Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]I don't see how putting people of other faiths into a Catholic monastery will be "infusing the Church's culture into society"?[/quote]
I don't either. But I think you left out the part where the monastic life is going to be exposed to millions of people--millions of people who would otherwise know nothing about it.

[quote]"Authentic Catholic culture doesn't include monasteries filled with non-monks who aren't even Catholic."[/quote]
The viewer would obviously realize this.

If the monks are orthodox and true to their faith, I don't see how anyone can think this would end up being bad... It is a chance to represent the church in a positive way for once. This is what phatmass is all about--using innovative media to glorify the church--and I think this is exactly what these monks are trying to do.

How about this. Can you think of a better way to expose the monastic life to millions of people not normally interested in the church?

Posted

From what I've seen at this monastery's website, it looks pretty orthodox with a strong monastic and Benedictine identity. I'm sure they know what they're doing.

One of the Benedictine traditions is welcoming strangers on retreat. That's what this show sounds like, except it will be captured for the world to watch.

Posted

All one has to do is look at how the monastery that was used in the European version of the show has handled the extra attention. The last time I checked their website, they have "How to become Catholic" instructions displayed for everyone who visits.

Posted

Saw this message from their Abbot:

[quote]One brother cooks each day; another brother does accounting each day; another does laundry; another cleaning in the Monastery itself; another cleaning in the Guest House; another answers guest reservations; another is in charge of the maintenance of the house; another works on the mailing lists; two brothers work on answering correspondence, immigration questions, Mass stipends and general inquiries; one brother is in overall charge of organizing and supervising all of this. Every day we spend four hours in common prayer, one hour in holy reading and at least a half hour of silent prayer or meditation. So generally we spend 6 hours of the day in various forms of prayer. Meals and the common cleanup afterwards take another 2 hours. Most of us work between 4 and 5 hours a day. Then there is some time for cleanup and always time for a siesta in the afternoon since the night sleep is generally at the most 7 hours and some brothers need more than that. Every day we have a meeting of at least 10 minutes in the morning and 20 minutes in the evening for announcements. The evening meeting always includes a short conference on spirituality by the Abbot.

[b]All of this makes for a very full day. Soon, starting on October 22nd, on The Learning Channel, anyone can see how this life affects people from outside. The documentary, “The Monastery,” is an amusing and fairly accurate glimpse into our daily life. Our life looks deceptively easy—and it is easy for a short time. But it requires that the monk focus all of his attention and energy only on living this life and on the search for God that is its basic motivation and reason. [/b]

Only a fairly clear life view and faith can make this life possible for a life time. At Vigils the other day, we heard a reading from Jean Danielou that was speaking about our lack of awareness of God’s presence in our world. This reading really made me think about my own perception that somehow, given enough time, we will be able to control everything in the world—at least the physical aspects. That is a sort of presumption that many of us have. We sort of think we, with our modern science, will be able to do almost everything. I am part of this culture and I often think the same way. All of that gets in the way of thinking that God is Lord of the Universe.

We don’t have to go to the other extreme and think that we are powerless and have no control. But it seems really arrogant when we think that we have total control. This kind of thinking affects everything from sexuality, to space travel, to controlling storms, and almost whatever else we can think of. Some of this way of thinking is a clear reaction to previous thinking that made God in control of everything and we humans had nothing to say or contribute. What we need now is some kind of integration of how we humans are still totally dependent on God and yet we cooperate with God in our universe—not as equal partners, but as God and humans. [/quote]

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Everyone in support of the show is still ignoring the fact that non-Catholics are the ones "living" the monastic life for a time. Monasticism is a vocation. You don't just walk in to try it out so you can say "oh, that's monasticism."

We already saw what "infusing Catholic culture" into public television was like with "God or the Girl" and that was a major flop. I'm all for using the media we have to reach people about Catholicism... like Phatmass uses the internet.

The difference, dUSt, is that you are in control of Phatmass and you are a practicing Catholic striving to lead others to the Church. The producers for TLC are not promoting Catholic culture, they're looking to make money on a "reality show" with a different twist. They aren't hoping someone from the show will convert to Catholicism and discover they have a vocation to the monastic life.

Posted

Living in a monastery doesn't mean you're pretending to have a vocation. Becoming a monk is a vocation, but adopting the structured life of prayer for a period of time is what everyone does when they go on retreat.

How is this any different from Benedictine retreats that happen every day? You don't have to be Catholic to go on retreat at a Catholic monastery. From the rule of St. Benedict:

[quote]Let all guests who arrive be received like Christ,
for He is going to say,
"I came as a guest, and you received Me" (Matt. 25:35).
And to all let due honor be shown,
especially to the domestics of the faith and to pilgrims.

As soon as a guest is announced, therefore,
let the Superior or the brethren meet him
with all charitable service.
And first of all let them pray together,
and then exchange the kiss of peace.
For the kiss of peace should not be offered
until after the prayers have been said,
on account of the devil's deceptions.

In the salutation of all guests, whether arriving or departing,
let all humility be shown.
Let the head be bowed
or the whole body prostrated on the ground
in adoration of Christ, who indeed is received in their persons.

After the guests have been received and taken to prayer,
let the Superior or someone appointed by him sit with them.
Let the divine law be read before the guest for his edification,
and then let all kindness be shown him.
The Superior shall break his fast for the sake of a guest,
unless it happens to be a principal fast day
which may not be violated.
The brethren, however, shall observe the customary fasts.
Let the Abbot give the guests water for their hands;
and let both Abbot and community wash the feet of all guests.
After the washing of the feet let them say this verse:
"We have received Your mercy, O God,
in the midst of Your temple" (Ps.47:10).

