Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Italian Nun Killed By Muslims


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/africa/09/17/somalia.nun.reut/index.html"]http://www.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/africa/09/17...reut/index.html[/url]

Enough is enough.

Muslims are the great evil of the devil

puellapaschalis
Posted

It is a long stretch to say that "Muslims", with no qualification to the term whatsoever, are "evil". Study their religion and their doctrines. Compare them with ours. Find faults in them where they don't measure up. State, if God wants you to, [i]in all Christian love and charity[/i], these differences in the comparison.

If those sources are morally opposed to the laws given to us by God, then - given a suitable situation and atmosphere - it might be justifiable to call it "evil".

But you would need to have much, much more clout than that to use the latter term with reference to a whole swathe of people, many of whom would condemn and be saddened and outraged by this murder just as much as we are.

Using blanket generalisations and acting on impulsive reactions reflects badly not only on the person doing it but also on those who share his faith. Let's not fall into that trap: let's not lower ourselves to the actions taken by hot-headed people who overreacted in the past few days.

Love and prayers,

PP

Posted

They are pagans.

Their "faith" and their god (allah) is based on a pagan worship of the moon.

mohamed was and is a fraud and followers of this "faith" have never been peaceful.

I have lived with these devil worshippers in NYC for years and we have felt their handiwork from 1988 (Pan Am, then 1993 bombing of the towers to 9/11 when they were celebrating on NYC streets when the towers fell).

They are the enemies of the Jews.

They are nothing more than a violent cult that are now achieving what they couldn't during the crusades, they are doing throughh imigration.

Please see one of their "clerics" putting out a demand that the Pope be hunted down and killed.

May St. Michael come down with his sword heavy on these heathens.

[quote name='puellapaschalis' post='1065194' date='Sep 17 2006, 02:08 PM']
It is a long stretch to say that "Muslims", with no qualification to the term whatsoever, are "evil". Study their religion and their doctrines. Compare them with ours. Find faults in them where they don't measure up. State, if God wants you to, [i]in all Christian love and charity[/i], these differences in the comparison.

If those sources are morally opposed to the laws given to us by God, then - given a suitable situation and atmosphere - it might be justifiable to call it "evil".

But you would need to have much, much more clout than that to use the latter term with reference to a whole swathe of people, many of whom would condemn and be saddened and outraged by this murder just as much as we are.

Using blanket generalisations and acting on impulsive reactions reflects badly not only on the person doing it but also on those who share his faith. Let's not fall into that trap: let's not lower ourselves to the actions taken by hot-headed people who overreacted in the past few days.

Love and prayers,

PP
[/quote]

puellapaschalis
Posted

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065384' date='Sep 18 2006, 02:26 AM']They are pagans.[/quote]

It would depend on how you define "pagan", but I could agree with you on this one.

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065384' date='Sep 18 2006, 02:26 AM']Their "faith" and their god (allah) is based on a pagan worship of the moon.[/quote]

I really don't know enough about Islam to be able to voice my agreement with this or not. I trust that you, however, do.

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065384' date='Sep 18 2006, 02:26 AM']mohamed was and is a fraud and followers of this "faith" have never been peaceful.[/quote]

Whilst I don't want to comment on your first statement here, I can provide you with about thirty counter-examples to your second assertion. They are the Muslims I've come into contact with who are very peace-loving, kind and gentle people.

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065384' date='Sep 18 2006, 02:26 AM']I have lived with these devil worshippers in NYC for years and we have felt their handiwork from 1988 (Pan Am, then 1993 bombing of the towers to 9/11 when they were celebrating on NYC streets when the towers fell).[/quote]

Yes, I remember both events quite vividly. I'm not sure, however, that you can safely accuse [i]all[/i] Muslims living in New York City for being responsible for [i]both[/i] attacks.

Furthermore, Islam is not about "devil worship". The Catechism states that they worship the God of Abraham, which is the same God whom we also worship. To refer to "their" God, then, as "devil" is blasphemy.

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065384' date='Sep 18 2006, 02:26 AM']They are the enemies of the Jews.[/quote]

From the little I know of Islam, Jews are to be respected as "People of the Book". To be sure, [i]some[/i] Muslims in Palestine (and perhaps other places in the world) will hold a grudge against the Israeli state, and perhaps against Jews in general, but you cannot extrapolate this so that it holds for [i]every single Muslim out there[/i].

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065384' date='Sep 18 2006, 02:26 AM']They are nothing more than a violent cult that are now achieving what they couldn't during the crusades, they are doing throughh imigration.[/quote]

Once again, I suspect that you are abusing language here. What do you mean by "They"? If you mean "all Muslims" then you are doing my thirty friends and acquaintances (at the very least) an injustice and slandering them, not to mention something about lacking charity.

If you are only referring to a particular subset of them, then I firmly believe that you should use appropriate qualifiers to make this clear.

