N/A Gone Posted October 30, 2006 Posted October 30, 2006 As an evangelical we have basically any option we want with Atonement to make Jesus fit in with the rest of our theology. The basic three models that I know of (*ignoring bizarre calvin stuff) are 1.) Penal Atonement 2.) Christus Victor 3.) Jewish Blood atonement So, as an evangelical I had this strongly thought out and worked through. Im curious. What does the church believe? What do they allow as possibilities? Links are appreciated. [quote]The Christian doctrine that through Christ’s passion, death and resurrection, infinite satisfaction is made to God for the sins of humankind. Through this satisfaction, we are reconciled to God. Christ’s atonement consists, not primarily in the intensity of the suffering He endured, but in the perfectly obedient and loving acceptance of the Will of the Father which He displayed in embracing this suffering for our sake. Christ’s perfect obedience atones for the disobedience of Adam and wins for us the grace of obedient discipleship and divinizing sanctification. Christ is the “Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world” (Jn 1:29), the perfectly innocent Servant Who suffers in the place of the truly guilty (cf. Lk 22:37; Is 53). The Epistle to the Hebrews expounds on the meaning of Christ’s atonement by showing that it fulfilled and surpassed the sacrifices of the Old Law. The words of institution, employed in all celebrations of the Eucharist, speak of the cup of “the blood of the new and everlasting covenant” which “will be shed for you and for all so that sins may be forgiven.” In the history of Christian doctrine, a variety of theological explanations have been developed to account for the mystery of the atonement. Theories that emphasize the love and obedience of Christ in suffering for our sake are preferable to those theories (either penal or substitutional) that center on the appeasement of divine wrath or the ransom paid to Satan.[/quote] -OSV Catholic Encyclopedia
N/A Gone Posted October 30, 2006 Author Posted October 30, 2006 hmm, Just told my teacher I have never really liked Penal atonement, and he says "and you call yourself a catholic" so I am confused..
phatcatholic Posted October 30, 2006 Posted October 30, 2006 some links for you: [b]Articles:[/b] --[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02055a.htm"]Doctrine of the Atonement[/url] --[url="http://ccc.scborromeo.org.master.com/texis/master/search/?sufs=0&q=atonement"]Atonement in the Catechism[/url] --[url="http://ic.net/~erasmus/RAZ348.HTM"]The "Ransom Theory" of Atonement in the Fathers[/url] --[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/1993/9307fea1sb1.asp"]Is the Atonement Limited....and Are You Out of Luck?[/url] [b]Definitions:[/b] --[url="http://www.catholic-forum.com/saints/ncd00860.htm"]New Catholic Dictionary: Atonement[/url] --[url="http://www.therealpresence.org/dictionary/adict.htm"]Pocket Catholic Dictionary: Atonement[/url] (see "Atonement" in the drop-down menu) --[url="http://www.catecheticsonline.com/Catechetics_words.html"]Words Every Catholic Should Know: Atonement[/url] i hope that helps pax christi, phatcatholic
phatcatholic Posted October 30, 2006 Posted October 30, 2006 you would have to explain the three models first. protestants always have wierd ways of categorizing doctrine.
N/A Gone Posted October 30, 2006 Author Posted October 30, 2006 Penal..(*or substitution) [quote]The Reformers agreed with Anselm that sin is a very serious matter, but they saw it as a breaking of God's law rather than as an insult to God's honor. The moral law, they held, is not to be taken lightly. "The wages of sin is death" (Rom. 6:23), and it is this that is the problem for sinful man. They took seriously the scriptural teachings about the wrath of God and those that referred to the curse under which sinners lay. It seemed clear to them that the essence of Christ's saving work consisted in his taking the sinner's place. In our stead Christ endured the death that is the wages of sin. He bore the curse that we sinners should have borne (Gal. 3:13). The Reformers did not hesitate to speak of Christ as having borne our punishment or as having appeased the wrath of God in our place. Such views have been widely criticized. In particular it is pointed out that sin is not an external matter to be transferred easily from one person to another and that, while some forms of penalty are transferable (the payment of a fine), others are not (imprisonment, capital punishment). It is urged that this theory sets Christ in opposition to the Father so that it maximizes the love of Christ and minimizes that of the Father. Such criticisms may be valid against some of the ways in which the theory is stated, but they do not shake its essential basis. They overlook the fact that there is a double identification: Christ is one with sinners (the saved are "in" Christ, Rom. 8:1) and he is one with the Father (he and the Father are one, John 10:30; "God was in Christ, reconciling the world to himself," 2 Cor. 5:19). They also overlook the fact that there is much in the NT that supports the theory. It is special pleading to deny that Paul, for example, puts forward this view. It may need to be carefully stated, but this view still says something important about the way Christ won our salvation.[/quote] -SOme old Evangelical dictionary [url="http://www.theopedia.com/Penal_substitution"]http://www.theopedia.com/Penal_substitution[/url] [url="http://www.religioustolerance.org/chr_atone10.htm"]http://www.religioustolerance.org/chr_atone10.htm[/url] So basically Jesus is paying the price. The basic Romans road proto situation. Once the debt is paid it is done. OSAS and Sola Fida work with this. Christus victor [url="http://www.sharktacos.com/God/cross_intro.shtml"]http://www.sharktacos.com/God/cross_intro.shtml[/url] [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christus_Victor"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christus_Victor[/url] let me get more later if you need...Im trying to avoid my proto theology right now.
