avemaria40 Posted September 17, 2006 Posted September 17, 2006 OK, so I'm a girl, but there are days when I don't feel like one, I'm loud, I laugh loudly at the most inopportune moments, I have messy handwriting, and I rarely wear skirts (though I like to dress nice, wear makeup, and jewelry). I have a guy's sense of humor and there are days when I'd rather hang with guys than girls. I even end up relating more to my dad and my brother than my mom and my sister at times. I feel I don't fit into what society tells me a girl should be. I also want to be a doctor and get married and have kids, I feel I am called to both things but I've been told that women always have to stay home if she has kids, even if they are in school. That makes me mad because I know women who are excellent wives and mothers and who still go to work when their kids are in school. One of the most Catholic women I know is married, has five kids, and she was my chemistry teacher last year. Also, St. Gianna Molla was still a doctor, even when she got married and had children. But guys at school always yell at me and my girlfriends because we want to work, I want to be a doctor, another friend wants to be a psychologist, and the guys are always like, why would you do that when you can play with kids all day? And I'm thinking, just because a woman works does not make her a bad Catholic or a bad mother. If a woman is called to stay home with kids, that's awesome. If a woman is called to work and have kids, that's awesome too. I'm sick of people judging women based on whether they stay home or not. Working does not automatically cut a woman off from God. My mom and dad work now and I don't resent my mom for deciding to work. She would die for us if she had to! I don't think it's fair that women are judged like this. OK, I"m done. Thanks for letting me rant
annehladik Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='avemaria40' post='1065393' date='Sep 17 2006, 08:43 PM'] OK, so I'm a girl, but there are days when I don't feel like one, I'm loud, I laugh loudly at the most inopportune moments, I have messy handwriting, and I rarely wear skirts (though I like to dress nice, wear makeup, and jewelry). I have a guy's sense of humor and there are days when I'd rather hang with guys than girls. I even end up relating more to my dad and my brother than my mom and my sister at times. I feel I don't fit into what society tells me a girl should be. I also want to be a doctor and get married and have kids, I feel I am called to both things but I've been told that women always have to stay home if she has kids, even if they are in school. That makes me mad because I know women who are excellent wives and mothers and who still go to work when their kids are in school. One of the most Catholic women I know is married, has five kids, and she was my chemistry teacher last year. Also, St. Gianna Molla was still a doctor, even when she got married and had children. But guys at school always yell at me and my girlfriends because we want to work, I want to be a doctor, another friend wants to be a psychologist, and the guys are always like, why would you do that when you can play with kids all day? And I'm thinking, just because a woman works does not make her a bad Catholic or a bad mother. If a woman is called to stay home with kids, that's awesome. If a woman is called to work and have kids, that's awesome too. I'm sick of people judging women based on whether they stay home or not. Working does not automatically cut a woman off from God. My mom and dad work now and I don't resent my mom for deciding to work. She would die for us if she had to! I don't think it's fair that women are judged like this. OK, I"m done. Thanks for letting me rant [/quote] You should inform your friends at school that medical school classes are now 50:50 male:female. And it's entirely possible to be a doctor and have children. After I graduate, my husband will be staying home with the children. That's always an option. There are also many women who practice medicine part time. Many women split their residencies with other women so that their schedule isn't so demanding, and continue to work part time in private practices after they complete their training. Many have children while they're in school. I have a student colleague right now who is pregnant, she did her surgery rotation 5 and 6 months pregnant. Some take a year off from school to have their babies. I'll be having my first baby in my 2nd year of residency (my husband and I practice NFP currently). So in short, I would advise you not to listen to your classmates. You need to do what will make you happy. Maybe you'll be a doctor, and that would be wonderful. Maybe you'll decide that you want to do something else in a few years, and that's wonderful also. But listen to yourself and not others.
avemaria40 Posted September 18, 2006 Author Posted September 18, 2006 Thanks you guys:) I have to realize that what other people say doesn't matter. Unfortunately, I care too much about what other people think of me:(
annehladik Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='avemaria40' post='1065405' date='Sep 17 2006, 09:02 PM'] Thanks you guys:) I have to realize that what other people say doesn't matter. Unfortunately, I care too much about what other people think of me:( [/quote] It takes time to stop caring about what other people think of you. However, it's essential for happiness. If you spend your life trying to get other people to like you, then you'll spend your entire life miserable...and the people you changed yourself for still won't like you. Be yourself, and become comfortable with the fact that you can't have everyone approve of you, and that you don't need it anyway. And you'll find how happy it makes you.
