thessalonian Posted October 25, 2006 Posted October 25, 2006 [url="http://www.cnn.com/2006/LAW/10/25/jersey.samesex.ap/index.html"]http://www.cnn.com/2006/LAW/10/25/jersey.s...x.ap/index.html[/url] The moral slide continues in this country.
Sojourner Posted October 26, 2006 Posted October 26, 2006 [url="http://www.alliancealert.org/2006/20061025.pdf"]Here's the actual text of the opinion[/url], for those who care to read it. The first several pages are a summary, while the rest is the actual thing. It's altogether about 90 pages. Here's the court's holding: [quote]The statutory and decisional laws of this State protect individuals from discrimination based on sexual orientation. When those individuals are gays and lesbians who follow the inclination of their sexual orientation and enter into a committed relationship with someone of the same sex, our laws treat them, as couples, differently than heterosexual couples. As committed same-sex partners, they are not permitted to marry or to enjoy the multitude of social and financial benefits and privileges conferred on opposite-sex married couples. In this case, we must decide whether persons of the same sex have a fundamental right to marry that is encompassed within the concept of liberty guaranteed by Article I, Paragraph 1 of the New Jersey Constitution. Alternatively, we must decide whether Article I, Paragraph 1’s equal protection guarantee requires that committed same-sex couples be given on equal terms the legal benefits and privileges awarded to married heterosexual couples and, if so, whether that guarantee also requires that the title of marriage, as opposed to some other term, define the committed same-sex legal relationship. Only rights that are deeply rooted in the traditions, history, and conscience of the people are deemed to be fundamental. Although we cannot find that a fundamental right to same-sex marriage exists in this State, the unequal dispensation of rights and benefits to committed same-sex partners can no longer be tolerated under our State Constitution. With this State’s legislative and judicial commitment to eradicating sexual orientation discrimination as our backdrop, we now hold that denying rights and benefits to committed same-sex couples that are statutorily given to their heterosexual counterparts violates the equal protection guarantee of Article I, Paragraph 1. To comply with this constitutional mandate, the Legislature must either amend the marriage statutes to include same-sex couples or create a parallel statutory structure, which will provide for, on equal terms, the rights and benefits enjoyed and burdens and obligations borne by married couples. We will not presume that a separate statutory scheme, which uses a title other than marriage, contravenes equal protection principles, so long as the rights and benefits of civil marriage are made equally available to same-sex couples. The name to be given to the statutory scheme that provides full rights and benefits to same-sex couples, whether marriage or some other term, is a matter left to the democratic process.[/quote] Here's the gist of the state's argument: [quote]In defending the constitutionality of its marriage laws, the State submits that same-sex marriage has no historical roots in the traditions or collective conscience of the people of New Jersey to give it the ranking of a fundamental right, and that limiting marriage to opposite-sex couples is a rational exercise of social policy by the Legislature. The State concedes that state law and policy do not support the argument that limiting marriage to heterosexual couples is necessary for either procreative purposes or providing the optimal environment for raising children.7 Indeed, the State not only recognizes the right of gay and lesbian parents to raise their own children, but also places foster children in same-sex parent homes through the Division of Youth and Family Services. The State rests its case on age-old traditions, beliefs, and laws, which have defined the essential nature of marriage to be the union of a man and a woman. The long-held historical view of marriage, according to the State, provides a sufficient basis to uphold the constitutionality of the marriage statutes. Any change to the bedrock principle that limits marriage to persons of the opposite sex, the State argues, must come from the democratic process.[/quote] It is, of course, more complex than this ... but I must confess I'm not surprised at the fact this decision was handed down. It was really just a matter of time.
