Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Need The Church's Teaching


Recommended Posts

Domine ut Videam
Posted

Okay here is my question:

What exactly does the Church teach in concern to harming oneself through restriction of bodily needs and other physical harms?

I mean, sure it is wrong, but are you going to hell because of it? What if it is a disease and you cannot control yourself? How do you know if you have crossed the line and can no longer control yourself?



Also, if something is told to a priest in confession i know about the seal of confession, but how much is the priest allowed to ask about what you confessed? What if you don't want to tell him because you are afraid it will lead to more sin? Is he allowed to demand that you come see him, or go see someone else outside of the confessional?

Thanks.....in advance, i know this is vague but i can't really divulge what i am going through right now. Thanks though for your help.

-Yours in Christ
Lauren

Posted

Well, in lieu of an expert, I'll respond. :ninja:

[quote name='Domine ut Videam' post='1087834' date='Oct 9 2006, 08:42 PM']
Okay here is my question:

What exactly does the Church teach in concern to harming oneself through restriction of bodily needs and other physical harms?

I mean, sure it is wrong, but are you going to hell because of it? What if it is a disease and you cannot control yourself? How do you know if you have crossed the line and can no longer control yourself?[/quote]
Like any sin, in order for it to be mortal you need grave matter, full knowledge, and deliberate consent. If you can't control yourself, you can't give deliberate consent.

How can you tell if you can't control yourself? C'mon! Normal people don't harm themselves for fun! I think there's got to be something wrong.

Not seeking help when you know you need it is more likely to be where any sin lies...

[quote name='Domine ut Videam' post='1087834' date='Oct 9 2006, 08:42 PM']
Also, if something is told to a priest in confession i know about the seal of confession, but how much is the priest allowed to ask about what you confessed? What if you don't want to tell him because you are afraid it will lead to more sin? Is he allowed to demand that you come see him, or go see someone else outside of the confessional?[/quote]
You're not under any vow of obedience. They can't make you come back, or do anything else, or answer any questions you don't want to.

This is kind of lame, but I suggest trying to find a priest who does quick confessions. :mellow: Mention the incident as vaguely as possible. "I felt a compulsion to do (harmful thing) to myself and I gave into it (once/a few/#) times." The only time I've ever had a priest ask questions, it wasn't about what I'd confessed. (And that is rare. 90% of the time it's just in and out without any conversation at all.)

Prayers for you...

Posted

[quote name='Domine ut Videam' post='1087834' date='Oct 9 2006, 09:42 PM']
Okay here is my question:

What exactly does the Church teach in concern to harming oneself through restriction of bodily needs and other physical harms?[/quote]
i tried to find something in the catechism but i wasn't having any luck. basically, the Church believes that your body is a special gift with great dignity. as a temple of the Holy Spirit, it is to be properly cared for and respected.


[quote]I mean, sure it is wrong, but are you going to hell because of it? What if it is a disease and you cannot control yourself? How do you know if you have crossed the line and can no longer control yourself?[/quote]
physically abusing your body is a serious sin, but only you and God know if you have full knowledge of the nature of the sin, and full consent of the will when you commit it. addiction can decrease culpability, but you must not rest on that. eating disorders in particular are tough, but you must always keep trying. never give up or give in. you can in fact gain back control over your body. counseling--possibly in conjunction with medication--can and does help. i suggest seeking the guidance of a licensed therapist and psychiatrist. also, and perhaps most importantly, try to be faithful in prayer. note that every time you commit the sin, this does not mean that you are hell-bound. as long as you are breathing you have the opportunity to overcome sin and nurture a right relationship w/ the Lord.


[quote]Also, if something is told to a priest in confession i know about the seal of confession, but how much is the priest allowed to ask about what you confessed? What if you don't want to tell him because you are afraid it will lead to more sin? Is he allowed to demand that you come see him, or go see someone else outside of the confessional?[/quote]
well, it depends ;) my understanding has always been that a priest can ask questions about the sin regarding its kind and number, and that, as a penitent, you should give him this information so that he doesn't have to ask it. for example, instead of just saying, "i sinned against chastity" you would want to say "i had sex before marriage" and then say how many times you did this (give your best estimate if you don't know for sure). if you don't give this information, he is allowed to ask.

he does this to ensure that you make a good confession and that your specific sins are forgiven. there are multiple sins that fall under "against chastity," so you need to name the exact one, so he knows what exactly you are sorry for. also, the number helps to determine the seriousness of the sin. this is important for the priest to know, so that he can tailor his spiritual counsel according to your needs and so that he can give you an appropriate penance. that is also why he may inquire further into the nature or extent of your sin. in most cases, he is simply trying to understand you better so that he can best help you.

that said, some lines of questioning are simply inappropriate and are asked for sheer curiousity and not out of a want to help. its pretty easy to determine when someone has crossed the line. just ask yourself if the person really needs to know the answer to the question in order to help you. for example, if you confessed to watching pornography, it would be inappropriate (to say the least) for the priest to ask you what your favorite movie is, or what gets you excited.

also, regarding the confessional, you are only obligated to make a good and thorough confession. once you have clearly stated the kind and number of the sin, you do not have to share anything further. it is up to you. the confessional is primarily for the forgiveness of sins. i consider spiritual counseling to be a bonus, and i am always thankful when the priest gives me good advice on how to overcome my sin. but, technically speaking, the priest is not required to give such counsel, and you are not required to participate in that.


[quote]Thanks.....in advance, i know this is vague but i can't really divulge what i am going through right now. Thanks though for your help.

-Yours in Christ
Lauren
[/quote]
i understand. i hope this was of help to you.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...