shortnun Posted October 7, 2006 Posted October 7, 2006 [b][u]Pastoral Associates:[/u] Non-ordained (lay) men and women, commissioned by their local diocese, who work in cooperation and collaboration with ordained ministers of a local Church in a variety of pastoral settings.[/b] [u] Questions:[/u] (1) What is your local experience with lay pastoral associates? (Ie, do you have them at your parish? Do you know of their existence in your diocese? Are you one?) (2) In light of your understanding of our tradition (scripture, teachings, and personal experience), do you see pastoral associates as a legitimate, valid, good way of serving the Church? [u] Answers to my own questions:[/u] (1) The first 21 years of my life in the Church did not have lay pastoral associates. At present, I work as a volunteer in a parish where my direct supervisor is a lay pastoral associate. (2) I hold that lay ecclesial ministry (ie, laity, empowered by their baptismal calling to be priest, prophet, and king, working in/for the Church) has always existed in the history of the Church, setting from the example of Christ himself. [i] [u]Mods[/u]: It is clearly not my intent that this turn into a debate. But if you feel this should be moved to a different phorum, please do so.[/i]
puellapaschalis Posted October 7, 2006 Posted October 7, 2006 (1) My parish doesn't have them (being the Cathedral parish), but many parishes in my dioese do, and there is a great number of them across the country. Well, in saying that, I'm making the assumption that Pastoral Associates as you describe them are (broadly) the same as Pastorale Werk(st)ers. I don't think the match is exact, however, as the latter are generally in place here where there is no available priest, let alone a resident one. They carry out duties that I don't believe would fall under your definition. In my limited knowledge and experience, PWs have very often overstepped their legitimate boundaries. The situation in the Netherlands is quite different to what most people on here are familiar with and I've no intention of boring people with the details. (2) It would seem to me that whether PAs are "legitimate, good and valid" depends [i]a lot[/i] on what exactly they're doing. I mean, if, for example, they're performing the works of mercy, which I think is something that Baptism positively demands from us because it's, well, Baptism, then I don't see that as being problematic. I wonder, though, seeing as the works of mercy is a Baptism-driven thing, why there needs to be a specific "title" for it: surely all of us, non-PAs included, are compelled to do so. Perhaps I'm missing something in the definitions though. Love and prayers, PP
Resurrexi Posted October 7, 2006 Posted October 7, 2006 I do not believe they are ligit. or valid or in a good way serving the Church. BTW, the "priesthood of the faithful" does not mean we are all called to be King, Priest and Propet by are baptismal calling... Our baptismal calling is to renounce Satan, be freed of Original Sin, and become a member of the Church
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted October 8, 2006 Posted October 8, 2006 my parish has a pastoral lady, but she is like the head of the parish not an associate. Personally, i do not think that Having a lay person leading the parish is a good idea. I would not be against it if she were under a Pastoer, but since we do not have one she is our pastor.
kateri05 Posted October 8, 2006 Posted October 8, 2006 (edited) its funny, extra, shes not your pastor, because canonically it is ILLEGAL to not have an ordained man as pastor, so dioceses that do this cheat the rules and assign fr. random pants from some other parish or who works for the diocese to be the canonical pastor even tho this lay (usually woman... funny isn't it ) person is RUNNING for all intents and purposes the parish. to add: my experience with pastoral whatevers, since they have about 8 different titles, is pretty negative. its always a woman who is thinly (or not all) veiling her agenda that women should be priests and the priests supporting it going on and on about it being so freeing to be only a "sacramental priest." what, may i ask, is a sacramental priest? ALL priests by virtue of their Holy ORders are sacramental. oh i know, it means a sacraments vending machine for their parish, not an actual shephard and guide to his flock. argh. in addition, our baptismal call to service, which has indeed existed since the days of the Apostles, DOES NOT translate into parish leadership, particularly in the sense of pastoral associates, who are THE leader. we are the sheep of Christ's flock to be led by those ordained to act in the person of Christ. sheep leading sheep is not anybody's idea of a good time! Edited October 8, 2006 by kateri05
Maria Posted October 9, 2006 Posted October 9, 2006 At one point (around when we were moving out of our church building, trying to sell it, and trying to work out our relationship with the parish we were renting use of their church building from) there were health problems of some sort with our parochial administrator, so a parishioner was given certain legal abilities, eg., a wardens meeting she attended would be legal even though father wasn't there. Of course, whenever father is able to come, he's more than welcome -- it's just that we're able to 'survive' without his presence at those meetings.
