Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Israel Henotheistic


Recommended Posts

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

What do you think of claims that early on in Biblical times, the Israelites were henotheistic? That as revelation continued that figured out there was only one God. Evidence to support such a claim is given in verses where God is called "God of gods" and "Lord of lords," etc.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

It's a pretty plausible model actually. It has been argued in various ways too. Personally I find it to be consistent with the Catholic teaching regarding Divine pedagogy and don't see it as at odds with orthodoxy. Although I would prefer to say that God revealed more and more of His truth to the Israelites rather than saying that they "figured it out".

When studied closely, there are discernable differences in the understanding of God expressed from the earlier books up to the prophets and finally the wisdom literature. And I'm sure no one here would deny that the messianic age brought with it a deeper understanding of God.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I thought it made sense to. It struck me odd when I heard it because I've never seen that said before. Would you say that the author of Genesis' intent was a henotheistic God when he writes that God said "let us" etc., but that the Divine purpose of the text was actually a preparation for the Trinity?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='1064209' date='Sep 16 2006, 10:58 AM']
I thought it made sense to. It struck me odd when I heard it because I've never seen that said before. Would you say that the author of Genesis' intent was a henotheistic God when he writes that God said "let us" etc., but that the Divine purpose of the text was actually a preparation for the Trinity?
[/quote]
I wouldn't necessarily say that, but it’s been put forth many times. On the surface it seems like a simple hypothesis and seems more likely than suggesting the original author was intending to hint at the Trinity. But I don't know how much we can say either way about the 'original author's intention'. As far as I see it the primary author is the Holy Spirit and the question of the Spirit's intent is more interesting to me.

But if one did want to get at the original author's meaning I suppose you'd have a lot on your plate as the text would have to be examined from a variety of perspectives. For example source criticism: it is a common view that Genesis 1 & 2 is a redaction of at least two distinct creation accounts presumably from different time periods and representing two different understanding of God. I personally do not find this theory to be radically compelling, but one must admit that it is plausible. This type of view is often coupled with the idea that the Elohist understanding of God was for the most part henotheistic, but the Yahwist understanding was more a more strict monotheism.

I think the heart of the argument for the view you express is based on a combination of historical and textual critical assumptions. Put simplistically it goes something like this: we know from extra-biblical sources that 'El' referred originally to the highest god in the Canaanite pantheon, and the word 'Elohim' in ancient sources has a plural meaning and can refer to the Canaanite pantheon as a whole (the family of El), thus it is deduced that the statement you quoted probably refers to Divinity in a polytheistic or henotheistic sense.

Well, that's a really simplistic way of putting it, I'm sure there are many complex and detailed studies of Genesis that go far beyond my little presentation, but you get the idea. And I'm sure there are many good criticisms of this view and that it could make for a very stimulating discussion.

It has been a long time since I've looked into these sorts of matters so I can't really say I actually have my own conclusive view on the matter. The most I would say at this point is that the view you put forth is plausible and can be quite intelligently argued, but its still just a theory.

I find modern critical biblical scholarship to be very fascinating and thought provoking, but as a general rule I tend to take it with a grain of salt, and many of the basic questions and presuppositions do not interest me all that much..

Oh, and I should note that deriving conclusions based on supposed links between Canaanite and Israelite religion can be quite dubious as it is quite easy to mistake linguistic similarities (they both spoke semitic languages) with actual religious connections. It's a very suspect approach in my opinion.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

Excellent post. Thank you, L_D.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...