Lil Red Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 in my diocese, the past two bishops will not allow a permanent diaconate program. hopefully a new bishop will allow it.
Dave Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 [quote name='Oik' post='1083892' date='Oct 4 2006, 03:17 PM'] Dave, All the Eastern Catholic Churches the Body and Blood of Christ are given and the most I have ever seen is five priests. Granted, we use intinction (or the Body of Christ is in the Chalice with the Blood, given to the servant of God or handmaid of the Lord with a spoon). I have seen priest give by intinction. It is quick, 'painless' and the servant or handmaid recieves Christ's Body and Blood. [/quote] I realize the Eastern Catholic Churches distribute Communion under both species, but that's just it -- they use intinction, which makes EMs unnecessary! And I'd personally love to see intinction practiced more widely in the Western Rite (I know it's allowed), but parishes that actually practice intinction are almost nonexistent.
goldenchild17 Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1083552' date='Oct 4 2006, 12:14 AM'] I do not believe it is permitted for a priest to distribute both at an FSSP mass. [/quote] I totally had a mental lapse there. I don't know what I was thinking about when I posted that (it was late : ) but yes, at both of the churches I mentioned, what I meant to say is that the priests only distribute His Precious Body, not the Blood at all, which the priest himself consumes. Except in cases of ciliac disease, which a whole family at the FSSP parish, had. In which case he distributed the Blood alone to them. Sorry about the confusion .
shortnun Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Dave' post='1083882' date='Oct 4 2006, 01:58 PM'] Distributing Communion under both species greatly increases the number of EMs being used at Masses. If most parishes just offered one species, then fewer EMs would be necessary at Mass -- if any would even be necessary at all. [/quote] The liturgical priority is that both species are distributed. But suddenly, to obey what is "ideal" for canon law (I'm not saying it's not abused), we look for a solution that seems easiest? It seems like we're putting a splint and a cast on a finger with a papercut. [quote name='Aloysius' post='1083907' date='Oct 4 2006, 02:19 PM'] because certain people think it's the answer to VII's call for the laity to be more "actively involved" in the liturgy. Of course, the Vatican has condemned that attitude many times, but it still persists. the bishops are afraid to institute more permanent deacons to distribute communion because then they have to kick out all the female EMHCs. same reason they won't make more acolytes who would also have a more proper role distributing communion. They live in a state of compromise with feminists... if we can't let you be priests we'll at least let you storm the altar in as many positions as possible (EMHC, girl altar boy, pastoral assosiate, music director, et cetera et cetera) [/quote] All the members of Christ's body are called to participate in the liturgy--in the entire life of the Church. Vatican II didn't come up with that one out of the blue. As for the rest of your post, I can't help but see it as entirely off topic and uncharitable. I'd be happy to speak with you in a new thread about why women (or lay men) can't be pastoral associates or music directors. I'm unfamiliar with documents prohibiting (or discouraging) them from such roles that give life to the Church. [quote name='Lil Red' post='1083916' date='Oct 4 2006, 02:26 PM'] in my diocese, the past two bishops will not allow a permanent diaconate program. hopefully a new bishop will allow it. [/quote] It is a truly life-giving ministry. It is very difficult to begin from scratch, and to continue to do well. I join you in your prayers for your bishop.
