N/A Gone Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 [quote]Regarding the Jews, the Eastern Orthodox Church might declare a day of mourning and repentance for the numerous anti-Semitic statements by the fourth century patriarch John Chrysostom, who among other things, said this about the Jews: The Jews are the most worthless of all men – they are lecherous, greedy, rapacious – they worship the devil, their religion is a sickness…the Jews are the odious assassins of Christ and for killing God there is no expiation possible, no indulgence or pardon. Christians may never cease vengeance and the Jews must live in servitude forever. God always hated the Jews and whoever has intercourse with the Jews will be rejected on Judgment Day. It is incumbent upon all Christians to hate the Jews. [/quote] [quote]And Roman Catholics could certainly join in mourning and repentance for their long history of anti-Semitism. Consider this statement by Thomas Aquinas: It would be perfectly licit to hold the Jews, because of their crucifying the Lord, in perpetual servitude. [/quote] whats the context of these?
Era Might Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 (edited) The context is religious anti-Judaism, not racial. It is true that the Saints were people of their time, and frequently fell into anti-Judaism and other polemics against Jews. This was not about race, as it was with the Nazis, but about religion, and a seeming conflict between Christians and Jews as the people of two opposing covenants. The Church has put this "theology of contempt" to rest in the last 50 years or so, and has opened the way for a positive vision of Catholic-Jewish relations. There are also other historical factors that have to be accounted for when dealing with this subject. Especially in the early Church, a lot of Jewish converts were forcing their Jewish heritage on the Gentile converts, and the Churches were genuinely worried about "Judaizing", which led to conflict and, unfortunately, contributed to the antipathy for the Jewish religion. A lot of this was based on an erroneous idea that the Jewish people inherited some kind of "guilt" because of their forefathers who helped crucify Our Lord. But the Jewish people bear no guilt anymore than the Gentiles do for the actions of the Romans. [quote]As Holy Scripture testifies, Jerusalem did not recognize the time of her visitation, nor did the Jews in large number, accept the Gospel; indeed not a few opposed its spreading. Nevertheless, God holds the Jews most dear for the sake of their Fathers; He does not repent of the gifts He makes or of the calls He issues-such is the witness of the Apostle. In company with the Prophets and the same Apostle, the Church awaits that day, known to God alone, on which all peoples will address the Lord in a single voice and "serve him shoulder to shoulder" (Soph. 3:9). Since the spiritual patrimony common to Christians and Jews is thus so great, this sacred synod wants to foster and recommend that mutual understanding and respect which is the fruit, above all, of biblical and theological studies as well as of fraternal dialogues. True, the Jewish authorities and those who followed their lead pressed for the death of Christ; still, what happened in His passion cannot be charged against all the Jews, without distinction, then alive, nor against the Jews of today. Although the Church is the new people of God, the Jews should not be presented as rejected or accursed by God, as if this followed from the Holy Scriptures. All should see to it, then, that in catechetical work or in the preaching of the word of God they do not teach anything that does not conform to the truth of the Gospel and the spirit of Christ. Furthermore, in her rejection of every persecution against any man, the Church, mindful of the patrimony she shares with the Jews and moved not by political reasons but by the Gospel's spiritual love, decries hatred, persecutions, displays of anti-Semitism, directed against Jews at any time and by anyone. --Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Declaration "Nostra Aetate"[/quote] [quote]The permanence of Israel (while so many ancient peoples have disappeared without trace) is a historic fact and a sign to be interpreted within God's design. We must in any case rid ourselves of the traditional idea of a people punished, preserved as a living argument for Christian apologetic. It remains a chosen people, "the pure olive on which were grafted the branches of the wild olive which are the gentiles" (John Paul II, 6th March, 1982, alluding to Rom 11:17-24). We must remember how much the balance of relations between Jews and Christians over two thousand years has been negative. We must remind ourselves how the permanence of Israel is accompanied by a continuous spiritual fecundity, in the rabbinical period, in the Middle Ages and in modern times, taking its start from a patrimony which we long shared, so much so that "the faith and religious life of the Jewish people as they are professed and practised still today, can greatly help us to understand better certain aspects of the life of the Church" (John Paul II, March 6th, 1982). Catechesis should on the other hand help in understanding the meaning for the Jews of the extermination during the years 1939-1945, and its consequences. --The Holy See's "Notes on the correct ways to present the Jews and Judaism in preaching and catechesis in the Roman Catholic Church"[/quote] Edited September 27, 2006 by Era Might
Mateo el Feo Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 I don't have a reply; but did have a question: does the author provide citations for the statements attributed to St. John Chrysostom and St. Thomas Aquinas? Also (just curious), who's the author of the text quoted?
