Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Religion Without Religion


Recommended Posts

Justified Saint
Posted

So what do you guys think of this whole "religion without religion" buisness (and likewise "theology without theology" and why not "God without God")? I think someone like John Caputo gives a wonderful phenomenological description of faith and the role of hermeneutics in religion, but I can't help think this is all in the service of some updated philosophical defense of agnosticism. And at the end of the day any notion of revelation is scoffed at and any understanding of God as Being, or even "beyond being" still is a metaphysical idol.

This stuff drives me crazy -- I know I need help. :smokey: :saint:

Posted

It sounds like a bunch of hogwash to me. If someone's pushing "religion w/out religion" it sounds like they've got emotional hangups.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I'm probably being mean but: Caputo is 10% cool insights, 40% copycat and 50% rhetoric. And don't be fooled into believing that he's a Catholic philosopher. He's a Catholic philosopher kind of like how John Kerry was going to be a Catholic president.

If the doctors of your church are Nietzsche, Heidegger and Derrida then I suppose Caputo may be your man.

It's sad too because there are many things that I think are cool about continental philosophy. It's just that some people have to bundle their presuppositions into a dogmatic system and pretend that they are in fact doing this to put an end to dogmatic systems.

I suppose you might say it is the tone of Caputo that rubs the wrong way more than anything. I'm convinced that if Gilson was still around he would mop the floor with Caputo.

Justified Saint
Posted

I think I agree with your assessment L_D. Caputo comes off a little (a lot) pretentious for my tastes. He does remind me of a heterodox version of Chesterton, except not nearly as witty and clever.

There is a decent amount that I like from reading some of Caputo, but like you it seems that he really wants it both ways -- to say something rather definitive all the while eschewing "orthodoxy" and "dogmatism". I'd say your percentages are just about right. People like this insist that one can only be so radical since one can never be free of history and culture. While the latter is true, it's absurd to think one can't be radically ahistorical coming up with "readings" and positions that often have little to do with the inherited tradition. In other words, if people want to go and invent their own religion then fine, but don't call it something that its not.

That said, when your church doctors do consist of the names on that list then I'd say Caputo does a lot for religion for those people.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...