jswranch Posted October 15, 2006 Posted October 15, 2006 As some of you know, I have written a large defense of the Perpetual Virginity. However, one response eludes me: [quote]If an unconsumated marriage would not be valid under Levitical Law and Mary and Joseph were married (MT 1:19 etc), then how could they be a celibate couple?[/quote] My initial (errant) response was they stayed in a betrothal status, but they were married. My best guess is that the above argument is based on a false premise: validity of marriage in old covenant. No evidence exists that a marriage would be invalid due to celibacy in the old covenant. As under canon law, a celibate marriage can be valid if both partners are aware of the condition before the ceremony. I suppose I could refer to the Protoevangelium of James to show it was a protectorate relationship. Let me know if I am wrong or if you can word this better.
thessalonian Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 I think your friend is confusing the Catholic position on marriage, which as you said is not universal, with the Jewish view of marriage. The case of Mary and Joseph is a very unique case but as I understand it there were and have been throughout time a few celibate couples of the nature you have described with vows of celibaby. There is no other way of explaining Mary's words, "how can this be for I do not know man" when the angel said she was to concieve and bare a son. "Ya, I know, I'm getting married. That's what happens when ya get married you silly angel". These kind of questions arise from those who do not understand Catholicism and it's teachings. Unfortunately most of them aren't that interested in your answer either. But give it a go. I do believe we have made progress on the net. Rarely do you get in to an exchange on "call no man father" for intance. Blessings
jswranch Posted October 16, 2006 Author Posted October 16, 2006 Thess, Thanks. Do we have any evidence that the Jews allowed celibate marriages back before Christ? Was a man wounded in battle in a not so sensitive place still allowed to get married?
thessalonian Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 While I have heard that it was practiced within the Jewish community, perhaps among the Essenians, before Christ I don't have any hard evidence. There happens to be a consecrated virginity site online. I thought they might have an answer and so I emailed them. I will let you know. [url="http://www.consecratedvirgins.org/index.html"]http://www.consecratedvirgins.org/index.html[/url]
phatcatholic Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 try the articles found here: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/12"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/12[/url] also, i don't know the reference off hand, but there are instances in the bible where God asked a prophet to remain celibate b/c he was to devote his entire self to the work of the Lord. we also know that rabbis were accustomed to remain celibate so that they could devote themselves to study of the word (the scriptures). if anyone was devoted to the word (jesus), it was mary. i also read somewhere (i forget where) that the obligation was not necessarily [b][i]to have sex[/i][/b], but to have sex [b]when the husband asked for it[/b]. we believe that joseph was her most chaste spouse and that he gave her body the utmost reverence as the ark who bore the new covenant. as long as he never asked for sex, mary wasn't breaking any type of marriage law. i hope that helps pax christi, phatcatholic
franciscanheart Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 couple of questions: can couples still be married with vows of celibacy? how does one explain these vows in a way which does not undermind views of marriage in the Catholic church? not that it would happen, though it might, could it still be that a woman and man never had sex during marriage simply because the man never asked? like... could a woman enter a marriage vowing to have sex when the man asked for it but only then? i guess that would be a case like the one i questioned above, huh? how beautiful is it that joseph was so chaste?! he never asked mary to submit to him in a sexual way. how holy!
thessalonian Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 (edited) [quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1093687' date='Oct 17 2006, 04:35 AM'] couple of questions: can couples still be married with vows of celibacy? how does one explain these vows in a way which does not undermind views of marriage in the Catholic church? not that it would happen, though it might, could it still be that a woman and man never had sex during marriage simply because the man never asked? like... could a woman enter a marriage vowing to have sex when the man asked for it but only then? i guess that would be a case like the one i questioned above, huh? how beautiful is it that joseph was so chaste?! he never asked mary to submit to him in a sexual way. how holy! [/quote] Hughyforlife, Yes, a couple can be married with a vow of celibacy as long as they both know and agree to it. It has been done throughout the ages, more in Eastern rites. By mutual agreement it is okay. Celibacy in no way undermines marriage. It is a different calling is all. Celibacy looks ahead to the kindgom forgoing a good, i.e. sexual relations for the kingdom, to devote their lives totally to God. The marital act is a shadow of what is to come. It will pass away and all will be celibates inheaven. Marriage and the sexual union is a sign/symbol of our unity in the trinity that we will experience in the hereafter. The sexual union between a man and a woman, even Mary and Joseph is completely holy when it's focus is on pleasing the other in the married state. This in turn brings more pleasure to ourselves. This needs to be the goal for every couple seeking holiness in sexual union. True love is not the opposite of hate. True love is having concern for the welfare of the other rather than looking at the other as an object for our pleasure. Mary and Joseph were of course a special case because Mary was in a sense the spouse of the Holy Spirit. I am sure a motivating factor for Joseph to take on the great responsibility of caring for her. Having relations with her would have been like touching the ark of the covenant. The almighty God was in that womb for nine months. I highly recommend that you get the christopher west tape series on theology of the body. It really clears up alot about celibacy and marriage. Celibacy should not be the repression of our sexuality but another path to the redemption of our sexuality so that it is rightly ordered. Our sexuality should not be repressed or indulged but redeemed by the blood of the cross and by his grace. Edited October 17, 2006 by thessalonian
franciscanheart Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 I picked up and read a lot of The Good News About Sex And Marriage but don't remember a whole lot of what I read - I have a tendency to do that.
