Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 (edited) I have more kids in my 7th grade class this year. 11 of them. Which, normally wouldn't seem too bad except at least 3 of them are probably on some medication that wears off by the time class starts (and since they all eat dinner beforehand they are stocked full of energy), and 1 kid must have some sort of "problem" that his parents aren't owning up to because he randomly says things out of nowhere in the middle of class that have nothing to do with anything. (i.e., we're talking about what Tradition is and how it's part of Revelation and he yells out "HEY, my brother has a snake" "so, I say, cool, how does that relate to Revelation?" and he says he doesn't know, and so I just said something about "let's try and stay on topic, we can talk about snakes later"-- but this happens at least once or twice during class). I have about 3 serious kids who honestly try and make sure I know that they are paying attention and they try to tell the other kids to pay attention as well; but I honestly spent most of the class moving seats around because they just refused to stop talking and pay attention. I tried to start off with a fun activity, but they wouldn't even settle down for that, so I said fine and skipped it... tried questioning them about their experience/knowledge, but they still wouldn't pay attention (all the while I'm moving seats and threatening to keep moving them until they all just be quiet), so finally I got fed up and made them pull out the books to read from them (which I usually don't do because I know they hate reading from the book-- so I try to be fun and do activities and things outside of the book rather than have them read and answer questions). And then I gave them this big lecture about how I was trying to fun and make their religion class interesting, but they weren't even giving me a chance. Amid some more snickering, I got so fed up with them, that my "adult voice" came out and I launched into a lecture telling them that I hoped that they would all go home and pray thanking God that they lived in Ohio-- in the United States-- and didn't have to worry about whether they might be killed tomorrow for what they believe in. I pulled out Saint Cecilia (my statue mimicking her catacomb tomb) and explained about martyrs in the earliest centuries of Christianity and then started talking about the middle east and the conflict that's going on today and pointed out that while they were laughing and treating religion class like a joke, people just across the ocean were being murdered for what they believe. And so, while they might not take it seriously, they were lucky that they had that choice, because not everyone in the world does. After this speech, one little boy thought he would be "smart" and said he would just say he didn't believe and pretend he believed what they did so he wouldn't die. And I said "funny you should say that.. Jesus talks about that in the Bible" and flipped open my Bible to where Jesus says if we deny Him before men, He will deny us before His Father and told him he can't have it both ways. He might get a few more days on earth by denying his faith, but it wouldn't get him anywhere good in the end. It was pretty somber after that... mostly because I think they realized I was ticked. But they were all jumping to leave when it came close for class to be over and all started talking and getting crazy again, so I made them sit and be quiet before I let them leave, and reminded them that next week, the pastor is teaching the class and he won't tolerate their disrespect as much I have and that I hoped they would show him more respect than they have been for me. I talked with the DRE a bit... I lost my CDD helper because he wanted to teach the class and not be a helper-- and refused my offer to let him teach some of the classes if we worked out a schedule, so I don't really have another adult in the room to act as a disciplinarian or anything. We're working on that for diocesan policy (for now I just keep the door wide open... but then the rest of the teachers have to close theirs cuz my class is so loud).. and my DRE is hoping they get better as they get to know me, since last year's "energentic class" responded well to me and we got along great (it was mostly the activities, I think). But I can't even get that far with this class, they can't manage simple activities even working in groups. It's frustrating. So, please say some prayers for these kids... but... any suggestions on ways to get them to be respectful? to pay attention? Assigned seats are definitely coming, I just have to figure out a way to separate them all without "punishing" the 3 kids who are honestly trying. I was thinking about perhaps reinterating my point about other places in the world that lack freedom of religion, without being too graphic, and then talking about my own experience in high school with Protestants attacking my Catholic faith and sort of explaining my conversion story so hopefully they can find something to relate to. But I'm not sure that will get them to be quiet and pay attention... Last year, the beginning was hard, but my activities worked, and I also used candy as an incentive. This year, the new DRE doesn't want us to do snacks or anything because CCD is about learning, not food-- which I agree with... but I think it was a good incentive. Perhaps I can talk with her about using it to get them under control... but I'd rather there be another way than bribery. Kids these days... this is why we need the graces of Confirmation earlier! Edited September 19, 2006 by Fides_et_Ratio
OLAM Dad Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 I'll pray for you and the kids. You're doing the right things. Always remember that you're in charge. Make examples of the brats and the others will fall in line. Whatever you do, don't show any weakness. You're not their friend and you're not their buddy...you're their TEACHER. Good luck and thanks for doing this hard and thankless job.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 Get a leather whip and whack things around the room once in a while. Or pretend to lose it and break a chair in front of the class...
