melikalani Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 Let us pray for unity within the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. Jesus, Mary, I love you. Save souls. Amen. [url="http://today.reuters.co.uk/misc/PrinterFriendlyPopup.aspx?type=worldNews&storyID=2006-10-16T071509Z_01_L15440470_RTRUKOC_0_UK-POPE-TRADITIONALISTS.xml"]http://today.reuters.co.uk/misc/PrinterFri...ITIONALISTS.xml[/url] [quote]Catholic schismatics see return to Roman fold soon Mon Oct 16, 2006 8:15 AM BST By Tom Heneghan, Religion Editor PARIS (Reuters) - After almost two decades of schism, Catholic traditionalists hope the Vatican will soon take them back into the fold by granting two key concessions and leaving unresolved the main issue that drove them away. Bishop Bernard Fellay, head of the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX), says the expected revival of the old Latin mass that was replaced in the 1960s by modern liturgy in local languages would be a "grand gesture" meeting one of his demands. The Swiss bishop, successor to the late SSPX founder French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, also expects the Vatican to lift the 1988 excommunications of Lefebvre and four bishops -- including Fellay -- whom he consecrated without Rome's approval. "Things are going in the right direction. I think we'll get an agreement," Fellay told journalists in Paris at the weekend. "Things could speed up and come faster than expected." Getting an agreement now would mean the Swiss-based SSPX and its 470 priests could return to the Roman fold without resolving a dispute over its opposition to the modernising reforms of the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965). Claiming a million followers, the SSPX is the vanguard of traditionalists among 1.1 billion Catholics worldwide. Its return would have no direct effect on most parishes but high symbolic value for arch-conservatives in the Church. The excommunications by the late Pope John Paul created the first schism in the Church in modern times. Since his election last year, Pope Benedict has been trying to hold out an olive branch to the SSPX. Fellay envisages the SSPX would be an independent group within the Church, free of control by local bishops, while it continued to advocate rolling back other Vatican II reforms. "We would be a bit like the Chinese Patriotic Church, in the Church without really being there," he explained. "There could be a relationship between Rome and us, but it would not yet be a juridical relationship." "INTERMEDIATE STATE" Speculation about an SSPX return arose last week when Vatican sources said Pope Benedict would soon allow wider use of the old Tridentine Mass in Latin that went out of favour when the Church switched to praying in local languages in the 1960s. Priests can say the old mass if they get permission but few bishops grant it and demand for Latin rites is minimal. Most Catholics under 50 years old have never heard Latin spoken. The SSPX thinks the post-Council liturgy, which stresses participation by worshippers in open praying and singing, has lost the sacred character and beauty of the traditional mass. The Tridentine rite it prefers is solemn, with the priest and altar boys quietly reciting the prayers in Latin with their backs to the silent congregation. The traditionalists also reject the Council decision that the Church, which long saw itself as the only path to salvation, should respect and work together with other faiths. Echoing this, a senior SSPX official sparked controversy last year by urging the Pope to tell Jews and followers of other religions to convert from their "false systems" to Catholicism. Fellay said the SSPX sought an "intermediate state" in the Church so it could continue to oppose what Lefebvre called "neo-Modernist and neo-Protestant tendencies ... in the Second Vatican Council and in all the reforms which issued from it." "We don't want a practical solution before these doctrinal questions are resolved," he said. "The focus should be on these discussions." Benedict, who sparked protest across the Muslim world last month with a speech hinting that Islam had been spread by the sword, has frequently stressed his support for Vatican II reforms including cooperation with other faiths. [/quote]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 Even if a universal indult comes, that doesn't excuse or fix the excommunications.
Ash Wednesday Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 I think an indult for the old mass will bring some people back, but I don't like the wording of the Vatican granting "concessions" and "meeting demands" and if that is the prevalent attitude then I don't see a formal reconciliation anytime soon. But again an indult would, I think, reduce the memberships of SSPX.
Aloysius Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1093023' date='Oct 16 2006, 01:56 PM'] Even if a universal indult comes, that doesn't excuse or fix the excommunications. [/quote] unless the pope says so. hmm... if Malachy's prophecies are right, what if "Glory of the Olives" means he will bring about the end of all schisms... starting with the SSPX, then the East (those talks started up again recently, right?)... and maybe even some mainstream protestant ones... you know, an olive branch-- glory of the olives-- hmmm lol sorry for the random hijack.. anyway, the Pope could lift the excommunications if he so desired. I personally wouldn't think lifting the excommunications is correct since Lefebvre did it because he doubted the validity of all the sacraments in the concilliar church and as such it was an act of direct schism and disobedience against the Roman Pontiff, but the pope could do it if he wanted to.
Dave Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 If there was a reconciliation, the SSPX would also need to accept Vatican II in its entirety and lose its (SSPX) spirit of anger and disobedience.