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065384' date='Sep 18 2006, 02:26 AM']Please see one of their "clerics" putting out a demand that the Pope be hunted down and killed.[/quote]

Again, you would do better to distinguish between a) what the religion teaches and b) what some extremists are saying. Sometimes these things overlap. But by simply casting a loose statement over the entire set of Muslim people is unfair to them, especially if a) and b) only partially overlap.

Choice of language and mode of expression is hugely important in this (and many other) debates. A poor choice will make us [i]no better than the extremists who are calling for the Holy Father's head on a plate themselves[/i]. Show yourself better than them - pray first, and then write something calm, collected and reasonable.

Love and prayers,

PP

Posted

the problem with Islam is that its a Christian heresy thats gotten violent. Not all muslims are evil but there is alot of evil in Islam. Call it what it is. But I agree- complete blanket generalizations are not true at all

Posted

Sometimes people around here need to sit back and realize that just because some people in a group did something bad that the entire group isn't bad. Catholics kill people too yet we like em okay. Calm down and think.

puellapaschalis
Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1065415' date='Sep 18 2006, 03:14 AM']
Sometimes people around here need to sit back and realize that just because some people in a group did something bad that the entire group isn't bad. Catholics kill people too yet we like em okay. Calm down and think.
[/quote]

Sometimes I'm much too wordy. Thanks for your concise version!

Love and prayers,

PP

Posted

The irony in this situation is that violence will probably break out in the Muslim world and some would see these remarks made by our Pope as true. (As violence shown by linkage galore)

The Pope commented upon a statement by the Byzantine emperor who said, “Show me just what Muhammad brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached.”

Repeating those statements was very unfortunate but so would be the violent outrage in the Muslim world. That violent outrage would only support the notion that Islam religion is violent. If they are trying to come across as non-violent, they could have fooled me.

The truth is Islamic extremists do exist. They are causing great harm to innocent women and children by their actions and are causing generalized and misplaced anger against Muslims who do not believe their religion advocates violence. In my opinion, if the Pope does believe that extremist Islamic practitioners are indeed acting violently due to their religion, he should speak out and state so. This Pope is the one who closed the cafeteria to Catholics!

If the moderate Islam leaders believe that the extremists are dangerous and hurting their own cause, they also should scream out loud. This is thier chance to show MANY in the world that there are Muslims out there who oppose violence and should demand that they live peacefully.

Violence in the streets will only support a bad conception and a general blanket statement. But what will have an even bigger impact on a bad conception of the Muslim faith are those who are too sheepish to stand up for their religion by denouncing those who are destroying it.

Let us pray that those who promote peace may take a stand.

Posted

[quote]A sister of the Consolata Missionaries in Italy said in statements to Reuters that the congregation has "no reason" to believe that the Italian nun's murder took place in protest against Benedict XVI's discourse on Tuesday at the University of Regensburg.

Speculation has arisen in the media, however, in light of an appeal launched on Saturday by a religious leader of Mogadishu to all Muslims to revenge the interpretation given to the Pope's words.

Sheikh Muktar Robow, deputy security chief of Supreme Islamic Council of Somalia (SICS), said in a statement to Missionary International Service News Agency: "We condemn the killing of the nun."

"It was barbaric and contrary to the teachings of Islam," he added.

[url="http://zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=94986"]http://zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=94986[/url][/quote]

[quote]Archbishop Charles Bo of Yangon said in comments to ZENIT that he is "sad to hear the misunderstandings of our brother Muslims" regarding the statements the Holy Father made Tuesday at the University of Regensburg.

The archbishop continued: "Benedict XVI was making a very clear statement, that violence is not compatible with the nature of God. Violence and killing is contrary to the nature of God.

...

"In this the Pope has fully expressed the sentiment and desire of millions of Muslims who in one way or another, say: 'Violence and Islam cannot be related,'" he added.

The archbishop said that Benedict XVI "said that many Muslims say: 'We are Muslims and we want to be Muslim believers in today's world and against those who use religion to strike at others with violence. Religion cannot be the foundation of a conflict, a war, or any other kind of violence.'"

[url="http://zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=94988"]http://zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=94988[/url][/quote]

Posted

I nominate Era Might for Man of the year.

Posted

Kill all those INFIDELS OF THE POPE! We're not violent as he has accused us!

Your not dealing with rational people.

Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='1065593' date='Sep 17 2006, 08:51 PM']
I nominate Era Might for Man of the year.
[/quote]


here, here.

thanks Era Might for the links.

Posted (edited)

What is up with some catholics and this "kumbaya" attitude!? affraid to call evil, evil, sin, sin and fallacy, fallacy! Where has it gotten us? Especially in america? gay priests, thousands of dissenters, new agers, liberals! Wake up! Stop acting like we are going to get exxcomunicated for dissagreeing with candy coated catholicsm!

We are being attacked here and Catholics are being killed and our pope has been threatened!

