cmotherofpirl Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 September 18, 2006 Contrary to many media reports, Pope Benedict XVI did not apologize on Sunday for his September 12 discourse at the University of Regensburg. He did not retract his words, and did not say he regretted his speech. Unless, of course, you consider an apology his expression of remorse that some misunderstood him, took offense, and reacted violently and irrationally, thus proving, ironically, the accuracy of his original thesis; that cultural dialogue is a pipedream unless all sides reject religiously-motivated violence. I can understand the journalistic misread. Many surely think that Benedict, as a German intellectual, must be as hard to understand as Heidegger, Hegel, or Kant. Maybe they skipped the reading and took the easy road of juicy sound bites. But Benedict is no typical German intellectual. He's so smart, and his thought is so refined, that he can be simple, profound, and precise at the same time. What he says, in its full context, is what he means, and much to the consternation of those who would like to offer their altogether unique interpretation, there is no need for fancy hermeneutics. After a year and a half of a low-key pontificate, Pope Benedict finds himself on center stage. He didn't mean to make a debut. That's not the way he is. Shy by nature and strong by faith, his meek demeanor reflects the kind of rare, humble soul that is most comfortable in absolute obscurity — but stands up nicely and fearlessly in the spotlight when the mission so demands. Those who begged for a retraction from the pontiff for his supposed explosive words, including Muslim fundamentalists and the New York Times, don't know Pope Benedict. Perhaps they thought his academic discourse on the relationship between faith and reason, in which the example of Islamic fundamentalism was a small part, had been pieced together by an out-of-touch Vatican bureaucracy. Or more likely, perhaps they never read it. Equally outlandish were the pundits who said Pope Benedict's "gaffe" should be overlooked as a well-intentioned public relations blunder committed by a pope still wet behind the ears. To my amazement, once-harsh critics of John Paul II now gushed with praise over the late pope's "spotless record of inter-religious dialogue" as they invited "Pope Ratzinger" (arguably John Paul II's closest friend and theological bosom buddy) to try to call up distant memories of his predecessor and learn from him a thing or two. With so many examples of media hubris, some may have missed the irony of this weekend's violent protests. In the name of Islam, angry Muslims in the Middle East torched papal effigies and Christian churches. These were violent protests against anyone who would dare call them or their religion violent. The senselessness reached new heights when gunmen killed a Catholic nun with four bullets in the back of the head. It was a fitting "thank you" to a woman who was dedicating her life to the sick and dying in a hospital in Somalia. Her patients, of course, were mostly Muslim. But these were street folk, kids. With a little graciousness, we could chalk up their shameless behavior to ignorance. It would be a stretch to think they had read the Arabic translation of Pope Benedict's speech to German professors. It is harder to find excuses for grown-ups. The Pakistani parliament led the way on Friday by condemning Pope Benedict. However, they avoided any comment on the Pope's central thesis: that violence and religion don't mix — not because Christianity says so, but because it flows from the very nature of God. Heads of state, including the president of Iran and the Prime Ministers of Malaysia and Turkey, jumped on the bandwagon with equally hollow condemnations, bereft of any intellectual rigor. Instead, they stuck to ad hominem talking points. Get ready. Today we will read self-congratulatory reports by journalists everywhere that the Pope finally changed his mind. The pressure, they will say, was just too much for this aging man who found himself with no other alternative than to offer a resounding "mea culpa." But by doing so, they will prove, once again, Benedict's intellectual clarity and spiritual honesty was, for them, too much to digest. Yes, the Pope is "deeply sorry for the reactions in some countries to a few passages of my address," as he said on Sunday, but he is equally firm in reiterating his original challenge to all of us, of all faiths, to reject all forms of religiously-motivated violence. Don't believe it because I said it. Pope Benedict speaks just fine for himself, "The true meaning of my address, in its totality, was and is an invitation to frank and sincere dialogue, with great mutual respect." And in the meantime, we're still waiting for political and religious leaders in the Middle East to take up the Pope's challenge, and to do so unapologetically. God bless, Father Jonathan --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tindomiel Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 (edited) Our ultra-liberal newspaper made a big deal out of the whole "apology" thing.... commenting on the "newness" of the gesture. How JPII had apologized for the Church's historical "evils", but none of its present ones, etc. Edited September 19, 2006 by Tindomiel
scardella Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 I love the irony of it: "We will kill anyone who says Islam is violent!"
Tindomiel Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 I was talking about that with some coworkers only moments ago.