CrossCuT Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [size=1]So what if people pee themselves when you say you want to be a doctor. DO WHAT YOU WANT! [/size]
avemaria40 Posted September 18, 2006 Author Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='CrossCuT' post='1065417' date='Sep 17 2006, 09:15 PM'] [size=1]So what if people pee themselves when you say you want to be a doctor. DO WHAT YOU WANT! [/size] [/quote] lol, thanks, I needed that
Era Might Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 I'm hesitant to reply, because what you do with your life is between you, God, and your spouse. But, I think there is validity to the traditional concept that mothers stay at home, because motherhood is a vocation. Priests, for example, do not work a separate job outside of the parish, because their duty is to the parish. In the same way, I think it is most beneficial for the family when the mother devotes herself to that vocation. I know women may want to achieve professional goals, but every vocation entails sacrifice. How many Priests would like to have the comfort of a wife and a family? They sacrifice a great good for their vocation. It's an example for all of us in our respective vocations. But, like I said, what you do is your business, and I wouldn't presume to say you're a bad mother or not sufficiently feminine because of it. And of course, necessity is always an exception here, when a mother has to work for the material support of the family.
IcePrincessKRS Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1065454' date='Sep 17 2006, 09:50 PM'] I'm hesitant to reply, because what you do with your life is between you, God, and your spouse. But, I think there is validity to the traditional concept that mothers stay at home, because motherhood is a vocation. Priests, for example, do not work a separate job outside of the parish, because their duty is to the parish. In the same way, I think it is most beneficial for the family when the mother devotes herself to that vocation. I know women may want to achieve professional goals, but every vocation entails sacrifice. How many Priests would like to have the comfort of a wife and a family? They sacrifice a great good for their vocation. It's an example for all of us in our respective vocations. But, like I said, what you do is your business, and I wouldn't presume to say you're a bad mother or not sufficiently feminine because of it. And of course, necessity is always an exception here, when a mother has to work for the material support of the family. [/quote] I don't disagree, but I also understand where Ave is coming from... and who's to say that she' ll get married and start having kids "young" (ie., in her early 20s or so)? A girl's gotta do something to support herself in the meantime, and if need be support her family when the time comes. I don't work because I choose not to. I am lucky to have that option, but many women don't. What irks me is the women who go back to work when they don't have to and stick their kids in daycare just because they want to be "free and independent." Sorry, but thats not what marriage and parenthood is about. (Sorry, total pet peeve of mine... I quit going to secular mothering forums because so many women on there were like that... that and contraceptive mentalities abound in those places.) I guess my point is, if working isn't taking you away from your duty to your family I don't have any problem with it. Working while the kids are in school is totally acceptable to me, especially if their dad is a stay at home/work at home dad, and even if he's not as long as you're there for the kids when they get off the bus its all good.
