Guest T-Bone Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 They are worshipers of the God of Abraham.
Era Might Posted October 17, 2006 Posted October 17, 2006 [quote]The Church regards with esteem also the Moslems. They adore the one God, living and subsisting in Himself; merciful and all- powerful, the Creator of heaven and earth, who has spoken to men; they take pains to submit wholeheartedly to even His inscrutable decrees, just as Abraham, with whom the faith of Islam takes pleasure in linking itself, submitted to God. Though they do not acknowledge Jesus as God, they revere Him as a prophet. They also honor Mary, His virgin Mother; at times they even call on her with devotion. In addition, they await the day of judgment when God will render their deserts to all those who have been raised up from the dead. Finally, they value the moral life and worship God especially through prayer, almsgiving and fasting. Since in the course of centuries not a few quarrels and hostilities have arisen between Christians and Moslems, this sacred synod urges all to forget the past and to work sincerely for mutual understanding and to preserve as well as to promote together for the benefit of all mankind social justice and moral welfare, as well as peace and freedom. --Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, "Nostra Aetate"[/quote]
scardella Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 (edited) through binoculars? Edited October 18, 2006 by scardella
toledo_jesus Posted October 18, 2006 Posted October 18, 2006 We give them respect and encourage dialogue, but we have to keep in mind that we're right and they're not.
Matty_boy Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 "Since in the course of centuries not a few quarrels and hostilities have arisen between Christians and Moslems, this sacred synod urges all to forget the past and to work sincerely for mutual understanding and to preserve as well as to promote together for the benefit of all mankind social justice and moral welfare, as well as peace and freedom. " It's kinda hard to forget the past when they seem to be expanding a worldwide campaign of violence and terror against non-believers. Pope Benedict XVI can't even seem to talk sense into them.
Aloysius Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 It may be considered by some to be splitting hairs, but I think it important that every document talking about the muslims describes what the muslims do: they direct their worship towards the God of Abraham. This does not necessitate one to believe that the Allah of Islam is the same as the God of Abraham; a Catholic may see that a God which is fueled by will and not reason is not at all the same as the God we understand. We know that on their initiative, they seek out the same God as us, send worship to the same God as us; but in their understanding of him he is nothing more than a pagan god which numbers one, they did not have the same radical monotheistic inversion in their religion that we had and their god is still in control of all reality in an arbitrary way; whereas our God is reason itself (not above reason, He IS the Logos, reason) Our attitude towards muslims is to help them come to know the God who they seek out but do not know and do not, necessarily, experience.
-I---Love Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 so i realize i am highjacking this thread i apologize in advance aloysius let me know if you got my pm to help me login to my svc email again i realize i totally wrongly highjacked this thread but i have reason to believe al will not check his pms respond asap by pm al thanks!
Era Might Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 [quote]We Christians joyfully recognize the religious values we have in common with Islam. Today I would like to repeat what I said to young Muslims some years ago in Casablanca: [b]"We believe in the same God, the one God, the living God, the God who created the world and brings his creatures to their perfection"[/b] (Insegnamenti, VIII/2, [1985], p. 497). The patrimony of revealed texts in the Bible speaks unanimously of the oneness of God. Jesus himself reaffirms it, making Israel's profession his own: "The Lord our God, the Lord is one" (Mk 12:29; cf. Dt 6:4-5). This oneness is also affirmed in the words of praise that spring from the heart of the Apostle Paul: "To the king of ages, immortal, invisible, the only God, be honour and glory for ever and ever. Amen'"(1 Tm 1:17). --Pope John Paul II [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP2MUSLM.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP2MUSLM.HTM[/url][/quote] When the Pope said "we believe in the same God", he meant "we believe in the same God".
Aloysius Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 There are many ways that could have been worded that would have troubled me. had he said "God gives us both faith in Him" my position would be troubled, or "God is pleased by both our worship" my position would be troubled, or even "we experience the same God", then my position would be troubled. but "we believe in the same God"... well of course, they believe in the God of Abraham and we believe in the God of Abraham. Two people could both believe in the great elephant... but one could actually possess the great elephant he believes in and the other might possess a statue of an elephant which they carved out and believe actually is the great elephant. though they both believe in the great elephant, only one of them experiences the actual great elephant; the others' great elephant is not the actual great elephant but they do believe in the actual great elephant.
Era Might Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 Ok, so we believe in the same God, and we address ourselves to the same God, but somehow one of us isn't actually talking to the same God. This is a breach of logic. If a) We believe in the same God, as Pope John Paul II says we do. And b) We both pray to the God we believe in, who is the same God, as Pope John Paul II says it is. Then c) We are worshipping and believing in the same God, as Pope John Paul II says we do. Pope John Paul II doesn't say we believe in the same revelation from this God, or we understand him quite the same, meaning we understand the same person, but we do not share all the facts about that person; in the same way two people could be standing talking to one person, but one of the two doesn't know that one person is a husband, thinking he's single. There is more to that man than what appears before the eye, but not knowing who he is fully doesn't detract from the fact that you are both talking to the same man, even though one of you knows he's married and one doesn't. What the Pope says is we believe in the same God, and we do. When a Muslim prays, he prays to the same God who spoke to Moses, as do we. Not an abstract concept, but the actual personal God.