Oik Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote]The liturgical priority is that both species are distributed. But suddenly, to obey what is "ideal" for canon law (I'm not saying it's not abused), we look for a solution that seems easiest? It seems like we're putting a splint and a cast on a finger with a papercut.[/quote] Exactly! That's why 15 mins extra waiting in line to receive your Lord and Saviour, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity is not a reason to have any EMHC. Rather, look at the tradition and biblical mandate of the deaconate to fill the roles of service the 30,000+ individuals (of which only 4-5,000 are men though) get paid for. Pay the deacons, not the laity! [quote]All the members of Christ's body are called to participate in the liturgy--in the entire life of the Church. Vatican II didn't come up with that one out of the blue. As for the rest of your post, I can't help but see it as entirely off topic and uncharitable. I'd be happy to speak with you in a new thread about why women (or lay men) can't be pastoral associates or music directors. I'm unfamiliar with documents prohibiting (or discouraging) them from such roles that give life to the Church.[/quote] I think he rather points out the reality that what has sadly arisen from lack men answersing the clerical vocation has become the norm. Namely, the offices praised by St. Igantios (especially the slaves, or deacons his so fond of) and other Church fathers, as well as the legitimate 'minor' orders founded on tradition have been overshadowed and downplayed in preference to the 'participation in th liturgy'. Participation in the liturgy must be according to place. The laity, as Clement says, sound adhere to the layman's code. The laity participate as laity, the clergy as clegy. The minor orders are ordained (institued in Western terms) to the specific task for which they perform.
shortnun Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Oik' post='1084500' date='Oct 4 2006, 11:01 PM'] Exactly! That's why 15 mins extra waiting in line to receive your Lord and Saviour, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity is not a reason to have any EMHC. [/quote] 15 mins!? Perhaps that's just an exaggertation. Participation in the table of the Lord is [u]not [/u]something that should be overly prolonged. And if that's the case, then we ought to look at ways to prevent that (installed acolytes, deacons, etc). [quote name='Oik' post='1084500' date='Oct 4 2006, 11:01 PM'] Rather, look at the tradition and biblical mandate of the deaconate to fill the roles of service the 30,000+ individuals (of which only 4-5,000 are men though) get paid for. Pay the deacons, not the laity! [/quote] I think that the historical development of and appreciation for the role of the deacons has been severely delayed. But let me see if I have this correct: You'd advise that we fire/lay off/etc 25,000+ individuals so that we can just pay men who are installed as deacons a salary? Please correct how I'm reading your post if I'm in error. [quote name='Oik' post='1084500' date='Oct 4 2006, 11:01 PM'] I think he rather points out the reality that what has sadly arisen from lack men answersing the clerical vocation has become the norm. Namely, the offices praised by St. Igantios (especially the slaves, or deacons his so fond of) and other Church fathers, as well as the legitimate 'minor' orders founded on tradition have been overshadowed and downplayed in preference to the 'participation in th liturgy'. Participation in the liturgy must be according to place. The laity, as Clement says, sound adhere to the layman's code. The laity participate as laity, the clergy as clegy. The minor orders are ordained (institued in Western terms) to the specific task for which they perform. [/quote] Yes, absolutely participation must be according to place. Please understand me, I'm not for a total "let's get ride of all rules and orders we have in the church." And I agree that the legitimate minor orders of the Church have been greatly overlooked in the past 1000 years. But I must temper my view with a realistic perspective of a the Church as dynamic, not static. Meaning the concept of "vocation" (particularly that of a "vocation" to minister within the Church) might be defined in ways that aren't explicitly found in scripture or tradition (but are certainly supported by revelation). And I respectfully disagree with your conclusion that a desire for "participation in the liturgy" is at all related to a lack of men "answering the clerical vocation."
