JamesTheYounger Posted October 21, 2006 Posted October 21, 2006 (edited) I didn't realise just how much opposition the Church faces. Today I was talking to my neighbour who is a Uniting Church/Methodist minister the topic turned to religion and he told me that there is no doctrinal unity within the Church, that there are conservative Catholics, middle of the road catholics and liberal catholics of course I denied it. But what frightened me is that he told me he has a Jesuit friend with whom he concelebrated Mass/Communion service and he goes to a retreat centre run by Josephite sisters (an Australian religious order, founded by Australia's first Beatified person) where the sisters think that the Holy Father is an idiot for not permitting female ordination. I wanted to tell him that these people are not really Catholic if they do not believe in the true presence of Christ's body, blood, soul and divinity in the Eucharist and do not respect the authority of the Pope. Unorthodox religious like those, to me, seem worse than schismatics who continue to uphold Marian devotion, the seven sacraments and the real presence. It's no wonder these two orders are dying out, and I suppose that is what liberal Catholicism is designed to do. I find it really frustrating that these religious, in this age of technology and information, have all the means at their disposal to find out the truth and I cant understand why any Catholic, let alone one practicing celibacy, would want to reject something so beautiful as transubstantiation. Are these errors really that common amongst religious? I always assumed that it was only the misinformed laity who could possibly support such errors and that it was surely evil for religious to do so. Edited October 21, 2006 by JamesTheYounger
jswranch Posted October 21, 2006 Posted October 21, 2006 It is one thing to disagree with what the Catholic Church teaches about the Christian faith. It is another to disagree on how we should carry out and live that faith in music, teaching, liturgy etc. Now who is the human representative and leader of the Catholic Fatih? The Pope. (Hold up a CCC) Whose signature is in the front cover of the CCC? The Pope. If someone disagrees with what the CCC says, are they not professing a faith contrary to the declarations of the Catholic faith? Now as for dissent, it does exist as you mentioned. So what? Dissent occured in biblical times. You can either agree with the Bishop of Rome and the bishops in full comunion with him or you can go start your own church. For those Catholic yet still Catholic dessenting, the church is working with them to either change their minds or to control the spread. The dissent you mentioned does occasionally occur. It is being cleaned up. Dont worry, those folks are in decline and are the last of their kind. Their teachings will not pass to the next generation. For the most part, when they die, their errors will die with them. The seminaries are correcting this problem with the priest in training.
XIX Posted October 22, 2006 Posted October 22, 2006 [quote name='JamesTheYounger' post='1097480' date='Oct 21 2006, 01:43 AM'] Unorthodox religious like those, to me, seem worse than schismatics who continue to uphold Marian devotion, the seven sacraments and the real presence. [/quote] Agree.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 23, 2006 Posted October 23, 2006 The difference between a Catholic dissident and a Methodist dissident is that if a Catholic rejects doctrines, we say that that rejection reflects a lack of conformity to the Church, thus, the person is lacking in Catholicity to that degree and their binding to the Church is looser, but when a Methodist rejects Methodist doctrines, he is only considered a Methodist with a different opinion of Methodism. Against what this minister seems to think, a Catholic dissident cannot be a Catholic insofar as he is a dissident, but his being a dissident is what makes him lack the being of a Catholic. This is because authority does not lie with the individual in Catholicism...his opinions are not to be taken as representative of Catholicism when they disagree with the Magisterium, but as lacking in Catholicism, and therefore, the Magisterium alone, as a whole, can be considered the normative representative of Catholic doctrine.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now