Edited by Akalyte
Posted

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1066273' date='Sep 18 2006, 08:51 PM']
What is up with some catholics and this "kumbaya" attitude!? affraid to call evil, evil, sin, sin and fallacy, fallacy! Where has it gotten us? Especially in america? gay priests, thousands of dissenters, new agers, liberals! Wake up! Stop acting like we are going to get exxcomunicated for dissagreeing with candy coated catholicsm!
[/quote]
Because the "kumbaya" attitude is easy. To allow oneself to be run over (figuratively or physically) is easy. You don't have to do anything, just sit and feel warm and fuzzy.

Posted

You Finalize words of the murdered sister S. Leonella Sgorbati: I forgive, I forgive, I forgive.

Posted

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1066273' date='Sep 18 2006, 06:53 PM']
What is up with some catholics and this "kumbaya" attitude!? affraid to call evil, evil, sin, sin and fallacy, fallacy! Where has it gotten us? Especially in america? gay priests, thousands of dissenters, new agers, liberals! Wake up! Stop acting like we are going to get exxcomunicated for dissagreeing with candy coated catholicsm!

We are being attacked here and Catholics are being killed and our pope has been threatened!
[/quote]
Calm down for a second there...

I agree that a lot of Catholics are afraid to promote what they believe. This is perhaps my most horrible sin.


But telling us to wake up and shooting from the hip is not the way to go. I've read this wole thread and I don't see much that can be interpreted as "kumbaya." Certainly nothing over which to flip out.

Clarifying that all Muslims are not murderers is not candycoating the situation, it's just true. It isn't making excuses for what happened. It doesn't even justify the religion of Islam. It's just an attempt to avoid a false generalization. Indeed, generalizations are all wrong. Including this one about generalization all being wrong.

I understand your frustration, but be careful. Even Jesus' righteous anger was relatively rare, and very well calculated.

puellapaschalis
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1066384' date='Sep 19 2006, 05:21 AM']
Calm down for a second there...

I agree that a lot of Catholics are afraid to promote what they believe. This is perhaps my most horrible sin.
But telling us to wake up and shooting from the hip is not the way to go. I've read this wole thread and I don't see much that can be interpreted as "kumbaya." Certainly nothing over which to flip out.

Clarifying that all Muslims are not murderers is not candycoating the situation, it's just true. It isn't making excuses for what happened. It doesn't even justify the religion of Islam. It's just an attempt to avoid a false generalization. Indeed, generalizations are all wrong. Including this one about generalization all being wrong.

I understand your frustration, but be careful. Even Jesus' righteous anger was relatively rare, and very well calculated.
[/quote]

Well said. To react with impulsive, misguided anger is to stoop just as low as those who have done so, threatening the Holy Father and failing to use their common sense. Christianity is better than that, and thus we are called to be better than that.

Love and prayers,

PP

Posted

You can say a lot about the muslim faith and be correct. You cannot say that they are pagans. In a nutshell, pagans believe that they can control the actions of their gods. This is not true of the muslim faith.

Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1066384' date='Sep 18 2006, 11:21 PM']
Calm down for a second there...

I agree that a lot of Catholics are afraid to promote what they believe. This is perhaps my most horrible sin.
But telling us to wake up and shooting from the hip is not the way to go. I've read this wole thread and I don't see much that can be interpreted as "kumbaya." Certainly nothing over which to flip out.

Clarifying that all Muslims are not murderers is not candycoating the situation, it's just true. It isn't making excuses for what happened. It doesn't even justify the religion of Islam. It's just an attempt to avoid a false generalization. Indeed, generalizations are all wrong. Including this one about generalization all being wrong.

[/quote]

:thumbsup:

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1066273' date='Sep 18 2006, 08:53 PM']
What is up with some catholics and this "kumbaya" attitude!? affraid to call evil, evil, sin, sin and fallacy, fallacy! Where has it gotten us? Especially in america? gay priests, thousands of dissenters, new agers, liberals! Wake up! Stop acting like we are going to get exxcomunicated for dissagreeing with candy coated catholicsm!

We are being attacked here and Catholics are being killed and our pope has been threatened!
[/quote]


[quote name='CameBackHome' post='1066275' date='Sep 18 2006, 08:54 PM']
Because the "kumbaya" attitude is easy. To allow oneself to be run over (figuratively or physically) is easy. You don't have to do anything, just sit and feel warm and fuzzy.
[/quote]

XIX is right, Islam itself is nothing to defend in any way, but most Muslims throughout the world are not radicals... they simply are Muslims because their parents, grandparents and so on were all of that religion and they know nothing else. Many of these people are trying their best to lead a good life with the few kernals of truth their religion does offer.
And I could not possibly define recognition of this fact as a "kumbaya" attitude. As far as I know, Catholics are called to love even the most radical terrorists (although this [i]does not[/i] mean condoning their actions out of a misguided sensitivity), not condemn the [i]people[/i] as the great "evil of the devil"

Posted

[quote name='StMichael' post='1065132' date='Sep 17 2006, 03:00 PM']
[url="http://www.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/africa/09/17/somalia.nun.reut/index.html"]http://www.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/africa/09/17...reut/index.html[/url]

Enough is enough.

Muslims are the great evil of the devil
[/quote]
The extremists have proved as much, haven’t they?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...