Oik Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote]15 mins!? Perhaps that's just an exaggertation. Participation in the table of the Lord is not something that should be overly prolonged. And if that's the case, then we ought to look at ways to prevent that (installed acolytes, deacons, etc).[/quote] We don't even use instruments and the Divine Liturgy is 1hour 20-30mins. God Be praised! Now, even a reverant Roman Mass can be celebrated in an hour with no exemptions. Therefore, what is 15 mins more? We alreay have it! [quote]I think that the historical development of and appreciation for the role of the deacons has been severely delayed. But let me see if I have this correct: You'd advise that we fire/lay off/etc 25,000+ individuals so that we can just pay men who are installed as deacons a salary? Please correct how I'm reading your post if I'm in error.[/quote] There has been a 30 percent increase in lay ministry in 8 years. There are now 30,000 lay ministers with another 30,000 in training. There are only 27,000 priests in active ministry in the USA and 14,000 deacons. So, already, 'lay ministry' has elipsed clerical ministry. Why are we doleing out money for ministry that has no tradition in our Church, yet failing to support the clearly defined, and apostolically instituted ministry already present. Do I think we should fire 25,000 plus people? YES. We need to support the ones that are indispensible to our Church first. [url="http://www.usccb.org/deacon/statisticsworld.shtml"]Deacon statistics[/url] [url="http://www.usccb.org/plm/summary.shtml"]Priest statistics[/url] [quote]Meaning the concept of "vocation" (particularly that of a "vocation" to minister within the Church) might be defined in ways that aren't explicitly found in scripture or tradition (but are certainly supported by revelation). [/quote] Neglect for clearly established clerical orders is not consdiered necessity for new offices. These new 'vocations' obscure already lacking numbers of clerical orders. When the clerical orders are bursting at the seems, then i'd be all for these new 'vocations'. [quote]And I respectfully disagree with your conclusion that a desire for "participation in the liturgy" is at all related to a lack of men "answering the clerical vocation."[/quote] You misunderstand. Rather it is the improper implementation of Vatican II that has lead to erroneous practices and ideas. Proper participation in the liturgy has nothing to do with being an altar server, EMHC, ect. In fact, actual and active, proper participation has to do with each performing thier own role. Laity are laity. Rather, some's desire for a misunderstood participation in the liturgy has lead to the decrease in men answering the clerical calling. All is well though. God is in control and these matters of disciple and praxis will all be hammered out in due time. The clergy, who are eucharistic ministers, Bishops and priests and deacons, ordinary ministers of Commuion, are indispensible, while lay ministry is not firm and fast and can fade into and out of necessity.
Aloysius Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 THe Vatican specifically says that Eucharistic Ministers are NOT in place in order to foster more active participation. Redemptionis Sacramentum: [151.] Only out of true necessity is there to be recourse to the assistance of extraordinary ministers in the celebration of the Liturgy. [b]Such recourse is not intended for the sake of a fuller participation of the laity [/b]but rather, by its very nature, is supplementary and provisional. As to the rest of it, it is very clear from the Vatican that altar boys are preferable, and that instituted offices such as cantor, lector, and acolyte are preferable to temporary non-stable ministries such as music director, reader, and extra-ordinary minister of holy communion. these stable ministries used to have minor orders attached to them but these have since been supressed, the requirement to be male has not. I only mentioned pastoral assosiates in passing and only with those in mind who sit next to the priest during mass in their own pseudo-vestments (it's been known to happen). how and why altar boys are preferable: Redemptionis Sacramentum [47.] It is altogether laudable to maintain the noble custom by which boys or youths, customarily termed servers, provide service of the altar after the manner of acolytes, and receive catechesis regarding their function in accordance with their power of comprehension.[119] Nor should it be forgotten that a great number of sacred ministers over the course of the centuries have come from among boys such as these.[120] Associations for them, including also the participation and assistance of their parents, should be established or promoted, and in such a way greater pastoral care will be provided for the ministers. Whenever such associations are international in nature, it pertains to the competence of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments to establish them or to approve and revise their statutes.[121] Girls or women may also be admitted to this service of the altar, at the discretion of the diocesan Bishop and in observance of the established norms.[122] I never expressed any contention against vatican ii's call for participation in the liturgy, I merely repeated what the vatican has said: being an extra-ordinary minister of holy communion is NOT something which is intended as a 'greater participation in the liturgy fuller participation by the laity means fuller understanding, responses, singing, perhaps bringing up the gifts... not having everyone in the congregation up on the altar doing some job. I am merely relating to you what Rome relates to the churches (and the churches largely disregard). Rome says the diaconate is preferable. Rome says the instituted ministries are preferable over the extra-ordinary in-case of grave necessity ministries. As it stands, the bishops have not provided a structure for the training of real lay lectors, cantors, and acolytes as was Paul VI's intention. This is why, out of necessity and not out of an answer to Vatican II's call for participation, there are readers, music directors, and EMHCs. It is the bishop's duty to provide programs to train and institute acolytes, lectors, and cantors; as well as or even more so deacons; to fill the liturgy with more stable ministries. one would be speaking against the will of Rome and Vatican II if one attempted to say "lay ministries such as EMHCs are in place to give the laity more active participation". Rome sees these things as temporary necessities grudgingly permitted. Rome sees Deacons, Acolytes, Lectors, and Cantors as preferable.