Seven77 Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1093101' date='Oct 16 2006, 01:54 PM'] hmm... if Malachy's prophecies are right, what if "Glory of the Olives" means he will bring about the end of all schisms... starting with the SSPX, then the East (those talks started up again recently, right?)... and maybe even some mainstream protestant ones... you know, an olive branch-- glory of the olives-- hmmm lol sorry for the random hijack.. [/quote] wow... [quote] Since his election last year, Pope Benedict has been trying to hold out an [b]olive[/b] branch to the SSPX.[/quote]
goldenchild17 Posted October 16, 2006 Posted October 16, 2006 This is definitely something I think Benedict wants to accomplish. I'm surprised he hasn't sealed it up already. It's too bad. I like the SSPX
Akalyte Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 Why does there seem to be a disomfort here when it comes to a possible return to the old rite? Why do some of you dislike this idea? You look at traditional catholics like they are slime!
Pio Nono Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 JMJ 10/17 - St. Ignatius of Antioch [quote]"We would be a bit like the Chinese Patriotic Church, in the Church without really being there," he explained. "There could be a relationship between Rome and us, but it would not yet be a juridical relationship."[/quote] This would be entirely unacceptable. This is a fundamentally Protestant ecclesiology. This is also a rather French attitude as well that the Church has never accepted. His Grace needs to read a couple of Fundamental Ecclesiology texts before he starts talking about a relationship with Rome, since what he suggests is what exists in the Anglican communion.
stbernardLT Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 It would be great to have our brothers back, but just because they get an indult doesn't mea they accept the Norvus Ordo. I think they must accept Vatican II and and be ok with the Norvus Ordo to be allowed back into the church. There is a difference between preferring one rite over the other and downright condemning a rite all together. If they want to unite with the Servant of Servants the must get off of their high horse. I have no problem with a Latin Mass, but then I have no problem with the Norvus Ordo either.
Akalyte Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 I have a problem with the thousands of parishes who dont even say the Novus ordo mass correctly. Even when its in english they cant seem to get it right. Its hard to even find a parish that includes latin in the novus ordo mass (there is suppose to be latin) The Vatican II documents say so. Yet thosuands upon thousands of parishes seem to get this wrong. this is why I openly welcome a return to the old rite.
Ash Wednesday Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote name='Akalyte' post='1093702' date='Oct 17 2006, 05:45 AM'] Why does there seem to be a disomfort here when it comes to a possible return to the old rite? Why do some of you dislike this idea? You look at traditional catholics like they are slime! [/quote] Criticism of SSPX/schismatic traditionalism does not necessarily mean one doesn't like the old rite. Personally, I'd love to go back to the old rite. I just don't like, as Dave put it, the SSPX's spirit of anger and disobedience. I really hope and pray the indult does happen and brings some separated bretheren back to the fold.
Anomaly Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote name='Akalyte' post='1093769' date='Oct 17 2006, 07:01 AM'] I have a problem with the thousands of parishes who dont even say the Novus ordo mass correctly. Even when its in english they cant seem to get it right. Its hard to even find a parish that includes latin in the novus ordo mass (there is suppose to be latin) The Vatican II documents say so. Yet thosuands upon thousands of parishes seem to get this wrong. this is why I openly welcome a return to the old rite. [/quote] Do you ever wonder WHY a properly said Mass is as rare as hen's teeth? Is it a failure of your perception of what is right, or is it due to an overall failure of the seminaries and bishops and Church to communicate and function?
Theoketos Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote name='Pio Nono' post='1093710' date='Oct 17 2006, 06:26 AM'] JMJ 10/17 - St. Ignatius of Antioch This would be entirely unacceptable. This is a fundamentally Protestant ecclesiology. This is also a rather French attitude as well that the Church has never accepted. His Grace needs to read a couple of Fundamental Ecclesiology texts before he starts talking about a relationship with Rome, since what he suggests is what exists in the Anglican communion. [/quote] You sound like St. Ignatius of Antioch.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1093101' date='Oct 16 2006, 03:54 PM'] unless the pope says so. hmm... if Malachy's prophecies are right, what if "Glory of the Olives" means he will bring about the end of all schisms... starting with the SSPX, then the East (those talks started up again recently, right?)... and maybe even some mainstream protestant ones... you know, an olive branch-- glory of the olives-- hmmm lol sorry for the random hijack.. anyway, the Pope could lift the excommunications if he so desired. I personally wouldn't think lifting the excommunications is correct since Lefebvre did it because he doubted the validity of all the sacraments in the concilliar church and as such it was an act of direct schism and disobedience against the Roman Pontiff, but the pope could do it if he wanted to. [/quote] Yes, but I'm just saying that the indult in itself wouldn't fix the excommunications, but would only allow the Tridentine Mass. Of course the bishop would lift the excommunications, but everytime there's talk of an indult, the radical traditionalists get all excited as if the excommunication will be lifted...but the excommunication really has less to do with the Tridentine Mass itself and more to do with disobedience which, despite any indult, was still not just disobedience.
Pio Nono Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 JMJ 10/17 - St. Ignatius of Antioch [quote name='Theoketos' post='1093785' date='Oct 17 2006, 08:34 AM'] You sound like St. Ignatius of Antioch. [/quote] I hope that's a good thing.....
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now