In the reception of the poor and of pilgrims
the greatest care and solicitude should be shown,
because it is especially in them that Christ is received;
for as far as the rich are concerned,
the very fear which they inspire
wins respect for them. [/quote]

The show intends to show monastic life by having ordinary people experience it. I think that's a very good thing. While it may not produce conversions or vocations from the participants, will it not lead to respect for the religious life? Maybe it will spark a vocation from someone watching. Maybe it will lead somene to question why these monks leave everything to follow Christ in the monastery.

You never know.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I'm open to that possibility, but I don't think it will come through on a show being produced by non-Catholics for "reality-show" purposes...

A&E's attempt at making a 'documentary' about discernment didn't go over well...

franciscanheart
Posted

Aren't the participants clothed in the habit? It looks that way from the advertisements on TLC. Has anyone else even seen those?

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1087490' date='Oct 9 2006, 11:57 AM']
I'm open to that possibility, but I don't think it will come through on a show being produced by non-Catholics for "reality-show" purposes...

A&E's attempt at making a 'documentary' about discernment didn't go over well...
[/quote]

+

Really? I thought it was well-received... :idontknow:

franciscanheart
Posted

It was well-received in the sense that a lot of Catholics were talking about it but it didn't get the ratings some were expecting. It was indeed a flop. (I wasn't impressed anyway.)

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1087511' date='Oct 9 2006, 02:45 PM']
+

Really? I thought it was well-received... :idontknow:
[/quote]
When the major headlines for the Church are a "crisis" of vocations and 3 of the 4 guys choose marriage... and the 1 guy who said on the show he wanted to enter the seminary, ended up not going after the show, but postponing his entering the seminary: that it doesn't help the outlook.

And, the show made it appear as though the decision was solely about celibacy and "giving up" everything to be priest. Not one of the guys mentioned the great graces that would be given in being a priest, or the awesome blessing to be able to consecrate the Eucharist, or be instrumental in the forgiveness of sins, etc. Being a priest, or choosing to pursue that path was portrayed very badly in the A&E show... everything about taking that path would've been a negative-- "giving up" something, "missing out" on something, etc. It was a very poor portrayal of a vocation to the priesthood. (do priests give up a lot to be a priest.. yes! a tremendous amount of sacrifice is involved. but it's not all negative, they gain a great deal too.)

Posted

Comparing this to "God and the Girl" is unfair. "God or the Girl" centered around some kids that, from the outside, didn't seem like they knew a ton about what they were doing.

This show, hopefully, is going to center around some people surrounded by orthodox monks who know what they are doing (fingers crossed). It seems like the show is about the contrast between today's secular world, and a life of holiness--it ruins the plot if the holiness is portrayed negatively because it would nullify the two extremes--which is what makes good TV. If anything, I'd think TLC would try to make the monastic life seem as holy and seperated from the world as possible.

We won't know until we watch it, so let's just wait and see.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I know one of the guys from "God or the Girl" and if he were on PM he'd have a 'church militant' under his screen name. He's a youth minister running a pretty smooth program. And while I don't like everything he does, he seeks orthodoxy at all times and he's not entirely inept at understanding the faith. Yet, in the show, he looked a total dork.

So I don't think it's an unfair comparision. TLC isn't exactly all that worried about portraying the monastery as orthodox and faithful to the Church, and those editors have free to cut and splice what they wish to make the show go how they want.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1087638' date='Oct 9 2006, 03:55 PM']
and those editors have free to cut and splice what they wish to make the show go how they want.
[/quote]
So we know for sure that the monastery doesn't have any say on the final cut?

Posted

I didn't know Steve didn't end up going to the seminary. :( I was really excited about that.

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1087728' date='Oct 9 2006, 06:49 PM']
So we know for sure that the monastery doesn't have any say on the final cut?
[/quote]
I don't think we do. But why would they?


At this point I'm really wishing someone would say whether or not they have seen the advertisements run for this show on TLC like I have. I'm actually really curious to see if anyone knows (or wondered) if these outsiders were wearing habits. I haven't seen the ad in a while so I'm having a hard time remembering...

Posted

Fides...

Actually as a Benedictine Oblate, I can tell you that welcoming non-monks in and introducing them to St. Benedict's rule is a corner stone of the order.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='1087874' date='Oct 9 2006, 09:14 PM']
Fides...

Actually as a Benedictine Oblate, I can tell you that welcoming non-monks in and introducing them to St. Benedict's rule is a corner stone of the order.
[/quote]
But not publicizing it... I'm not objecting to showing non-monks monastic life, I think it's great for people to learn about it. I'm objecting to having non-Catholics pretend to live in a Catholic monastery for entertainment purposes (which is the goal of TLC... they want to make money, entertain their viewers and keep people watching). Do I hope good comes out of it? Of course. But I doubt it will have a much different turn out than A&E's attempt at portraying private spiritual struggles.



dUSt... you don't honestly think the monastery has any serious say in the final cut and splice, do you? I would put money down that they don't. The producers of TLC decide the final cut.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1087891' date='Oct 9 2006, 08:25 PM']
dUSt... you don't honestly think the monastery has any serious say in the final cut and splice, do you? I would put money down that they don't. The producers of TLC decide the final cut.
[/quote]
Okay, so neither of us know.

TLC does have a vested interest in not making the monastery look bad. If the show is a hit, and they edit the show in a biased manner to make the monastery look bad, their chances of having a second season are out the window.

Posted

Don't you thnk the Monks thought all of this out before allowing them to tape the series? I think we are all thinking negatively about this. I am very hopefull of this series and i think it has a chance of being a good thing.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...