toledo_jesus Posted October 9, 2006 Posted October 9, 2006 (edited) In Richmond, our last bishop started a new parish every other week. There are now too many parishes for too few priests. So, they are all clustered. The last bishop instituted 11 or so Pastoral Coordinators to run some parishes, but the new bishop is phasing them out. In my experience, these women ( ) are unable to act with enough authority to actually be of help and uneducated to the point where they impede devotion. Por ejemplo, at my old parish the lady squashed the idea of a Rosary group by claiming it was a private devotion. Yeah. Bull. In short, my feeling is close parishes and make people drive a couple extra miles. If they don't show up it's on their souls. Edited October 9, 2006 by toledo_jesus
stbernardLT Posted October 9, 2006 Posted October 9, 2006 We have an excellent parish administrator who works under our ailing pastor. I'm no to sure about having a pastoral coordinator without a priest in the parish, it depends on the person. I think it is a good idea in parishes that have real busy priests or aged priest. Again, as long as they work directly under the pastor and don't make the big decisions. They can handle staff, ministries, budgets, policies, and even those gripers that drive our priests crazy.
cmotherofpirl Posted October 9, 2006 Posted October 9, 2006 I am torn by this one, because I see the great need in some places and the equally great potential for abuse. I would much rather see a council empowered to do the day to day running of the parish -pay the bills, schedule various programs and let the priest free to concentrate on the Mass and sacraments, than a single person left in charge. Usually this single person turns out to be female, and unless they are an extraordinary individual, a war between us and them or he and she results. Whatever the plan, clear lines of authority need established at the outset, and some mechanism for insuring actual catholic doctrine, rather than the latest fad from whatever popular theologian is out there, is taught.
toledo_jesus Posted October 9, 2006 Posted October 9, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1087697' date='Oct 9 2006, 07:12 PM'] I am torn by this one, because I see the great need in some places and the equally great potential for abuse. I would much rather see a council empowered to do the day to day running of the parish -pay the bills, schedule various programs and let the priest free to concentrate on the Mass and sacraments, than a single person left in charge. Usually this single person turns out to be female, and unless they are an extraordinary individual, a war between us and them or he and she results. Whatever the plan, clear lines of authority need established at the outset, and some mechanism for insuring actual catholic doctrine, rather than the latest fad from whatever popular theologian is out there, is taught. [/quote]
shortnun Posted October 9, 2006 Author Posted October 9, 2006 [b][color="#000099"]All these responses are just glorious. I wish I could have seperate posts for each individual, but they'll all lump into one. So please bear with me. [/color][/b] [quote name='puellapaschalis' post='1086422' date='Oct 7 2006, 05:54 PM'] (1) My parish doesn't have them (being the Cathedral parish), but many parishes in my dioese do, and there is a great number of them across the country. Well, in saying that, I'm making the assumption that Pastoral Associates as you describe them are (broadly) the same as Pastorale Werk(st)ers. I don't think the match is exact, however, as the latter are generally in place here where there is no available priest, let alone a resident one. They carry out duties that I don't believe would fall under your definition. [color="#000099"][b]Ours goes both ways in the US. When I say Pastoral Associates, I usually mean he/she is an "assistant pastor." In other words, there is an ordained pastor at that parish. When there is no available priest, then (in my experience at least0 they're called "Parish Life Coordinators."[/b] [/color] In my limited knowledge and experience, PWs have very often overstepped their legitimate boundaries. The situation in the Netherlands is quite different to what most people on here are familiar with and I've no intention of boring people with the details. (2) It would seem to me that whether PAs are "legitimate, good and valid" depends [i]a lot[/i] on what exactly they're doing. I mean, if, for example, they're performing the works of mercy, which I think is something that Baptism positively demands from us because it's, well, Baptism, then I don't see that as being problematic. I wonder, though, seeing as the works of mercy is a Baptism-driven thing, why there needs to be a specific "title" for it: surely all of us, non-PAs included, are compelled to do so. [color="#000099"][b] I agree very much... doing works (such as those of mercy) are things we are all called to do. The distinction I create with the PA's is one of training and professionalism. It's not as if we all deserve to be paid just b/c we gave to the poor or visited the sick. But in our tradition of justice and service, there are some individuals who train themselves to work in a professional capacity for the church.[/b] [/color] Perhaps I'm missing something in the definitions though. Love and prayers, PP [/quote] [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1086450' date='Oct 7 2006, 06:50 PM'] I do not believe they are ligit. or valid or in a good way serving the Church. [color="#000099"][b]Do you care to elaborate at all?[/b][/color] BTW, the "priesthood of the faithful" does not mean we are all called to be King, Priest and Propet by are baptismal calling... Our baptismal calling is to renounce Satan, be freed of Original Sin, and become a member of the Church. [color="#000099"] [b]In the Roman Catholic Church, those who are baptized as infants (or as young children) are anointed "priest, prophet, king." And by all means, our baptismal call is to renounce Satan and to be initiated into the Church. No doubt about that.