Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Serious Help Needed


Recommended Posts

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

For those of you who do not know, in Topeka, KS there is a small church (Westbourgh Baptist Church) lead by Fred Phelps. They often picket random places like Washburn University, my parish, other churches in town, the civic theatre, and anywhere they think people might be. They have recently made headlines by picketing the funerals of soldiers. They stand on a platform that 9/11 was God's judgement for America's acceptance of homosexualitiy, and that America is doomed.

Today my friend Adam and I decided that we would go talk to them as they were picketing down the street from us. We were curious about how they could get these firm and hateful beliefs from the Bible. Here are a couple of things that they believe that I would like your help, combating. They are Sola Scriptura, so anything from the Church Fathers may be beneficial for us, however we won't be able to use it in dialogue with them.

1) They believe that man does not have free will, and they believe in unconditional election

2) They believe creation served no purpose other than to show God's power

3) God does not love Everyone. They asked us to show ONE passage that states God loves everyone.

4) They believe that a VERY small number of people will recieve salvation, by the examples of the small number of survivors from Sodom and only noah's family was saved in the Ark.

Any help from the serious scripture buffs would be benificial, we are planning on talking with them again tommarrow.

They were fairly cordial with us until they had to leave at which time they called us "vain babblers" and "heritics" and all we did was ask questions.

Posted

I heard Sean Hannity talking about this guy and that he is actually a lawyer and the whole purpose of the group is to actually get someone to take a swing at them so he can sue... I wonder if that is true...

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

Actually the majority of his family and Church members are lawyers. That's how the fund their travels to picket ect. When they win law suits they get money. In fact as soon as my friend and I walked up they started to video tape the conversation. They have been known in the past to actually picket individual houses of people that are f*g lovers. meaning anyone who disagrees with them. They have won several constitutional law cases regarding free speach. KS is STILL working to get a viable law written that will limit their exposure to people without infringing on rights.

I would not say they do it FOR the law suits, but they use the law suits to fund their cult.

Posted (edited)

The Phelps "church" is also the group behind the "God Hates F*gs" website. Furthermore, these people travel around the country to the funerals of fallen soldiers killed in action in Iraq...and disrupt these brave mens' funerals and burials. They profess some nonsense along the lines of soldiers' deaths in Iraq being God's retribution against the United States for not punishing homosexuality. These are not rational people. They are frankly evil people. And yes, they do live to make money off of lawsuits...either they sue local governments that may try to present these nuts from causing disturbances, or they goad someone into a fit of anger that leads to physical conflict, following which they file charges for assault.

No discussion can be had with such evil people.

Edited by CameBackHome
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' post='1069628' date='Sep 21 2006, 08:53 PM']
For those of you who do not know, in Topeka, KS there is a small church (Westbourgh Baptist Church) lead by Fred Phelps. They often picket random places like Washburn University, my parish, other churches in town, the civic theatre, and anywhere they think people might be. They have recently made headlines by picketing the funerals of soldiers. They stand on a platform that 9/11 was God's judgement for America's acceptance of homosexualitiy, and that America is doomed.

Today my friend Adam and I decided that we would go talk to them as they were picketing down the street from us. We were curious about how they could get these firm and hateful beliefs from the Bible. Here are a couple of things that they believe that I would like your help, combating. They are Sola Scriptura, so anything from the Church Fathers may be beneficial for us, however we won't be able to use it in dialogue with them.

1) They believe that man does not have free will, and they believe in unconditional election

2) They believe creation served no purpose other than to show God's power

3) God does not love Everyone. They asked us to show ONE passage that states God loves everyone.

4) They believe that a VERY small number of people will recieve salvation, by the examples of the small number of survivors from Sodom and only noah's family was saved in the Ark.

Any help from the serious scripture buffs would be benificial, we are planning on talking with them again tommarrow.

They were fairly cordial with us until they had to leave at which time they called us "vain babblers" and "heritics" and all we did was ask questions.
[/quote]

1. If there is no free will, there is no sin, including homosexual activity. They are just self-defeated.

2. All of creation is of lesser beauty and power than God has in Himself. If He only created to show His power, then that would exclude the purpose of trying to bring man in awe to Himself, thus, He would have created solely for His own amazement. That doesn't hold up, since creation is less amazing than God is in Himself.

3. Your passage is this: "God is love." Most certainly, then, all who are loved (and all are loved by someone in some way) are loved by God.

4. It would be a very sad thing if, "in the fullness of time," God sent His Son as His greatest gift and did not in turn save the greatest number of people. It's reasonable to expect that in Christ, many more would be saved than on the Ark, since His blood speaks so eloquently.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

I agree, What is the verse God is Love. I know it's there, but can't find it.

I need verses. My friend and I recognize there are many contradictory poistions that they take, but...


