Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Guest lundercovera
Posted (edited)

you know what, i'm being selfish... willguy had a question.

Okay, I'm in a situation.  For a while, I've felt called to the priesthood (as I've described before).  I've come to grips with that reality, and have reached a point of liking and favoring the idea.  My parents have also grown to accept the idea.  I figured, "OK God, you've called, and I've answered."

But recently, I find myself attracted towards the religious life.  I'm very confused.  See, I'm a bit of an idealist and a romanticist.  So, the idea of a religious life appeals simply because of its simple beauty, devotion, and communality.  But I'm not sure if that's all that attracts me, or if God is truely drawing me to this life.  Part of me thinks its right, part of me wants to consider it, and part of me thinks its wrong.  I can't tell which part is God.  I tell myself "The Church needs priests more than it needs brothers," but is that really the case?  No.  Otherwise, God wouldn't call brothers.  I don't know.  There are definitly selfish reasons for wanting to be a priest, but ther are also Godly reasons, or at least ones that seem Godly.  I'm so confused.  I'm scared because this seems similar to the way I faught the priesthood, at least on the surface of it.  I'm so confused (I know I just said that, but its the jist of how I feel right now).

When I was discerning the priesthood, I told God that I wanted to do His will, whatever that may be.  I didn't think that it might be this.  Now I'm afraid.  I wish I could know, 100%, what He wanted.  I wish I could be the apostles or Paul and have Christ just walk up and say "Do this." 

Well, I'm done ranting now.  I think I need to pray.  Where are my rosary beads...

Blazer's Advice:

God calls by what you are attracted too . . . just like women . . . if you think one type of life is beautiful, you should check it out . . .

continue discussion

Edited by lundercovera
Posted

under,

Don't think of yourself as being selfish. You are a guy with a question about vocations, that means that this thread is for you. I would respond to your post right now, but I have to go take care of the laundry.

Posted

The vocations director just agreed to send me an application! Please pray.

peace...

Theologian in Training
Posted

You do realize that eventually you have to stop trying to figure out what God wants with you, and let God guide your decision. When I was entirely confused, despondent, and lost, I said simpy, "God, I have no idea what you want and I don't know what to do, take everything, it is all yours, I don't want it anymore. I am tired of this, what do you want of me?"

The vocation director called me the next day, and told me I was accepted.

Sometimes we have to stop telling God what we want and listen and follow what He wants. Takes time, but it also takes humility.

God Bless

Posted

I like that theo. I also do a lot of "Lord this is what I want." Because really, God begins with our desire. He begins with what will make us happy. Not necessarily what we think will make us happy, but I am not afraid to tell God what I want. He answers my prayers. It's amesome.

Posted

I'm also often tempted to say "How lovely is my dwelling place, O Lord". I've always dreamed of becoming a Priest from the age of about 10. There are times when I've pushed it away, but it has still always been there. I think one of the hardest things for me to do has been to accept that I have not chosen Him, but He has chosen me. Part of that for me has been coming to trust myself entirely to God's will, and accepting that even if he dosen't want me to be a Priest. This meant lettiing go of my precious dream that I would be a Priest, but absolutely essential to my continuing on this path. If I am ordained, it must be through God's choice that I assent to and not the other way around!

Willguy - I can empathise with your difficulty in discerning whether you are called to Priesthood or Religious Life. It's one I struggled with before entering the Seminary. I was lucky in having an excellent Spiritual Director. I think there are some excellent Religious Orders that are partly Apostolic, exercising your Priesthood in the world, but also partly contemplative, with a root in Contemplative prayer in the community, but this may not be what you;re looking for. I'll keep you in my prayers as you discern.

Posted

I think my problem is that I have trouble shutting up. I pray, but I have trouble listening. I don't have a problem with abandonment, with "Your will be done." I have trouble listening for God's will and discerning what is His voice and what is mine.

Blazer, I'm not sure I totally agree with your advice. There was a time when I would have said that I was not entirley attracted to the priesthood (part of me was, but part of me definitly wasn't). Yet here i am, waiting for them to get back to me on whether I've been accepted to the seminary.

under -

Your desires are things that you will have to deal with. As was stated, though there are a handful of modern hermitages, they are not entirely cut off, and you will have to deal with being around others. Lust and sexual desires are tough no matter what sexuality you are. Remember, when you are weak He is strong.

Posted

If you are going to enter the seminary it would help if you were doing it because you thought it would make you happy. If you don't think it will make you happy, why bother? I don't think its wise to pursue what you think will make you unhappy, even for the most noble reasons.

Something about the vocation has to be attractive to you. I'm not saying you have to feel all gung ho about the whole thing . . .felings are so susceptible to outside influence . . . but just like in a relationship, something about the other person has to be attractive to you .. . maybe there are parts that aren't attractive and you will come to love or accept them, but something has to attract you . . . otherwise, why bother?

Posted

I think we're just speaking past each other. I thought you were saying that God calls us to do things that we are completely and entirely attracted to (meaning no fear or hesitiation). Thanx for clearing it up.

