Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

does the USCCB know about the fundraisers that the Saw people do?
the blood drive, selling the posters and all proceeds goes to the Red Cross?
i mean even though it is a "bad" movie.....there is still some good coming out of it.

Posted

Some people would say that the ends don't justify the means.

Posted

It is better to go to heaven then to watch "Saw." It is barbaric and it desensitizes you to real violence. If you cannot see that I truly feel sorry for you. Whatever else good the movie does it does negate the fact the movie it self is morally repugnant. It matters not how well the film is put together, it is morally repugnant.

PVmelonhead91
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='1099316' date='Oct 23 2006, 04:55 PM']
It is better to go to heaven then to watch "Saw." It is barbaric and it desensitizes you to real violence. If you cannot see that I truly feel sorry for you. Whatever else good the movie does it does negate the fact the movie it self is morally repugnant. It matters not how well the film is put together, it is morally repugnant.
[/quote]


ok first of all your not gonna go to hell for watching saw. second lord of the rings and star wars are more violent then saw. so if anything it would desensitize you from gore. but there are movies out tehre that have alot more gore in it, and its not gore for the sake of gore, like heads getting shopped off by a lawn mower. and its not like its encourageing people to go and cut off tehre legs.

PVmelonhead91
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='1099316' date='Oct 23 2006, 04:55 PM']
It is better to go to heaven then to watch "Saw." It is barbaric and it desensitizes you to real violence. If you cannot see that I truly feel sorry for you. Whatever else good the movie does it does negate the fact the movie it self is morally repugnant. It matters not how well the film is put together, it is morally repugnant.
[/quote]

Ok look I agree with PV, that first line of your paragraph is just bad. Sorry. And secondly, have you ever watched any type of war movie? Have you watched 'The Patriot'? Have you watched 'Braveheart'? Howbout 'Silence of the Lambs'? Or 'Seven'? Have you seen anything with violence? I think it's silly how you're sitting here telling me how I shouldn't be watching it and how it's bad because some website says it is. Or how I'm gonna go to hell cuz I watch it.

Posted

[quote name='PVmelonhead91' post='1099473' date='Oct 23 2006, 09:02 PM']
[b]Ok look I agree with PV[/b], that first line of your paragraph is just bad. Sorry. And secondly, have you ever watched any type of war movie? Have you watched 'The Patriot'? Have you watched 'Braveheart'? Howbout 'Silence of the Lambs'? Or 'Seven'? Have you seen anything with violence? I think it's silly how you're sitting here telling me how I shouldn't be watching it and how it's bad because some website says it is. Or how I'm gonna go to hell cuz I watch it.
[/quote]
Well I'm glad you agree with yourself, its a start :lol:

Posted

[quote name='PVmelonhead91' post='1099473' date='Oct 23 2006, 10:02 PM']
Ok look I agree with PV, that first line of your paragraph is just bad. Sorry. And secondly, have you ever watched any type of war movie? Have you watched 'The Patriot'? Have you watched 'Braveheart'? Howbout 'Silence of the Lambs'? Or 'Seven'? Have you seen anything with violence? I think it's silly how you're sitting here telling me how I shouldn't be watching it and how it's bad because some website says it is. Or how I'm gonna go to hell cuz I watch it.
[/quote]


Ok I wrote all of that.

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1099476' date='Oct 23 2006, 10:04 PM']
Well I'm glad you agree with yourself, its a start :lol:
[/quote]

I didn't check to see if I was still signed in. lol. I forgot my brother signed on while I was at work :blush:

Posted

[quote name='onathing1' post='1098926' date='Oct 23 2006, 10:07 AM']
Well that definately stinks. Sounds like the USCCB is a fun sucker. And if they rate Saw like they did, which I did not find offensive at all, then it definatley stinks for people who go by those ratings and they're gonna miss out on some amazing movies.
[/quote]
Simply because the USCCB is wrong on some movies does not preclude the fact that they can be right on others

[quote name='Theoketos' post='1099316' date='Oct 23 2006, 05:55 PM']
It is better to go to heaven then to watch "Saw."
[/quote]
True, but I don't think its either or
[quote name='Theoketos' post='1099316' date='Oct 23 2006, 05:55 PM']It is barbaric and it desensitizes you to real violence. If you cannot see that I truly feel sorry for you.[/quote]
True
[quote name='Theoketos' post='1099316' date='Oct 23 2006, 05:55 PM']Whatever else good the movie does it does negate the fact the movie it self is morally repugnant. It matters not how well the film is put together, it is morally repugnant.[/quote]
True