Era Might Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 The Chrysostom citations probably come from his famous 8 homilies against the Jews (you can find it through google). Don't know about Aquinas. If you did get this from some website, I agree, the source issue is a common problem. I'll often see a quote somewhere, and I'll google it, and you'll only find different websites quoting the same text, with no citation. They just go around, and nobody ever substantiates the citations, so they're not trustworthy unless you know the source yourself. But, even with the Chrysostom quotes, I have tried to substantiate them when his 8 homilies were cited, but couldn't find the text they were supposedly quoting. So, even there, you should verify a citation for specific quotes. For example, the website that provides the 8 homilies has an introduction to the homilies, and has supposed summaries of what he says. According to them, in homily 6, paragraph 1, he says God hates the Jews. But there is nothing like that in homily 6, paragraph 1. I don't know what they're looking at, and they don't provide quotes, they only provide summaries about what he supposedly says, so who know what they're reading.
N/A Gone Posted September 27, 2006 Author Posted September 27, 2006 A very intellegent woman I dialogue with; has a pastor that cited both of these in a sermon. This part was about anti-jewish catholicism.
Era Might Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 What was the purpose of the sermon? Conflict between Christians and Jews is hardly a Catholic phenomena. The same problem existed after the Reformation for Protestants. It is what it is, a historical tragedy. And the antipathy was not always one-sided, particularly in the early Church, when Jews regularly persecuted and killed Christians. It's also a strange citation, because St. John Chrysostom and St. Thomas Aquinas were theologians, but their word is not Catholic doctrine. They were subject to error as much as anyone is. And I would ask for a specific citation from St. John Chrysostom and St. Thomas Aquinas, just for the record. It's hard to discuss something unless the facts are first verified. It would do not good to argue about something these Saints never said.
N/A Gone Posted September 27, 2006 Author Posted September 27, 2006 Here it is in context sir.. [quote]here's a letter from my pastor to our entire congregation (i put some very interesting comments in bold): Can There Be Peace In The Middle East? by Rich Nathan Recent events in the Middle East have led many to wonder whether there can be any framework for peace between Jews and Arabs in the Middle East. The Iranian President, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, has repeatedly made controversial statements questioning the Holocaust, and criticized European laws against Holocaust denial. According to numerous media reports, he stated that “they have invented a myth that Jews were massacred.” In July, Hezbollah para-military forces fired rockets and mortars into Israel resulting in the death of eight Israeli soldiers. Another Hezbollah unit crossed the border and seized two Israeli soldiers. Israel responded with massive air strikes killing over a thousand people, mostly Lebanese civilians, and displacing nearly one million Lebanese citizens. At the end of July, Israeli air strikes hit an apartment building in Qana. Human Rights Watch later confirmed that at least 28 died, of which 16 were children, with 13 more still missing. The conflict between the Israelis and Palestinians continues unabated. The Palestinians interpreted Ariel Sharon’s visit to the Dome of the Rock on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem (accompanied by a thousand police officers) as an act of extreme provocation. It became the event which sparked the second Intifada in which Palestinians took this to the streets in protest. These protests became more and more violent in the ensuing months with a series of suicide bombings. Both Jews and Arabs can cite a laundry list of injustices suffered at the hands of the other side. Both have become so vividly identified with their own sufferings that they have become blinded to the very real pain suffered by the other. Indeed, it has become a litmus test of allegiance to one’s own side to minimize, ignore, or distort the other side’s pain and to deny the other side’s right to exist as a nation. Can Christians inside and outside of the Middle East play a role in bringing peace? We who follow the Prince of Peace must first publicly repent of our own complicity in the terrible tragedy that has befallen Jews and Muslims. Before the Christian church will have any credibility in speaking a word of reconciliation, the church must take the massive