Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted October 22, 2006 Posted October 22, 2006 [quote]Also, in the early Church, bishops allowed penances, which were oftentimes severe, to be substituted with other works (indulgences), which may have been easier to fulfill but which promoted piety and strengthened the person spiritually. Eventually, popes decreed that certain practices could replace imposed penances. [/quote] this is from a catholic site. I thought indulgences took away temporal punishment due to sin. This seems to say the took the place of severe penances. can someone explain this to me? thanks! Sam
Fidei Defensor Posted October 22, 2006 Posted October 22, 2006 I think it could possibly be refering to the change of how penances were dealt with. In the past, they used to be quite severe, usually to fit the sin, and were not necessarily spiritual acts. Notice how it says "substituted with other works (indulgences) which may have been easier to fulfill but which promoted piety and strengthened the person spiritually". It is refering to the lessing of severity of penances. I'm not exactly sure why they would include "indulgences" with that. Possibly, to show how penances are indeed a form of indulgence, because they are in place of our temporal punishment. So, instead of being punished like we deserve, we do a simple act of piety as penance, and gain remission of our temporal punishment. Or, perhaps, I am just crazy. But what they are trying to say is a little bit confusing.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 23, 2006 Posted October 23, 2006 Penances take away temporal punishment due to sin. It's basically saying that one penance came to replace another, which is true, since, in the early Church, a typical penance was to go on a pilgrimage (keep in mind that Confession was only offered once in a lifetime then, so the penance was big, but you only made one penance).
Resurrexi Posted October 24, 2006 Posted October 24, 2006 Why would you day Penance was only offered once per lifetime?
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted October 24, 2006 Author Posted October 24, 2006 it was made at the end of your life maybe?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now