wouldn't be morally culpable for it as a sin, you still must fight it. Its not ok just because its not a sin (refer again to Al's post)--culpability is lessened or negated, but its still harmful to you.

Posted

i carry the cross of Anxiety/OCD. much like anorexia, it is a mental illness out of one's control. i've asked countless people and priests who have said it is in no way, shape, or form a sin because it's something in your mind and out of your control. the mind is a powerful thing.

stay close to God and throw your cares on Him. He'll show you the way. (though it may be very very hard!) my prayers are with you!

peace & love in Christ,
mj

Posted (edited)

sorry...I'm very sensitive on this topic. Sorry I lost my temper. :idontknow:
Godbless you guys, I throw a rock and you give me a flower. You are so kind-hearted.

Yeah I had OCD and psychosis thats what caused it, it went away with prozac and time.

Edited by peep
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Thanks all for your input. I was just wondering if I needed to confess it, because when I went to confession I didn't even think of it because I'd never thought of the possibility of it being a sin. It's been a few years since I really struggled with it. So... I'm still not sure if I should confess it because, though I know I made the decision to not eat every time I had the option to do so, I'm not sure if it was the disease that [i]caused [/i] me to make that dicision in the beginning. I just remember being disgusted with food in general and hardly ever feeling hungry. I still can't help feeling that it was my fault, and that I allowed society to convince me I needed to keep losing weight, that I was disgusting, and that if I ate [i]anything [/i] I was a pig. :sadder:

So my question is... Confess it... or no? :idontknow:

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

If you feel really compelled to confess it I am sure it wouldn't hurt, but the priest is very likely to tell you the same thing we have. I think its probably better to confess it and soothe your conscience rather than let it plague you... but I don't think its necessary. Its up to you, really.

DiscerningSoul
Posted

I confess to confessing this to my confessor from time to time.
and all that the others have said he too told me.
I just feel so guitly sometimes.

Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1067061' date='Sep 19 2006, 07:16 PM']
If you feel really compelled to confess it I am sure it wouldn't hurt, but the priest is very likely to tell you the same thing we have. I think its probably better to confess it and soothe your conscience rather than let it plague you... but I don't think its necessary. Its up to you, really.
[/quote]




Yeah I think I will feel better if I do. I think it will help me to leave it in the past and move on. Thanks for the help. :)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

A few general guidelines:

1. Do not confess scrupulous sins. If you aren't certain it's a sin, then it's not a mortal sin, at least.

2. Diseases are not sins. However, if you willfully go along with them (for instance, you truly have the power to resist the urge to starve/vomit, but choose not to), or willingly refuse to get professional help, then you may be culpable for that (however, gauging that in any particular case is something that no one here is qualified to do; it is something best left for you to discern with your confessor).

3. Always be obedient to your confessor, except when what he tells you to do is without a doubt sinful.

4. Please seek professional help. People care about you. We don't want to change you; we want you to be healthy so that we can enjoy your presence (and so that you can enjoy life) all the more.

God bless,

Micah

fearundercontrol
Posted

I recently asked a priest I know a similar question, and I think what he told me is a pretty good guideline to follow. He said for things like this, confess whatever is on your heart, and leave it up to God to decide whether it's a sin or not.

Posted (edited)

I used to have nonpurging bulimia nervosa.

Try to approach it in a compassionate and positive way rather than out of fear or negativity. People with eating disorders or a history of them often have a tendency to beat themselves up out of self-hatred enough as it is. Rather focus on achieving wellness out of LOVE. Love of God, neighbor and yourself. One of the things I learned in my trials with this was that Jesus said, "Love your neighbor AS YOURSELF." God loves you without end, so consider yourself loved and worthy of love.

When I did decide to get well, I did go to confession -- and it was helpful. I try to approach confessing things out of my separating myself from love and out of motivation of love, instead of out of fear.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

I asked a priest about something similar, and he told me that it is better to confess it if I feel it may be a sin, than to not. Discernment is the key.

The priest may you that it is not a sin. Then at least you have it off your chest. If through discernment you feel that it is a sin, then you will be absolved and be done with it. :)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1068175' date='Sep 20 2006, 03:29 PM']
I asked a priest about something similar, and he told me that it is better to confess it if I feel it may be a sin, than to not. Discernment is the key.

The priest may you that it is not a sin. Then at least you have it off your chest. If through discernment you feel that it is a sin, then you will be absolved and be done with it. :)
[/quote]
Yes, but if you know that it's scrupulous, you shouldn't confess it.

St. Alphonsus de Liguori, Doctor of the Church, outranks your priest. :P: jk

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...