log out of our own eye. Only then will we see clearly enough to take the splinter out of the eyes of our Jewish and Muslim brothers and sisters. Where shall we begin? Each church must examine its own history and ask forgiveness from Jews and Muslims for the crimes perpetuated against these two great peoples. Regarding the Jews, the Eastern Orthodox Church might declare a day of mourning and repentance for the numerous anti-Semitic statements by the fourth century patriarch John Chrysostom, who among other things, said this about the Jews: The Jews are the most worthless of all men – they are lecherous, greedy, rapacious – they worship the devil, their religion is a sickness…the Jews are the odious assassins of Christ and for killing God there is no expiation possible, no indulgence or pardon. Christians may never cease vengeance and the Jews must live in servitude forever. God always hated the Jews and whoever has intercourse with the Jews will be rejected on Judgment Day. It is incumbent upon all Christians to hate the Jews. Lutherans could join in that day of mourning and repentance for statements made by Martin Luther in which he said: [We must] set their synagogues on fire, and whatever does not burn up should be covered or spread over with dirt so that no one may ever be able to see a cinder or stone of it…in order that God may see that we are Christians…their homes should likewise be broken down and destroyed…they should be deprived of their prayer books and Talmuds…their rabbis must be forbidden to teach under the threat of death. And Roman Catholics could certainly join in mourning and repentance for their long history of anti-Semitism. Consider this statement by Thomas Aquinas: It would be perfectly licit to hold the Jews, because of their crucifying the Lord, in perpetual servitude. Of course, since the Holocaust, Jews have ceased to take the moral credibility of the church seriously. 90% of Germans before the war and in all probability, an even larger proportion of Poles, attended church weekly. Yet it is a tragic fact of history that many of these churchgoers participated in the extermination of European Jewry and very, very few raised a voice of protest or actually engaged in the rescue and protection of Jews. And it would be fitting regarding this day of Christian repentance and mourning to confess and grieve over the church’s treatment of Muslims for the past thousand years. Where shall we begin in our repentance regarding Muslims? The Crusades wouldn’t be a bad starting point. When Christian knights from Western Europe recaptured Jerusalem from the Muslims, they massacred the entire population of the city, both Muslims and Jews. Muslims were burned alive in mosques during the retaking of the Holy Land. More recently, the world stood by silently as tens of thousands of Muslims were slaughtered by Orthodox and Roman Catholic Christians in the former Yugoslavia. Following 9/11, Evangelical and Pentecostal Christians showed remarkable insensitivity to Muslim sensibilities, almost going out of their way to offend and provoke Muslims. Thus, Franklin Graham said: “I believe Islam is a very evil and wicked religion.” Benny Hinn said, concerning the Palestinian/Israeli conflict: “We are on God’s side. This is not a war between Arabs and Jews. It is a war between God and the devil.” Jerry Falwell called the prophet of Islam, Muhammad, a “terrorist” on CBS’s 60 Minutes. Pat Robertson said that Islam is “a monumental scam,” and claimed the prophet Muhammad was “an absolutely wild-eyed fanatic…a robber and brigand…a killer.” And, of course, Christian Zionists refuse to acknowledge that Palestinians have any legitimate claim to any part of the Holy Land thus eliminating their role as impartial mediators of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict. Following repentance, we Christians must reject a false interpretation of the ancient promises made by God to Abraham. It is simply not the case that the promises made to Abraham implies the biblical right of Jews to control the entirety of the Holy Land in the 21st century. God’s gift of the land to Abraham, according to the Old and New Testaments, was made with a view of God revealing himself eventually to the whole human race. The gift of the land was not an end in itself, but a means of God extending his love to the ends of the earth (for more on this huge issue, see Whose Promised Land? The Continuing Crisis Over Israel and Palestine by Colin Chapman). It is entirely biblical to promote a two-sided partition of the Holy Land, with Jews and Muslims living side-by-side in peace. We Christians must renounce the unwise view that more weapons and a greater military buildup in the Middle East will somehow bring peace to that region. We