Posted

willguy,

What diocese will you be studying for? I have a close friend studying for the Memphis, TN diocese at Franciscan Univ., and God willing, I'll be entering formation in a year and a half, after I finish up my degrees at MSU, for the Jackson, MS diocese.

Something that might help (cause it helped me) with discerning religious life vs. priesthood...the religious life vocation is first. If you are called to the religious life, that is your primary vocation, because when you join an order, you may or may not ever be a priest depending on what the order thinks is best for you. So, I think it's more of a calling to the religious life than to the religious life-priesthood. That's something our vocations director told us.

Also, seminary is itself a discernment process, so I wouldn't worry about not knowing 100% about your calling yet. You have embraced the initial calling, and you must be finding peace there or you would not have taken the steps you have. Follow God's call, and it comes to your ordination and you still feel that peace, you're in the right place. I think continued formation will continue to lead you down the path that the Holy Spirit has laid before you.

You and all who are discerning your vocations of all shapes and kinds are in my daily prayers!

Posted

St. Louis Archdiocese.

The way I see it, I have 8 (or maybe 9, I forget) years of school before becoming a priest. After 4, I transfer schools (from a college seminary to a theological school). I hope that at the end of the 4 years I will know which is best for me.

Posted

I think the most I have is 7.5 years (1.5 more at MSU, plus 1-2 years philosophy, plus 4 years theology).

Spiritual_Arsonist
Posted

There are many wonderful posts on this thread, many of which I can relate to.

I am discerning a vocation with the Archdiocese of Detroit, as I was just at the seminary for a few days this past weekend.

My discernment process has been quite the ride. It has taken me to the Fraternity of Saint Peter, The Legionaries of Christ, and the Trinitarians. Last but not least is my Archdiocese of Detroit.

At first I thought that the parish life was for me. After seeing my Archdiocese was not as healthy as it could be, I turned to religous orders. I discerned with them, and all have been truly wonderful. But the front for the battle is truly in the parish life. I could join the Leginaries or FSSP, and the parish, school, or other institution would be in perfect order. But I cannot bear the many parishes who suffer because no one is there to teach them the faith.

I had a lot of time last week to spend before the Blessed Sacrament at the Seminary. It was wonderful. A mental image came to mind as I sat before the Lord: the image of Christ with one hand outstretched, pointing towards my heart. So this is the point, that we know where God wants us when we know we can give all of our life to him, and our Hearts. We must give our Hearts to the Lord.

Theologian in Training
Posted

When I seriously discerned a very contemplative Franciscan order, I ultimately came to the same insight as DojoGrant. At first, I would have thought it was my own reservations in becoming a religious, but then when I entered the seminary, I learned of many who were religious and became diocesan. In my own opinion I believe that God is looking for more people that are comfortable with the contemplative life, but can live that life in the midst of the world, as it were, and as thus find God a lot easier. I think it is more than coincidence that four people of the 70 in this seminary were at one time a religious.

We must the face the fact that, like it or not, the parish life is suffering, and it is need of good and holy men. What happens if, in an effort to avoid the difficulties in a diocese, everyone runs to a religious order? What happens to the parish priest, does the identity of a parish priest cease to exist?

Think about it, the parish priest has the opportunity to touch many more lives, if it is God's will, because he is not limited to a certain place or religious order. Granted, he is to be a priest of his diocese, but that does not mean he cannot help out in other dioceses.

In most religious orders, it seems as though they are preaching to the choir, as it were. Everyone is there because they want to be, they know why they are there, and they love being there. In the parish life, this is sadly not the case. The challenge then, is to bring a foreign message to a confused and, oftentimes, ignorant congregation. Now, don't get me wrong, I am not trying to imply that everyone is completely ignorant, nor am I trying to imply that they aren't intelligent. Rather, I am trying to imply that a lot of people have been robbed of the proper teaching, understanding, and as thus love of Christ in His Church. This was incredibly evident when I taught RCIA and realized that these grown men and women had no clue what I was talking about, nor had ever heard of something as simple as the Theological Virtues.

We need religious, don't get me wrong, we need their prayers, their support, and their work, which is sometimes hidden and oftentimes very powerful. However, we also need people that aren't afraid to be in the midst of the world, on the frontlines, as it were. People are starving for God, and if we don't have enough parish priests to maintain those parishes, then another parish will close, and another generation may be lost.

I believe God is intentionally calling certain religious out of their orders to fulfill what has been lacking in the diocesan priesthood.

This is my humble opinion, but one that seems to make more sense, each and every day I see or hear of those leaving the religious order to become diocesan. In fact, at the sake of making this post even longer, I just met a guy the other day who was part of a religous order for a few years which was dissolved by the bishop and who now feels as though he may be being called to this diocese as a diocesan priest.

God Wills what He wants, it is not our job to completely figure out that Will, as much as it is to be obedient to it, IMHO.

God Bless

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...