veroni213 Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 [url="http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/10/19/foley.priest.ap/index.html"]http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/10/19/fol...t.ap/index.html[/url]
Ash Wednesday Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 Oh dear. Will this molestation crisis ever stop? Lord, have mercy on us.
Anomaly Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 Speaking of this sexual abuse thing, I've often heard that Vat-2 was the reason for this. Has anybody noticed that many, many of these abusers/molestors/inappropriate behaviors are from pre-Vat-2 priests? And did ALL the seminaries change overnight the month after Vat-2?
kamiller42 Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 These stories make me so sad. I ask in disbelief, "Another one?" Even though it's a very small percentage of all priests violating the trust of the cloth, it's enough to cause distrust between members of our Catholic family. Satan must be happy today. The press keep referring to him as "Rev." Please tell me he has been defrocked. He doesn't deserve title of "Reverend." His statements show no remorse.
LouisvilleFan Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 I think the abuse scandals are a sympton of the deeper reason Vatican II was necessary. I happened to see this month's U.S. Catholic at a friary I was visiting and it's a special issue on why young adults aren't in church. In all these stories of parents trying to get their grown-up kids back to church and those of young adults who have fallen away there is very little about having a relationship with God or experiencing the love of God. These parents think that twelve years of religious education is supposed to mean something and the people who have quit going feel like they can get along in life just fine without religion. Young people are leaving the church because they were never converted and their parents don't know how to draw them back because they aren't converted either.
thessalonian Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 I would say the misinterpretation and outright twisting of vatican II played a role in the crisis. This "spirit of vatican II" lead many away from proper understanding of the faith and exalted personal conscience such that man did not submit to the Churches teaching on morality anymore.
iKonstantin Posted October 19, 2006 Posted October 19, 2006 Er, if you read the article there was actually no abuse going on. The priest went to the theatre and the pool with the boy and went on camping trips with the youth group. However, it is a little odd that he gave him massages. That could be consider somewhat homosexual, whereas the rest could be male-bonding or even pastoral conditioning (although that might be a stretch). Besides the Sven Robinson in Canada wanted to lower the age of consent to 9 back in the 90's, and really can you argue with that? People are mature when they are nine. (Sorry, my attempts at sarcasm need more coffee. I am strictly against the lowering of the age of consent to anything below what it currently is here, which is 16.) bpat Konstantin
Ash Wednesday Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 (edited) I really don't think this has anything to do with Vatican II one way or another. Molestation usually occurs in a vicious cycle. Chances are the priests that molest were molested themselves, at the hands of someone molested, and so on. The only difference is, it just wasn't talked about in times past. Now it's just being brought to light because in one way, it's a good thing that people are being encouraged to be open about things. But it's also coupled with the media frenzy -- portraying this as if this sort of thing only happens within Catholicism. Perhaps it's meant to be a purifying and humbling process for the Church as a whole. I pray that something good may come of this. I feel somewhat torn, myself -- in that people in general have lost a sense of respect for authority figures, some of it justified. Admittedly I feel somewhat resentful towards a lot of higher figures in authority in the Church, such as our bishops and many others that are ambivalent towards the whole state of the Church in America today -- but in the end if there is no respect or obedience for authority, then chaos ensues. For example, I admire Father Altier for being so obedient despite what was doen to him in his criticism towards the bishop's sex ed program. It's all very ugly and depressing to watch and I pray that things change. The priest hasn't been defrocked, as I don't believe he has been convicted of anything yet, just accused. But it's all still very creepy. It makes my stomach turn to hear about yet another priest... and it makes me very sad. Again, may God have mercy on us. Edited October 20, 2006 by Ash Wednesday
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 why is this man a priest? he doesn't even understand what he did was wrong and disgusting!