Aloysius Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 The Pope says we believe in the same God, not that the Allah of Islam is the same as the God of Christianity. Like I said, it is important to note that all mention of muslims begins from the action of muslims, not from who God is. the action of the muslim to believe in or to send worship to the same God does not mean, necessarily, that they possess or experience the same God. But the god whom they have crafted to fill the role of who they are directing their worship and belief towards is not the true God.
Era Might Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 "The Allah of Islam" for those of you who don't speak Arabic translates "The God of Islam". The Pope says the God of Muslims and the God of Christians are the same. This means that "the God of Islam", that is, the God who is worshipped by Muslims, is the same "God of Christianity", that is, the God who is worshipped by Christians. Or, to put it plainly in the words of Pope John Paul II, Christians and Muslims worship the same God. If the God they direct their worship toward is not the same God Christians direct their worship toward, then that means we do not worship the same God. But Pope John Paul II says we do.
Guest St. Monica Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 [quote name='Catholictothecore' post='1094035' date='Oct 17 2006, 01:48 PM'] I really need to know. [/quote] I think it is important to realize that not all Muslims come from Arabic countries. It has been my experience that many, if not most, Asian Muslims are people who have positive feelings towards Christians. For example, in one particular Asian country which is about 85% Muslim, it is illegal for Muslims to marry Hindus because they do not share the same belief in one God; before marriage, one partner must convert to the other's religion. But Muslims are free to marry Christians because they feel both partners are worshipping the same God. My point is, we not only believe they worship our God, but they also believe we worship their God.
Aloysius Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 ahh yes.. the words of Era Might "The God of Islam is the same as the God of Chrisitanity" the words of the Pope "Christians and Muslims worship the same God" (which would be synonymous with direct their worship towards) these are not the same statements necessarily . draw your own conclusions, many say I am merely splitting hairs, but if the action is originating from the human beings it does not imply any substantial truth about that to which the action is being done.
Era Might Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 You're torturing what is plain, Aloysius. Christians and Muslims worship the same God. No need to dissect that with forced objections of "reason" and "will". We worship the same God. When a Muslim prays, he prays to the one, true God who reveals himself through conscience and reason (the first commandment is written on the human heart). It is not necessary to know what God has revealed through supernatural means to worship him, and neither does error about what he has revealed through supernatural means negate our worship of the personal God, who relates through reason that he is one, eternal, and almighty (see Romans 1), all of which Muslims acknowledge, in addition to their acknowledgement of his historical role as the God of Abraham. Christians and Muslims worship the same God. It's that simple. Honestly, it is. That's why Pope John Paul II said it. :
cmotherofpirl Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 Muslims worship God, but who they define as God is not the same as the God of Creation and Christianity. God worshipped by Christians is a God of reason, but their god is a god of will - whatever he wills is correct whether the action is rational or evil.
Era Might Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 The first commandment is "I am the Lord your God, you shall have no false Gods before me". St. Paul explains in Romans 1 that man can know by reason that God is one, that he is eternal, and that he is almighty. This is all that is necessary on a natural level for man to know the one, true God, creator of Heaven and Earth. Questions about whether reason is compatible with God are theological questions that are not essential to knowing the one, true God, who Muslims know, and who they worship along with us. The idea that non-essential theological questions about God affect whether we worship the one, true God is scary. What if a Catholic doesn't know that God possesses the ability to reason? Are they no longer praying to the one, true God, because they have made a theological error? Of course not, because it's not an essential point about who God is, that is, that he is one, eternal, and almighty, the creator of Heaven and Earth.
Aloysius Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 it is an essential truth about God: God is reason. It is in the prologue to the Gospel of St. John. anyway, as I have said and been vindicated by every quote you hurl at me: the Church documents about the muslims speak to the actions of the muslims, not to the substance of God. if two people believe in the same God, it does not say that substantially the one God is the same as the other, but merely that they send belief towards the same thing. human actions, be they belief or worship or attempted obedience, speak nothing about the substance towards which they are directed. I am perfectly in line with Church teaching to not affirm the God of Islam as substantially the same as the God of Christianity. there are some minor theological errors that come from the mistake as to whether God is reason or God is will, minor theological errors which may exist in Christians as well as muslims; but in an entire belief system based upon that theological error that God is will there are major, essential, radically important problems. It is a substantial problem, it deals with the very substance and nature of God within Himself and in His relationship to humanity; an entire system such as that of Islam has carved out for itself a god of will which is wholly and substantially different than the God who has been revealed to us. Yet we both send our belief and our worship towards the same God, and that's a good place to begin dialogue. There is an inherent substantial difference which is not just splitting hairs nor unnecessarily complicating things.
Catholictothecore Posted October 24, 2006 Author Posted October 24, 2006 Ok, forgive me for bumping this thread, but I have questions. Don't the muslims believe that if you don't believe in Allah, you shouldn't be allowed to live? I don't like the war right now, but isn't against the Muslim world? They seem to believe so. Bush can say anything he wants, but as long as they believe he is attacking what their religion is at core, they will be what they are. And what is the attitude we're supposed to have towards people who believe they are saints for flying airplanes into buildings? I mean, isn't that what their religion tells them to do?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now