Christians must humbly invite Jews and Muslims to acknowledge the suffering and the pain each has caused the other. We must further encourage the view that the land belongs to God and not to the Jews or to the Muslims. One of the most helpful perspectives on this conflict was offered by Naim Ateek, a Palestinian Christian priest. Father Ateek said this: The Palestinians need to become conscious of and sensitive to the horror of the Holocaust, Nazi Germany’s attempt to exterminate the Jews. Granted the Holocaust was not a Middle Eastern phenomenon, and the Palestinians had nothing to do with it; nevertheless, we need to understand the extent of the trauma for the Jews…we as Palestinians have refused to accept, much less to internalize, the horrible tragedy of the Holocaust. We have resisted even acknowledging it, believing that we have been subjected to our own Holocaust at the hands of the Jews. As we adopt a new attitude vis-a-vis the Holocaust…we may candidly acknowledge that the only justification that the Palestinians will accept for the creation of a Jewish State in Palestine is the Holocaust. It was the Holocaust and only the Holocaust that necessitated a home for the Jews. The Palestinians have to come to accept giving the Jews the best part of Palestine (Western Palestine), not because they had any right to it, not because of the Balfour Declaration, and not even because of anti-Semitism, but because of the Holocaust. Father Ateek went on to address the Jews saying: Jews in Israel must approach the Palestinians saying: “We are sorry that we came to you with arrogance and a feeling of superiority. We came with good and not so good reasons. But we are now here in the land. Forgive us for the wrong and the injustice that we have caused you. We took part of your country. We ignored you. We pretended that you did not exist, or even worse, that you did not matter. We stereotyped you, convincing others that you are all terrorists. We have refused to recognize that you have any rights, while we have insisted that you should recognize and legitimate our right to your land. We have insisted and convinced the United States and others to insist that you recognize our claim to your land. We have wronged you. Your own country of Palestine used to be our country 2000 years ago. We still have many cherished historic memories that keep pulling us to it. It is ‘our Holy Land’ too, our ‘Promised Land’ also. But there is room for both of us here, both Jews and Arabs.” Is there any hope for peace in the Middle East? I believe there is. But the conditions for peace have plainly been laid out by the Prince of Peace, Jesus the Messiah. There can be no peace until individuals, religions and nations are willing to acknowledge not only their own pain and their own injustices suffered, but the pain and injustice suffered by their enemies, as well as the pain and suffering perpetuated at our own hands. A willingness to acknowledge the pain of the other is the first step towards creating a just and lasting peace.[/quote]
Era Might Posted September 27, 2006 Posted September 27, 2006 (edited) Well, aside from the reference to the Crusades, which is loaded and completely ignores the complexity of the situation, the Catholic Church has already dealt with the historic Christian anti-Judaism. Has this Pastor never read "Nostra Aetate" or the many documents from the Holy See in the last 50 years that expressed sorrow for the past, and initiated renewed relations? In fact, Pope John Paul II publicly and formally apologized on behalf of the Church's people who may have sinned in the past. What more can we do? We can't get on our knees and beg forgiveness every other week. Christian and Jewish relations have taken a turn for the better. The Church is already involved in the process of peace in the Middle East. [quote]More recently, the world stood by silently as tens of thousands of Muslims were slaughtered by Orthodox and Roman Catholic Christians in the former Yugoslavia. [/quote] A million and a half Christians were killed by Ottoman Turks in the Armenian genocide. The past is the past, and there is enough blame to go around on all sides. Edited September 27, 2006 by Era Might
Resurrexi Posted September 28, 2006 Posted September 28, 2006 I don't think there is anything wrong about those saints said, I actually will try to emitate their belief on the Jews from now on, I mean, they are both Doctors of the Church... so we should listen to them. [quote]This was not about race, as it was with the Nazis, but about religion[/quote] very true. [quote]But the Jewish people bear no guilt anymore than the Gentiles do for the actions of the Romans.[/quote] Myself, The Angelic Doctor, and 1900 years worth of Christians would beg to differ.