ardillacid Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='avemaria40' post='1065393' date='Sep 17 2006, 07:43 PM'] OK, so I'm a girl, but there are days when I don't feel like one, I'm loud, I laugh loudly at the most inopportune moments, I have messy handwriting, and I rarely wear skirts (though I like to dress nice, wear makeup, and jewelry). I have a guy's sense of humor and there are days when I'd rather hang with guys than girls. I even end up relating more to my dad and my brother than my mom and my sister at times. I feel I don't fit into what society tells me a girl should be. I also want to be a doctor and get married and have kids, I feel I am called to both things but I've been told that women always have to stay home if she has kids, even if they are in school. That makes me mad because I know women who are excellent wives and mothers and who still go to work when their kids are in school. One of the most Catholic women I know is married, has five kids, and she was my chemistry teacher last year. Also, St. Gianna Molla was still a doctor, even when she got married and had children. But guys at school always yell at me and my girlfriends because we want to work, I want to be a doctor, another friend wants to be a psychologist, and the guys are always like, why would you do that when you can play with kids all day? And I'm thinking, just because a woman works does not make her a bad Catholic or a bad mother. If a woman is called to stay home with kids, that's awesome. If a woman is called to work and have kids, that's awesome too. I'm sick of people judging women based on whether they stay home or not. Working does not automatically cut a woman off from God. My mom and dad work now and I don't resent my mom for deciding to work. She would die for us if she had to! I don't think it's fair that women are judged like this. OK, I"m done. Thanks for letting me rant [/quote] You aren't ranting against society. You are ranting against the Church's traditional view of women
annehladik Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1065469' date='Sep 17 2006, 10:07 PM'] I guess my point is, if working isn't taking you away from your duty to your family I don't have any problem with it. Working while the kids are in school is totally acceptable to me, especially if their dad is a stay at home/work at home dad, and even if he's not as long as you're there for the kids when they get off the bus its all good. [/quote] Exactly. Fatherhood is as important a role as motherhood...and who is anyone to suggest that motherhood should be a woman's only role? As a woman who will not be a homemaker, I have nothing but the utmost respect for women who stay home with their children. It's hard work. However, God has called me to be not only a mother, but also a doctor who heals children with cancer. And no one is going to convince me that following this calling will make me a neglectful wife or mother. Frankly, if I know that I have the talent and will to do such a thing as what I aim for, then it's selfish and neglectful for me not to pursue it. No, I won't be home with my children all the time, but their father genuinely wants to stay home with them, and I love him for it. And I know that what matters is not the number of minutes that I spend with my children, but the quality of parenthood I provide for them. So I join you in again urging avemaria40 to do what is going to fulfill her life.
IcePrincessKRS Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='CameBackHome' post='1065483' date='Sep 17 2006, 10:19 PM'] and who is anyone to suggest that motherhood should be a woman's only role? [/quote] This is the only thing I take issue with; I would say "parenthood" rather than "motherhood" because no one can truly fill the role of Mommy other than Mommy--not even Daddy (not to minimalize the role that he plays, because its a big one, especially if he is the main caregiver). Some people make it seem like [b]parenting[/b] is the mom's job (that annoys me, too), which is obviously not the case at all, the dad should be parenting, too.
Era Might Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 (edited) John Paul's Apostolic Letter, "Mulieris Dignitatem", deals with the vocation of women. Good stuff. [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_letters/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_15081988_mulieris-dignitatem_en.html"][u]Link[/u][/url] [quote]A woman is strong because of her awareness of this entrusting, strong because of the fact that God "entrusts the human being to her", always and in every way, even in the situations of social discrimination in which she may find herself. This awareness and this fundamental vocation speak to women of the dignity which they receive from God himself, and this makes them "strong" and strengthens their vocation. Thus the "perfect woman" (cf. Prov 31:10) becomes an irreplaceable support and source of spiritual strength for other people, who perceive the great energies of her spirit. These "perfect women" are owed much by their families, and sometimes by whole nations.[/quote] Edited September 18, 2006 by Era Might
annehladik Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1065490' date='Sep 17 2006, 10:31 PM'] This is the only thing I take issue with; I would say "parenthood" rather than "motherhood" because no one can truly fill the role of Mommy other than Mommy--not even Daddy (not to minimalize the role that he plays, because its a big one, especially if he is the main caregiver). Some people make it seem like [b]parenting[/b] is the mom's job (that annoys me, too), which is obviously not the case at all, the dad should be parenting, too. [/quote] Now my brain is a little addled by lack of sleep, so I've got to say that I'm not understanding the semantic distinction in your first sentence. But I don't think that we're in disagreement, by any means. Must...get...sleep.
IcePrincessKRS Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 I draw a distinction between mothering and parenting. Parenting is a 2 person job. I must be tired, too, because I'm having some trouble finding the exact words I want to use... so, I'm turning to the dictionary for a little clarification. lol Parenting: 1. the rearing of children: The schedule allows her very little time for parenting. 2. the methods, techniques, etc., used or required in the rearing of children: a course in parenting. 3. the state of being a parent; parenthood. –adjective 4. of or concerned with the rearing of children: good parenting skills. When I say parenting I mean raising the children; parenting is not a job that belongs solely to mothers. When I say mothering I mean the special sort of nurturing that comes only from mothers... I still am not finding the right words to explain exactly what I mean when I say mothering. We probably don't disagree, I'm just not comfortable with using the term "mothering" in place of "parenting" because I think it gives the wrong idea/message.
