Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Need Some Advice About My Situation


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey guys, long time no see! Sorry I haven't been around much lately, I don't know what's been happening with me as of late. Though one thing is for sure, I think I may be in love with someone for the first time. However, there is a catch, and that's why I need your advice on this.

She's not Catholic, nor does she attend any church (from what I know). Bummer.

I know that it's not a sin to go out with a non-Catholic, but I don't see it as a wise choice either, for obvious reasons. But at the sametime, from what little information I know about her, she's a nice girl who's doing her best to make it in this world. I know it isn't just about "looks", because I've seen other females of the human race who were gorgeous, but didn't feel anything for them. She isn't a model, but her face is absolutely amazing (I'm not saying she isn't great looking to me either). She has a great smile, and from the conversations I've had with her, she seems to be a noble girl. Not only that, I can't stop thinking about her!

I don't know why I feel this way, because this is the first time I'm experiencing this. Part of me would like to pursue this opportunity, but another part of me is telling me not to. This may seem over the top, but if it ever led to marriage, how would my Catholicity affect our relationship? How would she be able to support me spiritually? From what I know, she isn't anti-religious, and probally wasn't raised in a religious home. Yet, just because your spouse is Catholic, doesn't mean they will be perfect for you, or if they were met for you in the first place. Being part of the same faith is extremely important, but it doesn't guarantee a long lasting relationship either.

Maybe it's my hormones, or maybe it's not. All I know is, I'm 19, and my hormones kicked in years ago, and I've never felt [b]this way[/b] about a girl before.

I want to hear your opinions on this, especially the couple members of this forum who are currently married to non-Catholics. Thanks in advance.


[b]Note:[/b] I also know her cousin, and her cousin knows I find this girl attractive. I may speak with her privately whether or not I should go for it, and ask for her input about this religious compability as well. Maybe if I find out more about her, it will help me make a better judgement.

Posted

Date, do things with each other, etc. She might be willing to convert if you to decide on "making it serious, the 'Christian way.'"

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Nothing wrong with going on a few dates while you're building a friendship, but at the point where you start taking to the level of a relationship then it's good to be up front about your beliefs and the role they play in your life. That kind of open communication just makes for a better relationship because otherwise you'll likely end up making assumptions about her beliefs or willingness to support yours whatever that aren't true.

Also, when it comes to a Catholic and non-Catholic (even a non-Catholic Christian), the hurdles only become more difficult as the relationship grows more serious. Right now it's easy to attend different churches or whatever, but when you're married you have to deal with different faiths, deciding how to raise children, and issues of morality like contraceptive use. It's definitely not impossible, but it's also going to be more difficult than a Catholic-Catholic marriage would be (and any marriage, for that matter, is difficult enough!).

homeschoolmom
Posted

I don't see any problem with you dating her if she's open to learning about Catholicism. I would probably advise against getting too serious about someone with whom I could not share my faith, though.

Posted

well, seeing how i married a non-Catholic, my perspective will be different from mostly everyone else's. ;) one question though, is she non-religious, or just non-Catholic? there's a big difference.

i think there's a lot that depends on a lot of factors: is she willing to abide by certain rules (contraception, etc.)? is she at least friendly to Catholicism? is she willing to learn? is she willing to grow in faith?

my hubby is still not Catholic (working on it though ;)) but he understands there are certain things i cannot compromise. and he's learning about my faith, and is willing to explore it (now i've got him to come to Mass with me at least once a month, YAY!)

it is hard! not sharing a faith complicates things! but if you truly love someone, you can work on it! my responsibility as a wife is to bring my spouse to Christ - if i wouldn't have married him, who knows if it would've happened?

(ask Azriel her opinion about this as well, as i know she did not marry a Catholic either)

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

Personally, I probably wouldn't be anything more than friends with a guy who did not share my beliefs... I've tried that already. It was a long relationship - about 3 1/2 years. He was Catholic too, just very far from practicing. The struggle I went through in that relationship, and the pain I went through when I realized it just couldn't work because we had different beliefs, was enough for me to realize where I needed to set my standards as far as who I would date in the future. I'm just not up for a struggle like that again, so I can't imagine trying to make a relationship work with someone who wasn't at least brought up Catholic or already had an interest in converting. I know any relationship and marriage has its ups and downs, but you have to be on common ground with a sturdy foundation, especially when you're going to build a family on it.

