Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Run Down On My Current Diologues W/separated Bretheren


Recommended Posts

Posted

I have alot of balls in the air here. I want to highlight our fundamental differences:

Dad, conservative Episcopal Priest- Opposes any dogma he finds were concluded by logic alone. While his worship tends to be more Anglo-Catholic, oddly his theology is of Evangelical rather than Anglican roots. I am currently waiting for him to respond to the 17 page paper I wrote him on the Perpetual Virginity. He also has multiple tapes I gave him on the Pope and Mary by Rosalind Moss and Tim Staples.

Ellen, Reformed. OSAS. She contends we are without free will. Baptism does not sanctify. People who call themselves Christians can have 'saving faith' or 'false faith.' Our election was predestined before the beginning of time. I feel I should just listen and learn what her faith teaches.

Don, Pentacostal of 'Holy Laughter' type. "All 'Religion' is man made rules that get in the way of our personal relationship with Jesus Christ. We are made of body, soul sprit (Gnosticism/Pagan). Our bodies are corrupt and all that is corpreal gets in the way of our work in God (Manichiesm). When we are ressurected, we will receive new, spiritual bodies that are assexual (Origenism). I am currently putting together a paper that we are a soul consiting of a body and spirit and how God works in us.

Mike, Fundamentalist. Writes Anti-Catholic tracts of the Jack Chick flavor. He hands them out to Catholics when we pray the rosary/mass at planned parenthood. The bottom of his tract reads 'we invite anyone for the Catholic Church to refute these facts.' I am. I started by responding to his section of Faith and Salvation. He opposes sola scriptura, but writes the Catholic Church says we earn salvation by the 7 sacraments without any other details. I got him to read Trent session VI, watch Alex Jones conversion story, listen to Tim Staples conversion story, and read Fundamentalism and Catholicism by Karl Keating. We seem to get along when we sit down and talk.

Patrice, non-practicing Assembly God. Rejected by her church because her same sex attraction has not stopped, which shows lack of faith. Not in contact with her currently as she is working over seas. Sent her alot of Tim Staples/CA stuff. She is looking for some sort of Christianity that make sense of her issue. She also voiced jealousy my wife, a convert from AG with patrice, had found 'the bottom line' of Christian truth.


Comment or post your own diologue

Posted

friend,

the key in dialogue that makes it different than debate is the intentions and openess of the dialogue. Are these people open and willing to hear you out, or are the content in trying to convert you.

With your dad. As I was reading your summery I thought of alot of people I know. I go to an evangelical school with strong patristic studies. In our ecumenism class I recommened a book called "Is the reformation over" by Mark Noll. Mark Noll is one of the more respected protestant historians and the book has the angle of good ecumenism. comparing the differences and common aspects of our mutual faiths from the evangelical perspective. His conclusion is that the "offenses" that started the reformation are over. It lends credbility to the Catholic faith as a viable christian faith. And that is the first step. In that same class I also recommended "Mother Church" by Braaten (director for the center of Catholic and Evangelical something or another) These books, if your dad is open, will show credibility for the catholic faith.

Your friend Ellen,
as a protestant I was trained to attack calvinists. The problem with that is I dont know how to dialogue without destroying when it comes to conversations. I have friends in this background, but the doctrinal talks always get rough. Theodicy is a good ground for debate. Also, is a proper reading of Romans. Hence much of calvinism extends from a perverted reading of Calvinism. But good luck friend. I dont know how you can dialogue a calvinist without destroying tulip.

Don,
Depends on how intellectual he is willing to get. Most pentacostals do not "do" theology. This is always tough. My mom is the free church emotion type that thinks all theology and doctrine is man made and gets in the way of our relationship with Christ. Try not to overwhelm him. Seriously. I know when I try to debate with my mother theology turns her off entirely. I will pray for you.

Mike,
I think you are going the right route here. Keating is a lil tough, but it works if they are open to it. A big key is to show how fundamentalism is not even valid christian expression of faith. The basis is unbiblical restriction. And a hate for anyone different without actually researching your own view or developing a biblical systematic. There is a book I just read called "Born fundamentalist, born again Catholic" that helps alot.

Dont know about the AG girl. I had some problems with some AG girls in my town cause they were trying to convert my wife. So im not a good source for them :yawn:

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1074795' date='Sep 25 2006, 04:24 PM']
Your friend Ellen,
as a protestant I was trained to attack calvinists. The problem with that is I dont know how to dialogue without destroying when it comes to conversations. I have friends in this background, but the doctrinal talks always get rough. Theodicy is a good ground for debate. Also, is a proper reading of Romans. Hence much of calvinism extends from a perverted reading of Calvinism. But good luck friend. I dont know how you can dialogue a calvinist without destroying tulip. [/quote]

While I was trying to figure out my beliefs, I briefly had it narrowed down to either Catholicism or Calvinism: one extreme or the other, but nothing in between. :) I wasn't going to halfway belief the Real Presence or in a little bit of hierarchy without going all the way with it. So I really believe that Calvinist theology as a whole makes more sense than anything else within Protestantism.