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 I really think that candy is one of the best ways to get them to pay attention, but then again, I think they like to get stuff period, so maybe holy medals may peak an interest... I like to give them holy cards too... They may not take to it as well as candy, but they are getting stuff... kids like stuff...
Mary-Kathryn Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 Hi there, Try laying down a very structured routine...start off with 10 minutes of slient prayer or adoration in the Church [this is what my children will do this year in their CCD] Go from there...don't assume all kids have eaten. Some may have gone straight from after school care or sports pratice to there. Kind of gently see what their day is like. Ask the DRE if there's funds for a small practical snack if you find this is the case. Hungry distracted kids can act up. If the DRE gives permission send home a note asking parents to fill out a form informing you of any special needs their child has so that you may be aware as their teacher. My child is obviously "different" but others may not be. Parents should speak up for the sake of their child. Have a set of classroom rules. Hope maybe one or some of this might help?
cmotherofpirl Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 Take them outside the building and do 3 laps around it before class and get their energy out. Start with a situation instead of reading etc. Ask them what do they say when a homeless man asks them for money, then use that as a springboard for charity, every man is our brother, the beatitudes, St James on works. Ask them if they download music, and have a discussion about stealing. They are old enough to start from real life and derive Catholic ideas and teachings from it.
Era Might Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1066322' date='Sep 18 2006, 09:09 PM'](i.e., we're talking about what Tradition is and how it's part of Revelation and he yells out "HEY, my brother has a snake" "so, I say, cool, how does that relate to Revelation?" and he says he doesn't know, and so I just said something about "let's try and[/quote] Jesus slays the snake in Revelation.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 19, 2006 Author Posted September 19, 2006 If I could take them somewhere else and have them run.. I would. My class is later in the evening though, so that presents its own challenges. And they definitely wouldn't sit still or be quiet for 10 minutes of silent prayer... I start off the class with a prayer, but the noise level only lowers after I say "IN THE NAME of the Father.." and start making the sign of the cross. After the prayer, I try and do an activity.. which, yesterday's activity was supposed to have been having them do some short skits (because I thought that would let them get out some energy) about a situation that relates to their lives at school-- I was going to have them pretend to be at lunch and someone asks them why they believe in God, or how do they know anything about God and how they would respond, what they would say-- could they do it without using the Bible? etc. But they couldn't manage that and were just getting out of control. I don't like to read from the book (because I don't like the book), so reading from the book is only a last resort and a sort of "punishment" coming from me. This is my typical structure for class: 1. Prayer (I take attendance as they trickle in since there are not very many of them) 2. Activity relating to the day's topic-- it might be a game or a puzzle or a group project of sorts 3. Discussion-- I usually give a small "overview" of the topic, asking them questions to see what they know, if they make the connection between the game and the topic, and just elaborate on the topic a bit. If it's a Bible story we open up the Bible to look at it more closely, etc. 4. Question/Answer-- I let them ask questions or comment on what we did/talked about and then try to make it relate to their lives today.. to give it some personal meaning for them 5. Announcements for the next class/week 6. Prayer and then they leave after the last prayer. But like next week, Father is giving them a tour of the church, and he does a great job, explaining the significance of all the "objects" and just totally random trivia about the church-- why the stained glass windows are done a certain way to symbolize prayer, etc. And he goes into some detail about what goes on at Mass... hopefully to give them all a better meaning/understanding of Mass and the church building. And during Lent we take a whole class to do Stations of the Cross-- actually praying the Stations, but also talking about each Station and coming up with "mini-activities" for each Station as well. So, reading from the book, or just sitting down and reading period is a VERY rare occurance in my CCD classes... I know that they don't want to do that, so I try to make CCD fun and relevant to "today" while still geting across the truths of the Church. This class just doesn't seem to want to give me that chance. They won't calm down, and talk almost incessantly whenever they can-- talking back to me, mimicking me, making fun of the other students (which is a pet-peeve of mine). I tried to talk about what do they want to do/what do they want to get out of the class.. and basically none of them want to be there, their parents don't really care and so they don't even see what the point is in coming (neither do I)... and so I've asked them to just give me 1 hour a week to show them that it doesn't have to be boring and that it does relate to their lives, etc. ... but it doesn't seem to be getting through. OH, and I don't want to sound ungrateful. I DO greatly appreciate all the replies and responses! I just wish I knew a way to get through and have them settle down.
