Aloysius Posted October 27, 2006 Posted October 27, 2006 So... the French Bishops are throwing a big temper tantrum over the possibility of a universal indult, alluding to threats of open schism. Our own bishops have said much more tempered things, but are still by and large against the possibility. So here's a scenario to ponder: If the French Bishops; or even God forbid the US bishops; went into open schism, what would that mean at an individual parish level? Could an individual parish refuse to adhere to the schism and retain their church building? Or would all the church buildings be under the ownership of schismatic bishops? Say the USCCB went into open schism, could some dioceses oppose it and fracture the US Church by diocesan lines? Would Rome appoint new bishops over those areas where the bishops were in schism... and would those bishops be able to claim ownership of the parish churches? It's not a pleasent scenario to ponder, sure, and hopefully it's very unlikely (though it is not so unlikely in France, sadly), but nevertheless I am curious as to how that would play out. I mean, the diocese owns most church buildings as I understand it; but if the Pope appointed a new bishop of the diocese whilst the other one refused to step down what would US law say about who administered those buildings? Would we flood the US courts with property cases the likes of which no US court has ever seen?
son_of_angels Posted October 28, 2006 Posted October 28, 2006 I would hope that ecclesial law would limit the number of cases which appear before the civil authorities. Hopefully, the Vatican and the code of Canon Law would help parishes to pick their battles and negotiate for the handover of many of the churches and real estate in question. It is, after all, unbecoming for Christians to quarrel in civil court over disputes arising amongst us. I'm not at all an expert on this matter, but, as the parishes have already been shown by precedent to have an interest in their property, such that the bishops cannot just arbitrarily close them, I think probably the number of adherent parishes which would have to be handed over to those in schism would be small. On the other hand, acknowledging and/or exercising this precedent in ecclesial practice would lead to an insufficient church organization. Catholic doctrine holds that the bishops hold the plenitude of power, save for that reserved by the Holy See and its designates, over the individual churches. If we utilize a principle which undermines that authority, it could lead, in the future, to the possibility of open revolt by parishes against their bishops, with the bishops simply whispering moralistic and empty threats. So, we have a dilemma. I think the better option would be, were this unthinkable thing to happen, for the members of adherent parishes, and their priests, cooperating with corporate partners, etc. to build up a fund to BUY parishes from these schismatics, and fund publicity campaigns to expose them as schismatics and betrayers.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now