Posted (edited)

So far many great points, I really appreciate the time you guys put into your replies, it is most needed. If she's not anti-religious, and is open to learn and isn't put off by my Catholicity, then I'll go for it. If she is against it however, I cannot out of good conscience make compromises and betray my faith, no matter how much I feel about her.

She's had a rough past, so she didn't have a great example to start off with. It doesn't mean she's rebellious towards religion, she just never had the opportunity while growing up.

Like with [b]Lil Red[/b], the reason she married the man she married, was she had a special chemistry with him, and felt it was the right decision to wed. I believe God in certain cases, directly makes it possible for Catholics to marry non-Catholics, so we can be vessels of God's plan of salvation to our spouses. I'm not implying that Catholics should marry non-Catholics simply to convert people to the Church, but if you love that person and eventually marry them, why wouldn't you, with God's grace, try (with descretion) your best to bring them to Christ?


[b]EDIT:[/b] As [b]Trisha[/b] pointed out, that is the reason why I want to find more about her first, before I make the first overt move on the girl. Of course the only true way of finding out will be to go out with her, or talk to her more in conversation, but if it doesn't work out, at least I gave it a shot.

I just pray that it could work out, because I really like her already. But, if it isn't God's will, then so be it.

Edited by Paladin D
Posted

The only thing that matters is that if she is intelligent and attractive enough to produce high quality children that you, as the male, will raise properly into the Catholic religion.

They only get uglier as they age.




bpat Konstantin

Posted

[size=1]I do not see anything wrong with marrying someone who is not catholic, but my own personal preferance would be that they should be catholic.
It helps with alot of things.
Of course in marriage you should always be able to support eachother in everything and really, marriage is about sacrifice, but the support that you can get from eachother spiritually I think is VERY important.
But like you said, it doesnt gaurantee relationships either.

But if you feel that you CAN have a relationship without that spiritual connection or similarity then I say go ahead! But like many of the others have pointed out, some of the requirements when marrying a non-catholic is that they have to be open to having childeren, and they have to agree to raise them Catholic.

But everything you said so far is so sweet! Im sure she is a great girl and you seem like a great guy so just talk to her about it somtime if it would be too weird and see how see feels on it!
:)
[/size]

Posted

As an "old" bachelor, I'm probably not one to give romance advice, but here's my $.02.

What you are describing is just a typical crush; nothing more, nothing less. While it's a very powerful feeling, it's just that, a feeling.
All it means is that you are strongly attracted to and infatuated with this girl. It does not necessarily mean you are destined to marry her, or this is God's holy will, or anything else. I'm not saying it's [b]not[/b], but the feeling in itself means little. I've been infatuated, and felt "in love," a number of times, yet obviously, none of those was destined to be "the one."
You may find this hard to beleive now, but for all you know, five years down the line you may have forgotten all about her and feel the same way about someone new.
I know it sounds cynical, but that's the truth. Of course, you should be strongly attracted to your (future) wife, but just because you're strongly attracted to someone doesn't in itself mean that you are destined to marry her or anything. The infatuation is an emotion, and however strong it may be, you shouldn't let it dominate you. (Easier said than done, of course).

Bottom line, at this point, I wouldn't spend too much time worrying about whether you should marry each other, when you are not even dating! Nothing wrong with talking to her, ort casual dating, but don't rush into something that it will be hard to get yourself out of at this stage.
You should first get to know her, and find out if she is at least open to conversion before going further. If she continues to be indifferent to religion, I probably wouldn't recommend seeking marriage. If you're serious about the Faith, and raising kids in the Faith, that could create serious problems down the line as regards the children's faith.
Contrary to what that "iKonstantin" character says, a woman is not just a baby-making machine, but will be the children's [i]mother[/i], and will likely have at least as strong an influence on her children's beliefs/attitudes as the father. If the parents are conflicted with each other about religion, the chances are much less likely that the kids will be strong Catholics.

