Joey1976 Posted October 20, 2006 Posted October 20, 2006 I have always heard that Jesus and Mary who are in Heaven are sad when we sin. If they are in Heaven how can they be sad since Heaven is perfect and sadness doesn't exist there? Also, if they are sad when we sin, wouldn't they be sad all the time considering the state of the world and how much people sin and defame our Lord?
cathoholic_anonymous Posted November 2, 2006 Posted November 2, 2006 I've often wondered the same thing, but was able to get a good answer from people at my church. Heaven stands outside time, so Our Lord and the souls in the Beatific Vision are able to see everything that was, that is, and that is to come - all the sorrows and the joys and the triumphs, stretching out in a glorious vista and finally culminating in the resolution of God's plans for us. Remember that during Communion at Mass we are spiritually transported to Calvary itself; the moment when Jesus knew every sin and anguish in the world. In short, Jesus and Mary do feel sorrow for our sins, but their sorrow isn't the two-dimensional, primitive 'sadness' that we have on earth - their vision is too wide for that. All we have to do is look at the paradox of the Beatitudes to understand that tears on earth may equal rejoicing in Heaven.
thessalonian Posted November 2, 2006 Posted November 2, 2006 This is a difficult question. I guess I've never seen a statement "jesus and mary are crying in heaven". I have never heard of an apparition of a weeping Mary or Jesus. I have heard of statues weeping and this puts the context of the question in to the physical realm. Jesus himself wept when he walked this earth. The statues are in the physical and so if tears are coming from them then that is not Jesus or Mary weeping in heaven. If you have a statement somewhere that says the weep in heaven I would like to see it.
jmj Posted November 2, 2006 Posted November 2, 2006 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1108535' date='Nov 2 2006, 06:31 AM'] I've often wondered the same thing, but was able to get a good answer from people at my church. Heaven stands outside time, so Our Lord and the souls in the Beatific Vision are able to see everything that was, that is, and that is to come - all the sorrows and the joys and the triumphs, stretching out in a glorious vista and finally culminating in the resolution of God's plans for us. Remember that during Communion at Mass we are spiritually transported to Calvary itself; the moment when Jesus knew every sin and anguish in the world. In short, Jesus and Mary do feel sorrow for our sins, but their sorrow isn't the two-dimensional, primitive 'sadness' that we have on earth - their vision is too wide for that. All we have to do is look at the paradox of the Beatitudes to understand that tears on earth may equal rejoicing in Heaven. [/quote] I've also been thinking about this -- would this response also be equatable for anger? Like if someone says God is angry when you sin? Or is that a whole different concept?
Era Might Posted November 2, 2006 Posted November 2, 2006 It's a symbol of the perfect love for God that they have, and how serious it is in their eyes for us to offend God who they know face to face. Crying represents sorrow on earth, and so when applied to a Saint, it represents the sorrow of some particular object, such as sin. In the same way, Mary doesn't have a literal sword going through her Immaculate Heart and Jesus doesn't have literal thorns around his Sacred Heart, even though they are often depicted that way. These are symbols for something important.
beatty07 Posted November 3, 2006 Posted November 3, 2006 It also has meaning with regard to the earthly lives of Christ and His Mother. Christ's Passion did incorporate every human sin, including any we might commit this morning. So in that sense, our sins quite literally cause Him to weep. His Blessed Mother, of course, shares in that sorrow quite perfectly. That being said, it is important to hold up the analogy of faith regarding the emotions of the Blessed in Heaven. Mary's earthly sorrows are part of who she is, even part of her great glory in Heaven... but we probably shouldn't try to imagine what it "feels like" in Heaven. "Every tear shall be wiped away."
Joey1976 Posted November 3, 2006 Author Posted November 3, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1108667' date='Nov 2 2006, 11:30 AM'] This is a difficult question. I guess I've never seen a statement "jesus and mary are crying in heaven". I have never heard of an apparition of a weeping Mary or Jesus. I have heard of statues weeping and this puts the context of the question in to the physical realm. Jesus himself wept when he walked this earth. The statues are in the physical and so if tears are coming from them then that is not Jesus or Mary weeping in heaven. If you have a statement somewhere that says the weep in heaven I would like to see it. [/quote] I never mentioned in my question them crying in heaven. I said that they are sad. ???? I don't know where you got the crying part?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now