phatcatholic Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 as far as i know, married priests (in the eastern rite, or a married pastor who converts and becomes a priest in the western rite) have celibate marriages. this would be a modern-day example.
franciscanheart Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 are you sure about that second part? (the converts) i thought they were NOT celibate. If they are, that would be a huge blow to the whole 'if only priests were allowed to marry' argument...
thessalonian Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 Phat, I don't believe that is the case. We had a lutheran pastor convert and become a priest a few years back. He was not celibate that I know of. I read several articles about him and there was no mention of that.
iKonstantin Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 Eastern rite priests are not required to be celibate in their marriage. bpat Konstantin
homeschoolmom Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 yeah, I'm pretty surprised to read that.
jswranch Posted October 18, 2006 Author Posted October 18, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1094718' date='Oct 18 2006, 08:18 AM'] Phat, I don't believe that is the case. We had a lutheran pastor convert and become a priest a few years back. He was not celibate that I know of. I read several articles about him and there was no mention of that. [/quote] Married protestant ministers can become priests. I have never heard they are required to be celibate. I do believe they cannot get remarried if wife dies.
son_of_angels Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 As I understand it, while a marriage can be contracted between two celibate persons, the sacrament is not fully conveyed, and an un-consumated marriage can be dissolved, with a dispensation from the affinity which exists by virtue of the marital vows. As I recall, this was the case with several nullified marriages in the Middle Ages, where the couple had never consumated the marriage. As I also understand, this was, in Medieval Canon Law, part of a woman's rights, that if she was married, and the person never consumated it with her, the marriage could be dispensed with, but the woman had the right to demand him to keep his vows. However, the sacrament of marriage COULD have been conveyed, as revelation indicates, to Mary and Joseph because they were married from the direct inspiration of God. As such, it was conveyed in an even fuller way, as, perhaps, Adam and Eve, who said "She is now bone of my bone and flesh of my flesh" prior to any mention of consumation. Mary, having been chosen directly by God as the companion of Joseph, and under his care, shared in the spiritual flesh of Joseph, and was thereby given the grace of matrimony AND chastity.
son_of_angels Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 [quote]Can. 1141 A marriage that is ratum et consummatum can be dissolved by no human power and by no cause, except death. Can. 1142 For a just cause, the Roman Pontiff can dissolve a non-consummated marriage between baptized persons or between a baptized party and a non-baptized party at the request of both parties or of one of them, even if the other party is unwilling. [/quote]
phatcatholic Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 hmm, maybe that was just an assumption on my part, that a married protestant pastor who becomes a catholic priest has to live a celibate marriage. i'll do some research on it.....
franciscanheart Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 yeah i was reading an article about married priests in the us (about a year ago) in some magazine and it featured eight priests. it said nothing about living a celibate life.
son_of_angels Posted October 22, 2006 Posted October 22, 2006 The only examples we have of married priests being forced to remain abstinent from sex in marriage come from the Middle Ages. Priests, given special permission, of course, to be married are NOT required to maintain abstinent. Rather, their faithful married life is truly a source of blessing for their congregations. As to the original question, what about Mary and Joseph's wedding? Personally, I stand by the Adam and Eve theory. If God joins two people by an explicit supernatural act, the grace of marriage can be obtained, even when that marriage has not been consumated. On the other hand, the vows of marriage would still apply, and therefore they could rightly be called "married" even in a non-consummated relationship, because the vows had been solemnly and publicly made. However, in this case, I believe that the added grace of marriage was obtained through God's direct intervention, i.e. his explicit volition. As Mary was created like Eve, without original sin, it would be unseemly for her to lie with a man who could. How then may they be joined, but by the joining which happened at Creation between Adam and Eve? He looked at her, saw the means and beauty of his salvation, and at that moment he knew her, perfectly and without any object of lust, and called her bone of his bone, flesh of his flesh, as Adam looked on the perfect Eve.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now