Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Alright, well I tried this in the questions phorum, but I haven't gotten an answer yet and I'm really impatient... So I'll try it here. (Please, if someone was working on finidng or writing an answer over there, post it there, and take this thread down if necessary)

I know one of the "prerequisites" for a mortal sin is knowledge that it is a mortal sin... What if someone is doing stuff and knows its not that good, but doesn't think its THAT bad, what might happen to them??

Ok, the thing is, someone I know hasn't been to church in a long time I think, she has lived with her boyfriend for over a year and they got engaged this summer. And along with living together, I'm sure, comes the use of birth control. I don't know if she knows the Church considers these mortal sins although she knows it doesn't approve. Obviously she doesn't believe she is in mortal sin. I really love her and I'm am worried for her, I don't know what to do!

What do you think?

Hope that all made sense...
Thanks,
~Katie

Posted

First you need to break down the following terms:

Grave matter- doing something really bad

Full Knowledge- Knowing what you are doing is really bad (grave matter). Someone can 'know' these by the power of the conscience alone.

Total Consent- Having the ability to choose (not being drunk, or forced against will)

Mortal Sin- Only when all three of the above are in place.


You should check the Catechism for a complete deffinition. Ultimately only God and the offender knows if one is in Mortal Sin.

I recommend you get some CDs or tapes for her to learn. Another option would be for the two of you to sit down with a priest.

Posted

As JS says it must be grave matter, full knowledge and consent to be mortal. All three issues are of course grave matters. We cannot judge knowledge and will and leave that to God to judge. One person might have had full knowledge and will against something and gone against it and be in mortal sin. Their conscience later becoming seered and their will bent. Another may not have known better in the first place, though for all we have God's laws implanted in our hearts (rom 2:14-16) so we bear some guilt.

You should try to gently speak to her but don't get in to an arguement. As far as contraception, Janet Smith's tape "Contraception, Why Not" is excellent and should be available on the net if you do a search on Google.com or Ask.com.

Posted

Oh yes, and PRAY! She could well be in a state of mortal sin and we should not assume she is not.

Posted (edited)

(All references are to the CCC)

[i][b]CONIDITIONS TO “MORTAL” SIN:[/b][/i]
1857 For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must together be
met: "Mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is
also committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent."131

2352 To form an equitable judgment about the subjects' moral
responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into
account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit,
conditions of anxiety, or other psychological or social factors that can lessen,
if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability.

1862 One commits venial sin when…he disobeys the moral law in a grave matter, but without full knowledge or without complete consent…Deliberate and unrepented venial sin disposes us little by little to commit mortal sin.

2283 By ways known only to him, God can provide the opportunity for salutary repentance [after death in mortal sin]

2355…the immutability of the offense can be attenuated by destitution, blackmail, or social pressure

2413 …grave matter, unless the damage inflicted is so slight that one who suffers it cannot reasonably consider it significant

1874 To choose deliberately - that is, both knowing it and
willing it - something gravely contrary to the divine
law and to the ultimate end of man is to commit a
mortal sin.

[b]OBLIGATIONS AND PROHIBITIONS [u]SPECIFICALLY [/u] SET ASIDE AS "GRAVE":[/b]

(2081) The Ten Commandments

GRAVE OBLIGATIONS
(2387) Must honor obligations of any valid marriage
(2321) Must defend those in danger, if force is legitimately needed
(2439) Rich nations must assist nations unable to develop by themselves
(2223) Must provide a good example for one’s children
(2181) Deliberately failing to participate in the Eucharist on days of obligation

GRAVE SEXUAL PROHIBITIONS
(2400) Adultery, Polygamy, Free Union
(2353) Fornication
(2354) Pornography
(2355) Prostitution
(2356) Rape [and pedophilia]
(2357) Homosexual acts
(2376) Surrogate uterus, heterologous artificial insemination/fertilization, donation of sperm or ovum
(2388) Incest
(2390) Fornication [that is, premarital sex]
(2396) Masturbation

GRAVE CIVIL PROHIBITIONS
(2303) Deliberate hatred with desire towards grave harm
(2320) Murder
(2274) Pre-natal diagnosis, out of consideration of abortion
(2302) Deliberate Desire to seriously wound or kill a neighbor
(2268) Infanticide, parricide, fratricide, murder of spouse
(2269) Exposing someone to mortal danger or failing to assist someone in danger w/o just cause; society/government must not tolerate hunger/famine/epidemic
(2272) Abortion
(2277) Euthanasia
(2281) Suicide
(2290) Endangering self/others via drunkenness or speed while traveling