Maria Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Assisting at Mass refers to being there and participating in the prayers, etc. We don't need to be up on the sanctuary. There might be a need for us to be there, but we don't need to be there.
shortnun Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Oik' post='1084653' date='Oct 5 2006, 12:57 AM'] There has been a 30 percent increase in lay ministry in 8 years. There are now 30,000 lay ministers with another 30,000 in training. There are only 27,000 priests in active ministry in the USA and 14,000 deacons. So, already, 'lay ministry' has elipsed clerical ministry. Why are we doleing out money for ministry that has no tradition in our Church, yet failing to support the clearly defined, and apostolically instituted ministry already present. Do I think we should fire 25,000 plus people? YES. We need to support the ones that are indispensible to our Church first. [/quote] Perhaps we ought to clarify our positions here. [b]Why is [u]bad[/u] that (as you call it) 'lay ministry' elapsed clerical ministry?[/b] I beg to differ with you. Lay ministry has no tradition in our Church?! Pardon me for considering [u]them [/u]to be some of the ones who are indispensible! A reference I would cite as valuable for the history of lay ministry is [color="#FF0000"][b][url="http://www.amazon.com/Ministry-Catholic-Church-History-Theology/dp/1592441572/sr=1-9/qid=1160086101/ref=sr_1_9/104-7602641-7448764?ie=UTF8&s=books"]Ministry: Lay Ministry in the Roman Catholic Church it's History and Theology[/url] [/b][/color]by Kenan Osborne, OFM. And along the lines of Osborne, I would refer you to Jesus' model of calling all to be his disciples. [quote name='Oik' post='1084653' date='Oct 5 2006, 12:57 AM'] Neglect for clearly established clerical orders is not consdiered necessity for new offices. These new 'vocations' obscure already lacking numbers of clerical orders. When the clerical orders are bursting at the seems, then i'd be all for these new 'vocations'. [/quote] So there is no ebb and flow for you? [b]There is no change when you look at Church history? [/b]The only way for something new to come about is if everything else is humming along as it should? So with that logic, there is no need for religious orders? People were neglecting the order of the presbyterate and deaconate. Thus vocations as a sister, nun, or brother are unfounded and merely detract from the already established orders? [quote name='Oik' post='1084653' date='Oct 5 2006, 12:57 AM'] All is well though. God is in control and these matters of disciple and praxis will all be hammered out in due time. The clergy, who are eucharistic ministers, Bishops and priests and deacons, ordinary ministers of Commuion, are indispensible, while lay ministry is not firm and fast and can fade into and out of necessity. [/quote] I guess it's the beauty of our Catholic faith that can allow you to say "All is well" and for me to say the exact same phrase back to you. I would disagree with you that lay ministry is not firm and fast. I think it has existed since the Old Testament, and is not even something that came about as a result of Christ. And, even if it is as you say--that such ministry can fade into and out of necessity--who are you to say that now is the time for it to fade away? That sounds awfully close to a judgement. And who are we to judge? And [b]if I may introduce a new topic... [/b]I see you're from FUS. What do you think about the lay men and women being educated at your institution? Is it your hope that they are unable to find jobs upon graduation, lest they perpetuate the "infection" that is lay ecclesial ministry"? Should seminaries no longer accept non-orditation track students to their schools? Should all (Catholic) graduate theological schools be closed down? I hate to sound like I'm stating extreme examples, but I would very much like to hear your position on these matters. [b] ****************************************[/b] [quote