Norseman82 Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 [quote name='scardella' post='1066652' date='Sep 19 2006, 12:37 PM'] "We will kill anyone who says Islam is violent!" [/quote] Definitely one for the "Stupidest things ever said" calendar...
isilzha Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 I love Fr. Jonathan. Even when I don't agree with him (although most of the time I do) he is well reasoned and writes well.
kamiller42 Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 [quote]With so many examples of media hubris, some may have missed the irony of this weekend's violent protests. In the name of Islam, angry Muslims in the Middle East torched papal effigies and Christian churches. These were violent protests against anyone who would dare call them or their religion violent. [b]The senselessness reached new heights when gunmen killed a Catholic nun with four bullets in the back of the head. It was a fitting "thank you" to a woman who was dedicating her life to the sick and dying in a hospital in Somalia.[/b] Her patients, of course, were mostly Muslim.[/quote] God bless Leonella Sgorbati for doing God's work. Rest in peace.
Lounge Daddy Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 Long Live The Pope! (and screw the liberal media)
Akalyte Posted September 19, 2006 Posted September 19, 2006 [quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1066822' date='Sep 19 2006, 03:55 PM'] Long Live The Pope! (and screw the liberal media) [/quote] AMEN!
Socrates Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 Well-spoken! The "mainstream media" makes me sick. They first criticize the Pope for his remarks, as though HE was the propogator of this violent reaction, then they report that he backed down and apologized for his error.
Theologian in Training Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 If anything, the reaction to what the Pope has said has given me fodder for my homily tomorrow
OLAM Dad Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1067373' date='Sep 19 2006, 10:44 PM'] If anything, the reaction to what the Pope has said has given me fodder for my homily tomorrow [/quote] I wish I could be there.
Theologian in Training Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 [quote name='OLAM Dad' post='1067972' date='Sep 20 2006, 09:50 AM'] I wish I could be there. [/quote] Well, you can at least read it, if you so desired.... The early Christian writer and Father of the early Church, Tertullian, has a famous quote that I am sure some of you have probably heard at least once: “The blood of martyrs is the seed of the Church.” How relevant this is today, especially with those whose memorial we celebrate, Saint Andrew Kim Taegon, Saint Paul Chong Hasang, and their many companions. Men and women, who did not just boldly profess their faith, but laid down their lives for that faith. The stories of how they died are very graphic and very inhumane, from beheading, to being pierced with hot coals, to having their skin torn, and yet, despite these many horrible methods of torture, they remained steadfast in their belief. Yet, it was the blood of these priests, these bishops and these laypersons, both men and women, that were the seed, the foundation of the Church in Korea. And it was their witness and their bravery that made that Church so strong. In fact, when John Paul II, in 1984 canonized these many martyrs he said: "The Korean Church is unique because it was founded entirely by lay people. This fledgling Church, so young and yet so strong in faith, withstood wave after wave of fierce persecution. Thus, in less than a century, it could boast of 10,000 martyrs. The death of these martyrs became the leaven of the Church and led to today's splendid flowering of the Church in Korea. Even today their undying spirit sustains the Christians in the Church of silence in the north of this tragically divided land" And, as dark as this may sound, as scary as it may be, the same may be in store for the Church today. Yes, the Pope was misunderstood and it is ironic that what the news has called militant Muslims seem to be, as Cardinal Pell has said, with regard to the violence: “justifying one of the Pope’s main fears of Islam.” But they have vowed to knock down the walls of the Vatican and make war on “worshippers of the cross.” They have even threatened the Christians in the Gaza Strip. In other words, it is now not just the Pope’s life that is in danger, but every Christian’s life. And now the question is, are we ready to follow the example of the martyrs and lay down our life for our faith, are we ready to be that example, that witness for others? It is a hard question and probably one we never thought we would have to entertain, but if it ever came down to that, what would we do? What would we do?
eddieloudog Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 Wow. To be blessed enough to suffer for the church. I still find it amazing that God will forgivesome one like me. It's all beyond me.
toledo_jesus Posted September 20, 2006 Posted September 20, 2006 the most important thing to note is that Benedict's lack of an apology is a stand against this wave of whitewash for Islam. If he retracted his statement, it would be a clear signal that Islam is not to be criticized, and that we cannot have rational discussions about it. That's unacceptable. Islam should be held to the same standard as Christianity. The news doesn't get that, and neither do Muslims who call for the pope's resignation or death.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now