Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Two Questions On Judas Iscariot


Recommended Posts

Posted

As for Judas Iscariot:

1. Did he have valid orders? Could he have consecrated the Eucharist or ordained men to the priesthood?

2. Is there any purpose in praying for the repose of his soul. If it is good to 'pray for the repose of poor souls in purgatory who have no one else to pray for them,' then wouldn't he be the best possible candidate especially since we are not certain he is in hell? If I can pray for the repose of the soul of my family members (athiests, fornicators, Masons) can I not pray for God's mercy for Judas?

Posted

His orders were absolutely valid. Remember that he was along through the sending of the Twelve... they were working miracles and spreading the Gospel, and Judas was part of that. To understand his betrayal, we have to understand that he was truly elected Apostle. We have to look at the Church's history with that understanding: the presence of wretched scoundrels at the pinnacles of the Church is nothing new. The growth of tares along with wheat is a fact of this world, and Holy Orders is no exception. If you really want to delve into this, consider looking into the heresy of Donatism.

Besides, it doesn't seem likely that Our Lord would invalidly confer a Sacrament!

Regarding his salvation, that's a very big question and actually right now a very popular debate. It's tied up with the question "May we hope that all are saved?" It seems like if anyone isn't, Judas is the guy. After all, "Better for him had he never been born." How could that possibly be the case if he was going to end up in Heaven? On the other hand, John Paul the Great expressed his private opinion in "Crossing the Threshold of Hope" that we can't be certain of Judas's damnation. So it's a very thorny question. It seems to me that a healthy agnosticism is the best response for us. Given that, I don't see a problem in desiring that he be saved, assuming it's done with the proper disposition.

But admittedly, this is a VERY controversial topic that doesn't seem to have been settled by the Magisterium.

Posted

Yes, and yes.

You can pray for anyone's soul.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1109847' date='Nov 3 2006, 01:11 PM']
Yes, and yes.

You can pray for anyone's soul.
[/quote]
that is certainly what Hans Urs von Balthasar would have us do.

Posted

wait a sec... is it anachronistic to speak of Holy Orders prior to Pentecost?

Posted

[quote name='beatty07' post='1109938' date='Nov 3 2006, 02:00 PM']wait a sec... is it anachronistic to speak of Holy Orders prior to Pentecost?[/quote]
From Session 22 of the Council of Trent:

[quote]If any one saith, that by those words, "Do this for the commemoration of me," Christ did not institute the apostles priests; or, did not ordain that they, and other priests should offer His own body and blood; let him be anathema. [/quote]
The Apostles were made Priests (Bishops) at the Last Supper, and Christ commanded them to pass on these orders to perpetuate the sacrifice he offered.

Posted

Thanks Era Might. Mightily thou wieldest thy well-worn copy of Denzinger.

Posted

Hahaha. I wish I had a Denziger! I do have the Canons of Trent though.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Yes.

Yes - the Bible records numerous instances of Judas' remorse and regret, ie repentance for his deed. Since the only unpardonable sin is that of unrepentant turning away, he has a chance.

As the CCC teaches, even with suicide, there are other factors that come into play to reduce the sin of self-murder from venial to mortal.

So...we don;t know for sure where he is now...so pray for him. :-)

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1110088' date='Nov 3 2006, 03:08 PM']
From Session 22 of the Council of Trent:
The Apostles were made Priests (Bishops) at the Last Supper, and Christ commanded them to pass on these orders to perpetuate the sacrifice he offered.
[/quote]
But didnt Judas take off before the institution of the Eucharist at the last supper.

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1110307' date='Nov 3 2006, 08:27 PM']But didnt Judas take off before the institution of the Eucharist at the last supper.[/quote]
I'm pretty sure he took off just after. The Gospels don't specify, but in John 13 is where Jesus gives Judas a piece of bread, and then tells him to go do what he is going to do. There is no institution narrative in John, so there's no way to tell if this is before or after the institution of the Eucharist, but I think it's assumed that the bread Judas received was the consecrated host, which would make him present for the institution.

I'm not sure though, because I know there's some controversy about whether or not Judas received communion or not.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1110322' date='Nov 3 2006, 07:46 PM']I'm not sure though, because I know there's some controversy about whether or not Judas received communion or not.
[/quote]

I have heard this before. As I understand it, the controversy is if the bread and wine in Jn13:26 were consecrated. Corect? Everybody agrees he took off before Lk22:19?

Posted

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/408102.htm"]HERE'S[/url] what St. Thomas has to say in the Summa.

I think it is assumed that Judas was present for the institution of the Holy Eucharist, and I don't see how he could have been excluded from the rite, because it was necessary that the Apostles be made Priests, and he was an Apostle.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...