GRAVE DIVINE PROHIBITIONS
(2148) Blasphemy
(2181) Deliberately missing Mass on Obligation days
(2384) Divorce
(2117) Magic, Sorcery, seeking Occult powers

GRAVE SOCIETAL PROHIBITIONS
(2434) Refusing or withholding justly earned wages
(2284) Scandal [becomes grave, when successful]
(2413) Unfair wages or cheating at games
(2297) Terrorism
(2476) False witness
(2152) Perjury
(2291) Non-medicinal use of drugs

[b]I'm pretty sure that the following is the Church's “official” examination of conscience given in The Roman Ritual (Volume I): Rite of Penance, Appendix III
Examination of Conscience for Adults[/b]

[i]The following is an examination of conscience for adults. This serves as only a beginning understanding. Each of the Ten
Commandments is explained in detail in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, CCC 2052-2557.[/i]
[b]FIRST COMMANDMENT[/b]
"I am the Lord your God. You shall not have
strange gods before Me." (Ex 20:2,3)
Did I doubt or deny that God exists?
Did I give time to God each day in prayer?
Did I love God with my whole heart?
Did I despair of or presume on God's mercy?
Did I refuse to believe what God as revealed to us?
Do I seek to surrender myself to God and His Family, the
Church?
Did I believe in fortune telling, horoscopes, dreams, the
occult, good-luck charms, tarot cards, palmistry, Ouija
boards, seances, reincarnation?
Did I deny that I was Catholic?
Did I leave the Catholic Faith?
Did I have false gods in my life that I gave greater attention
to than God, like money, profession, drugs, TV, fame,
pleasure, property, etc.?
Have I ever received Communion in a state of mortal sin?
Have I ever deliberately told a lie in confession or have I
withheld a mortal sin from the priest in confession?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------
[b]SECOND COMMANDMENT[/b]
"You shall not take the Name of the Lord your
God in vain." (Ex 20:7)
Did I blaspheme or insult God? Did I get angry with God?
Did I take God's name carelessly or uselessly?
Did I curse or break an oath or vow?
Have I wished evil upon another person?
Have I insulted a sacred person or abused a sacred object?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------
[b]THIRD COMMANDMENT[/b]
"Remember to keep holy the Sabbath." (Ex 20:8)
Did I miss Mass Sunday or Holy Day through my own fault?
Did I come to Mass on time? Leave early?
Did I do work on Sunday that was not necessary?
Did I set aside Sunday as a day of rest and a family day?
Did I show reverence in the presence of Jesus in the Most
Blessed Sacrament?
[b]FOURTH COMMANDMENT[/b]
"Honor your father and your mother." (Ex 20:12)
Did I disobey or disrespect my parents or legitimate
superiors? Did I neglect my duties to my husband, wife,
children or parents? Have I prayed for them? In the case
of deceased, have I remembered to offer Masses?
Did I neglect to give good religious example to my family?
Did I fail to actively take an interest in catechesis
and formation of my children? Do I insist that they pray
their morning and evening prayers, go to Confession, and
attend Mass? Do I pray with and for them? Do I correct
them and strive to assist them in overcoming their faults,
without shaming or nagging them?
Do you give your children good example as a Catholic by
word and deed? Do I watch over my children's company?
Do I allow my children to attend any places which could
lead them into sin? Do I allow them to be out at late hours
and without knowing their whereabouts? Have I neglected
my duties in any way to my children?
Did I give scandal by what I said or did, especially to the
young?
Did I cause anyone to leave the faith?
Did I cause tension and fights in my family?
Did I care for my aged and infirm relatives?
Did I give a fair wage to my employees?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------
[b]FIFTH COMMANDMENT[/b]
"You shall not kill." (Ex 20:13)
Did I kill or physically injure anyone?
Did I have an abortion or advise someone else to do so?
Did I use or cause my spouse to use birth control pills?
Have I mutilated myself through any form of sterilization?
Have I encouraged or condoned sterilization?
Did I attempt suicide?
Did I take part in or approve of "mercy killing" (euthanasia)?
Did I get angry, impatient, envious, unkind, proud,
revengeful, jealous, hateful toward another, lazy?
Did I give bad example by drug abuse, drinking alcohol to
excess, fighting, quarreling?
Did I refuse to pardon injuries, or to be reconciled to our
enemies, or to such of our neighbors with whom we have
had some misunderstanding, or falling out?
Did I give scandal to anyone, thereby leading them into sin?
Did I eat or drink to excess, thus damaging my own body?.
Parent Handbook, 67
[b]SIXTH & NINTH COMMANDMENT[/b]
"You shall not commit adultery." (Ex 20:14) “You
shall not covet your neighbors wife.” (Ex 20”17)
Did I willfully entertain impure thoughts or desires?
Did I use impure or suggestive words? Tell impure stories?
Listen to them?
Did I deliberately look at impure TV, videos, plays, pictures
or movies? Or deliberately read impure materials?
Did I commit impure acts by myself (masturbation)?
Did I commit impure acts with another - fornication
(premarital sex), adultery (sex with a married person)?
Did I practice artificial birth control (by pills, device,
early withdrawal)?
Did I marry or advise anyone to marry outside the Church?
Did I avoid the occasions of impurity?
Did I try to control my thoughts?
Did I engage in homosexual activity?
Did I respect all members of the opposite sex, or have I
thought of other people as objects?
Did I or my spouse have sterilization done?
Did I abuse my marriage rights?
Have I dressed modestly?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
[b]SEVENTH & TENTH COMMANDMENTS[/b]
"You shall not steal." (Ex 20:15) "You shall not
covet your neighbor's goods." (Ex 20:17)
Did I steal, cheat, help or encourage others to steal or keep
stolen goods? Have I made restitution for stolen goods?
Did I fulfill my contracts; give/accept bribes; pay my bills;
rashly gamble or speculate; deprive my family of the
necessities of life?
Did I waste time at work, school or at home?
Did I envy other people's families or possessions?
Did I make material possessions the purpose of my life?
Did I eat or drink to excess, or anything else, thus using
what belongs to others?
Was I troubled at the good success of my neighbor?
Did I rejoice at my neighbor's harm?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
[b]EIGHTH COMMANDMENT[/b]
"You shall not bear false witness against your
neighbor." (Ex 20:16)
Did I lie? Did I commit perjury?
Did I deliberately deceive others, or injure others by lies?
Did I gossip or reveal others' faults or sins?
Did I fail to keep secret what should be confidential?
Did I endeavor to do an unkindness, or speak against or
create an ill opinion of my neighbor in the mind of another?
[b]SIN OF PRIDE – ROOT OF ALL SIN[/b]
The Sin of Pride consists,
1. In entertaining too great and opinion of ourselves, or in
valuing ourselves above our deserts.
2. In publishing what we think good in ourselves, that we
may be esteemed by others.
3. In arrogance, by attributing to ourselves the good we
have not.
4. In presumption and ambition, by confiding too much in
our own strength, conceiving ourselves capable of
accomplishing things above our abilities, and in rashly
attempting them.
5. In contempt of others, on account of the good opinions
we have of ourselves, and when this contempt is
manifested by words or actions or by being severe and
exacting on inferiors.
6. In want of submission to our superiors, by disobeying
them, blaming their conduct, or murmuring against them.
7. In not acknowledging our faults; or when, in confessing
facts, we maintain we have done well, or at least allege
false excuses.
8. In contempt of admonitions and corrections.
9. In discord.
10. In hypocrisy.
11. In curiosity, which inclines us to know things prejudicial
to our salvation.
12. By ingratitude for God's benefits.