Lil Red Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 have you gone over rules? a couple of years ago for youth group, i made up a contract and had each child and parent sign it. part of it states that if they do not live up to these rules, i'll have a meeting with them and their parent, or be asked to leave the group. now i understand that these are younger kids, but if you haven't gone over expectations/rules, then now is the time. make an example out of one kid - a kid that acts out gets sent out into the hall or another appropriate punishment.
Groo the Wanderer Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 You have 11? .... My class this year is smaller than it has ever been...I have 23. so...pppbbbtttt!!!! Of course, we have 2000 kiddos enrolled in PK-10 and 102 in confirmation class...so I guess a larger class is to be expected. Oh yeah...and we have 200+ on the waiting list in case any slots openup. YIKES!!! Send yer building fund donations to.......
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 19, 2006 Author Posted September 19, 2006 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1066790' date='Sep 19 2006, 02:30 PM'] have you gone over rules? a couple of years ago for youth group, i made up a contract and had each child and parent sign it. part of it states that if they do not live up to these rules, i'll have a meeting with them and their parent, or be asked to leave the group. now i understand that these are younger kids, but if you haven't gone over expectations/rules, then now is the time. make an example out of one kid - a kid that acts out gets sent out into the hall or another appropriate punishment. [/quote] Oh yes, rules are a must. And they're fine with turning off their cell phones, not having snacks... it's just all the rules about respecting each other (and myself) and being quiet that they ignore. The Monday night CCD kids have a rep for being the bad kids... but usually it's just that their parents don't care and don't take them to Mass-- they are at CCD because "it's what they're supposed to do with their kids". Most of the parents don't know and don't care about being Catholic and if we say their kid is a problem, they just pull their kid out and we don't see them anymore. CCD takes a backseat to almost anything and everything. It's not your ideal catechizing situation. And so, of course because the parents don't care and don't teach their child anything, the child doesn't care and sees CCD as a waste of time. We try giving them "homework" but it never comes back, if we let them take home their books/papers before the end of the school year they don't bring them back to class, and they all do very poorly on tests/quizzes if we give them to them (which I do, just to judge my own effectiveness in teaching). But very little of what I say sticks, so I try and drive home important points-- seeds-- that will hopefully mature at a later point in their lives.
phatcatholic Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 maybe there could be some type of incentive you could set up for the end of the class? like, you could teach, and then at the end they would all watch a movie, with popcorn...............or some other type of incentive. then, u could be like, "we're not going to be able to watch the movie until you all be quiet and listen to what i have to say." and if anyone acted up u could deprive them of that incentive. i have no idea if that will work or if its a good thing to do at all. just an idea i had......
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 I could have used this page last year when I was teaching Fifth Grade
brandelynmarie Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 [quote name='FutureNunJMJ' post='1066512' date='Sep 19 2006, 03:19 AM'] I really think that candy is one of the best ways to get them to pay attention, but then again, I think they like to get stuff period, so maybe holy medals may peak an interest... I like to give them holy cards too... They may not take to it as well as candy, but they are getting stuff... kids like stuff... [/quote] I'm thinking Holy Cards & BLESSED medals & rosaries & such would be good...You could have them get on-line at home or at the library during the week & casually google info on say, the life of a saint or a Church teaching...& one of the items could be a prize for responding.... I'm thinking about the games we would play in BYF (Baptist Youth Fellowship)...but I'm not too certain that they would wind them up even more!
scardella Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1066322' date='Sep 18 2006, 09:09 PM'] 1 kid must have some sort of "problem" that his parents aren't owning up to because he randomly says things out of nowhere in the middle of class that have nothing to do with anything. (i.e., we're talking about what Tradition is and how it's part of Revelation and he yells out "HEY, my brother has a snake" "so, I say, cool, how does that relate to Revelation?" and he says he doesn't know, and so I just said something about "let's try and stay on topic, we can talk about snakes later"-- but this happens at least once or twice during class).[/quote] A friend of mine had taught a kid like that. It's a disorder where they blurt out anything that's on their mind. If you can channel it effectively, it may significantly improve your class.
Dave Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 At my previous parish, I knew a guy, "John" (he wasn't a regular CCD teacher but was a substitute), who coached a lot of youth sports, so whenever anyone acted up, he'd make 'em do push-ups! He'd say, "Drop and give me 5!" Of course, these kids were pretty young, so that's why they did just 5 and not more. I think that would be a great way of disciplining the kids! Problem is, would parents get upset? That's what happened with "John" -- some of the parents learned about it and got really upset -- something about fears of doing inappropriate things with kids. They went to our pastor (WITHOUT first talking to "John"), and the pastor said he couldn't allow "John" to teach CCD anymore!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now