Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Holy Spirit...


Recommended Posts

Posted

[b]This was originally posted in Open Mic but I was told to get an "official" answer here...[/b]

So I was in church today (I go to a somewhat unorthodox, liberal, but quite Catholic church) and everything was more or less dandy until we got to the creed. The church did the Nicene creed, but I noticed something funny about what the woman behind me was saying...

"...And in the Holy Spirit. the Lord, the Giver of Life,
Who proceeds from the Father
With the Father and the Son [i]SHE[/i] is worshipped and glorified
[i]SHE[/i] has spoken through the Prophets..."

So I'm like...what's going on here? This lady thinks the Holy Spirit is a female?!

I know that the Holy Spirit is considered a "male." There's no question about that. I'm not sure if it's dogmatic or anything but I mean...let's be honest. We refer to the Holy Spirit as a He.

My question is if any of you have heard f this before? Is it some underground feminist movement? Some ancient heresy? Or was this women just plain off her rocker? I'm dying to know.

God Bless and Mary protect,

Dan

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I've had similar experiences. For example I once went to a parish where the priest took the liberty of changing the creed for feminist reasons. Instead of saying "for us men and for our salvation" this priest would say "for ussss and for our salvation". I kind of chuckled actually because it was so silly.

Considering that this priests "associate pastor" was an older woman in street clothes (although a religious sister) I think it is safe to assume that this fellow was influenced that feminist revisionism.

My first assumption regarding your matter would be similar, namely that this woman has her own private version of the creed inspired by some sort of feminist revisionism.

The idea of the Holy Spirit as a feminine principle is in fact something that I've encountered in the literature of certain revisionists within the Church which to my mind strengthens my suspicion.
But knowing exactly where this woman was coming from is difficult as there are many different versions of this sort of thing out there. You have radical feminist theologians who prefer characterizing God as feminine across the board, or you may have people who relate the Holy Spirit to 'Sophia' and simply consider the Spirit to be a sort of mother within the Godhead along side the Father and the Son as well as a feminine principle in creation. One can even find different sorts of systematic defenses of these kind of view points.

Often times the systematic presentations are based on feminist scriptural hermeneutics and often focus on Old Testament imagery pertaining to the Spirit of God. There is also, in my experience, quite often an affinity toward Gnostic literature in these circles which often comes accompanied with a certain critique of early Christian history not unlike what you might expect from the Da Vinci Code.

But again, it is a complex and decentralized phenomenon so knowing much of anything about where this woman was coming from is impossible (at least with any certainty).

So I suppose I'll answer your questions:

"My question is if any of you have heard f this before?"
- Yes, see above.

"Is it some underground feminist movement?"
- I suppose you could describe it in this way, but its complex and multifaceted.

"Some ancient heresy?"
- It is often directly and explicitly connected with ancient heresies, but not necessarily.

"Or was this woman just plain off her rocker?"
- I doubt it. I'm sure she has just been influenced by literature and persons who have these sorts of view points and I suppose she believes she is doing the right thing by dissenting from the actual Creed in this way.

I would also like to note that there is a certain validity to the discussion of the application of feminine language to God and the Holy Spirit in particular. I'm not saying that I think we should be calling God 'She' or that the Creed should be revised to refer to the Spirit as 'She', but I don't believe that these trains of thought are absolutely without some thread of truth.

There is an orthodox approach which explores the theological meaning of masculinity and femininity in light of the authentic tradition, and then there are heterodox approaches which are more akin to new age and gnostic thought or secular radical feminist thought. The heterodox approaches are pretty much always bundled with the idea that the Church (and the tradition) is an oppressive patriarchal entity and that dissent and revision is necessary to liberate and elevate the truth of femininity. The decision to outright revise the Creed would suggest this spirit of heterodoxy.

You said: "I know that the Holy Spirit is considered a "male." There's no question about that. I'm not sure if it's dogmatic or anything but I mean...let's be honest. We refer to the Holy Spirit as a He."
- This is true, it is proper to refer to the Holy Spirit as 'He', but God is not gendered as we are so this type of language is more or less metaphorical in nature.
My problem is not with the discussion of the theological meaning of gender in light of God and His revelation, but rather the revisionary attitude which seeks to create a new Christianity.

There are feminine images in Scripture which pertain to God, and there are things in Christian tradition (notably the Syriac tradition) which make use of feminine imagery in expounding upon the mystery of God, and there are no doubt sweet theologians who have explored such topics in different ways (Soloviev, Kolbe, etc). But these facts alone do not by necessity lead to the feminist rebellion which seeks to overhaul and critique the tradition and bring about (in the worst cases) such things as priestesses and a gnostic revival.

As I said before, it is a complex phenomenon and it is not possible to lump everyone into convenient categories, but in my estimation it is mostly a dangerous and heterodox phenomenon. And changing the creed to suit our agendas is hardly appropriate behavior.

One thing that this phenomenon clearly says to me is that there is truly a need in our culture for more orthodox explorations of the theological meaning of femininity and masculinity. As long as people who have little respect for the Church are driving, it will only be a divisive and destructive movement.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...