[/b][/color] [/quote] [quote name='kateri05' post='1086832' date='Oct 8 2006, 05:48 PM'] ... canonically it is ILLEGAL to not have an ordained man as pastor, so dioceses that do this cheat the rules and assign fr. random pants from some other parish or who works for the diocese to be the canonical pastor even tho this lay (usually woman... funny isn't it ) person is RUNNING for all intents and purposes the parish. [color="#000099"][b]I like Fr. Random Pants. For clarification, are you saying that you advocate having Fr. R-P assigned as canonical pastor, even though he hasn't the time nor the energy to be able to make decisions for said parish? [/b][/color] to add: my experience with pastoral whatevers, since they have about 8 different titles, is pretty negative. its always a woman who is thinly (or not all) veiling her agenda that women should be priests and the priests supporting it going on and on about it being so freeing to be only a "sacramental priest." [color="#000099"][b] Many titles... for example....? It is unfortunate that any individual (ordained or lay) is working for the Church only (or for the most part) to satisfy his/her agenda. [/b][/color] what, may i ask, is a sacramental priest? ALL priests by virtue of their Holy ORders are sacramental. oh i know, it means a sacraments vending machine for their parish, not an actual shephard and guide to his flock. argh. [color="#000099"][b] Well if you're referring to when Fr. R-P is assigned and is seen only as a "sacraments vending machine" then I don't think we (as the Church) are doing a very good job of educating towards the value of the priesthoods and the sacraments we desire to participate in. This is a great struggle for the (American) church today. Many places are finding successes, and others are still working through the difficulties.[/b][/color] in addition, our baptismal call to service, which has indeed existed since the days of the Apostles, DOES NOT translate into parish leadership, particularly in the sense of pastoral associates, who are THE leader. we are the sheep of Christ's flock to be led by those ordained to act in the person of Christ. sheep leading sheep is not anybody's idea of a good time! [color="#000099"][b]I totally agree. And I hope I didn't imply that by being baptised I suddenly had some right to "be in charge." But the same can be said for Holy Orders. Holy Orders doesn't equal a "I'm in charge all the time" card. Additionally, I might encourage you to expand your idea of shepherd. I hold that priests are sheep, and that we can be shepherds. A lay person working on a military base, whose pastor is suddenly shipped overseas, might become the "shepherd" of that community until (God-willing) their pastor returns. And by your definition, that would be sheep leading sheep. But I would certainly hold that to be appropriate under the circumstances.[/b][/color] [/quote] [quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1087665' date='Oct 9 2006, 05:16 PM'] In Richmond, our last bishop started a new parish every other week. There are now too many parishes for too few priests. So, they are all clustered. The last bishop instituted 11 or so Pastoral Coordinators to run some parishes, but the new bishop is phasing them out. In my experience, these women ( ) are unable to act with enough authority to actually be of help and uneducated to the point where they impede devotion. Por ejemplo, at my old parish the lady squashed the idea of a Rosary group by claiming it was a private devotion. Yeah. Bull. In short, my feeling is close parishes and make people drive a couple extra miles. If they don't show up it's on their souls. [color="#000099"][b] Well you certainly have definate feelings on these manners. Thanks for sharing. It's unfortunate that parishes were created without any long-term vision. Additionally, I'm sorry to hear that there was no established lay ministry formation program in your diocese for the pastoral coordinators. That having been said, the closure/clustering/merging of parishes/schools/hospitals/etc is a very painful process (when it's done well!). So please try not to be too hard or quick to jump to "easy-to-fix" solutions. Again, thanks for sharing.[/b][/color] [/quote] [quote name='stbernardLT' post='1087691' date='Oct 9 2006, 06:01 PM'] We have an excellent parish administrator who works under our ailing pastor. I'm not too sure about having a pastoral coordinator without a priest in the parish, it depends on the person. I think it is a good idea in parishes that have real busy priests or aged priest. Again, as long as they work directly under the pastor and don't make the big decisions. They can handle staff, ministries, budgets, policies, and even those gripers that drive our priests crazy. [color="#000099"] [b]This is a great (real-life) example of how I've see pastoral associates help a parish grow and thrive. Thanks for sharing![/b][/color] [/quote] [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1087697' date='Oct 9 2006, 06:12 PM'] I am torn by this one, because I see the great need in some places and the equally great potential for abuse. I would much rather see a council empowered to do the day to day running of the parish -pay the bills, schedule various programs and let the priest free to concentrate on the Mass and sacraments, than a single person left in charge. Usually this single person turns out to be female, and unless they are an extraordinary individual, a war between us and them or he and she results. Whatever the plan, clear lines of authority need established at the outset, and some mechanism for insuring actual catholic doctrine, rather than the latest fad from whatever popular theologian is out there, is taught. [color="#000099"][b]Cmom, I agree with you. I'd rather see a number of individuals making decisions and running a parish. Unfortunately, there are parishes where one priest makes these decisions just as often as there's a parish where one (female) pastoral associate makes these decisions. I think that the more we hold all parish workers (ordained and lay) to professional standards (meaning they can't fly off the handlebars theologically, morally, ethically, socially, etc), the better off our parish lives are.[/b][/color] [/quote]
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted October 9, 2006 Posted October 9, 2006 we don't even have a pastor at my parish.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now