[quote name='PVmelonhead91' post='1099473' date='Oct 23 2006, 09:02 PM']
Ok look I agree with PV, that first line of your paragraph is just bad. Sorry. And secondly, have you ever watched any type of war movie? Have you watched 'The Patriot'? Have you watched 'Braveheart'? Howbout 'Silence of the Lambs'? Or 'Seven'? Have you seen anything with violence? I think it's silly how you're sitting here telling me how I shouldn't be watching it and how it's bad because some website says it is. Or how I'm gonna go to hell cuz I watch it.
[/quote]
Just because a movie is a war movie doesn't mean it needs to be filled with gratuitous violence. The Patriot and Braveheart both have violence, but it is fairly brief, before it cuts to another scene. Saw keeps close to the "action." For example, where the man is in the furnace burning alive, the scene just seems to never end. Or when the girl is thrown in the pit of hypodermic needles and she comes out looking like a pincushion. Or the man cutting or the flesh of his own neck, or when the guy has to cut out his eye, or the girl has to cut open an alive person, or a dozen other times that are just flat out disturbing and I would probably be edited if I listed them (if i don't get edited already). The sick sadistic Jigsaw is portrayed as a genius and a philosopher of sorts all while playing God with the lives of people that he finds disgusting. I can say that that was the one movie that I have seen in my life that I just wanted to end. I walked out of that movie totally deadened, and believe me, if anyone can say they are numbed to violence, I can. The Saw series has taken it to another level, and if the previews mean anything, the 3rd looks to be the worst of the trilogy.

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1099536' date='Oct 23 2006, 11:18 PM']
Simply because the USCCB is wrong on some movies does not preclude the fact that they can be right on others
True, but I don't think its either or

True

True
Just because a movie is a war movie doesn't mean it needs to be filled with gratuitous . The Patriot and Braveheart both have , but it is fairly brief, before it cuts to another scene. Saw keeps close to the "action." For example, where the man is in the furnace burning alive, the scene just seems to never end. Or when the is thrown in the pit of hypodermic needles and she comes out looking like a pincushion. Or the man cutting or the flesh of his own neck, or when the guy has to cut out his eye, or the has to cut open an alive person, or a dozen other times that are just flat out disturbing and I would probably be edited if I listed them (if i don't get edited already). The sick ic Jigsaw is portrayed as a genius and a philosopher of sorts all while playing God with the lives of people that he finds disgusting. I can say that that was the one movie that I have seen in my life that I just wanted to end. I walked out of that movie totally ened, and believe me, if anyone can say they are numbed to , I can. The Saw series has taken it to another level, and if the previews mean anything, the 3rd looks to be the worst of the trilogy.
[/quote]


Well I think that there is a point deeper than just people off for the sake of and gore I think the point it to show you that when you take someone elses life into your own hands it gets messy and that you shouldn't be worried about others who descust you. For by looking at these people with hatred you are therefore commiting a sin your own self. Just remember guys that everything points to God even things that are sick and twisted and it is our Job as Chrisitan to finds things that point to God in things that are popular and point them out to people who do not have the eyes we have. Another thing do u think that they didn't show all of the voilence when Jesus was dying at the cross how then would you appreciate what he did for you....

Posted

I don't think anyone can show how much Jesus suffered. But even if they did, it would be entirely different...He did so out of love, but Saw is a movie based upon hatred. Jigsaw hates these people because he got screwed out of a full life so he is going to return the favor to others.

As for pointing out good in popular things, no christian goes to a porno so he can point out the good in it :lol:

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1099536' date='Oct 23 2006, 11:18 PM']
Just because a movie is a war movie doesn't mean it needs to be filled with gratuitous violence. The Patriot and Braveheart both have violence, but it is fairly brief, before it cuts to another scene. Saw keeps close to the "action." For example, where the man is in the furnace burning alive, the scene just seems to never end. Or when the girl is thrown in the pit of hypodermic needles and she comes out looking like a pincushion. Or the man cutting or the flesh of his own neck, or when the guy has to cut out his eye, or the girl has to cut open an alive person, or a dozen other times that are just flat out disturbing and I would probably be edited if I listed them (if i don't get edited already). The sick sadistic Jigsaw is portrayed as a genius and a philosopher of sorts all while playing God with the lives of people that he finds disgusting. I can say that that was the one movie that I have seen in my life that I just wanted to end. I walked out of that movie totally deadened, and believe me, if anyone can say they are numbed to violence, I can. The Saw series has taken it to another level, and if the previews mean anything, the 3rd looks to be the worst of the trilogy.
[/quote]

Have you seen the Patriot and Braveheart uncut? In the Patriot when the church burns with the people in it? In Braveheart where he kills the man that's in his bed? I believe that the way this movie affects people and the take that they have on it is way different. All I did by posting this was hope to find other people who were excited about the movie as well. Not start any type of argument and I feel awful for even instigating it with Theoketos. However, I still think that these movies were well done and just all around good movies.