Sojourner Posted October 26, 2006 Posted October 26, 2006 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1101055' date='Oct 25 2006, 04:25 PM'] Why Jersey... why!? [/quote] Because New Jersey has a long history of policies that protect gay individuals. [url="http://www.volokh.com/archives/archive_2006_10_22-2006_10_28.shtml#1161826380"]Read this post from The Volokh Conspiracy (excerpted below):[/url] [quote] It’s significant that no other gay-marriage case (with the possible and instructive exception of Vermont, where the court adopted similar reasoning) has been brought in a state with as favorable a public policy toward gays as this one was: a broad set of antidiscrimination laws, domestic partnerships, second-parent adoptions, a hate crimes law, and so on. In this environment – where the state was committed to protecting gay people, sustaining gay couples, and facilitating gay parenting – it was both logically and practically difficult to hold on to the procreation and child-rearing rationales. The state had nothing left in defense of the rights gap except an unadorned “tradition” that the state itself had steadily undermined in its public policy. . . . [T]he New Jersey court’s quotation from Justice Brandeis’ famous dissenting opinion praising the states as “laboratories” to “try novel social and economic experiments” is a bit ironic. The New Jersey court now holds that once the state substantially experiments with gay equality it must go all the way, ending the experiment. While the result in this case is surely a good one for gay families, it may chill experiments in other states where legislators might fear that they cannot move incrementally toward equality for gay couples without surrendering the judicial basis for any remaining distinctions. I doubt that’s really a great danger in most states, where courts tend to be less aggressive than New Jersey’s and where the standard rational-basis test should allow legislatures to proceed incrementally, but this opinion will surely be cited as a reason not to grant any rights to gay couples.[/quote]
thessalonian Posted October 26, 2006 Author Posted October 26, 2006 [quote]Because New Jersey has a long history of policies that protect gay individuals.[/quote] People do not need protection as gays but as people. Their dignity is not in their homosexuality. It is in their being created by God. Two gays living in a home have no right to medical benefits of another any more than two straights. Heck even a man and woman, unmarried and living together, have fewer rights than cohabitating gays these days. Marriage is the only way that "couples" should have rights. Anything else is encouraging sin by society and the breakdown of the family, by cheapening the great sacrament of marriage. They have no right to marriage. Dr. Mirrevali yesterday made a great anology. He said these laws are like saying to a man with a broken leg, your fine, you don't need a cast. Homosexuality is disordered Sojourner, and society has a serious reason to discourage it and work to cure these people of their disordered behavior just as much as to cure child molesters and people having sex outside of marriage, causing and epidemic of STDs.
Sojourner Posted October 26, 2006 Posted October 26, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1101443' date='Oct 26 2006, 09:38 AM'] People do not need protection as gays but as people. Their dignity is not in their homosexuality. It is in their being created by God. Two gays living in a home have no right to medical benefits of another any more than two straights. Heck even a man and woman, unmarried and living together, have fewer rights than cohabitating gays these days. Marriage is the only way that "couples" should have rights. Anything else is encouraging sin by society and the breakdown of the family, by cheapening the great sacrament of marriage. They have no right to marriage. Dr. Mirrevali yesterday made a great anology. He said these laws are like saying to a man with a broken leg, your fine, you don't need a cast. Homosexuality is disordered Sojourner, and society has a serious reason to discourage it and work to cure these people of their disordered behavior just as much as to cure child molesters and people having sex outside of marriage, causing and epidemic of STDs. [/quote] Uh ... I wasn't making an argument one way or another. Just stating that this is the reason behind the decision.
thessalonian Posted October 26, 2006 Author Posted October 26, 2006 (edited) The words I quoted were not New Jerey's or the court's but yours. They are words with a false premise that "gay individuals" need to be protected. No, individuals need to be protected. When we change th focus to "gay individuals" our reasoning becomes skewed and we create rights for sinful behavior. Edited October 26, 2006 by thessalonian
Sojourner Posted October 26, 2006 Posted October 26, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1101471' date='Oct 26 2006, 10:10 AM'] The words I quoted were not New Jerey's or the court's but yours. They are words with a false premise that "gay individuals" need to be protected. No, individuals need to be protected. When we change th focus to "gay individuals" our reasoning becomes skewed and we create rights for sinful behavior. [/quote] whatever ... I was making no such argument. But you read into it whatever you want to read into it.
