Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

catholicinsd
Posted

Hey Pham, I come to ask your opinion:
[b]
Can a Youth Ministry function with a core group of older kids in the place of Youth Minister? [/b]

heavenseeker
Posted

if they are set on running the youth group like a youth minister would and it works then why not?

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='heavenseeker' post='1085996' date='Oct 7 2006, 12:45 AM']
if they are set on running the youth group like a youth minister would and it works then why not?
[/quote]

So you think it could work?

heavenseeker
Posted

sure thing, as long as they are dedicated to running it

Posted (edited)

It could work, but they'd still need a supervisor and chaperones.
A core group of older kids tends to have more drive, more time, and more dedication than one youth minister does (hence why usually there's both). It depends on how old/mature all of the kids are.

Oh, and I wouldn't really recommend it, just because kids will slack off every so often and have conflicts with each other.

Edited by Franimus
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1085942' date='Oct 6 2006, 09:29 PM']
Hey Pham, I come to ask your opinion:
[b]
Can a Youth Ministery function with a core group of older kids in the place of Youth Minister? [/b]
[/quote]

No.

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='inDEED' post='1086214' date='Oct 7 2006, 01:51 PM']
No.
[/quote]

Why not?

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1086118' date='Oct 7 2006, 07:28 AM']nope[/quote]what he said

Posted

ditto on the "no"



lol, wonder what the stats are on the "nos" coming from youth directors or former youth directors? :P:

Birgitta Noel
Posted

I'm not a youth director, but I'd say no simply for the fact that youth need mentors in the Church to guide them and help them discern the tough issues. There's nothing wrong with having a core team (even with the likely problems noted above) of teens, but having no youth director I would think would be like having the 12 disciples and no Christ to form and guide them. (not that YDs are alter Christus mind you!)

Posted

of course not, but you can't have a body without a head and you can't have an anything without a leader.

Birgitta Noel
Posted

you took the words right out of my mouth Kateri!

homeschoolmom
Posted

I really think of youth ministry as being sort of a mentorship... can't really work without a mentor. Now, can a core group of teens get together and pray and support one another? Sure, but it's not quite the same thing....

Posted

No, can't do it. The most obvious reason is that there is no one responsible and I mean that from a legal standpoint.

catholicinsd
Posted

Here's the thing my: parish doesn't have a Youth Group anymore, and I'm pretty sure the only way it be brought back is with a core group (no Youth Minister.)

Birgitta Noel
Posted

Can you have a volunteer as opposed to a paid YM? I'm assuming that finances are part of the issue here? :idontknow:

Posted

In my humble opinion,

A youth minister will find it [i]extremely difficult[/i] (I stop short of saying [i]impossible[/i]) to do his/her job without a "core group" of teenagers who can function as his/her arms and legs within the youth group.

Similarly, it would be [i]extremely difficult[/i] (once again, not necessarily [i]impossible[/i]) for a group of teenagers to run a youth group. This comes from experience, for I was in a "core group" of teens that was asked (unofficially) to run a youth group while we waited for a new youth minister. It was draining, and I hate to say that we were not completely successful; however, we did accomplish a wonderful retreat and a few solid LIFE Nights.

Take this for what it's worth. I am a former youth groupie as well as a current youth minister, so I've been in both arenas and I can say with certainty that both are needed.

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1086221' date='Oct 7 2006, 11:08 AM']
Why not?
[/quote]

Well, I'd pretty much be echoing what most others said here...

A core group of teenagers are not equipped nor are they mature enough to lead a youth ministry program. It's really that simple.

I like the comparison of the 12 apostles w/out Christ the best...

And, like hsmom said - it's awesome if a core group wants to start some sort of prayer group or activity group - but as far as leading a program - wouldn't be effective.

Posted

ditto on what everyone said.

Why not ask the priest? Or ask him to announce that there is a need for a YM right now? Or better yet, the priest himself if there is such a great need?

Too many chiefs and not enough indians will also be a problem.

kids will be kids.

and a YM is vital for a successful YM group.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...