Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Catholic Education


Do you think that home schooled children know there Catholic Faith better than those who attend a Catholic School?  

24 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

The talk is one - lets find out where we stand.

Posted

The talk is on - lets find out where we stand

Posted

I lean heavily to the Home-Schooling side more thought. I would say on average home-schoolers know there faith better - and even practice it with more sincerity.

Posted

There is no objective standard to measure knowledge of the Catholic Faith.

There is no standard of teaching the Faith in home schoos stituations.

You're trying to crack a walnut by throwing fresh marshmallows at it.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

What are you a sociology major or something?

You are really into polls.

Posted

yeah I like them. I am interested in where other people stand. And no - I am not a sociology major. Actually, I have my Degree in Theology from Franciscan University - and am now a High School and Jr. High Youth Minister.

but I think it is a interesting question - nonetheless (my own word).

Posted

There is no objective standard to measure knowledge of the Catholic Faith.

There is no standard of teaching the Faith in home schoos stituations.

You're trying to crack a walnut by throwing fresh marshmallows at it.

No, I am not - I am just askinga question - and hoping people will vote and say what they think. No need to blow it out of proportion.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

jas is right.

It depends on each particular student in each particular family etc.

Posted

not implying he was wrong.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I think it is way too general a poll.

Posted

Great. But I am still interested in what people think. You vote and then you give your reasoning.

Posted

i think that it depends on the school or what it's like at home. I went to catholic school, and had a nun as my religion teacher, and learned a whole lot. I was never home schooled so i don't really know what thats like, but i think that it really depends.

Posted

yeah - there are some variables. Usually- most people who homeschool are very solid Catholics - from my experience those who are homeschooled really stick with there faith - and practice it with devotion and love. But you cannot escape the variables.

Posted

it depends on the school system. Like the Catholic school system here? Umm, no.

jrndveritatis
Posted

It definitely depends on the school and on the family.

From my experience, most homeschooled students are practice their faith much more sincerely than those who go to Catholic schools. However, this could just be because devout Catholic families are more willing to homeschool. One thing that we should keep in mind is that those students in Catholic schools who come from devout families are usually faithful Catholics as well.

But obviously a larger proportion of homeschoolers who are Catholic are faithful than their counterparts who go to Catholic schools. Again, this is mainly because devout Catholics are a vast majority of homeschoolers.

Catholic schools aren't all bad. Of course lots of them have problems and teach nothing at all of doctrine, but there are a few good ones out there.

Posted

This is all just my personal experience but that's all about we have to go on so...

I am a product of Catholic Schools and a bunch of my friends are products of homeschools. Given our families the kids in home school have more devout parents (lets just leave it at that). Right now my friends still strike me as more in tune with The Faith, but I'm not sure how they feel about me concerning that.

I do know that my life is much more secular as compared to theirs and my sense of reality is different from theirs (that maybe because of the family). They seem much more comfortable with their faith and more comfortable showing it to other people. In the way of actual knowledge about the faith they may know a little more about it than me, but I've learned a lot in the last two years because of CL (not school). I think Catholic schools could teach it, but some kids don't want to listen and there's nothing the teachers can really do about that. I think parents can be better showing the Faith to their kids, while in a school parents show some of it (if any) and then teachers show part of it.

I'm really torn on the subject because if a kid really wants to know they can usually find out. Ya I should stop talking now.

Posted (edited)

I thought the comment about cracking a walnut with a marshmallow was funny, not out of proportion. No wonder my SAT's stank...

There is no real comparison because there is no real question. The two groups are very different in size and make up so the sample selection is flawed. Are you measuring the environment, the ability of the teachers, the receptiveness of the students?

**crack**

Wanna walnut??

Edited by jasJis
Don John of Austria
Posted

In my experiance homeschooled children are devout but know almost nothing about their faith, And as a Catholic School teacher I have seen a lot of Homeschooled Children come in to the jounior high level( parants have trouble once kids get over a grade level, for example junior high science can be VERY expensive to set up.) at any rate they were very faithful and had a good grasp of differant prayers and such but almost no understanding of theological concepts or the Church hierarchy or scripture, that has been my experiance and the experiance of those teachers I have talked to about it. Now a bad Catholic School can be pretty bad, but a good one can't be beaten, you just have to look carefully.

Jas -- you are right we cannot judge Faith but we can Judge knowledge, I think that is what was being asked.

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

On the contrary, every Catholic home school program I've seen has the faith embedded in most of their literature and books - at least the books specifically designed for Catholics...

Now, by the same token, most Catholic schools these days no longer use textbooks specifically designed for and by Catholic schools. Which is a shame. And it seems to me that many Catholic schools are becoming more like secular schools - much less than when my mother attended Incarnate Word in San Antonio. There are less nuns and hardly any priests involved and that is truly a shame.

But I would always choose a Catholic school over public (not that there aren't good public schools out there), simply because I feel like I owe it to my faith to help keep the Catholic schools alive.

And if I can't afford the Catholic school when the time comes I will home school.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...