Anthony Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 [quote name='Budge' post='1092140' date='Oct 15 2006, 03:30 PM'] There is a huge chasm in the Catholic church, and I believe many of the man-made traditions in Rome were meant to cement the power of the clergy as an elevated non-accountable class. Really when one exits the Catholic church and becomes a Christian, they discover that one can be called to endless ministries, and that God is no respecter of persons and they do not a need a Catholic priest to approach the throne because Jesus Christ is the high priest.... The idea of their being a much holier class of men and women {Catholic religious} is against the fact that God is no respecter of persons. The average Catholic is put further away from God, because they think I could never be as holy as that priest, that nun, etc. [/quote] Don't listen to Budge. She doesn't know what she is talking about.
Norseman82 Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 [quote name='imthepresident' post='1092023' date='Oct 15 2006, 08:39 AM'] What authority do I have? None? Unfortunately that is the impression I have and have always had. I know know many other people feel the same way. So as far as "vocations" go, being a lay person given no authority to do anything but attend mass, how much can I possibly be called to do? This question may be phrased a little wrong, but I'm sure you understand. [/quote] What authority are you seeking?
shortnun Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 [quote name='Budge' post='1092140' date='Oct 15 2006, 03:30 PM'] There is a huge chasm in the Catholic church, and I believe many of the man-made traditions in Rome were meant to cement the power of the clergy as an elevated non-accountable class. Really when one exits the Catholic church and becomes a Christian, they discover that one can be called to endless ministries, and that God is no respecter of persons and they do not a need a Catholic priest to approach the throne because Jesus Christ is the high priest.... The idea of their being a much holier class of men and women {Catholic religious} is against the fact that God is no respecter of persons. The average Catholic is put further away from God, because they think I could never be as holy as that priest, that nun, etc. [/quote] Budge, you are correct in your historical perceptions. Throughout (though not constantly) history, the Church as an entity has tried to preserve itself. By this I mean, it strives to continually allow the Holy Spirit to guide and inspire their works. Now, sometimes these endeavors have been more successful than others. Sometimes great pain arrives out of these decisions. But I do not make this connection to God, as you do. I do believe that God respects all persons, b/c we are created[i] imago dei[/i]. Certainly as humans we claim our faults and recognize we do not always see others the way our Creator sees us. I also agree with (and I forget who said it exactly) the person on this thread who pointed out the changes that have occurred over the last 40 years. Much of the Western idea of "holier-than-though" religious and priests have gone away. Thank God that most of the destruction of these difference was done through individual relationships. In some situations, it was the sex abuse scandal that caused people to see priests as truly human. But does this say anything negative about God? Not at all! If it says anything, it shows us our brokenness, and how that can be made whole each day through the mystery of the Incarnation. And I pray that all unfair chasms are filled with prayers each day, so that one day the valleys will be raised up and mountains made low for a straight pathway to the LORD. (Isaiah 40: 2-3)
Socrates Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote name='imthepresident' post='1092033' date='Oct 15 2006, 08:49 AM'] Socrates, are you calling me a Protestant? I assure you, I am not a Protestant troll, but a little debate never hurt anyone. And yes I might want to study up on Church history and theology, I don't have a full understanding and useful knowledge to fully discuss such things. But if I have to also rely on the subsequent additions to the Word (such as the concept of vocations), geez, where does it stop?[/quote] Sorry, I missed this post after the thread got moved from the debate table. Anyway, Mr. President, my asking whether you are Catholic or Protestant was in no way intended to insult, but merely to seek clarification and see where you were coming from. Obviously, this makes a big question in how the issue is addressed. For example, there would be no point to start out expounding on Catholic Church teaching if you do not believe the Catholic Church to be the True Church founded by Christ! And not all protestants are trolls, of course. (Though a few individuals on here seem to have been doing all in their power to give protestants a bad name.) If you are Catholic you would not have a [i]Sola Scriptura[/i] ("Bible Alone") understanding of Church teaching, but would understand that Christ continues to teach and lead through His Church on earth. [quote]And I say to thee: That thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it And I will give to thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven. And whatsoever thou shalt bind upon earth, it shall be bound also in heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth, it shall be loosed also in heaven.