Socrates Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1096325' date='Oct 19 2006, 07:13 PM'] I really don't think this has anything to do with Vatican II one way or another. Molestation usually occurs in a vicious cycle. Chances are the priests that molest were molested themselves, at the hands of someone molested, and so on. The only difference is, it just wasn't talked about in times past. Now it's just being brought to light because in one way, it's a good thing that people are being encouraged to be open about things. But it's also coupled with the media frenzy -- portraying this as if this sort of thing only happens within Catholicism. Perhaps it's meant to be a purifying and humbling process for the Church as a whole. I pray that something good may come of this. I feel somewhat torn, myself -- in that people in general have lost a sense of respect for authority figures, some of it justified. Admittedly I feel somewhat resentful towards a lot of higher figures in authority in the Church, such as our bishops and many others that are ambivalent towards the whole state of the Church in America today -- but in the end if there is no respect or obedience for authority, then chaos ensues. For example, I admire Father Altier for being so obedient despite what was doen to him in his criticism towards the bishop's sex ed program. It's all very ugly and depressing to watch and I pray that things change. The priest hasn't been defrocked, as I don't believe he has been convicted of anything yet, just accused. But it's all still very creepy. It makes my stomach turn to hear about yet another priest... and it makes me very sad. Again, may God have mercy on us. [/quote] It's not Vatican II nor any other Church Council. It is caused by a lack of holiness in the Church and among the clergy. And let's not play this "molesters were probably victims" thing. That has been shown to be a hoax, an excuse used by molesters to turn sympathy towards them - make them objects of pity rather than wrath and disgust.
Ash Wednesday Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Socrates' post='1096398' date='Oct 19 2006, 09:14 PM'] And let's not play this "molesters were probably victims" thing. That has been shown to be a hoax, an excuse used by molesters to turn sympathy towards them - make them objects of pity rather than wrath and disgust. [/quote] I wasn't asking anyone to sympathize with molesters. There comes a point in time where someone is accountable for their actions regardless of their background, and I never stated otherwise. I still stand by my belief that molestation like any other form of abuse often occurs in cycles (http://www.radkids.org/issues_our_children_face.html) so if it's a hoax I'm curious to hear what source this comes from. My point is, like sin in general, it's a problem that was there but people in their pride didn't acknowledge it in the past, and has nothing to do with the council of Vatican II. I speak not specifically about the church, I mean people in general. That's not to excuse it or say it hasn't gotten worse -- just because sin is capital in nature doesn't excuse it. Edited October 20, 2006 by Ash Wednesday
Winchester Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 (edited) Reality check. [quote]His comments came after the Florida newspaper published a story on Thursday that quoted him as saying in an interview that he had an inappropriate two-year relationship with Foley in the 1960s that included massaging the boy in the nude, but he did not specifically remember having sex.[/quote] Someone needs to tattoo the definition of scandal on this idiot's forehead. [quote]I have to confess, I was going through a nervous breakdown," the newspaper reported Mercieca as saying from his home on the island of Gozo, south of Italy. "I was taking pills -- tranquilizers. I used to take them all the time. They affected my mind a little bit."[/quote] I can hardly type because of the big tears I'm shedding for that poor stressed out priest. What a load. Predators are predators are predators. There's one defense against a ravening wolf. Edited October 20, 2006 by Lil Red
Lil Red Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1096325' date='Oct 19 2006, 06:13 PM']Perhaps it's meant to be a purifying and humbling process for the Church as a whole. I pray that something good may come of this. I feel somewhat torn, myself -- in that people in general have lost a sense of respect for authority figures, some of it justified. Admittedly I feel somewhat resentful towards a lot of higher figures in authority in the Church, such as our bishops and many others that are ambivalent towards the whole state of the Church in America today -- but in the end if there is no respect or obedience for authority, then chaos ensues. For example, I admire Father Altier for being so obedient despite what was doen to him in his criticism towards the bishop's sex ed program.[/quote]very well said. [quote name='Winchester' post='1096712' date='Oct 20 2006, 08:25 AM']There's one defense against a ravening wolf.[/quote]shoot them?