thessalonian Posted October 26, 2006 Author Posted October 26, 2006 (edited) You may not have been. I am sorry but it came accross that way to me. Please take no offense. Glad you have clarified that you do not argue in favor of such things. As I recall you are somewhat nuetral on the matter of states passing amendments against gay marriage. Edited October 26, 2006 by thessalonian
Sojourner Posted October 26, 2006 Posted October 26, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1101477' date='Oct 26 2006, 10:21 AM'] You may not have been. I am sorry but it came accross that way to me. Please take no offense. Glad you have clarified that you do not argue in favor of such things. As I recall you are somewhat nuetral on the matter of states passing amendments against gay marriage. [/quote] In this case, my statement was a paraphrase of the reasoning of the court and of the commentator I quoted. In answer to Paladin's question about why this decision happened in New Jersey, I said: [quote]Because New Jersey has a long history of policies that protect gay individuals.[/quote] The court said: [quote]The statutory and decisional laws of this State protect individuals from discrimination based on sexual orientation.[/quote] And the commentator I quoted said: [quote][b]It’s significant that no other gay-marriage case (with the possible and instructive exception of Vermont, where the court adopted similar reasoning) has been brought in a state with as favorable a public policy toward gays [/b] as this one was: a broad set of antidiscrimination laws, domestic partnerships, second-parent adoptions, a hate crimes law, and so on. In this environment – where the state was committed to protecting gay people, sustaining gay couples, and facilitating gay parenting – it was both logically and practically difficult to hold on to the procreation and child-rearing rationales. The state had nothing left in defense of the rights gap except an unadorned “tradition” that the state itself had steadily undermined in its public policy. . . .[/quote] I wasn't making a statement of my own opinion on this matter at all. This is, after all, not the debate table.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 26, 2006 Posted October 26, 2006 They might as well say, "we went ahead and legalized it for you...but the rest we'll leave to the legislature, since making laws is their job anyway...we only wanted enough of the action to open the door and force the issue on them, you know, as good, non-legislating, non-biased judges and all. "
Socrates Posted October 27, 2006 Posted October 27, 2006 Good 'ol liberal judicial activism strikes again. The vote on "gay marriage" is coming up in Virginia, and homosexual activists are confident courts will strike it down. Pray for us!
Norseman82 Posted October 27, 2006 Posted October 27, 2006 [quote]Although we cannot find that a fundamental right to same-sex marriage exists in this State, the unequal dispensation of rights and benefits to committed same-sex partners can no longer be tolerated under our State Constitution[/quote] We are rapidly turning into a judicial dictatorship. Any American should shudder at that. [quote]The name to be given to the statutory scheme that provides full rights and benefits to same-sex couples, whether marriage or some other term, is a matter left to the democratic process.[/quote] Gee, how thoughtful of youse....it would have been nice if you had thought of leaving things "to the democratic process" before issuing your ruling in the first place. I wonder how many computers were ruined by people spitting up their coffee reading that line?
Socrates Posted October 27, 2006 Posted October 27, 2006 [quote name='Norseman82' post='1102026' date='Oct 26 2006, 08:31 PM'] We are rapidly turning into a judicial dictatorship. Any American should shudder at that.[/quote] Absolutely. Tyrannical activist judges have done more damage to this country politically/legally than any other single group of people, including the Roe v. Wade ruling! And the liberals of course are all fine with this (even some "Catholics" here), 'cause they always rule in their favor. (Of course these same folks scream "oppression" whenever anyone suggests any that law should in any way reflect morality!) [quote]Gee, how thoughtful of youse....it would have been nice if you had thought of leaving things "to the democratic process" before issuing your ruling in the first place. I wonder how many computers were ruined by people spitting up their coffee reading that line?[/quote] Yeah, they let the people name the little monster the courts created, how sweet!
Matty_boy Posted October 29, 2006 Posted October 29, 2006 You know why New Jersey had to get the judges rule gay marriage to be ok? Because every state that has voted on the issue has banned gay marriage! People become judges because they can't read the Constitution.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now