The way I look at, these people are often shown nothing, but hate. In recent history some of the thrid generation (Phelps grandkids) have left the church. If I am able to show God's love, just by being able to have a civil conversation, then should I not do it?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' post='1069753' date='Sep 21 2006, 10:13 PM']
I agree, What is the verse God is Love. I know it's there, but can't find it.

I need verses. My friend and I recognize there are many contradictory poistions that they take, but...
The way I look at, these people are often shown nothing, but hate. In recent history some of the thrid generation (Phelps grandkids) have left the church. If I am able to show God's love, just by being able to have a civil conversation, then should I not do it?
[/quote]
1 John 4:8

Actually, the whole first letter of John is an abundant source of quotes.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

thnxs

Posted

How about Jn 3:16? [u]God so loved the world[/u]...

1Jn2:2
And he is the propitiation for our sins: and not for ours only, but also for the sins of the whole world.

1Jn4:8
He that loveth not knoweth not God; for God is love.

Rom 5:5
And hope maketh not ashamed; because the love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the Holy Ghost which is given unto us.

Lk18 9-14 has a great parable about being condescending. It starts

[b]9And he spake this parable unto certain which trusted in themselves that they were righteous, and despised others[/b]

I guess you could start with:

[quote]Could you help me Ms. Fundi? I hear you say _______ but 1 jn 2:2 says jesus died for all, including homosexuals. I seem to see a conflict between the bible and your doctrine. (listen to response)

Also, could you tell me how you understand Lk 18 and tell me how that applies to our lives today?"[/quote]

Finally, I am not sure I would bless him with a title such as Phelp's doctrine. The root of much of this is no different than Calvinism/reformed theology.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

I tried for God so loved the world, and the gave some hooy about it meaning the WORLD not people... :blink:

Posted

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' post='1070299' date='Sep 22 2006, 12:38 AM']
I tried for God so loved the world, and the gave some hooy about it meaning the WORLD not people... :blink:
[/quote]Wow, I did not see that one coming. Keep trying more verses. When they go ad hom attack or change the subject, you know you have found a sweet spot.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted (edited)

good point, at picking out the weaknesses. This is a really screwy version of Calvanism, maybe we should get church record keepres down here to start a file an a new heresy, :boink:

Edited by PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted (edited)

IMO they are a cult-like group led by a maniac. They shout things at soldiers funerals like "Thank God for dead soldiers!" and "Thank God for I.E.D.s! [improvised explosive devices]". At one funeral they even sang vulgar songs.

The Patriot Guard [url="http://patriotguard.org/"]http://patriotguard.org/[/url] should be recognized and thanked for their hard work. I've never met them but they've been in the news here and there. These are motorcycle riders who gather at a soldiers funeral to shield the family from the Phelps gang. Their presence will often draw support of community members who stand with them also. Also the noise of motorcycles has a way of drowning out anything the Phelps folks is yelling out. ^_^

I have heard they only come if the family asks them to and they are very respectful and cooperative with the laws. They are there to see that the families can bury their loved ones in peace.

You cannot argue with the Phelps gang just as one couldn't have argued with Jim Jones and his cult. Stay away from them. They are dangerous.

Edited by Mary-Kathryn
Posted

God bless the patriot guard people. Many states are trying to pass laws that protests at funerals are illegal.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

These folks prove just how devastatingly dangerous unguided, private interpretation can be.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

[quote name='Mary-Kathryn' post='1071191' date='Sep 22 2006, 09:21 AM']
The Patriot Guard [url="http://patriotguard.org/"]http://patriotguard.org/[/url] should be recognized and thanked for their hard work. I've never met them but they've been in the news here and there. These are motorcycle riders who gather at a soldiers funeral to shield the family from the Phelps gang. Their presence will often draw support of community members who stand with them also. Also the noise of motorcycles has a way of drowning out anything the Phelps folks is yelling out. ^_^
[/quote]


I am an honorary member of the Patriot Guard, I don't have a bike yet, to make the events... :)

Don't sell the power of God short. All it takes is people to say yes God I will go where you send me, I will set my face like flint, and do my best to show Christ's love to these people. When I was beginning my theological training here in Topeka as a Protestant, the local Pastors organization, would talk with Fred on a bi-weekly basis. After a few months they decided to tell Fred that they were no longer to meet to talk about his Church's teachings. Fred's response was basically "That doesn't mean we have to stop meeting does it?" This is a man who is hurt, he and his family do not see Christ Love ANYWHERE. community members yell and curse at them ect.

I'm not saying that the community is wrong at feeling outraged, but aren't we called to turn the other cheek? Shouldn't we, like the early Church Fathers, seek to combat the Heresy rather than curse them back? When I talked wioth them I saw somethinig in their eyes, through Christ there is hope. We all can come to the Truth of Christ.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...