Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Anyone read it? Is it any good?

[img]https://www.ewtn.com/vcatalogue/images/items/263-1.jpg[/img]

Posted

i hear its excellent, tho i haven't read it.

franciscanheart
Posted

i've just started it. i'm really enoying it. i highly recommend it. :thumbsup:

Posted

I've started reading it. It reminded me of this poem:


[quote name='Sonnet XVII' date=' Pablo Neruda']
I don't love you as if you were the salt-rose, topaz
or arrow of carnations that propagate fire:
I love you as certain dark things are loved,
secretly, between the shadow and the soul.

I love you as the plant that doesn't bloom and carries
hidden within itself the light of those flowers,
and thanks to your love, darkly in my body
lives the dense fragrance that rises from the earth.

I love you without knowing how, or when, or from where,
I love you simply, without problems or pride:
I love you in this way because I don't know any other way of loving

but this, in which there is no I or you,
so intimate that your hand upon my chest is my hand,
so intimate that when I fall asleep it is your eyes that close.

-Pablo Neruda, Sonnet XVII
[/quote]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

it's phat. my copy is at Luthien's house right now.

Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1076058' date='Sep 26 2006, 08:45 PM']
Anyone read it? Is it any good?

[img]https://www.ewtn.com/vcatalogue/images/items/263-1.jpg[/img]
[/quote]

I am a Secular Carmelite and I am not so much reading the book, as slowly going through it. Fr. Dubay has much to say and there are alot of lessons to be learned in this book.

It is an excellent book and very down to earth. I think there is something in there for everyone. Just thumb through it and see what you think.

Posted

I've got a big Q:

Repeatedly, Fr. Dubay states that discursive meditation is to be abandoned once infused prayer is reached. Doesn't that conflict w/ lots of statements about saying the rosary every day (particularly in terms of apparitions)?

Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1082213' date='Oct 2 2006, 05:12 PM']
I've got a big Q:

Repeatedly, Fr. Dubay states that discursive meditation is to be abandoned once infused prayer is reached. Doesn't that conflict w/ lots of statements about saying the rosary every day (particularly in terms of apparitions)?
[/quote]
If you're not able to finish a rosary because God is giving you infused contemplation, you should just go along with whatever God wants. You can at least [i]start[/i] a rosary every day.

I think it is often possible to kind of look at a mystery without discursively meditating on it. Some kinds of infused contemplation won't make you stop praying the rosary.

If you don't use some kind of external prompt, it may be hard to finish in a timely manner, though. :mellow:

(That is one of my favorite books!)

Posted

You should never abandon the rosary as if you have outgrown it. If this were the book's assertion, the book would be wrong. The only way you can "outgrow" the rosary is by saying the 150 psalms on those beads with your aves. Prayer formulas are important because they keep you grounded to a truth which you can fully know is outside of yourself. to always only abandon yourself to meditative prayer outside of set formulas is to abandon the unity and teaching of the Church in your prayer and leave yourself unprotected from the trickery of satan. because of this, any meditation technique which purported to tell you that you should abandon the rosary because it is so much more sophisticated and higher-level is a trick of satan.

I don't know what this man discusses in his book, all I can say is never view your meditation, no matter how much it lifts you in intimate communion with God, as outgrowing formulated prayers. rather, infuse those formulated prayers with that deeper love and knowledge you have received; ever being faithful to the formulated prayers as well.

but it shouldn't become an either/or question until you have become so raptured in perpetual divine ecstacy that you never return to everyday activity... and if that happens (perpetually) then I'm thinking you'll be entering heaven shortly.

also, God never gives you anything that would distract you from the Holy Rosary. if He gives you this infused meditation while you are praying your rosary, continue with your rosary allowing this infused contemplation to give deeper meaning to the prayers. infused contemplation should never take away your ability to concentrate on the mysteries of the rosary nor your cognitave ability to pray aves through them.

Posted

Leaving aside Fr. Dubay's book, here's some of his source material--

From [url="http://www.ccel.org/ccel/john_cross/dark_night.vii.x.html"]St. John of the Cross[/url] Dark Night, Chapter Ten:[quote]DURING the time, then, of the aridities of this night of sense (wherein God effects the change of which we have spoken above, drawing forth the soul from the life of sense into that of the spirit—that is, from meditation to contemplation—wherein it no longer has any power to work or to reason with its faculties concerning the things of God [. . .]

The way in which they are to conduct themselves in this night of sense is to devote themselves not at all to reasoning and meditation, since this is not the time for it, but to allow the soul to remain in peace and quietness [. . .]