name='Aloysius' post='1084741' date='Oct 5 2006, 06:03 AM'] THe Vatican specifically says that Eucharistic Ministers are NOT in place in order to foster more active participation. ... one would be speaking against the will of Rome and Vatican II if one attempted to say "lay ministries such as EMHCs are in place to give the laity more active participation". Rome sees these things as temporary necessities grudgingly permitted. Rome sees Deacons, Acolytes, Lectors, and Cantors as preferable. [/quote] [quote name='Maria' post='1085028' date='Oct 5 2006, 04:29 PM'] Assisting at Mass refers to being there and participating in the prayers, etc. We don't need to be up on the sanctuary. There might be a need for us to be there, but we don't need to be there. [/quote] [b]Thank you both for calling me to clarify my point. [/b]While I never explicitly stated what I meant by "active participation," I did [u]not [/u]mean to imply that the appointment of lay individuals as EMHC was a means of fostering active participation. Forgive me if I lead you to think otherwise. Edited October 5, 2006 by shortnun
Aloysius Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 you lead me otherwise by responding to my comment by defending active participation in the liturgy, something which I did not attack in principle and therefore I took that as you defending EMHCs as active participation. My point is that these are things which the Vatican specifically calls temporary and specifically states that it would be desirable if they were not necessary. Rome says that lay ministry (as regards the LITURGY) is temporary and only out of necessity. Rome says that the desirable state of things is that the liturgy, in terms of the principal parts which take place on the sanctuary at least, ought to be as populated as possible with ordained positions, and if not by ordained positions then at least by instituted positions which used to have the minor orders. the proper order always has been, and Rome insists that it should remain so, that the ministerial priesthood and diaconate minister to the people (supplemented only out of necessity by laity but then only insofar as they are laity in instituted positions... in the liturgy those things which used to hold minor orders, outside of the liturgy in catholic education primarily monks and nuns and brothers and sisters and then, only out of necessity, others in non-instituted ministerial positions) and then the role of the people, the majority of the laity, is to minister to the rest of the world. That is the desirable orientation of the Church from Rome's perspective.
Oik Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 (edited) Shortnun, Glory to God! FUS is a great school. As for myself, I will finish my degree and get married. As an Eastern Catholic, I will pursue my vocation as a Deacon and I hope and pray God will grant me the Grace to serve the Church well. As a Father, I hope and pray I will raise my chilredn to love and serve God and to live God-fearing Christian lives. Edited October 5, 2006 by Oik
Oik Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 I overspoke and misguiding the thread. The canon law information provided in this thread gives a hard and fast answer to the original question according to the disciplines of the Roman Catholic Church In the Eastern Churches, only can distribute Communion. I don't see anything else to comment on.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [quote name='Oik' post='1085257' date='Oct 5 2006, 10:10 PM'] I overspoke and misguiding the thread. The canon law information provided in this thread gives a hard and fast answer to the original question according to the disciplines of the Roman Catholic Church In the Eastern Churches, only ________ can distribute Communion. I don't see anything else to comment on. [/quote] Only what?
Oik Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 hahaha Thanks for the edit! Only clergy can distribute Holy Communion.