Edited by Ziggamafu
Posted

I should also suggest that you pick up Christopher West's series on Theology of the Body. Perhaps you can get her to listen to it with you or at least here it yourself so you are better versed in why these things she is involved in are wrong. It is an excellent teaching on how human sexuality can be redeemed by the Cross of Christ.

www.christopherwest.com.

Posted

Ahhhh guys I need help! Thank you sooooo much for the advice thus far, and now I realize I REALLY need to talk to her... I don't know how though! I mean, you don't just call someone and be like "Hey, I think you should stop having sex", you know? Should I call and just bring it up? Send her a link to a good website? Start with bringing up church and then try to work toward the rest of it gradually? This is breaking my heart, over the summer we were having a really deep conversation and she said that her biggest fear was not going to Heaven... I'm so scared!

Ok, so mostly just prayers and encouragement would be good. Pray for courage and so I know what to say, and that the timing is right and she is open to it and so is her fiance.

:( :wacko: :ohno: :sadder:

~Katie

Posted

A wise nun taught me a prayer which I'd like to share with you, one I think will be helpful in this instance:

Everything that [your friend and her fiance] have and everything that they are is yours, Jesus, through Mary, your Mother.

This nun shared this with me when I was anxious over my parents' stubborn refusal to accept my decision to enter the postulancy. She and I prayed this prayer everyday, inserting my parents' names in the brackets there. Within a few months, they came around and were able to dialogue with me in ways that weren't hurtful.

My point is, if you truly want to reach your friend and her fiance, make this prayer every day on their behalf. Entrust them to Jesus and Mary, and you can never go wrong.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...