What they must do is merely to leave the soul free and disencumbered and at rest from all knowledge and thought, troubling not themselves, in that state, about what they shall think or meditate upon, but contenting themselves with merely a peaceful and loving attentiveness toward God[/quote]
From St. Teresa of Avila's [url="http://www.ccel.org/ccel/teresa/castle2.ix.i.html"]Interior Castle[/url], describing the Fifth Mansions:
[quote]I said ‘some,’ but in reality there are very few who never enter this mansion: some more and some less, but most of them may be said at least to gain admittance into these rooms. [. . .]

Do not imagine that this state of prayer is, like the one preceding it, a sort of drowsiness (I call it ’drowsiness’ because the soul seems to slumber, being neither quite asleep nor wholly awake). In the prayer of union the soul is asleep, fast asleep, as regards the world and itself: in fact, during the short time this state lasts it is deprived of all feeling whatever, being unable to think on any subject, even if it wished. No effort is needed here to suspend the thoughts: if the soul can love it knows not how, nor whom it loves, nor what it desires. In fact, it has died entirely to this world, to live more truly than ever in God.[/quote]

I think, likely, saying a rosary in a group would still be possible, but I think solo vocal prayer it might become hard for an individual in either of the above-described states. Being unable to meditate at such a time would not be a failing on their part.

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1082626' date='Oct 3 2006, 01:33 AM']
Leaving aside Fr. Dubay's book, here's some of his source material--

From [url="http://www.ccel.org/ccel/john_cross/dark_night.vii.x.html"]St. John of the Cross[/url] Dark Night, Chapter Ten:
From St. Teresa of Avila's [url="http://www.ccel.org/ccel/teresa/castle2.ix.i.html"]Interior Castle[/url], describing the Fifth Mansions:
I think, likely, saying a rosary in a group would still be possible, but I think solo vocal prayer it might become hard for an individual in either of the above-described states. Being unable to meditate at such a time would not be a failing on their part.
[/quote]
I think this is Father Dubay's message as well. I do not think he means anything other than what people have said thus far. It did not occur to me that he would be saying it any other way, at least.

Posted

I have not read the good priest's book, so I am just offering general advice. Notice St. John says " this is not the time for [reasoning and meditation]", this supposed that there are times for it; and if you set out a time for it (reasoning, meditation, i.e. rosary) then God will not send you anything that would distract you from completing it. this type of prayer is not a "graduation" from the other type of prayer as if the other type of prayer should no longer be practiced.. it should surely make those prayers more meaningful but it should not be done in replacement of them... because the mind and its reasonings are not things merely of this world but also of the next.

Posted

I guess to get at whether I'm understanding it properly, it's not when you've gotten to the 4th mansion that you should entirely abandon the rosary, but that when God is actively infusing prayer, to try anything else would be ludicrous. Is that accurate?

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1082764' date='Oct 3 2006, 07:36 AM']
I guess to get at whether I'm understanding it properly, it's not when you've gotten to the 4th mansion that you should entirely abandon the rosary, but that when God is actively infusing prayer, to try anything else would be ludicrous. Is that accurate?
[/quote]
Sounds right to me.

Posted

and I still suggest that God would not send something to distract you from completing a rosary you set out to complete. it'd be like God giving you this infused grace in the middle of mass and you no longer paying attention to any of the words of the liturgy... it'd be ludicrous and it wouldn't be from God. if you're praying a rosary, it is time for reasoning and meditation. if you are meditating this way, then as St. John of the Cross says, it is not time for reasoning. Both times continue to remain vitally important.

personally, in many ways, I find myself with Hilaire Belloc on this type of prayer: "I don't say-I am not so foolish to say-that it is false. But I do say that I was never made for understanding this "union with God" business: St. Theresa and the rest. I don't know what it is all about and the description of isolation and detachment, "the necessary night of the soul," disgusts me like Wagner's music or boiled mutton. Good for others: not for me. I am no more fitted to it than is an elephant for caviar, or a dog for irony"

This type of prayer isn't for everybody, and those who do reach it are not somehow praying better or uniting with God better than the average Catholic clutching his rosary beads.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1083093' date='Oct 3 2006, 02:20 PM']
and I still suggest that God would not send something to distract you from completing a rosary you set out to complete. it'd be like God giving you this infused grace in the middle of mass and you no longer paying attention to any of the words of the liturgy... it'd be ludicrous and it wouldn't be from God. if you're praying a rosary, it is time for reasoning and meditation. if you are meditating this way, then as St. John of the Cross says, it is not time for reasoning. Both times continue to remain vitally important.[/quote]

I wouldn't call infused prayer a distraction. It's like saying that a phone call from the president is a distraction when you're trying to read his biography to learn about him. I've read accounts of saints going into ecstasies and infused prayer, losing contact w/ the outside world, directly triggered by receiving the Eucharist. (I want to say St. Faustina, at least, but I'm not positive on that.)

