Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Should I Turn Down Being A Groomsman For Moral Reasons?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Over the weekend a good friend of mine asked me to be a groomsman for his wedding in May. I agreed, although now I'm wondering if doing so implies that I approve of the fact that he's effectively married already, sans the ring and legal paperwork. While I've served as groomsman for other weddings where the couple was cohabitating, they were only nominally Christian and didn't claim to be following a Christian lifestyle. This guy, however, still attends regularly at his Baptist church and, for all I can tell, claims to be a Christian.

Of course, I'm glad they're getting married and I believe they're a good couple, so I want to be there to celebrate with them. I definitely wouldn't serve as a witness to their wedding since that means signing your name in approval, but the only thing I'm gonna be signing is the credit card receipt for my tux rental :) So is it worth making a fuss about this?

Mainly, I'm just wondering if this could be a matter of actual sin. If it's not, I'll probably go ahead and do it since he is my friend, but if it is then I'm not afraid to do the right thing.

Posted

You can take the stance of "I don't like how you got here" and not be a groomsman. Or you can look at it that he's now trying to make right where he was sinning before, and support that move. When I am asked to be in weddings, I try to look at where they are going instead of where they are coming from. But its entirely your decision.

Posted

True... I'm probably tending a little towards legalism or self-righteousness (or appearing to be that way, which is just about as bad). With non-Christians, I don't expect them to be accountable to something they don't believe in their hearts and I know that God can use marriage and childbearing to draw them closer to Him. This is a more unusual situation, since he's been a Christian as long as I've known him and until he dated this girl was always adament about waiting til marriage. But he got frustrated when the last relationship didn't work out even though he followed the "rules" (like not having sex).

I also look at my own heart and my past know that on several occasions I probably would have given up the gift of virginity if the opportunity were available. Maybe it's God's way of saving me from pride or helping me understand why others struggle or completely give in to sexual temptations. Anyway... I think I'm just rambling now :)

Posted

As you know, the decision is ultimately up to you.

I think, in essense, the past is history. (and history is miles away) If you approve of where the couple is [b]going[/b] by marrying, then I'd say support it. So, if they're free to marry, and you approve the marriage itself (ie you think it'll be something that'll last, etc.), then I'd be ok w/ being in the wedding party.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

At the same time, he's not really looking at improving the situation if he's still sleeping with her. I wouldn't do it.

Posted

If he was Catholic, I would say no. Since his is baptist, what can you do?

Posted

Why wouldn't you want to encourage/support his decision to rectify matters a little? You're not supporting his sin, but rather his getting out of the sinful decision. I mean I really don't like the idea of saying that, if you're sleeping together, you're a hopeless case and it's not worth getting married; just keep on ruining your life. I know that's not what you're thinking, but that's what it seems to say to me. If you don't support someone's choice to more from a sinful situation to a regular situation because they are in that sinful situation, what does that say?

Posted

I'd have to concur w/ Maria. I'd much rather a cohabitating couple to resolve the situation by getting married (unless they're not free to marry or the relationship is not able to last) than by less joyful means. Like was said before, they're basically living as if they're married anyway. I'm not trying to condone pre-marital cohabitation, but I see marriage as generally the best way to resolve it.

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1076000' date='Sep 26 2006, 07:55 PM']
If he was Catholic, I would say no. Since his is baptist, what can you do?
[/quote]

I don't think this makes much difference since in this area of morality we agree with pretty much all Christians. I haven't actually prayed about it yet, which would probably be a good thing to do :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...