Resurrexi Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [quote]The liturgical priority is that both species are distributed. But suddenly, to obey what is "ideal" for canon law (I'm not saying it's not abused), we look for a solution that seems easiest? It seems like we're putting a splint and a cast on a finger with a papercut.[/quote] The liturgical priority is for a priest to distribute Communion, becuase only the Priests can act in Persona Christi when doing so. Communion under both species is not necessary becuase when recieveing Communion, even under one species, you recieve the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of God the Son made Man, you recieve Christ, the Whole Christ, and nothing but Christ. [quote]because certain people think it's the answer to VII's call for the laity to be more "actively involved" in the liturgy. Of course, the Vatican has condemned that attitude many times, but it still persists. the bishops are afraid to institute more permanent deacons to distribute communion because then they have to kick out all the female EMHCs. same reason they won't make more acolytes who would also have a more proper role distributing communion. They live in a state of compromise with feminists... if we can't let you be priests we'll at least let you storm the altar in as many positions as possible (EMHC, girl altar boy, pastoral assosiate, music director, et cetera et cetera)[/quote] right on! [quote]All the members of Christ's body are called to participate in the liturgy--in the entire life of the Church. Vatican II didn't come up with that one out of the blue.[/quote] Of course all the members of Christ's [i][u]MYSTICAL[/u][/i] Body (i. e. not His physical Body) are obliged to participate in the liturgy, but not in ways such as distributing Communion (I don't think there would ever be a great enough need to use EMHCs at all during Mass: they are meant for extraordinary Communion services). Lay people should participate in the Mass following along in their Latin-English Missal (the norm for the Missa Normativa is Latin) and offering up the Victim to God with the priest. Boys also may, if there are no/not enough acolytes and deacons (males are the norm in the Church, females are supposed to be a rare exception) serve at the altar. [quote]As for the rest of your post, I can't help but see it as entirely off topic and uncharitable. I'd be happy to speak with you in a new thread about why women (or lay men) can't be pastoral associates or music directors. I'm unfamiliar with documents prohibiting (or discouraging) them from such roles that give life to the Church.[/quote] It is not uncharitable, it is so correct you don't even want to admit it. women should not be pastoral associates (a position I don't think should exist) or music directors (in fact, unless there are not enough men to make a chior, women aren't even supposed to sing in the chior). [quote]Exactly! That's why 15 mins extra waiting in line to receive your Lord and Saviour, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity is not a reason to have any EMHC.[/quote] Ita vero! [quote]Rather, look at the tradition and biblical mandate of the deaconate to fill the roles of service the 30,000+ individuals (of which only 4-5,000 are men though) get paid for. Pay the deacons, not the laity![/quote] I totally agree that if there are not enough priests to distribute Communion, deacons should be ordained to do so. [quote]15 mins!? Perhaps that's just an exaggertation. Participation in the table of the Lord is not something that should be overly prolonged. And if that's the case, then we ought to look at ways to prevent that (installed acolytes, deacons, etc).[/quote] Are you kidding me? You can't wait fifteen minutes? There is nothing that says Mass shouldn't be long. In fact, the most beautiful Masses (such as St. Padre Pio's) were 2 hours long. Moreover, I can barely do all my pre and post revieving devotions in fifteen minutes. [quote]I think that the historical development of and appreciation for the role of the deacons has been severely delayed. But let me see if I have this correct: You'd advise that we fire/lay off/etc 25,000+ individuals so that we can just pay men who are installed as deacons a salary? Please correct how I'm reading your post if I'm in error.[/quote] We shouldn't have EMHS being paid to do their job at all, they should be in extraordinary circumstances and not be hardly used at all. [quote]We don't even use instruments and the Divine Liturgy is 1hour 20-30mins. God Be praised! [/quote] I love the Eastern Divine Liturgy(s). If my diocese didn't have an indult for the TLM every month, I'd attend one. [quote]Now, even a reverant Roman Mass can be celebrated in an hour with no exemptions. Therefore, what is 15 mins more? We alreay have it![/quote] I agree that Mass should take longer.
