curtins Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 Whats open, Whats not. Whats secret, who has access to what. For the stuff thats secret, why is it secret. What would you say to someone who says the Vatican is covering up abuses, scandals, etc etc. All the stuff I've searched on this is big round about talk. I want streight up facts.
CatholicCid Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 I know some of the files of the Holy Inquistion are closed. Or what's left of them since Napoleon took them. Due to their nature, they won't be made public as they hold the Seal of Confession.
curtins Posted October 4, 2006 Author Posted October 4, 2006 Why do they have the seal of the confessional? Are they like transcripts of a confession?
Guest T-Bone Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 The Seal of Confession means what is said in the Confessional stays in the Confessional.
prose Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 Yes, but he is asking why the writings about it contain that seal. Were there recorded transcript of a confession?
cappie Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 The Vatican Secret Archive Has Opened a New Mine for Historians It is the pope’s private archive: a thousand years of documents in eighty kilometers of shelving. Since September 18, thirty thousand new volumes of papers are available for consultation, for the period from 1922 to 1939, corresponding to the pontificate of Pius XI. Including the previously unpublished diaries of then-cardinal Eugenio Pacelli [url="http://www.chiesa.espressonline.it/dettaglio.jsp?id=87082&eng=y"]http://www.chiesa.espressonline.it/dettagl...87082&eng=y[/url]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 The Church, like any organization, has the right to keep some information private.
curtins Posted October 5, 2006 Author Posted October 5, 2006 but what are they keeping secret? and why? whats to hide?
iggy Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 There is a difference between respecting privacy and trying to hide something.
jswranch Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='curtins' post='1084373' date='Oct 4 2006, 07:43 PM'] but what are they keeping secret? and why? whats to hide? [/quote] I do not know specifics, but like any big organization, buisness, school, or government somethings should stay private. For example, a management position opens above you at work. You and 3 others are eligible. However, you are not selected. Should the company emails on why the promotion wasn't given to you be made public? No. Here are more guesses: 1. Who did not make bishop or cardinal and why? 2. Imagine a congregation leader (cardinal) wishes to publish a ruling, but the pope disagrees with the document. We know all Congregational documents have the Pope's approval. Would we really expect the Vatican to release a note from the pope telling the Cardinal to pull his head out of his cassock then resubmitt? 3. Prayer requests and miracle claims of a sensitive nature (the BVM made my anal fissures go away). 4. Disciplinary actions, rulings, accusations. 5. Private matters. Imagine Fr. Smith got genital warts before he became a Christian and his bishop needs to ask the Vatican about it. Should this info be released? 6. Diplomatic policies and information. We know the US government told the Vatican private info on Communist plans and operations. Such info was made in confidence. It should remain as such for now. 7. International scandals. I have heard the KGB has released info on whether the assasination attempt on JPII was a hit ordered by the Kremlin. Should those details be released? 8. Underground church. The public 'bishops' in certain countries are defacto excommunicated (China). The real leadership is underground. Releasing info on this will result in greater tribulation. 9. Name and locations of kids fathered by celibates. 10. Names of donors who wish to remain private. Just guesses.
kateri05 Posted October 8, 2006 Posted October 8, 2006 sorry, those are all perfectly legit guesses, but i couldn't help but giggle. i used to be the kind of person to get upset about "the man" hiding things, but then i realized as regards the Holy Mother Church, info is on a "need to know" basis. and guess what? there are whole LOADS of stuff that we just don't need to know. so ask Mary for help in humility and acceptance and move on!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now