Norseman82 Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 These days it's a blessing just to have both your parents in the same house...
Claudine Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='Norseman82' post='1065582' date='Sep 17 2006, 09:37 PM'] These days it's a blessing just to have both your parents in the same house... [/quote] that is so true.
XIX Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='avemaria40' post='1065393' date='Sep 17 2006, 06:43 PM'] OK, so I'm a girl, but there are days when I don't feel like one, I'm loud, I laugh loudly at the most inopportune moments, I have messy handwriting, and I rarely wear skirts (though I like to dress nice, wear makeup, and jewelry). I have a guy's sense of humor and there are days when I'd rather hang with guys than girls. I even end up relating more to my dad and my brother than my mom and my sister at times. I feel I don't fit into what society tells me a girl should be. [/quote] Yea I hear you totally. I'm a guy but I don't like beer, I'd rather hang with girls, I'm very affectionate, I don't like Braveheart or bloody movies in general, etc. And I can relate to my Mom better than my Dad...by a lot, in fact. I don't think any of those things really violate your femininity (or my masculenity) because that's all stuff that society kinda invented. While gender roles are very biblical, I don't think any of the above is actually in the Bible. I wanna screwdriver. [quote]I also want to be a doctor and get married and have kids, I feel I am called to both things but I've been told that women always have to stay home if she has kids, even if they are in school. That makes me mad because I know women who are excellent wives and mothers and who still go to work when their kids are in school. One of the most Catholic women I know is married, has five kids, and she was my chemistry teacher last year. Also, St. Gianna Molla was still a doctor, even when she got married and had children. But guys at school always yell at me and my girlfriends because we want to work, I want to be a doctor, another friend wants to be a psychologist, and the guys are always like, why would you do that when you can play with kids all day? And I'm thinking, just because a woman works does not make her a bad Catholic or a bad mother. If a woman is called to stay home with kids, that's awesome. If a woman is called to work and have kids, that's awesome too. I'm sick of people judging women based on whether they stay home or not. Working does not automatically cut a woman off from God. My mom and dad work now and I don't resent my mom for deciding to work. She would die for us if she had to! I don't think it's fair that women are judged like this.[/quote] Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't society seem to wanna push women into the workforce so as to obliterate gender roles? I don't think you're really disagreeding with society for the most part; maybe it's just your part of the country, or maybe you hang out with lots of Catholics who take the idea of the female gender role a little too far. I don't have a problem with women working. But I believe that supporting the family financially is a requirement for a good husband and a good father. It is only an option for a quality wife and mother. Basically For the woman, raising kids comes first. For the man, producing an income comes first. If somebody wants to try having a job and being a devoted stay-home parent, that's great. But not at the expense of "what comes first." Is everybody following me so far? I guess it's a little trickier for me to relate to the female side of things, b/c I have always thought of gender roles in terms of what I shall do as a guy. For example, I will probably go with a slightly more annoying but better paying job as a sacrifice for my future wife and family. I have a bunch of reasons for this, but it mainly boils down to this: if I make the money, then my wife will have more options to do what she loves to do. Plus, I'll be able to afford more Catholic babies!! I believe this is a modern day application of "husbands, love your wives [b]as Christ loved the Church.[/b] Men, you all prepared to do for her, what Christ did for the Church?
IcePrincessKRS Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 [quote name='Claudine' post='1065586' date='Sep 17 2006, 11:42 PM'] that is so true. [/quote] Ditto that. I was going to expound on this more, but my post was getting a little "dramatic" so I thought better of it. Suffice it to say, right now my family is "daddy-less" and we feel his absence greatly, especially our 3 year old.
prose Posted September 18, 2006 Posted September 18, 2006 I work and I have 2 kids., and I like to think I am an excellent mother and a strong Catholic. And I have a 3 year old and a one year old.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now