But I wouldn't worry too much about that yet. Just start out casual, and see how things go, and leave possibilities open. You're still young and have got time ahead of you.

Posted

You make an extremely good point, [b]Socrates[/b]. Even though I have "feelings" for her, I'm still trying to be logical in this scenario. Emotions deceive many, and I don't want to become a victim of that. For a while I was keeping this as my basis, but I guess lately I let my guard down and now this happens. I'm not gonna rush into it, but I'll have to keep my cool and be alert.

The odd thing is, I've been working with her (she's a co-worker) for 9 months now, and this has only happened recently. Seeing how nasty relationships can become, I've been deliberately ignoring and brushing off any romantic thoughts or hype, until recently (big mistake?). I can't pin point how it started, but it took me by suprise. Curses!

This aspect of life is complicated, considering you are never sure who is right for you, and who isn't. I was doing great avoiding the whole romantic scene, where much of the world's drama resides, but it seems I got caught.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Paladin D' post='1087699' date='Oct 9 2006, 06:12 PM']
She's had a rough past, so she didn't have a great example to start off with. It doesn't mean she's rebellious towards religion, she just never had the opportunity while growing up.[/quote]
Sometimes these are the people who are most hungry for the Gospel.

Posted (edited)

Don't underplay physical beauty - simply stated, you cannot breed if you are not attracted to one another. And before I get another warning, understand that this is serious, once the initial infatuation wears off you need to keep rediscovering love. It is far easier with an attractive woman / man, I speak from experience.





bpat Konstantin

Edited by iKonstantin
Posted

[quote name='iKonstantin' post='1087931' date='Oct 9 2006, 10:11 PM']Don't underplay physical beauty - simply stated, you cannot breed if you are not attracted to one another.[/quote]
Really? That must have been one of the biology classes I was asleep for.

:topsy:

Posted

[quote name='Paladin D' post='1087808' date='Oct 9 2006, 07:00 PM']
You make an extremely good point, [b]Socrates[/b]. Even though I have "feelings" for her, I'm still trying to be logical in this scenario. Emotions deceive many, and I don't want to become a victim of that. For a while I was keeping this as my basis, but I guess lately I let my guard down and now this happens. I'm not gonna rush into it, but I'll have to keep my cool and be alert.

The odd thing is, I've been working with her (she's a co-worker) for 9 months now, and this has only happened recently. Seeing how nasty relationships can become, I've been deliberately ignoring and brushing off any romantic thoughts or hype, until recently (big mistake?). I can't pin point how it started, but it took me by suprise. Curses!

This aspect of life is complicated, considering you are never sure who is right for you, and who isn't. I was doing great avoiding the whole romantic scene, where much of the world's drama resides, but it seems I got caught.
[/quote]Don't be afraid to experince life and make mistakes. When I met my wife, I was Catholic, she wasn't anything. Now, it's the opposite.
It seems relationships are either too serious or too shallow now-a-days. Date her and be true to who you are so she can get to know you and let her be herself. My wife and I were friends for a good while before we became romantically involved as a couple. You're both teens. Some things will change and develop. Discern the big questions and problems later on after you both have established a foundation. In other words, don't fret about re-painting the barn if you haven't bought the farm.
Konstantain is an idiot. You only have to go to Wal-Mart to see that ugly people can willingly and successfully breed. I'm quite hideous and have a hot wife, but she thinks I'm sexy (well, maybe in a gargoyle-ish way). But what does future fornification have to do with someone you're not married too?
Relax. Go on a few casual dates and tone down the level of seriousness. You don't need all that baggage if you're just dating.

Posted

Hey! I am dating a non-Catholic and I have a couple things to say about that.