Just my two cents about that...

Posted (edited)

I also think strong Calvinist theology is the only real other halfway logical possibility. Of course it's invalid. But if Catholicism weren't true (yet Christianity were true) I think Calvinist theology would have to be it.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

are you serious...tulip people...tulip

Posted

I left out:

Deserie- Pagan (by default for those who have no faith)- Will not visit Catholic Church because it believes we should tell others what to do, such as telling people they should not have abortions. Has tried other churches but finds they sometimes look at her condescendingly for her highlighted hair etc..


Eric-LDS- If I read the Book of Mormon and do not find it is true, he will start RCIA.

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1075392' date='Sep 26 2006, 05:46 AM']
are you serious...tulip people...tulip
[/quote]
Hey, it is nice, and easy. At least they took the time to think through their doctrines vs a 'hey lets wing it' idea of the 'essentials.'

Posted

True..in the same form as the mormons..;)

When I was 17 I was participating in a debate between Dr. Greg Boyd and John Piper and I got some heat for calling Calvinists in the same boat as mormons and JW. Their theology is so beyond truth that I doubt much truth can come out of it.

Total depravity---we smell of elderberries so much we can not seek God. This is impossible for catholicism.

Unconditional elections.---God sovereignly chooses who he saves. But not everyone cause otherwise he doesnt show how he can save. We have no choice here. Free will is a myth, Faith and merit do not matter. The Church teaches that all are predestined for heaven, but not all come to grace.

Limited atonement--Christ pays for the sins of the elect on the cross. Penial atonement that pays a debate. But it is limited to only paying for those who God pre-ordanes to be in heaven. If you didint win that lotto then no luck.

Irrestiable Grace--Since we have no free will we can not reject God nor make the decision to seek Him. God's grace is relentless and comes at us and we can not refuse it. Jesus does not knock on the door. He comes straight in with a mob hit.

Perservance of the Saints--Since it is God that calls the elect to him, of course the elect can never go away. Go shoot up 100 people, if you are elect then sin does not matter. If you fall away then you either never were elect, or you will come back.

And there is more. Predestination in theodicy makes a messy situation.

I got to a point that if I was not catholic I would be free-church independant because the arguments of authority from any other denomination was so easily torn apart.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

For your father, try to get him to read Ven. John Henry Cardinal Newman. He also had evangelical theological roots and an Anglican sense of the Church. Apologia Pro Vita Sua would probably be a good start.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1077805' date='Sep 28 2006, 09:22 AM']
Total depravity---we smell of elderberries so much we can not seek God. This is impossible for catholicism.[/quote]

Careful, we believe this also. The difference is that we stop sucking once we are born again and then may seek God. Pelagian heresy said we could seek God on our own. The church responded with sanctions. We agree with the T in TULIP here. However, we disagree we remain in that state after our conversion.

Raphael,

I am saving Newman for the knock-out punch. Looking at the Marcus Grodi conversion, let us wait until we have an unsettling of his stone wall: a leak in his dam.

Posted

We do not believe in Total depravity. The key there is total. We believe in depravity and most christians do. In calvinism they ontologically smell of elderberries(**bad term, but we are usin it) in salvation they are given a free ticket and covered by grace. Nothin changes in them. This is completely different than our system of soteriology. We have a will that is the decision making force. Calvinism states that free will is a myth.

Posted (edited)

First, Total Depravity is not the same thing as no free will.

Second, I respectfully disagree with you on our rejection of total depravity. I agree it is a harsh term, but it is not contrary to our beliefs. However, Catholics disagree with Calvinist in that the T in TULIP that we remain incapable of pleasing God on our own after our conversion.

Let us both look up 'total depravity' at catholic.com and report back.

Edited by jswranch
Posted

[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1993/9309fea1.asp"]Here is a Jimmy Akin article, "Tiptoe through TULIP." [/url]

[quote]While [a Catholic] would not use the term "total depravity" to describe the doctrine,[...] he would actually agree with it. The accepted Catholic teaching is that, because of the fall of Adam, man cannot do anything out of supernatural love unless God gives him special grace to do so.[... Ott gives the following as a defined article of faith: "For every salutary act internal supernatural grace of God (gratia elevans) is absolutely necessary"...]. [/quote]

I too was suprised to learn this.

Posted

I do not mean to sound rude here but your first point is wrong and right. It is right because they do not literally mean each other. But, in calvinism tulip is a co-dependant doctrine and free will is a myth. Both of those things are viable calvinist concepts.

U can look up total depravity on catholic.com, I am just telling you what it means from a calvinist pov. There is no functional way to have a catholic soteriology while holding onto a calvinist understanding of total depravity.

Where is Brother Adam when you need him? He would be a great help here.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...