curtins Posted September 24, 2006 Posted September 24, 2006 idk this just kinda crossed my mind but I wanna get your guys's take on it: Love is complete self giving for the better of the other. FAMILY- Forget about me, I love you. So you have 2 people that love each other sincerely. Now theres a situation- where someone has to suffer some pain/ discomfort/inconvenience- etc (it can be big or small). Person A wants to suffer it so person B doesn't have to and person B wants to take it so person A doesnt have to. Is this making any sense? They like cancel each other out and get no where.
Franimus Posted September 24, 2006 Posted September 24, 2006 "You take this one. I'll take the next one." or both sharing the same, if possible or just the stronger one takes it, and the other prays such is love Jesus was an example of the last of those three things I said.
Era Might Posted September 24, 2006 Posted September 24, 2006 Not sure what you mean, but we can't bear eachother's crosses, we can only help one another to bear them. Even Our Lord needed help along the way to his crucifixion.
curtins Posted September 25, 2006 Author Posted September 25, 2006 [quote name='Franimus' post='1074096' date='Sep 24 2006, 08:30 PM'] "You take this one. I'll take the next one." or both sharing the same, if possible or just the stronger one takes it, and the other prays such is love Jesus was an example of the last of those three things I said. [/quote] hmmm yeah that makes sense
Didymus Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 I've listened to F.A.M.I.L.Y. by Fr. Stan so many times, and I only now got the whole thing F orget A bout M e I L ove Y ou That's ingenius... I know I'm slow
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 You can never just step into the other person's shoes and take on their pain for them. It's not possible. You can be there to love them and support them, though. Believe me, being present to someone is sometimes the best gift you can give.
Aloysius Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 men and women are different, and men and women are supposed to take different roles in their total self-giving to one another. the man's is called "self-sacrifice" and the woman's is called "submission" they are not absolutely interchangeable... and that's where the dance of marriage begins. the man leads, but only insomuch as the woman agrees to follow... the man must lead where he knows the woman wants to go, sacrificing what he wants and his own personal ambitions for the sake of the woman's life and not going against the womans' greatest interests; the woman follows, submits, but in that following she also affects the direction of the dance with just as much force as the leading man. you solve your problem when your relationship seeks to follow these two roles. it'd be the man who ought to suffer for the sake of the woman, and the woman who ought to follow him in that suffering and 'submit' to his lead. each giving of themselves to the other in their own way, each directly affecting the directions and choices of the relationship in their own way. St. Paul describes it all very eloquently.
picchick Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 I understand what you are saying Aloysius but I don't completely agree with it. Maybe it is that I am reading your post wrong and in the end have it all wrong myself. Feel free to correct me. Women and men both suffer. However they suffer different things. Why is it assumed that two people who love each other sincerely are man and wife? Couldn't it be two friends? Even if it is man and wife, they are equal within the suffering context. (woman needs to be submissive to her husband but they are still equal) "it'd be the man who ought to suffer for the sake of the woman" To say that a man needs to be the one to suffer for his wife is denying the wife a very important thing. Suffering is for everyone. Everyone has their own sufferings and not because they are following the lead of someone else. I do like your last statement. "each giving of themselves to the other in their own way, each directly affecting the directions and choices of the relationship in their own way" Meg
XIX Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 Here's how I usually break it down: It's better to give than to receive. But receiving is not an objectively bad thing because it is not self-seeking. In fact, it can be a very good thing, dare I say almost as good as giving, because it's a sign that you are important to somebody. Gifts can definitely build a relationship, be it a friend-relationship or a romantic relationship. Now, demanding gifts or thinking you are entitled to a gift is something you don't want. You must still abandon your worldly desires. But I don't think you could say that just being the beneficiary of another person's good act is a bad thing. What you want to avoid like the devil is [b]taking.[/b] But do accept help if you need it, especially if a friend really can and wants to offer it. Insist on helpig if your friend/significant other needs it. [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/encyclicals/documents/hf_ben-xvi_enc_20051225_deus-caritas-est_en.html"]Deus Caritas Est[/url]
prose Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 [quote name='curtins' post='1074093' date='Sep 24 2006, 06:27 PM'] idk this just kinda crossed my mind but I wanna get your guys's take on it: Love is complete self giving for the better of the other. FAMILY- Forget about me, I love you. So you have 2 people that love each other sincerely. Now theres a situation- where someone has to suffer some pain/ discomfort/inconvenience- etc (it can be big or small). Person A wants to suffer it so person B doesn't have to and person B wants to take it so person A doesnt have to. Is this making any sense? They like cancel each other out and get no where. [/quote] Well, I see it this way (I haven't read the responses yet). When someone I truly love is suffering, I pray to the Lord to help me take some of their pain and to make their suffering more bearable to them. I believe that we all suffer for a reason, so I think it would be robbing them of something to take away any pain they may have, but I think it is good to pray for their strength and to ask the Lord to let you help carry their cross like Simon. That is how I see praying for sould in purgatory also. I can't take their pain, but I can ask the Lord to help them any way that I can.