[quote]This type of prayer isn't for everybody, and those who do reach it are not somehow praying better or uniting with God better than the average Catholic clutching his rosary beads.
[/quote]

Fr. Dubay (and I'm not saying he's right for sure, but he makes a great argument for it) argues directly against that. Unfortunately, I don't have a complete enough grasp of it to be able to articulate it well or succinctly.

Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1084138' date='Oct 4 2006, 05:55 PM']
I wouldn't call infused prayer a distraction. It's like saying that a phone call from the president is a distraction when you're trying to read his biography to learn about him. I've read accounts of saints going into ecstasies and infused prayer, losing contact w/ the outside world, directly triggered by receiving the Eucharist. (I want to say St. Faustina, at least, but I'm not positive on that.)[/quote]

well the Eucharist is the culmination of the mass, I understand that. that'd be like going into ecstacy upon the completion of the last mystery of the rosary but before you had said the salve regina... but would such a thing happen at the credo during the mass? and you just would no longer be supposed to focus and pay attention to the words and form of the liturgy? no, I don't believe such a thing would be from God.

it would be a distraction if it caused you not to complete a rosary that you started. God would not interrupt you that way, IMHO.

[quote name='scardella' post='1084138' date='Oct 4 2006, 05:55 PM']
Fr. Dubay (and I'm not saying he's right for sure, but he makes a great argument for it) argues directly against that. Unfortunately, I don't have a complete enough grasp of it to be able to articulate it well or succinctly.
[/quote]
I believe he is wrong if he attempts to assert that his personal spirituality, or even the spirituality of any one saint, is better than the spirituality of any other person, or of any other saint. If I have a spirituality like St. Dominic and ferverently pray 15 mysteries of the rosary every day, that doesn't make me any less united to God than one who has a spirituality like St. John of the Cross. I would go so far as to argue, if this is what he is saying, that he is caught up in the spirit which is directly condemned by the inspired pen of St. Paul in the Scriptures.

perhaps many are called to this type of spirituality. good, such people will probably not find as much fulfillment in other types of spirituality as they will in this type which they are called to. but others are not called to this type of spirituality. all are called to a union with God, but "infused prayer" is not the only, nor necessarily the best, way to approach that.

Posted

I'd just like to clarify (and again remind everyone I haven't even read this book so this is not a critique of the book, but of the positions of the book as I understand them as they have been related to me here): if the good father has merely said that it is possible for everyone, then I have no problem. if he has said that it is preferable for everyone, I think he might be overstepping there. if he has said that it is a better way of approaching God than other legitimate spiritualities within the Church, then you may apply what I said above about his position (that his spirituality or even the spirituality of St John of the Cross is better than others' within the Church) being condemned by St. Paul (see: divisions where some say "I follow Paul" or "I follow Kephas" or "I follow Jesus") this would, of course, reflect nothing ill towards his actual spirituality, just his attitude that it is better than others' spiritualities.

Posted (edited)

To clarify a little bit, Dubay argues that teresian/sanjuan teachings on mystical/infused prayer are a universal call bound up directly in the Gospel. He even goes so far as to say that it is simply a more concrete look at natural prayer progression; ie it is not a spirituality, [i]per se[/i], in the sense that you have an Ignatian or a Franciscan spirituality.

If he is right, then the average person should aspire to receive mystical contemplation, and it wouldn't be a matter of "following Kephas" or "following Paul" or "following Jesus". If he's wrong, he seems well intentioned. I haven't yet found any problems with it. I can say that I haven't run across anything that would give me doubts about his orthodoxy. He quotes Scripture, Vatican II, saints (at least one or two other than our friendly Carmelites; and I'm not finished w/ it).

Like I said, though, I'd recommend reading it to see what he has to say, because I'm not quite familiar enough to actually argue the point.

Edited by scardella
Posted

I would have a problem with that, because that would mean a majority of the faithful over 2000 years, and indeed a great number of saints, had never 'progressed' into this better type of union with God. this is one way of responding to and approaching the universal call of prayer and union with God found in the gospels, but it is not the only way nor is it necessarily the best way for everyone. it is [i]a[/i] spirituality compatible with the gospels, not [i]the[/i] spirituality compatible with the gospels.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...