beatty07 Posted October 31, 2006 Posted October 31, 2006 None of these models exhaust the mystery of salvation (sorry if that's insultingly obvious!). I think Anselm is often misinterpreted... people tend to associate his theory of penal substitution with the image of an angry Father whose wrath is satiated by smacking around His Son. Pretty shabby model... it makes the Father into some kind of easily offended sadist. That's not what Anselm meant at all. He used the language of infinity to help us understand why sin required such an awful redemption. It safeguards from easy, reductionary soteriologies where Christ just told us to get along, and unfortunately got killed for it. Sin is real, it destroys cosmic order, and the very nature of God requires that it be redressed. Jewish Blood Atonement? Not real familiar with that terminology, but certainly Hebrews requires us to acknowledge that Christ's Salvation has a deep connection here. Well, you could hardly fail to notice the typology of Temple sacrifice with the sacrifice of Our Lord, right? I won't try to expound on this here, except: C.F. the Letter to the Hebrews. Another important aspect to compliment these is often termed "vicarious substitution." This model emphasizes that Christ wasn't just taking the lumps that we had coming, but was totally identified with us in His sacrifice. This is perhaps related to that strange Scripture: "He became sin for us." This is what enables us to anamnetically participate in His once-and-for-all sacrifice in the Holy Mass. We are not reproducing the event, "recrucifying" the Lord, but rather participating in the one event, by our Baptismal participation in the Mystical Body of Christ, mysteriously transcending the veil of time. That was pretty jargon heavy, but I'm just trying to give some clues to the various aspects. I guess the truth is we can't answer the question, at least right here, because it boils down to "what is Catholic soteriology" and that just won't fit in a forum! It's just not part of the Catholic sensibility and temperament to pronounce on the central mysteries of the faith with a brief answer, and then say "okay, that's all. I've explained it."
Pennypacker11 Posted October 31, 2006 Posted October 31, 2006 (edited) I think that it is vital to always recognize, as Beatty says, that we are dealing with mystery here. None of us will ever fully comprehend what the Son of God has done for us on the cross. We are given a glimpse of it through Revelation, but this does not exhaust the mystery. That said, the most helpful theologian I have found on this issue is Hans Urs von Balthasar. Here is a quote: "As the proceding historical outline showed, the quintessence of Scripture is found in five motifs. We must take account of all five motifs if our reflection is to be truly ecclesial. 1) The Son gives himself, through God the Father, for the world's salvation. 2) The Sinless One 'changes places' with sinners. While, in principle, the Church Fathers understand this in a radical sense, it is only in the modern variations of the theories of representation that the consequences are fully drawn out. 3) Man is thus set free (ransomed, redeemed, released). 4) More than this, however, he is initiated into the life of the Trinity. 5) Consequently, the whole process is shown to be the result of an initiative on the part of divine love. We have seen that it did not prove easy to do equal justice to all of these aspects.... ([i]Theo-Drama IV[/i], p317)" Balthasar then discusses how he some of these being omitted by certain theologians and then goes on to provide his own 'dramatic soteriology'. Obviously this is not an authoritative document on soteriology but I find is quite wise and persuasive. It also does not mandate one particular soteriology but allows for diverse ways of expressing how Jesus' death saves us while still strongly maintaining a Scriptural and Christological core. Edited October 31, 2006 by Pennypacker11
beatty07 Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 My last post was probably too vague and obvious to be helpful, but a more specific example does come to mind. One model that I think is wholly contrary to Catholic doctrine is Luther's. I point this out because it is still rather popular. In this view, the atonement consists of God imputing Christ's purity to us in a merely legal sense - Luther's gutted version of justification. You're probably familiar with the whole "pile of excrement covered in snow" analogy that he is said to have used (I've never read that passage myself.) The point is, we stay corrupt and wholly depraved, but the Father looks at us through the Son, and see the Son's goodness in us. Admittedly, I'm no Luther scholar so I can't say whether this is a fair assessment of his doctrine. But I do know from experience that many Christians hold something along these lines. Christ's atonement doesn't really affect us or improve us, it simply allows us to squeeze into heaven like a "get out of jail free" card. In Catholic teaching, very firmly rooted in the Fathers and in Scripture and Prophecy, the work of Christ really does change us... there is real purity and healing to be found in Baptism and Reconciliation.
N/A Gone Posted November 27, 2006 Author Posted November 27, 2006 awesome.. the entire class, the entire semister is built around showing how the church is abusing a power that is not seen in the gospel and using Anslem and penal substitution to inact that perverted authority..
beatty07 Posted November 28, 2006 Posted November 28, 2006 you mean they're claiming that Christ never entrusted to the Apostles the authority to forgive sins?
N/A Gone Posted November 28, 2006 Author Posted November 28, 2006 Betty, I think you mean to responsd to my other thread.. Or at least it fits there also..but to your point. of course not...Jesus did all that for us. Why would Jesus need man? Confession to an authority is just for control anyway. Man has no ability to forgive, only God does. The individual sins do not need to be asked for forgiveness either. The Jews had their temporary sacrifice, Jesus was the complete sacrifice, once and for all. Man might help another man in counciling or helping with the damage caused by the sin. But can not help the sin. Also, we do not need to respond to that grace either, for if we did, to what degree would we need to respond? or at least thats what they say..and I would have a few years ago.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now