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 28, 2006 Posted September 28, 2006 [url="http://www.klezmonauts.com/"]Oy to the World!![/url]
N/A Gone Posted September 28, 2006 Author Posted September 28, 2006 (edited) oh..I got a reply.. [quote]I never thought it was racial, I always suspected it was religious. How can an INFALLIBLE church ever come up with a notion that there is no way of forgiveness for the Jews? I don't care if it was an old thought and if your church has been more open-minded in the last 50 years...That has idea has always been completely contrary to what Jesus himself said a long, long time ago: that he is the savior of JEWS and Gentiles. The Muslim Allah is definitely not the same as the Christian God. Here's why: Muslims believe the idea of a Triune God is an abomination. That alone makes their understanding of God very clearly different than ours. They also reject the incarnation of God as Jesus and that Allah would have to suffer for our sins. [/quote] oyoy... Edited September 28, 2006 by Revprodeji
Era Might Posted September 28, 2006 Posted September 28, 2006 (edited) [quote]How can an INFALLIBLE church ever come up with a notion that there is no way of forgiveness for the Jews? I don't care if it was an old thought and if your church has been more open-minded in the last 50 years[/quote] #1) Just because the Church possesses a charism of infallibility doesn't mean everything her leaders say is infallible. This is a basic rule of Catholic theology. That must be clarified off the bat. #2) The Church never taught that "there is no way of forgiveness for the Jews". That's why there have always been Jewish converts to Catholicism. Even in the most hardened circles of contempt for the Jewish religion among Catholic thinkers, the entrance into the Church through baptism was always open; again, because it was not a racial conflict, it was religious. #3) Aside from specific historical examples that you would like to bring up, it's hard to address a broad issue like this. A "theology of contempt" is not a doctrine or specific theological principle, but a broad negative outlook on the Jewish religion as a dead entity because of the coming of the New Covenant. Christian thought over the centuries contributed to antipathy for Jews because of this theological error. But, even in Christendom, there were always voices which protected the Jewish people from the regrettable excess of the time. Pope Clement VI had to threaten a group called "the flagellants" with excommunication in the 14th century for their sins against Jews: [quote]Beneath an appearance of piety, [the Flagellants] set their hands to cruel and impious works, shedding the blood of Jews, whom Christian piety accept and sustain.[/quote] The Catechism of the Council of Trent also formally repudiated any special "guilt" for the Jewish people: [quote]In this guilt [for Christ's death] are involved all those who fall frequently into sin; for, as our sins consigned Christ the Lord to the death of the cross, most certainly those who wallow in sin and iniquity crucify to themselves again the Son of God. ...This guilt seems more enormous in us than in the Jews since, if they had known it, they would never have crucified the Lord of glory; while we, on the contrary, professing to know him, yet denying him by our actions, seem in some sort to lay violent hands on him.[/quote] Pope Benedict XV also addressed this problem in 1915: [quote]The Supreme Pontiff...as Head of the Catholic Church, which, faithful to its divine doctrines and its most glorious traditions, considers all men as brothers and teaches them to love one another, he never ceases to indicate among individuals, as well as among peoples, the observance of the principles of the natural law, and to condemn everything that violates them. This law must be observed and respected in the case of the children of Israel, as well as of all others, because it would not be comformable to justice or to religion itself to derogate from it solely on account of divergence of religious confessions.[/quote] During World War II, the Catholic Church was a hero to the Jewish people. Albert Einstein, a Jew, wrote: [quote]Only the Church stood squarely across the path of Hitler's campaign for suppressing truth. I never had any special interest in the Church before, but now I feel a great affection and admiration because the Church alone has had the courage and persistence to stand for intellectual truth and moral freedom. I am forced thus to confess that what I once despised I now praise unreservedly.[/quote] It's necessary to have a full historical perspective before imagining Catholics as monolithic haters of Jews. Edited September 28, 2006 by Era Might
Mateo el Feo Posted September 28, 2006 Posted September 28, 2006 Great post, Era Might! Still curious about the sources for the original post's quotes...
kenrockthefirst Posted September 29, 2006 Posted September 29, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1077516' date='Sep 27 2006, 11:05 PM']Myself, The Angelic Doctor, and 1900 years worth of Christians would beg to differ. [/quote] So, what, the Jews *were* responsible for Christ's death. Gee, and here was I thinking that it was necessary as the result of the Fall and all of mankind's sin. Bad Jews! Bad! BTW, *if* the Jews *were* "responsible" for Christ's death, isn't it a good thing that they were there so God's purpose could be accomplished?
Resurrexi Posted October 2, 2006 Posted October 2, 2006 Christ didn't have to suffer the way he did. [quote] 12 Q. Was it necessary for Jesus Christ to suffer as much as He actually did? A. No, it was not absolutely necessary for Jesus Christ to suffer as much as He did, because each of His acts being of infinite value, the least of His sufferings would have sufficed for our redemption. 13 Q. Why, then, did Jesus suffer so much? A. Jesus Christ suffered so much in order to satisfy divine justice all the more abundantly; to display His love for us still more; and to inspire us with the deepest horror of sin. [/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now