Aloysius Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 when one says "2 people who love each other" it generally brings the connotation to me of a relationship... hence I went into a discussion on marriage. if it is self-sacrifice, then the man ought to self-sacrifice for the woman not the woman for the man. if it is submission, then the woman ought to submit to the man, not the man to the woman. neither is an absolute, and the lines are not always clear cut, but an organic growing relationship can tell the difference and everyone can fit into their proper roles. paraphrasing chesterton: a man is defined in doing what he does, a woman in being who she is. the man is called to sacrifice his state of just being who he is and cultivating who he is for the sake of the woman being able to be and cultivate who she is. he is the catalyst, the doer, the sacricer. the woman is of higher dignity, the goal of his catalyst and sacrifice is so that the woman can be totally fulfilled. in exchange for this sacrifice, and in parallel to it, he is also the catalyst/leader of the dance of marriage... the woman called to submit to him; that lead is tied up in the necessity for him to self sacrice and only lead where the woman may best cultivate who she is.
Jaime Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 [quote name='curtins' post='1074093' date='Sep 24 2006, 07:27 PM'] idk this just kinda crossed my mind but I wanna get your guys's take on it: Love is complete self giving for the better of the other. FAMILY- Forget about me, I love you. So you have 2 people that love each other sincerely. Now theres a situation- where someone has to suffer some pain/ discomfort/inconvenience- etc (it can be big or small). Person A wants to suffer it so person B doesn't have to and person B wants to take it so person A doesnt have to. Is this making any sense? They like cancel each other out and get no where. [/quote] Yeah I've lived your situation. When I was in college, I (and my girlfriend) was flat out broke. It was coming up on Christmas and even though I had no money I really wanted to do something special for her. So I went on the black market and sold my shin bones illegally to a disreputable doctor. But with the money, I was able to buy her a pair of earrings . She loved to wear earrings and she had exceptionally shaped ears. (She would get a lot of compliments about them) . It hurt to walk but I was so excited to give her the present on Christmas morning. Christmas morning came and we got together. She was all excited because she had a gift for me too! Imagine my surprise when I opened up her gift to find expensive shin bone cream. Not wanting to ruin her excitement, I said "Thank you honey! I love it!!" To which she replied "WHAT?!!? WHAT DID YOU SAY!??!" That's when I realized....
picchick Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1074827' date='Sep 25 2006, 04:27 PM'] if it is self-sacrifice, then the man ought to self-sacrifice for the woman not the woman for the man. if it is submission, then the woman ought to submit to the man, not the man to the woman. neither is an absolute, and the lines are not always clear cut, but an organic growing relationship can tell the difference and everyone can fit into their proper roles. paraphrasing chesterton: a man is defined in doing what he does, a woman in being who she is. the man is called to sacrifice his state of just being who he is and cultivating who he is for the sake of the woman being able to be and cultivate who she is. he is the catalyst, the doer, the sacricer. the woman is of higher dignity, the goal of his catalyst and sacrifice is so that the woman can be totally fulfilled. in exchange for this sacrifice, and in parallel to it, he is also the catalyst/leader of the dance of marriage... the woman called to submit to him; that lead is tied up in the necessity for him to self sacrice and only lead where the woman may best cultivate who she is. [/quote] Ok...Maybe I am still not understanding but why cannot the woman self-sacrifice for her man? For example, let's say I was married. My husband and I have a few kids yet still have a way of going to hang out with friends at the bowling alley. However, this week our babysitter got sick. My husband says, "Why don't you go honey? You've had a rough day and you deserve to go. I will stay with the kids." I say, "Oh no, you go. You were at work all day. I want you to go. Say hi to everyone for me." I am not being submissive to my husband. He told me to go and he was going to self-sacrifice his going time for me. However, I love him dearly and I want him to go to have fun. I will sacrifice my fun time so that he can enjoy himself. By going into submission and doing what my husband said, I am denied the chance to perform a sacrifice of love for my husband. Think of the opposite. I wonder what would happen if my husband were to say, "Honey, you are the mother of our children. It is your job to stay and take care of them. So you will stay here and I'll go. I won't stay the whole time. I just need some time to unwind. I had to work over time to make sure that the bills were paid for this month. I'll pick up some medicine on the way home." Now I could be submissive but do you not think that statement would cause an argument or hurt feelings? Meg
Aloysius Posted September 25, 2006 Posted September 25, 2006 the man in your second example is not living up to his end of self-sacrifice... in your first example it's like I said: the two are not absolutes and the lines between them are not always easy to define... I'm describing the direction the overall marriage should go and its guiding principles. if, after that conversation, your husband insisted that you be the one to go and he stay home; you ought to submit to that. but if you want to stay home (for him) and he wants to go, that is fine. it's organic, it varies by situation, the lines are not clear cut: but maintaining the symbolism of these roles and using them as guiding principals will work well.