Posted

I have indeed seen both Patriot and Braveheart uncut. I would still say saw is on an entire different level. Like I said before, both those movies with Mel the violence is much more fleeting and the [i]tone[/i] is entirely different. In saw it is about misery, suffering, despair. in the gibson movies it is about hope and redemption.

The church scene in the Patriot: It shows the people scream in fright because of their impending doom.
The furnace scene in saw: We see the man in the furnace burning alive and here him scream in agony for God knows how long. If the church sscene in the patriot had actually shown some people on fire, in pain, and dying then it would have been comparable.

The same goes for Wallace killing the noble in his bed. It was fleeting violence, unlike in saw 2 where we get to see a man have a bullet through the head then get some close ups on it. and have him lying there for a significant portion of time

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1099595' date='Oct 24 2006, 12:04 AM']
I have indeed seen both Patriot and Braveheart uncut. I would still say saw is on an entire different level. Like I said before, both those movies with Mel the violence is much more fleeting and the [i]tone[/i] is entirely different. In saw it is about misery, suffering, despair. in the gibson movies it is about hope and redemption.

The church scene in the Patriot: It shows the people scream in fright because of their impending doom.
The furnace scene in saw: We see the man in the furnace burning alive and here him scream in agony for God knows how long. If the church sscene in the patriot had actually shown some people on fire, in pain, and dying then it would have been comparable.

The same goes for Wallace killing the noble in his bed. It was fleeting violence, unlike in saw 2 where we get to see a man have a bullet through the head then get some close ups on it. and have him lying there for a significant portion of time
[/quote]

I personally think that the two scenes in Mel's movies were more disturbing for me then anything in Saw. So like I said, it just affects people in different ways. And if you disliked Saw so much why did you see Saw 2? Not that it matters cuz like I said before, I didn't start this topic to create arguments so you don't even have to reply to that question.

Posted

I saw Saw II before Saw I. I saw the 1st one on a recommendation from someone with whom I share taste in movies (most of the time). Needless to say I did not enjoy it. Anyhow I hope you don't take anything I've said in the wrong way, I don't mean to be argumentative over this

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1099741' date='Oct 24 2006, 03:40 AM']
I saw Saw II before Saw I. I saw the 1st one on a recommendation from someone with whom I share taste in movies (most of the time). Needless to say I did not enjoy it. Anyhow I hope you don't take anything I've said in the wrong way, I don't mean to be argumentative over this
[/quote]

HAhah yea right.........

PVmelonhead91
Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1099536' date='Oct 23 2006, 09:18 PM']

Just because a movie is a war movie doesn't mean it needs to be filled with gratuitous violence. The Patriot and Braveheart both have violence, but it is fairly brief, before it cuts to another scene. Saw keeps close to the "action." For example, where the man is in the furnace burning alive, the scene just seems to never end. Or when the girl is thrown in the pit of hypodermic needles and she comes out looking like a pincushion. Or the man cutting or the flesh of his own neck, or when the guy has to cut out his eye, or the girl has to cut open an alive person, or a dozen other times that are just flat out disturbing and I would probably be edited if I listed them (if i don't get edited already). The sick sadistic Jigsaw is portrayed as a genius and a philosopher of sorts all while playing God with the lives of people that he finds disgusting. I can say that that was the one movie that I have seen in my life that I just wanted to end. I walked out of that movie totally deadened, and believe me, if anyone can say they are numbed to violence, I can. The Saw series has taken it to another level, and if the previews mean anything, the 3rd looks to be the worst of the trilogy.
[/quote]

what about when mel gibson chops the soldiers up after they killed his son? i know saw is violent and gorey but so is that. they show the guy getting an ax to the forehead...close up. and hess got blood all over him after that.

Posted

[size=1]I will never go see it.
I hate scarry movies.
Never never never
[/size]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...