Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Loaded Question Regarding Reconciliation


Recommended Posts

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

OK, I realize this may require an indepth answer so take your time if necessary. I have never thought of this before tonight, and don't know how to answer this question. Have not been asked it I'm just curious.

1) The Church recognizes Baptisms performed outside the church as long as it is valid. Form and Matter, right?
2) This means that these persons recieving the sacrament outside the Church are part of the Family of God, we refer to as seperated brethen
3) Reconciliation is reserved only for those who have been baptised and members of the Church or in preperation for being recieved into the Church.
4) in the case of those being recieved into the church they are not yet in full union with Rome
5) Why do is it allowed then for those recieving baptism outside the Church to recieve Reconciliation when joining the Church, but not yet recieved, but at the same time, say a Non-denominational Christian, who has been baptized, recognizes the need and validity of baptism in the Church, but not yet ready to join the Church entirely can not recieve the Sacrament?

They are both necessary, so why is one recognized in the cases of those outside the Church, but the other is not?

Posted

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' post='1077570' date='Sep 28 2006, 12:40 AM']
OK, I realize this may require an indepth answer so take your time if necessary. I have never thought of this before tonight, and don't know how to answer this question. Have not been asked it I'm just curious.

1) The Church recognizes Baptisms performed outside the church as long as it is valid. Form and Matter, right?
2) This means that these persons recieving the sacrament outside the Church are part of the Family of God, we refer to as seperated brethen
3) Reconciliation is reserved only for those who have been baptised and members of the Church or in preperation for being recieved into the Church.
4) in the case of those being recieved into the church they are not yet in full union with Rome
5) Why do is it allowed then for those recieving baptism outside the Church to recieve Reconciliation when joining the Church, but not yet recieved, but at the same time, say a Non-denominational Christian, who has been baptized, recognizes the need and validity of baptism in the Church,[b] but not yet ready to join the Church entirely[/b] can not recieve the Sacrament?

They are both necessary, so why is one recognized in the cases of those outside the Church, but the other is not?
[/quote]

You have the answer in bold.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...