[/quote] Matthew 16:18-19 Thus we should heed the Church when she teaches us, and not take lightly what Peter (the Pope) chooses to bind and loose. [quote]Hmm, let's discuss this. I agree with you, a priest has so many responsibilities that he simply does not have a whole lot of time to take care of a wife and children! And my post basically argued that if a married Peter could do it AND start the Church, well a priest could do it too! I'm probably flawed here because we're all not rocks like Peter. We didnt' get to experience firsthand, a living breathing talking resurrected Jesus. BUT, let's examine why Peter could do it in a married state. I read Acts and the Letters of Paul and I was thoroughly impressed at how people of all walks of life just wanted to help the Church with all they had. Peter and Paul had a lot of help and a lot of support!!! From many fervent new believers! I really believe this is one of the reasons why the Church founders were successful and why the Church has such a solid foundation. Maybe if Catholics today had this attitude, it would be holier and there would be more "vocations".[/quote] Scripture itself doesn't speak much of Peter's wife. (His marriage is only indirectly mentioned when his mother-in-law is healed.) However, ancient tradition (not infallible) is that Peter was an older man and lived a celibate life after assuming the duties of temporal head of the Church. We must remember also that in the Bible, the Church was starting from scratch, and men had to be called from all walks of life "as they were." There were no seminaries and such in place yet. However, a tradition of priestly celibacy was established very early on. Celibacy was in fact the norm (though not a rule) through the early centuries of the Church. It was only declared a binding rule, when this tradition was becoming widely ignored, and married clergy were creating all kinds of problems in the Church. The fact that things were in a bad state in the Church at a time when married clergy was becoming common practice (and that there was a renewal in the Church after priests were banned from being married, among other reforms), should in itself show that priestly celibacy is not the problem, and that married priests are not the solution to all our problems. Also, the Church had some of its most holy and successful periods (1100s-1300s) during a time when priestly celibacy was the rule. Your personal beliefs about priestly celibacy being a problem are really not backed up by the facts of Church history. [quote]So what's the real cause of the problem? Hmm, I did read about more conservative diocese having increased vocations. I guess that just means we should be more conservative? How do we be more conservative? Not asking sarcastically, I genuinely want to know what being more conservative looks like.[/quote] Note that I put "conservative" in quotes. What I'm really talking about is [b]"orthodox"[/b] - that is, faithful to the Magisterium and teachings of the Catholic Church. (Often labeled "conservative" by the media. Btw, I generally dislike the labels "conservative" and "liberal" when applied to the Church, because they make it sound like mere political factions.) I'm talking about where orthodox Catholic dogma is taught by priests, and the Faith is loyally followed - where people strive to teach, live, and worship, in accord with that which is taught by Rome. This is in opposition to watered-down heterodox do-your-own-thing "liberal Catholicism," in which dissent from true Catholic teaching is commonly taught. [quote]As far as there being a lack of faith and fervor among Catholics, yes, this is true. But why? Did we all of a sudden decide to have less faith and fervor? Heh, not that simple. The world is a very tempting place, an easy place for a sheep to be lead astray. I'm going to take a leap here and "blame" it on the chasm between laity and clergy. In one of my other posts I talked about how the priest has a clear delineation of his responsibilities, but a lay person ....really doesn't. Maybe there needs to be a more clear emphasis on what lay person can do to be more holy, besides going to Mass and celebrating the Eucharist. I mean really, it's hard for anyone to name a Saint that wasn't part of a religious order (if any). [/quote] The reason is increasingly worldiness (by both clergy and lay people) and decreased focus on heavenly things, as well as increased dissent from Catholic moral and dogmaticteaching (by both clergy and lay people), and lack of solid teaching on the Faith, resulting in widespread ignorance and indifference. Whatever the problem is, it is not the discipline of priestly celibacy, which has been in place for many centuries before the recent crisis in the Church and vocations. Your leap is just that - a leap - without solid evidence or logic to back it up. There are many holy lay people witnessing to Christ in their daily lives. And there are literally hundreds of canonized saints who were not members of religious orders. (I'll name St. Elizabeth of Hungary as a random example off the top of my head.) [quote]I believe this is a leadership problem; rather than encouraging laity to be more involved, just say that they lack faith! I've heard this many, many times! And while it is true that there is a lack of faith among Catholics today, well.....what do you want us to do about it? Please give us feedback, guidance; remember we are sheep, we can't lead ourselves. Please don't have the attitude of blaming us for lack of faith.