xTrishaxLynnx Posted September 26, 2006 Posted September 26, 2006 [color=#000000][quote name='prose' post='1074719' date='Sep 25 2006, 02:21 PM'] Well, I see it this way (I haven't read the responses yet). When someone I truly love is suffering, I pray to the Lord to help me take some of their pain and to make their suffering more bearable to them. [b]I believe that we all suffer for a reason,[/b] so I think it would be robbing them of something to take away any pain they may have, but I think it is good to pray for their strength and to ask the Lord to let you help carry their cross like Simon. That is how I see praying for sould in purgatory also. I can't take their pain, but I can ask the Lord to help them any way that I can. [/quote] I agree. God would not have us suffer if no good would come of it... like my banner says... "Everything happens for a reason." Personally, I see suffering as a blessing... a chance to offer pain, wether physical, emotional, or otherwise, up to God in a sign that you submit to His will. I also like your approach to praying for souls in purgatory... leave it up to God wether you are able to help them or not, and how you may go about doing so. Wonderful post.
homeschoolmom Posted September 26, 2006 Posted September 26, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1074853' date='Sep 25 2006, 04:46 PM'] Yeah I've lived your situation. When I was in college, I (and my girlfriend) was flat out broke. It was coming up on Christmas and even though I had no money I really wanted to do something special for her. So I went on the black market and sold my shin bones illegally to a disreputable doctor. But with the money, I was able to buy her a pair of earrings . She loved to wear earrings and she had exceptionally shaped ears. (She would get a lot of compliments about them) . It hurt to walk but I was so excited to give her the present on Christmas morning. Christmas morning came and we got together. She was all excited because she had a gift for me too! Imagine my surprise when I opened up her gift to find expensive shin bone cream. Not wanting to ruin her excitement, I said "Thank you honey! I love it!!" To which she replied "WHAT?!!? WHAT DID YOU SAY!??!" That's when I realized.... [/quote] You realized that you're not O. Henry???
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 26, 2006 Posted September 26, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1074853' date='Sep 25 2006, 05:46 PM'] Yeah I've lived your situation. When I was in college, I (and my girlfriend) was flat out broke. It was coming up on Christmas and even though I had no money I really wanted to do something special for her. So I went on the black market and sold my shin bones illegally to a disreputable doctor. But with the money, I was able to buy her a pair of earrings . She loved to wear earrings and she had exceptionally shaped ears. (She would get a lot of compliments about them) . It hurt to walk but I was so excited to give her the present on Christmas morning. Christmas morning came and we got together. She was all excited because she had a gift for me too! Imagine my surprise when I opened up her gift to find expensive shin bone cream. Not wanting to ruin her excitement, I said "Thank you honey! I love it!!" To which she replied "WHAT?!!? WHAT DID YOU SAY!??!" That's when I realized.... [/quote] What will we ever do about you? [quote name='picchick' post='1074884' date='Sep 25 2006, 06:33 PM'] Ok...Maybe I am still not understanding but why cannot the woman self-sacrifice for her man? For example, let's say I was married. My husband and I have a few kids yet still have a way of going to hang out with friends at the bowling alley. However, this week our babysitter got sick. My husband says, "Why don't you go honey? You've had a rough day and you deserve to go. I will stay with the kids." I say, "Oh no, you go. You were at work all day. I want you to go. Say hi to everyone for me." I am not being submissive to my husband. He told me to go and he was going to self-sacrifice his going time for me. However, I love him dearly and I want him to go to have fun. I will sacrifice my fun time so that he can enjoy himself. By going into submission and doing what my husband said, I am denied the chance to perform a sacrifice of love for my husband. Think of the opposite. I wonder what would happen if my husband were to say, "Honey, you are the mother of our children. It is your job to stay and take care of them. So you will stay here and I'll go. I won't stay the whole time. I just need some time to unwind. I had to work over time to make sure that the bills were paid for this month. I'll pick up some medicine on the way home." Now I could be submissive but do you not think that statement would cause an argument or hurt feelings? Meg [/quote] This is why men and women need both to be generous and to accept generosity graciously. Not give and take...give and receive.
Old_Joe Posted September 26, 2006 Posted September 26, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1074853' date='Sep 25 2006, 04:46 PM'] Yeah I've lived your situation. When I was in college, I (and my girlfriend) was flat out broke. It was coming up on Christmas and even though I had no money I really wanted to do something special for her. So I went on the black market and sold my shin bones illegally to a disreputable doctor. But with the money, I was able to buy her a pair of earrings . She loved to wear earrings and she had exceptionally shaped ears. (She would get a lot of compliments about them) . It hurt to walk but I was so excited to give her the present on Christmas morning. Christmas morning came and we got together. She was all excited because she had a gift for me too! Imagine my surprise when I opened up her gift to find expensive shin bone cream. Not wanting to ruin her excitement, I said "Thank you honey! I love it!!" To which she replied "WHAT?!!? WHAT DID YOU SAY!??!" That's when I realized.... [/quote] Do the Magi have a return policy?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now