tonyofpadua Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 So I was in church today (I go to a somewhat unorthodox, liberal, but quite Catholic church) and everything was more or less dandy until we got to the creed. The church did the Nicene creed, but I noticed something funny about what the woman behind me was saying... "...And in the Holy Spirit. the Lord, the Giver of Life, Who proceeds from the Father With the Father and the Son [i]SHE[/i] is worshipped and glorified [i]SHE[/i] has spoken through the Prophets..." So I'm like...what's going on here? This lady thinks the Holy Spirit is a female?! I know that the Holy Spirit is considered a "male." There's no question about that. I'm not sure if it's dogmatic or anything but I mean...let's be honest. We refer to the Holy Spirit as a He. My question is if any of you have heard f this before? Is it some underground feminist movement? Some ancient heresy? Or was this women just plain off her rocker? I'm dying to know. God Bless and Mary protect, Dan
Veritas Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 [quote name='tonyofpadua' post='1060566' date='Sep 10 2006, 10:06 PM'] So I was in church today (I go to a somewhat unorthodox, liberal, but quite Catholic church) and everything was more or less dandy until we got to the creed. The church did the Nicene creed, but I noticed something funny about what the woman behind me was saying... "...And in the Holy Spirit. the Lord, the Giver of Life, Who proceeds from the Father With the Father and the Son [i]SHE[/i] is worshipped and glorified [i]SHE[/i] has spoken through the Prophets..." So I'm like...what's going on here? This lady thinks the Holy Spirit is a female?! I know that the Holy Spirit is considered a "male." There's no question about that. I'm not sure if it's dogmatic or anything but I mean...let's be honest. We refer to the Holy Spirit as a He. My question is if any of you have heard f this before? Is it some underground feminist movement? Some ancient heresy? Or was this women just plain off her rocker? I'm dying to know. God Bless and Mary protect, Dan [/quote] + Totally inappropriate. Furthermore, the Priest should be leading the creed. Take this to Q & A to get a more complete answer from a clergyman.
heavenseeker Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 i wouldnt know, maybe she has a speech problem, maybe not. but deffenately ask in the Q&A board
Aloysius Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 she wasn't leading it, according to his post, she was in the pew behind him it is absolutely indefensible. there are some orthodox, or at least semi-orthodox until something definitive rules against it, theologies which describe the role of the Holy Spirit as embodying some of the quoteunquote "feminine" aspects of God within the Trinity... read Dr. Scott Hahn's stuff, he comes to this conclusion in his analogy of marriage as a mirror to the Trinity, but it is absolutely unacceptable to address the Holy Ghost as female; because God as a whole relates to the Human Race and specifically to His People in the Church as a bridgroom to a bride, and as such for proper prayer and belief we must refer to Him as masculine in all Three Persons. I personally even think Scott Hahn might go too far with that, but it is definitely going too far and borderline heretical to address God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, in anything but masculine terms. My anthropology professor (also a priest) was once saying mass for a group of nuns... and the whole lot of them were purposefully ommitting any gender-references to God... so he of course had to deal with that right in the middle of mass! needless to say, he ended up with a church full of crying liberal nuns on his hands
tonyofpadua Posted September 11, 2006 Author Posted September 11, 2006 Oh, the priest was most certainly leading the congregation in the recitation of the Creed. It was just this one woman behind me who was saying the stuff.
Era Might Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 Aside from why God is referred to with a masculine pronoun, it is absolutely not allowed to change the text of the Liturgy, let alone the creed. We have a creed for a reason, so that we have a sure norm to express our faith that is not subject to the whims and additions of your local parish.
cmotherofpirl Posted September 11, 2006 Posted September 11, 2006 [quote name='tonyofpadua' post='1060764' date='Sep 11 2006, 02:39 PM'] Oh, the priest was most certainly leading the congregation in the recitation of the Creed. It was just this one woman behind me who was saying the stuff. [/quote] theres always one nut in the crowd...
shortnun Posted September 12, 2006 Posted September 12, 2006 (edited) [quote name='CrossCuT' post='1060623' date='Sep 11 2006, 07:51 AM'] [/quote] [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1060977' date='Sep 11 2006, 06:45 PM'] theres always one nut in the crowd... [/quote] Please refrain from comments that are uncharitable and do not directly address the topic at hand. I cannot ask you to not laugh in the privacy of your own home. But it is my hope that I don't have read these things on the boards. Thanks! Edited September 12, 2006 by shortnun
cmotherofpirl Posted September 12, 2006 Posted September 12, 2006 [quote name='shortnun' post='1061065' date='Sep 11 2006, 10:55 PM'] Please refrain from comments that are uncharitable and do not directly address the topic at hand. I cannot ask you to not laugh in the privacy of your own home. But it is my hope that I don't have read these things on the boards. Thanks! [/quote] I was not uncharitable, and I was directly addressing the issue. Tony asked if she was off her rocker, and I responded. Anyone who deliberately alters the prayers of the Church first needs prayers. But if they are lost in their own personal issues and triy to rewrite the Creed to suit a personal agenda, then I consider them a feminist nut case.
shortnun Posted September 12, 2006 Posted September 12, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1061082' date='Sep 11 2006, 10:21 PM'] I was not uncharitable, and I was directly addressing the issue. Tony asked if she was off her rocker, and I responded. Anyone who deliberately alters the prayers of the Church first needs prayers. But if they are lost in their own personal issues and triy to rewrite the Creed to suit a personal agenda, then I consider them a feminist nut case. [/quote] The prayers for this woman is appropriate. But no one here has any idea what this woman's personal agenda is, or how she's been catechized. Thus no judgement of if she is "on" or "off" her rocker can be made. Sorry for the
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 12, 2006 Posted September 12, 2006 I think we have at least a little idea of how she's been catechized.
shortnun Posted September 12, 2006 Posted September 12, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1061177' date='Sep 12 2006, 05:22 AM'] I think we have at least a little idea of how she's been catechized. [/quote] Then I can't even begin to fathom what people around me are thinking about how I've been catechized.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now