My boyfriend has been my best guy friend for three years and we have been dating for almost three months. He is not a Catholic, however, he is a Protestant who is in love with Jesus Christ and is one of the most moral guys I know. He has been such a good friend and is very considerate and respectful of women. He also is funny and loves to debate (I love guys I can have a good debate with), is very chivalrous, and fun to hang out with, not to mention he is very handsome :blush:

Now, that said, it is difficult dating a non-Catholic. My boyfriend and I are fine if we're both talking about how a movie connects with the Bible, but mention Purgatory or Confession, then we have to watch what we are talking about. It's hard at times because my faith is the most important thing to me and he doesnt' see why I would [i]need[/i] Confession because he says that you should only have to say sorry to God and that's it. Or why we need a Pope. It's difficult when someone you love just doesn't see eye to eye with you

However, it can be done. My boyfriend and I realize that though we don't worship the same way, we still worship the same God and he understands that if he were to marry me, that I would have to be married in the Catholic Church and that I want to raise my kids Catholic. He also agrees with me on a couple very important issues, such as the immorality of contraception. Not to mention we have a very good foundation of friendship and trustworthiness that is very important in any relationship. We can talk about anything.

So, what are my suggestions for interfaith dating?

1. Pray A LOT. You need to see God's will in this and you have to know if you are doing the right thing. Also, pray for your significant other, that God will be with them and help them see His love through your example.

2. Start off as friends first. You need to get to know each other better and be able to trust each other. Besides, it can help you sort through the chemstry you feel. When you start dating, keep it light and use that time to get to know each other better, to get to know their expectations of dating, as well as getting to know their families and friends.

3. Make sure they know how important faith is to you but don't push it on them. Instead, allow God to speak through you and let them think about it. It is very easy to get emotional and defensive during some discussions.

4. If you two get serious and think you might be "the one" for each other, make sure you talk about the moral issues. Make sure they understand how important it is for you not to use birth control, to marry in the Church, and to raise your kids in the Faith.

If God wills it, everything will fall into place. God bless you!

Posted

i've been dating a southern baptist for over a year. it's hard on me at times (especially when his whole church would love for me to be 'saved'), but i deal and it's been well worth it

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Socrates' post='1087777' date='Oct 9 2006, 07:35 PM']
Bottom line, at this point, I wouldn't spend too much time worrying about whether you should marry each other, when you are not even dating!
[/quote]

I can always count on Socrates to have my back when I'm not around.

[quote name='Socrates' post='1087777' date='Oct 9 2006, 07:35 PM']
If the parents are conflicted with each other about religion, the chances are much less likely that the kids will be strong Catholics.

But I wouldn't worry too much about that yet. Just start out casual, and see how things go, and leave possibilities open. You're still young and have got time ahead of you.
[/quote]

+1

The only other thing I would add is to find out what her attitudes are regarding sensitive subjects, mainly regarding chastity issues. If she does not have a strong religous background, she could tempt you, especially considering that you openly stated about the hormones kicking in. So be especially slow and careful with her and drop her quickly if she becomes an occasion of sin.

From the other "old" bachelor of phatmass (probably older than Socrates).




[quote name='Anomaly' post='1088088' date='Oct 10 2006, 08:25 AM']
You only have to go to Wal-Mart to see that ugly people can willingly and successfully breed. [/quote]

You just made me laugh so hard I thought I was going to pass out! You are on a roll the past couple of days between this and the fake dog vomit!

[quote name='rachael' post='1088295' date='Oct 10 2006, 01:57 PM']
i've been dating a southern baptist for over a year. it's hard on me at times (especially when his whole church would love for me to be 'saved'), but i deal and it's been well worth it
[/quote]

If you whoop their butts in a bible debate they may leave you alone and show you respect. I'm not joking about this, I actually made a potential mother-in-law walk out of the room in a bible debate, and they were Baptists.

Edited by Norseman82
Posted (edited)

Recently talked to her cousin, and her cousin knows about my feelings.

I can't afford to have a serious relationship, and nor can she. So this may work out for the both of us, if we are able to be friends (yet knowing I like her, not sure if she likes me :lol: ).

If she doesn't, it's no problem. A guy can dream at least. :D:

Edited by Paladin D
Posted
:sadder:

Dallas is all grown up now.


I miss you. Prayers. Ditto on what Socrotes has stated. Wow. Get to know her more. Seems like you don't know her enough. My brother was dating a non-catholic and she was the sweetest thing and hard core Protestant. Only when they got to discussing thier faiths, she couldn't respect the Eucharist and away she went.

It's different for everybody. Bottom line: pray. If it's Gods will, you will be married one day. Love ya!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...