Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

  

31 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I just recently joined the Knights, and I thought that this would be a good idea. I'm not sure whether to have it open to all men here on Phatmass or just those who are Knights. In the case of the latter, I'm not sure how exactly to verify the claims of someone who says that they are a Knight.

Any thoughts or suggestions?

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

I say leave it open... that way men who may be interested in joining the Knights can see what it's all about, and women who are related to, married to, or friends with Knights will probably also have valuable input and opinions to add.

Posted

I agree to leave it open. This will show there are no dark secrets or anything along those lines.

Posted

We really have no secrets. Keep it open.

Theologian in Training
Posted

But one of our rules is not to say everything about certain things. Perhaps, it is not seen as keeping a secret as much as it is as keeping the integrity of the organization in tact. Granted, we are not the Masons, but there is a level of "secrecy" that must be maintained.

Just my .02

Posted

Well, regarding secrecy, we as Knights have an obligation to ensure that we don't discuss that which are bound to discuss only with those we are sure are brothers in good standing in the order.

Not too difficult a task.

I think a place to discuss the KofC on phatmass is a great idea. Who knows, maybe we can gather some more brothers into the fold.

Posted

discussing KofC issues is one thing as well as the secrets are another. We are all adults in the KofC and we can learn from each other to help each other help others. For me, I am looking for info on the columbian squires. I am looking to start them uop at my council and would like info on them.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

If there is a phorum for one Catholic group, would it not follow that a lot of other groups will want one for themselves as well? What about Opus Dei? Legion of Mary? I don't mean to be a stick in the mud but it doesn't really seem like phatmass to cater to just one group in the Church.

And the security reasons mentioned (verifying someone's Knighthood) are reason enough to leave it open if there is such a phorum. If there are secret things discussed with KofC then they probably shouldn't be discussed online. As most people know there have been problems with satanists spamming the board recently and the internet is full of imposters and hackers, so I don't really think that having a "private" board would be such a good idea.

Posted

I agree with Ash on all counts. Great though the KofC is, it just seemse like it would be odd to have a phorum specifically for one organization. And I think it's pretty pointless to have a closed phorum. I still remember the NFP phorum, and how contentious it got because people assumed it was secure ... but you really can't assume any sort of security online.

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1099903' date='Oct 24 2006, 09:20 AM']If there is a phorum for one Catholic group, would it not follow that a lot of other groups will want one for themselves as well? What about Opus Dei? Legion of Mary? I don't mean to be a stick in the mud but it doesn't really seem like phatmass to cater to just one group in the Church. [/quote]agreed

Posted

Secrets in the KofC? :blink:

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1099942' date='Oct 24 2006, 01:05 PM']
Secrets in the KofC? :blink:
[/quote]
I'm gonna write a book!

Posted

how bout a big phorum sectoin for various groups, and have other subforums for other groups, along with KoC?

Posted

Having a big group for threads based on groups is a great idea. Have it titled something like (just an example) Religious orginizations and have the KofC, Legion of Mary, Opis Dei and Daughters of Isabela to list a few. Not keep it secret but an easier way to find Religious Group info. It would be up to the members of the group to keep anything secret OFF the site. Being a knight I would not discuss things I know I can not discuss (no secrets of course). smiles

Posted

[quote name='Franimus' post='1099963' date='Oct 24 2006, 12:21 PM']
how bout a big phorum sectoin for various groups, and have other subforums for other groups, along with KoC?
[/quote]

I like this idea. That way, Phatmass isn't catering to one Catholic organization. The more I thought about it, the more the whole verification idea didn't seem plausible.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

If dUSt agrees to it then cool, but I think the idea of the board being private "members only" is a bad idea. If such a thing were put into place it should be something where members could chat about what they do, and where those interested can learn more.

Posted (edited)

just got my first degree last Thursday!

And as far as secrecy issues, I am not sure a private board is workable, so I would think that all Knight business should be left off the Net.

Edited by toledo_jesus
Posted (edited)

Any matters regarding the KofC which are normally discussed privately in a local council meeting, should not be brought to Phatmass. Simply because administrators/moderators who are not part of the Brotherhood, or those simply who may have skills in obtaining access to restricted areas (i.e. hacking), could be exposed to such discussions.

I don't find it a bad idea to have some sort of section for the KofC to openly discuss about the organization to non-members, or talk about public-sponsored KofC events. However, we would also have to give the same treatment to other Catholic organizations, by giving them their own section. The best thing to do in my opinion (which some have already suggested), is create one section for ALL organizations, and create a separate thread for each one.



[size=6][b]Most importantly:[/b][/size]

If we are to run with this idea, we should have at least 2 or 3 moderators to oversee this section, who are part of these organizations. Because how would a non-KofC moderator discern what specifics of a discussion fall under the vow of secrecy?

But overall, I think it would be pretty awesome to have a place where fellow Brothers can talk about the KofC, and what each of our councils has done.




[b]Note:[/b] I'm getting my 4th Degree this Saturday, pray that I do well!

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1100626' date='Oct 25 2006, 01:43 AM']
just got my first degree last Thursday!

And as far as secrecy issues, I am not sure a private board is workable, so I would think that all Knight business should be left off the Net.
[/quote]

Welcome to the Brotherhood! :cool:

Edited by Paladin D
Posted

Maybe someone can explain this to me: what the heck is a knight of Columbus? Why a knight, and why Columbus? And why a knight OF Columbus? Is "Columbus" THE "Columbus", as in Christopher Columbus?

Am I asking too many secret questions?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...