shortnun Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [b]My quotes are inter-textual and bold. STM, in the future, it would be helpful if you could include who you are quoting, just so we can all keep the conversation straight.[/b] [quote][quote]The liturgical priority is that both species are distributed. But suddenly, to obey what is "ideal" for canon law (I'm not saying it's not abused), we look for a solution that seems easiest? It seems like we're putting a splint and a cast on a finger with a papercut. [/quote] ... Communion under both species is not necessary becuase when recieveing Communion, even under one species, you recieve the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of God the Son made Man, you recieve Christ, the Whole Christ, and nothing but Christ. [b] Yes, concomitance. I've stated that I fully comprehend and understand. What I'm stating, is that the distribution of the cup fell into an historical lack of appreciation/distribution throughout history, and that I find this to be problematic. Hence my insistancy that both species be made available if at all possible.[/b] ... [quote]As for the rest of your post, I can't help but see it as entirely off topic and uncharitable. I'd be happy to speak with you in a new thread about why women (or lay men) can't be pastoral associates or music directors. I'm unfamiliar with documents prohibiting (or discouraging) them from such roles that give life to the Church.[/quote] It is not uncharitable, it is so correct you don't even want to admit it. women should not be pastoral associates (a position I don't think should exist) or music directors (in fact, unless there are not enough men to make a chior, women aren't even supposed to sing in the chior). [b]Please check Al's orginal post here. It was the comments about women "storming the altar" and the disrespect I perceived in his lack of empathy with the difficulty that comes with the role of episcopacy that I called off topic and uncharitable. Also, I intend on creating a new thread on pastoral associates, and I would welcome you into that discussion.[/b] ... [quote]15 mins!? Perhaps that's just an exaggertation. Participation in the table of the Lord is not something that should be overly prolonged. And if that's the case, then we ought to look at ways to prevent that (installed acolytes, deacons, etc).[/quote] Are you kidding me? You can't wait fifteen minutes? There is nothing that says Mass shouldn't be long. In fact, the most beautiful Masses (such as St. Padre Pio's) were 2 hours long. Moreover, I can barely do all my pre and post revieving devotions in fifteen minutes. [b]It's one thing to have a longer, reverent, well-planned liturgy. It's entirely different to have people wait for their taste of heaven here on earth. It is the latter which I am calling to not be absurdly lengthy in time. [/b] [quote]I think that the historical development of and appreciation for the role of the deacons has been severely delayed. But let me see if I have this correct: You'd advise that we fire/lay off/etc 25,000+ individuals so that we can just pay men who are installed as deacons a salary? Please correct how I'm reading your post if I'm in error. [/quote] We shouldn't have EMHS being paid to do their job at all, they should be in extraordinary circumstances and not be hardly used at all. [b]I am unaware of a single circumstance where EMHC are paid simply for doing that task. The Church [u]does not[/u] pay lay ministers [u]just [/u]for that.[/b] [/quote]
Guest Maldod Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 Does anyone know if there is a specific age limit for EMHCs. My parish wants to have some youth EHMCs from about the age of 14 or 15.
cappie Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 [quote name='Maldod' post='1095288' date='Oct 19 2006, 08:53 AM'] Does anyone know if there is a specific age limit for EMHCs. My parish wants to have some youth EHMCs from about the age of 14 or 15. [/quote] The minimum age in Australia is 18
son_of_angels Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 Here's the thing.... If a priest has already celebrated more than his allowed number of Masses for a given day, he could still come to the mass, in choir dress, or function as the deacon or lector, and distribute communion as an ordinary minister. Indeed, the church would be greatly enriched by seeing more priests fulfilling their ministerial as opposed to presidential role. Also, The GIRM and Sacramentary both conceive of distributing under both species with only one priest. It means everybody goes up once, then goes back to their seats, then goes up again. Intinction is another option (not self-intinction of course!), but it requires careful coordination. The books also allow for an Eastern-style distribution (if I remember correctly), which might also be effective. In the Tridentine Papal Mass, the Holy Father would even receive from a sort of straw! Why no EMC's? Generally, I think what has been lost in the modern liturgy is reflection on the priestly character of ministerial roles. Reading the Scriptures, is it not a presentation of Christ, almost like the Eucharist? Why then shouldn't those ordained "ad ministerium" or at least those blessed to that end, and possessing the male gender be the ones to present those Scriptures. Or, in their absence, let the priest fulfill this ministry, as he is not simply presider at an assembly, but also a minister of grace to his people. The same goes with the Blessed Sacrament. Let those consecrated to be our ministers fulfill their roles, and perhaps we'll have a little less sketchy people, given only to vanity, politics, and maneuvering, running our Congregations!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now