Ash Wednesday Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 (edited) If there is one thing in recent history that HAS greatly contributed to this crisis -- it's the dictatorship of relativism. It not only makes someone incapable or unwilling to account for their sins (such as this guy), but makes people around them ambivalent to what they are doing (bishops that move them around). Which makes me wonder what this priest is doing now and why -- I'd like to know why he is apparently living a cushy existance as a priest in southern Italy. Edited October 20, 2006 by Ash Wednesday
Anomaly Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 (edited) I heard an excerpt of the 'priests' interview on the radio today. The priest said he may of 'fondled' Foley, but doesn't remember having sex, or it happening more than once (or twice). What a load of crock! Meanwhile, people are wanting to slam Foley for e-mails with an 18 year old. No accusations against Foley for sex (yet). Slamming the the Republicans for not doing anything, but not slamming the press or other persons who knew Foley was flirting with the pages. People ignoring how the Dem [mod]Inappropriate language. - Era Might[/mod] was forgiven for having SEX with a 17 yo page just to jump on the Republican. It's all a twisted mess with people promoting or attacking different agendas solely for politcal gain. The catholics are 'protecting' the Church. The democrats are 'protecting the kids' when it comes to Foley, but the [mod]Watch the language. -Era Might[/mod] with the kids when it comes to the Dem (who died a few weeks ago) that did the same thing. The republicans don't know whether to [mod]Watch the language. -Era Might[/mod] or go blind. They kick Foley out, but should they without alienating the 'tolerant'? They were mad at the dems, but do they stand up for traditional families? Who's got a clear answer and consistent behavior? Anyone? Anyone? Anyone? Edited October 21, 2006 by Era Might
Socrates Posted October 21, 2006 Posted October 21, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Anomaly' post='1097035' date='Oct 20 2006, 03:21 PM'] I heard an excerpt of the 'priests' interview on the radio today. The priest said he may of 'fondled' Foley, but doesn't remember having sex, or it happening more than once (or twice). What a load of crock! Meanwhile, people are wanting to slam Foley for e-mails with an 18 year old. No accusations against Foley for sex (yet). Slamming the the Republicans for not doing anything, but not slamming the press or other persons who knew Foley was flirting with the pages. People ignoring how the Dem [mod]Inappropriate language. - Era Might[/mod] was forgiven for having SEX with a 17 yo page just to jump on the Republican. It's all a twisted mess with people promoting or attacking different agendas solely for politcal gain. The catholics are 'protecting' the Church. The democrats are 'protecting the kids' when it comes to Foley, but the [mod]Watch the language. -Era Might[/mod] with the kids when it comes to the Dem (who died a few weeks ago) that did the same thing. The republicans don't know whether to [mod]Watch the language. -Era Might[/mod] or go blind. They kick Foley out, but should they without alienating the 'tolerant'? They were mad at the dems, but do they stand up for traditional families? Who's got a clear answer and consistent behavior? Anyone? Anyone? Anyone? [/quote] And I'd bet everything in the bank that if [mod]Inappropriate language. -Era Might[/mod] Foley had been a [i]Democrat[/i], the media would be hailing him as a holy martyr! But since he's a Republican, this shameful debacle is gleefully reported as showing how evil the whole Republican party is! Remember that "I am a Gay-American!" Dem ex-gov of New Jersey? The hypocritical double-standard in the liberal media is sickening. Homosexuality is always a wonderful and beautiful thing so long as those engaging in it are not Catholic priests or Republicans! Edited October 21, 2006 by Era Might
Anomaly Posted October 21, 2006 Posted October 21, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='1097310' date='Oct 20 2006, 08:36 PM'] And I'd bet everything in the bank that if [mod]Inappropriate language. -Era Might[/mod] Foley had been a [i]Democrat[/i], the media would be hailing him as a holy martyr! But since he's a Republican, this shameful debacle is gleefully reported as showing how evil the whole Republican party is! Remember that "I am a Gay-American!" Dem ex-gov of New Jersey? The hypocritical double-standard in the liberal media is sickening. Homosexuality is always a wonderful and beautiful thing so long as those engaging in it are not Catholic priests or Republicans! [/quote]Nah. The Republicans wouldn't have a problem with [mod]Inappropriate language. -Era Might[/mod] if they could keep it out of the paper. [mod]Polemical criticism of the Bishops. -Era Might[/mod]
Socrates Posted October 21, 2006 Posted October 21, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1097343' date='Oct 20 2006, 09:24 PM'] Nah. The Republicans wouldn't have a problem with [mod]Inappropriate language. -Era Might[/mod] if they could keep it out of the paper. [mod]Vitriolic criticism of the Bishops. -Era Might[/mod] [/quote]Yeah, but the papers don't have a problem with them if they're Dems. - that's my point.
Era Might Posted October 21, 2006 Posted October 21, 2006 There would be Republicans exploiting this too if Foley were a Democrat. The donkeys didn't just invent scandal mongering.
Anomaly Posted October 21, 2006 Posted October 21, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1097359' date='Oct 20 2006, 08:48 PM'] There would be Republicans exploiting this too if Foley were a Democrat. The donkeys didn't just invent scandal mongering. [/quote][mod]Contact me privately if you have a problem with my moderating. - Era Might[/mod] Calling people 'donkeys' is a perjurative too. [mod]Contact me privately if you have a problem with my moderating. - Era Might[/mod] But since you're so young, you don't know about the Dem who actually had sex with a minor page a number of years ago. He got a standing ovation from the Dems for standing up as a Gay American.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now