[/quote] This is nonsense. No one is letting the clergy off the hook. I believe bad clergy (including many bishops) are responsible for many of the problems of the Church. I also know plenty of lay people (single and married) acitve in the Church and leading holy lives. Where the Church is healthy, both clergy and lay people will be holy and active in the Church. This is the responsiblity of both. And saying "we are sheep, we can't lead ourselves" is a lame excuse. We have the words of the Church for guidance; and you can step up and take action where needed. [quote]Socrates, this is not a personal attack, but I believe what you said to me more or less sums up the chasm between laity and clergy. I obviously didn't know much about church history or theology......and yet, you told me my arguments were Protestant.....you surreptitiously accused me of being a Protestant.....you didn't tell me where I was wrong or correct me......you only told me that my arguments were Protestant. And then, you tell me I "might want to study up on Church history and theology" (which I really might want to do). Please....please don't have that attitude. If my arguments are wrong, please send links, tell me "You might want to check out this site to see why there are vocations" or "this is the Church's reasoning behind a celibate priesthood". Are there Catholic lay institutes where people can go? This chasm needs to be eliminated.[/quote] To get you started, [url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0102fea5.asp"]Here's an article on priestly celibacy.[/url] [url="http://www.catholic.com/search.asp?query=celibacy"]Here's a whole list of articles/resources.[/url]
LouisvilleFan Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote name='HisChild' post='1091464' date='Oct 14 2006, 10:42 AM'] I can tell you one thing, however. . .having been in religious life, as well as experiencing a pastor in our parish that was a married converted Anglican. . .being married and being in a religious state, is incredibly rough, if not downright impossible. [/quote] I've heard this said so many times, and I agree that there's some truth to balancing those demands, but what about the Eastern Churches? The Orthodox freely ordain married men and they seem to think we're the crazy ones for demanding celibacy. What is structurally different about the Orthodox Churches that makes it far from "downright impossible" for their priests to balance family and parish life?
cmotherofpirl Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1094011' date='Oct 17 2006, 02:35 PM'] I've heard this said so many times, and I agree that there's some truth to balancing those demands, but what about the Eastern Churches? The Orthodox freely ordain married men and they seem to think we're the crazy ones for demanding celibacy. What is structurally different about the Orthodox Churches that makes it far from "downright impossible" for their priests to balance family and parish life? [/quote] Because they are small churches totally supported by their culture. And they will tell you it is never easy.
cmotherofpirl Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 article written by one of our few maried priests: [url="http://www.crisismagazine.com/october2006/ryland.htm"]http://www.crisismagazine.com/october2006/ryland.htm[/url]
fonebone Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 [quote name='imthepresident' post='1092033' date='Oct 15 2006, 08:49 AM']This chasm needs to be eliminated. [/quote] My dear sir, there are two things I'm thinking. The first is, you've experienced or see a negative separation of clergy and laity, a separation either pushed to the extreme or one wrongly interpreted. The second is this: each and every one has a specific role in the Church. To slur and combine all the roles together would bear no fruit; there is hierarchy in God Himself. The Father initiates the gift, pours Himself out for the Son, who accepts the gift and returns it to the Father, and the love shared is so strong it [i]is[/i] another divine person, the Holy Spirit. Given this is an incomplete understanding of the mystery of God, we can still see the importance of roles. If God the Son wanted to be on top, it would disrupt the order of God. Of course, such a thing could never happen. But the role of the family reflects God; the man initiates the gift, the woman accepts his love and returns it, the domestic church community finds its grounding on that, and through the marital embrace, the total self-giving, they concieve life. The woman cannot initiate. The man cannot be receptive as a woman can. The child concieved certainly cannot step outside of his role, either. Don't worry, I'm getting to something! Now, please bear with me if I am understanding you incorrectly, but it sounds as if, by you saying "the chasm needs to be eliminated," you show a lack of understanding of roles. And from what I've read, you don't understand the role of the laity in the Church, or you see it as marginalized. If the latter is the case, don't worry! The lay people in the Church have a very, very important role, especially in the restoration... Pope John Paul II wrote a whole apostolic exhortation on the role of the lay faithful, entitled "Christifideles Laici" (found [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_exhortations/documents/hf_jp-ii_exh_30121988_christifideles-laici_en.html"]here[/url]) So the roles are important. But please, tell me; is this where the issue lies? In misunderstanding of the roles of clergy and laity, of dissatisfaction with the roles, or something else? God bless you!
HisChild Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 Regarding married priests and priestly celibacy. . .I came across this article that I thought you might be interested in. [url="http://www.crisismagazine.com/october2006/ryland.htm"]http://www.crisismagazine.com/october2006/ryland.htm[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now